The text discusses the complex relationship between tribalism and nation-building in Saudi Arabia. While acknowledging the historical significance and enduring social influence of tribes, it highlights how tribal pride and fanaticism have been identified as obstacles to social development. The Saudi government’s efforts to manage tribal influence are examined, including legal frameworks aimed at curbing harmful tribal expressions and initiatives to integrate tribal identities within a broader national framework. Despite progress in promoting national unity and meritocracy, the persistence of some tribal practices underscores the ongoing challenges in achieving a fully cohesive national identity. The text also briefly compares Saudi Arabia’s experience with that of other countries where tribal structures remain influential in political and social life.
Tribalism in Saudi Arabia: A Study Guide
Short Answer Quiz
- According to Saudi sociologists, what positive aspects of tribal structures can be utilized in the transformation to civil society?
- What is a primary negative impact of tribalism, as identified by a 2016 Saudi study, and what is the root cause of this impact?
- Describe how the Saudi state has attempted to mitigate tribal fanaticism using the example of the camel beauty pageants.
- How has the Saudi government addressed historical issues of tribal-based discrimination within its institutions?
- Name three historical pre-Islamic wars in the Arabian Peninsula that were attributed to tribal conflicts.
- In what other Middle Eastern and North African countries does tribalism play a significant political or social role?
- How does the Saudi ruling family’s history differ from traditional tribal structures, and how does this difference affect the role of tribes in the Kingdom?
- What types of actions are subject to legal penalties, in terms of the law, for inciting tribalism?
- What examples of individual actions were monitored in 2024 that illustrate the persistence of tribalism in Saudi society?
- How do Saudi sociologists envision the role of tribes in the future of a civil society in the Kingdom?
Answer Key
- Saudi sociologists see tribes as having positive values that can be built upon, particularly in strengthening national unity and resolving blood issues. They also believe tribal ways of thinking can help refine the behavior of their members.
- The 2016 study identified tribal pride and fanaticism as obstacles to social development, stemming from a desire to demonstrate prestige and the superiority of one tribe over another.
- The Saudi state took over the camel beauty pageants, transforming them from individual tribal events that incited fanaticism into a state-sponsored festival that promotes national identity, thus mitigating the issue.
- The Saudi government, under King Salman and Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, has addressed historical racism through implementing policies that emphasize competence and merit, rather than tribal affiliation, in hiring and admissions.
- The three pre-Islamic wars mentioned are the Dahis and Ghabra war, the Basus war, and the Fijar war.
- Tribalism is influential in the political and social spheres of Kuwait, Jordan, Libya, Iraq, Lebanon and Yemen.
- The Saudi ruling family has urban roots dating back two centuries before Islam, giving it an equal distance from all tribes, allowing it to act as an institution, not a tribe, that frames and influences tribal tendencies, promoting a national identity.
- Legal penalties apply to actions that promote tribalism in media, talk shows, poetry, national occasions, and in commercial advertising. The penalties include fines and prison sentences.
- In 2024, examples of tribalism include guest appearances in talk shows, raising tribal flags at national events, tribal references in entertainment, and using tribal names in commercial branding.
- Saudi sociologists believe that tribes should be transformed into civil society institutions, building upon existing values to strengthen national unity, address social issues, and refine behavior as they move forward.
Essay Questions
- Analyze the tension between the historical prevalence of tribalism in Saudi Arabia and the country’s modern efforts to forge a national identity. What factors have contributed to the persistence of tribal identity?
- Discuss the ways in which the Saudi government has attempted to reform the role of tribes in Saudi society. What have been the successes and what are the ongoing challenges in this transformation?
- Compare and contrast the role of tribalism in Saudi Arabia with its impact in other Middle Eastern and North African countries mentioned in the text. What common threads and distinct characteristics exist?
- Evaluate the effectiveness of legal measures in Saudi Arabia in curbing tribalism. Are these laws sufficient, or are other methods needed to achieve the country’s goals for a modern civil society?
- Explore the potential for using the positive aspects of tribal structures to build a stronger national identity. How could values of tribal unity and behavior refinement be re-contextualized for civil society development?
Glossary of Key Terms
- Tribalism: A social organization based on kinship ties and shared ancestry, often associated with loyalty to the tribe above other forms of social organization or national identity.
- Civil Society Institutions: Organizations and groups that operate outside of government control that work to advance the common interests of people and address societal needs.
- National Unity: The sense of shared identity, purpose, and cohesion among the citizens of a nation.
- Blood Issues: Disputes or conflicts arising from acts of violence between individuals or groups, often requiring resolution through tribal mediation or other customary processes.
- Tribal Fanaticism: Extreme, irrational devotion to one’s tribe, often involving prejudice against other tribes and leading to inter-tribal conflicts.
- Vision 2030: Saudi Arabia’s strategic plan to diversify its economy and modernize the country.
- Bedouinism: A nomadic lifestyle traditionally associated with the Arabian Peninsula and characterized by tribal organization and pastoral practices.
- Labbat: A term used to describe tribal affiliations or heritage.
- Shila: Traditional form of Saudi music and poetry that can incorporate themes of tribalism.
- Qalta Poetry: Another form of traditional Arabic poetry often delivered in spoken form that can incorporate tribal themes.
- Al-Mazain Festival: A term that refers to camel beauty pageants, which can be a source of tribal competition.
- Basic Law of Governance: The constitution of Saudi Arabia that outlines the principles of governance and the rights of its citizens.
- Criminal Procedures Law: Laws that govern the process of criminal justice in Saudi Arabia.
- Audiovisual Media Law: Laws that regulate the media sector in Saudi Arabia including what is permissible to be broadcast.
- Anti-Cybercrime Law: Laws that cover electronic offenses, including incitement of tribalism.
Tribalism in Saudi Arabia: A Nation’s Balancing Act
Okay, here’s a briefing document summarizing the key themes and ideas from the provided text about tribalism in Saudi Arabia:
Briefing Document: Tribalism in Saudi Arabia
Introduction:
This document analyzes a provided text discussing the complexities of tribalism in Saudi Arabia. The text explores historical roots, contemporary manifestations, and governmental responses aimed at fostering national unity. It highlights a tension between traditional tribal affiliations and the state’s push towards modernization and a unified national identity, as well as ongoing efforts to manage tribal influence.
Key Themes and Ideas:
- Tribalism as a Historical Force:
- Tribalism is not a new phenomenon in Saudi Arabia, with roots extending back to pre-Islamic times. The text mentions “wars that lasted for hundreds of years,” such as “the Dahis and Ghabra war, the Basus war, the Fijar war, and the Baath war”, underscoring the deep historical significance of tribal identity and its potential for conflict.
- The text highlights that tribalism’s influence is not unique to Saudi Arabia. It is also described as present and influential in the Levant and the Maghreb, and playing an important role in parliamentary elections in Kuwait and Jordan, and in power structures in post-Saddam Iraq, Libya, and Yemen. This indicates the widespread nature of tribalism in the Middle East, and its impact on politics and society across the region.
- Tribalism as an Obstacle to Social Development:
- A 2016 Saudi study revealed that “tribal pride and fanaticism are considered obstacles to social development.” These sentiments are perceived as rooted in a desire to “show the superiority of one tribe over another.”
- The text uses the example of camel beauty pageants to illustrate how tribalism can manifest. Historically, individual tribes held such pageants in a way that incited “tribal fanaticism and strife”. This was one of the reasons the state intervened, taking control of the Al-Mazain festival.
- The State’s Role in Managing and Reforming Tribalism:
- The Saudi state has actively sought to mitigate the negative aspects of tribalism and redirect it towards national unity. An example is its involvement in camel beauty pageants: “the state hold the beauty pageant festival… with a comprehensive identity for all tribes under the umbrella of the state, and tribal biases were replaced with a comprehensive national identity, in line with the requirements of modern civilization and Vision 2030.” This showcases the state’s desire to shape tribal traditions in accordance with national objectives.
- The ruling house is not tied to any one tribe, which the text describes as allowing it to be “at an equal distance from all components of Saudi society” and positioned to be an “influence the tribal tendency and framing it,” working to promote “individual ownership and the person’s responsibility for his actions, regardless of his (Labbat)”. This is contrasted with other nations in the region where the tribe may hold greater political significance.
- The state has implemented laws and regulations, such as Article 12 of the Basic Law of Governance and others, with substantial penalties (ranging up to 10 million riyals and imprisonment) for actions that incite tribalism. This indicates the seriousness with which the state takes the issue.
- Progress in Addressing Discrimination:
- The text acknowledges past instances of “scientific, professional and geographical racism” where individuals from tribal backgrounds faced discrimination in education and employment.
- However, it notes that, under the leadership of King Salman bin Abdulaziz and Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, discrimination based on tribal affiliation has been largely eliminated. “the criterion of preference is competence and entitlement, not ethnic affiliation or civilization,”. The text indicates a move towards meritocracy and away from the bias that existed in prior decades.
- Persistent Manifestations of Tribalism:
- Despite the legislative and governmental efforts, the text highlights that tribalistic tendencies are still apparent in some areas, with about 30 incidents in 2024. This includes the raising of tribal flags on national occasions, tribal themes in “Shila, series and Qalta poetry”, and cafes marketing in tribal names.
- These “limited” instances demonstrate that there is still a need to continue to work towards a comprehensive national identity. It suggests that the battle to shift the cultural emphasis of citizens away from tribe toward nation is ongoing.
- The Potential of Tribal Structures:
- While acknowledging the negative impacts of tribalism, Saudi sociologists recognize that tribes “include a set of values that can be built upon, especially in strengthening national unity, and in blood issues.”
- The text suggests the need to transform tribes into civil society institutions, leveraging their existing social frameworks for positive purposes. This signals a move to integrate, not abolish, tribal structures.
Conclusion:
The provided text offers a nuanced perspective on the issue of tribalism in Saudi Arabia. It acknowledges the deep historical roots of tribalism, its challenges to social cohesion and progress, and the government’s multi-pronged approach to managing and reforming it. Despite progress, there is an ongoing need to actively shape cultural norms and prevent the resurgence of tribalistic sentiments, as the Saudi state continues to aim for a unified national identity, in the context of the “modern civilization and Vision 2030.” The suggestion that tribal structures can evolve into civil society institutions points towards a future in which tribal values and the national identity can exist in harmony.
Tribalism and National Identity in Saudi Arabia
FAQ: Tribalism and National Identity in Saudi Arabia
- How do Saudi sociologists view the potential role of tribes in modern Saudi society?
- Saudi sociologists see tribes as having the potential to transform into civil society institutions. They believe that tribes possess a set of values that can be leveraged to strengthen national unity and resolve issues related to blood feuds. Furthermore, they see tribes, as a way of thinking, as playing an important role in refining the behavior of their members. This suggests a view of tribes not as relics of the past but as potential contributors to a more cohesive and civil society.
- What negative impacts has tribalism had on social development in Saudi Arabia?
- Tribal pride and fanaticism have been identified as obstacles to social development. The focus on tribal prestige and the desire to demonstrate superiority over other tribes have been linked to negative effects. Examples like the once-individual tribal camel beauty pageants, which incited tribal fanaticism, illustrate this. The desire for tribal superiority was identified as a primary source of these issues.
- How has the Saudi government addressed the issue of tribal fanaticism, particularly in the context of camel beauty pageants?
- The Saudi government has taken steps to address tribal fanaticism by taking control of the camel beauty pageant. The individual tribal pageants were replaced with the state-sponsored King Abdulaziz Camel Festival. This festival aims to foster a comprehensive national identity, replacing tribal biases, and aligning with the requirements of modern civilization and the nation’s Vision 2030 plan. This is a clear attempt to channel tribal pride into a more unified national expression.
- How has the Saudi government addressed issues of tribal-based discrimination in professional and educational settings?
- In the past, the sons of tribes faced scientific, professional, and geographical racism within government institutions. However, under the current leadership of King Salman bin Abdulaziz and Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, this discriminatory preference has been largely eradicated. Competence and merit are now the primary criteria, rather than ethnic affiliation or social status.
- Is tribalism a phenomenon unique to Saudi Arabia?
- No, tribalism is not unique to Saudi Arabia. It is a widespread cultural phenomenon across the Arab world, with significant influence in the Levant and the Maghreb. It plays roles in parliamentary elections in Kuwait and Jordan, controls oil wells in Libya, is a factor in the political landscape of Iraq, and influences political life and appointments in Lebanon. In Yemen, tribal consensus is vital for stability. Thus, tribalism is a regional phenomenon, with different levels of influence and power in different contexts.
- How does the role of tribes in Saudi Arabia differ from their role in other parts of the Arab region?
- Unlike many other Arab countries, Saudi Arabia’s ruling family does not have traditional tribal links. This allows them to stand at an equal distance from all societal components. The Saudi state, as a state of institutions, has been able to reframe and influence tribal tendencies, promoting individual responsibility and ownership, aligned with the concept of a modern civil state. In other nations, tribes can exert significant influence on political power, access to resources and can be at the heart of conflicts.
- What legal measures have been implemented in Saudi Arabia to counter the negative aspects of tribalism?
- Saudi Arabia has enacted several laws and regulations to control negative aspects of tribalism, such as Articles of the Basic Law of Governance, the Criminal Procedures Law, the Audiovisual Media Law, and the Anti-Cybercrime Law. These laws impose penalties for actions that incite tribalism or discrimination, including imprisonment, fines, and suspension of professional licenses. These measures indicate a serious commitment to combatting any tribal influence that undermines national unity.
- What types of actions still exemplify tribal biases in Saudi Arabia, and how are they being addressed?
- Despite legislation, tribal biases still surface in some instances, albeit limited in scope. These include actions like raising tribal flags on national occasions, tribal affiliations in talk shows, and the marketing of businesses using tribal names, and tribal influences in cultural productions like Shila, series and Qalta poetry. To counter this, there is a push to create a national plan that utilizes education and media to promote national unity and control these actions. In addition, sociologists seek to transform tribes into civil society institutions that align with national goals.
Tribalism in Saudi Arabia
Tribalism in Saudi Arabia is a complex issue with historical roots and modern manifestations [1, 2]. Here’s a breakdown of key points from the sources:
- Historical Context: Tribalism is not a new phenomenon, existing before Islam and causing wars that lasted for centuries [2]. Examples include the Dahis and Ghabra war, the Basus war, the Fijar war, and the Baath war [2].
- Tribalism and Social Development: Some Saudi studies have found that tribal pride and fanaticism can hinder social development, stemming from a desire to show superiority over other tribes [1]. Camel beauty pageants, which were once held individually by tribes, were seen as a cause for inciting tribal fanaticism [1]. The state intervened to hold the camel beauty pageant festival under the umbrella of the state, replacing tribal biases with a comprehensive national identity [1].
- Transformation of Tribes: Saudi sociologists believe that tribes should be transformed into civil society institutions, leveraging their existing values to strengthen national unity [1, 3]. They also believe that tribes play an important and decisive role in refining the behavior of their sons [1, 3].
- Tribalism in the Region: Tribal culture is not unique to Saudi Arabia, being present and influential in the Levant and the Maghreb [2]. It also plays a significant role in parliamentary elections in Kuwait and Jordan [2]. In other countries, it has a significant impact on political and economic issues. For example, tribes in Libya control oil wells, and in Iraq, they are a key part of the political landscape [2]. In Lebanon, tribalism is present in family and religious sects [2]. In Yemen, stability is tied to understanding and cooperation with tribes [2].
- Government efforts to control Tribalism: The Saudi ruling house is not linked to a traditional tribe, allowing it to stand at an equal distance from all components of Saudi society [4]. The government seeks to enhance individual ownership and responsibility, regardless of tribal affiliation [4]. The state is working to reformulate tribal tendencies by influencing and framing it to be in line with the national narrative [4].
- Legislative Measures: There are regulations in place to control negative aspects of tribalism [3]. These measures, controlled by the Basic Law of Governance, the Criminal Procedures Law, the Audiovisual Media Law, and the Anti-Cybercrime Law, include penalties like imprisonment, fines, and license suspensions [3].
- Contemporary Manifestations: Despite the government’s efforts, individual actions that reflect tribalism still occur [3]. These include: raising tribal flags on national occasions, tribal themes in media, and marketing businesses with tribal names [3]. There have been about 30 incidents monitored in 2024 [3].
- Combating negative aspects of Tribalism: The legislative aspect is comprehensive, but further work on the social level, in education and media is required [3]. This includes working on a national plan to control negative aspects of tribalism [3].
- Positive Aspects: The tribes have a set of values that can be built upon, especially in strengthening national unity [1, 3]. There has also been a shift in preferences with competency and entitlement being the main criteria, not ethnic affiliation, civilization, or social status [5].
Transforming Tribal Structures in Saudi Arabia
Transforming tribal structures in Saudi Arabia is a key focus of the government and sociologists, aiming to harness the positive aspects of tribalism while mitigating its negative impacts [1, 2]. Here’s a breakdown of the transformation efforts based on the sources:
- Civil Society Institutions: Saudi sociologists advocate for transforming tribes into civil society institutions [1, 2]. This is because tribes possess values that can be leveraged to strengthen national unity and address issues, particularly blood feuds [1]. The tribal way of thinking is seen as a means of refining the behavior of its members [1].
- Shifting from Tribal Bias to National Identity: The state is actively working to replace tribal biases with a comprehensive national identity, aligning with the requirements of modern civilization and Vision 2030 [1]. The King Abdulaziz Camel Festival is an example of how the state has taken over an event that was once cause for tribal conflict, replacing it with a national identity [1]. The state aims to move away from tribalism by promoting a national narrative where every citizen has equal standing [3].
- Promoting Individual Responsibility: The Saudi government is working to enhance individual ownership and a person’s responsibility for their actions, irrespective of their tribal affiliation [3]. The state wants to move away from the idea of “Labbat”, or tribal affiliation, and focus on the individual as a part of the nation [3].
- Addressing Negative Aspects: The government recognizes that tribal pride and fanaticism can hinder social development [1]. In the past, some members of government institutions exhibited racism against members of tribes. However, in the present time, competence and entitlement are the main criteria of preference, not ethnic affiliation or social status [4]. The state acknowledges that tribal actions still occur but are limited and works to address them via education and media [2].
- Legislative Measures: The government is using regulations to control the negative aspects of tribalism [2]. These include imprisonment, fines, and license suspensions for those who violate the laws [2]. The laws are comprehensive, however, further work on the social level is required to control negative actions [2].
- Government’s Unique Position: The Saudi ruling house is not connected to any traditional tribe and views itself as equal to all members of society, giving it the ability to stand at an equal distance from all components of Saudi society [3]. This allows the government to work to influence and frame the tribal tendencies in society [3].
In summary, the transformation of tribal structures involves leveraging the positive aspects of tribal values for national unity, while actively working to mitigate negative effects like fanaticism and discrimination. The government is using a combination of legislative measures, cultural events, and a national narrative to promote individual responsibility and national unity over tribal affiliations.
National Unity in Saudi Arabia
National unity and identity are central themes in the context of tribalism in Saudi Arabia, with the government actively working to foster a cohesive national identity that transcends tribal affiliations [1, 2]. Here’s a breakdown of how national unity and identity are addressed in the sources:
- Overcoming Tribalism: The sources indicate that tribal pride and fanaticism are seen as obstacles to social development, stemming from a desire to show superiority over other tribes [1]. To combat this, the Saudi state is actively promoting a comprehensive national identity to replace tribal biases [1].
- State’s Role in Fostering National Unity:
- The Saudi ruling house is not linked to a traditional tribe, positioning itself as a unifying force [2]. This allows it to stand at an equal distance from all components of Saudi society [2].
- The government aims to reformulate and influence tribal tendencies and to frame them in the context of a national narrative, much like other immigrant societies like Canada, the United States, and Australia [2].
- The state enhances individual ownership and responsibility for actions, irrespective of tribal affiliation [2]. This is a key step in building a sense of national identity that goes beyond tribal loyalties [2].
- The government is working to promote competence and entitlement as the main criteria of preference, not ethnic affiliation or social status, in order to establish national unity [3].
- Cultural Events and National Identity:
- Camel beauty pageants, once a source of tribal conflict, have been transformed into the King Abdulaziz Camel Festival. This festival promotes a comprehensive national identity, replacing tribal biases with a unified national event [1]. The state intervention in the camel beauty pageant demonstrates how it’s trying to build national unity [1].
- Legislative Measures for National Unity:
- The Saudi government has implemented regulations to control negative aspects of tribalism that can undermine national unity [4]. These measures, including imprisonment and fines, aim to curb actions that promote tribalism over national identity [4].
- The laws are comprehensive, but there is also a need for more work on a social level, in education and media, to promote national unity [4].
- Tribal Values and National Unity:
- Saudi sociologists believe that the values within tribes can be used to strengthen national unity [1, 4]. They advocate for transforming tribes into civil society institutions that can contribute positively to the broader society and promote national unity [1, 4].
- Tribes are seen as playing an important and decisive role in refining the behavior of their members [1, 4]. This function can contribute to a more cohesive and unified society when framed in a national context [1, 4].
- Challenges to National Unity: Despite efforts, there are still individual actions that reflect tribalism, such as raising tribal flags on national occasions or marketing businesses with tribal names [4]. These instances highlight the ongoing need for a national plan to control and address these actions [4].
In summary, the pursuit of national unity and identity in Saudi Arabia involves a multi-pronged approach. It includes the transformation of tribal structures, the promotion of a national narrative, and the implementation of legislative measures. While there are still challenges, the state is actively working to create a unified national identity that transcends tribalism, drawing on the positive values of tribes while mitigating their negative effects.
Combating Tribalism in Saudi Arabia
The legal framework in Saudi Arabia plays a crucial role in controlling and mitigating the negative aspects of tribalism, and it aims to promote national unity and a unified national identity. Here’s a breakdown of the legal measures based on the sources:
- Comprehensive Regulations: The Saudi government has implemented a set of regulations to control tribalism. These are primarily controlled by:
- Article 12 of the Basic Law of Governance [1]
- Articles 15 and 17 of the Criminal Procedures Law [1]
- Articles 5 and 17 of the Audiovisual Media Law [1]
- Article 6 of the Anti-Cybercrime Law [1] These laws form the basis for addressing actions related to tribalism that are deemed harmful to national unity [1].
- Penalties: Violations of these laws can lead to significant penalties, which are both administrative and criminal. These penalties include:
- Imprisonment: A period of one to five years [1]
- Fines: A minimum of 500,000 riyals (approximately $134,000) and a maximum of 10 million riyals (approximately $2,667,000) [1]
- Professional Suspension: Suspension from practicing a profession for up to six months for media-related violations [1]
- License Cancellation: Cancellation of licenses for media-related violations [1]
- Focus on Media: The regulations specifically target media, reflecting the government’s concern over the potential for media to incite tribalism or division [1]. The penalties related to media demonstrate the effort to control the spread of tribal sentiments that go against the national narrative [1].
- Addressing Contemporary Manifestations: Despite the comprehensive legislative measures, some individual actions that reflect tribalism still occur, though they are limited [1]. The government has monitored about 30 incidents in 2024 [1]. These include:
- Raising tribal flags on national occasions such as National Day and Founding Day [1]
- Tribal themes in media such as talk shows interested in the Al-Mazain Festival, in some Shila, series, and Qalta poetry [1]
- Marketing businesses, such as cafes, with tribal names [1] These incidents highlight that the legal framework is in place, but there is an ongoing need for further work on a national level [1].
- Legislative Adequacy: The sources state that the legislative aspect of controlling tribalism is comprehensive, suggesting that the existing laws are robust [1]. However, there is also recognition that these laws must be supported with efforts at the social level, in education and the media [1].
- National Plan: The limited instances of tribal actions highlight the need for a national plan to control them on the social level, in education, and media. The legal framework provides the tools, but the sources emphasize the need for continued effort [1].
In summary, the legal framework in Saudi Arabia is designed to deter tribalism through a combination of regulations and penalties. While the existing laws are considered comprehensive, there is an emphasis on the need for more work on the social level to reinforce national unity and counter actions that promote tribalism.
Modernization and Tribalism in Saudi Arabia
Modernization and tribal culture in Saudi Arabia represent a complex interplay, with the government actively seeking to integrate traditional tribal structures into a modern, unified nation. Here’s a breakdown of this dynamic based on the sources:
- Transformation of Tribal Structures: Saudi sociologists advocate for transforming tribes into civil society institutions, recognizing that tribes possess values that can be leveraged to strengthen national unity [1, 2]. This transformation involves building upon positive tribal values, especially in strengthening national unity, while mitigating negative aspects [1, 2].
- Shifting from Tribal to National Identity: A key aspect of modernization is the conscious effort to replace tribal biases with a comprehensive national identity [1]. This shift is aligned with the goals of modern civilization and Saudi Vision 2030 [1]. The government is working to move beyond tribalism, promoting a national narrative where every citizen has equal standing [3].
- Government’s Role: The Saudi ruling house is not linked to any specific tribe and views itself as equal to all members of society, thus giving it the ability to stand at an equal distance from all components of Saudi society [3]. This allows the government to influence and frame tribal tendencies in the context of national unity [3].
- Individual Responsibility: Modernization efforts in Saudi Arabia emphasize individual ownership and responsibility for actions, regardless of tribal affiliation [3]. This focus on the individual aims to move beyond tribal loyalties and create a society where merit and competence are valued [3, 4].
- Addressing Negative Aspects: The government recognizes that tribal pride and fanaticism can hinder social development [1]. In the past, some members of government institutions exhibited racism against members of tribes [4]. However, in the present time, competence and entitlement are the main criteria of preference, not ethnic affiliation or social status [4].
- Cultural Events: The King Abdulaziz Camel Festival is an example of how the state has taken over an event that was once a source of tribal conflict, replacing it with a national identity [1]. This festival demonstrates how cultural events can be used to promote modernization and national unity over tribal biases [1].
- Legislative Measures: The government has implemented a comprehensive set of regulations to control negative aspects of tribalism that can undermine national unity [2]. These laws include penalties like imprisonment and fines for violations [2]. The sources indicate that the legislative measures in place are comprehensive, but there is a need to reinforce those measures on a social level with education and media [2].
- Challenges to Modernization: Despite these efforts, some individual actions that reflect tribalism still occur [2]. Examples include raising tribal flags on national occasions or marketing businesses with tribal names [2]. These instances highlight the need for a continued effort to control these actions [2].
- Tribalism Beyond Saudi Arabia: It is important to note that the influence of tribalism is not unique to Saudi Arabia, as it is present and influential in the Levant and the Maghreb, and it plays an important role in parliamentary elections in the states of Kuwait and Jordan [5]. The sources note that in current Libya, the tribe controls some oil wells, and has geographical influence and borders. In post-Saddam Iraq, the tribe has become a difficult number in the political equation. In Lebanon, the tribe is present in the family and in the religious sect, and both of them influence political life and the appointment of people. Stability cannot be achieved and life cannot continue in Yemen except by understanding with the tribe and obtaining its blessing, or buying its silence [5].
In summary, modernization in Saudi Arabia involves a complex and deliberate effort to integrate tribal culture into a unified national framework. The government is actively working to mitigate the negative aspects of tribalism while leveraging the positive values for national unity. This process involves a combination of legal measures, cultural shifts, and the promotion of a comprehensive national identity, although challenges still exist.

By Amjad Izhar
Contact: amjad.izhar@gmail.com
https://amjadizhar.blog
Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!




