The provided text presents a psychological analysis of Jane Austen’s novels, focusing on character motivations and the author’s underlying values. It examines mimetic characterization, particularly in Mansfield Park, suggesting that Fanny Price embodies a self-effacing solution to basic anxiety, which the novel seems to glorify. The analysis contrasts this with Emma, where the protagonist’s narcissism and perfectionism are explored as defensive mechanisms, ultimately leading to a flawed “education.” Finally, the text considers Pride and Prejudice as a wish-fulfillment fantasy of an “expansive solution” and Persuasion as a nuanced exploration of duty and romance, while also categorizing Austen’s works through the lens of Horneyan psychology and her own potential personality trends.

A Study Guide to Bernard J. Paris’s Character and Conflict in Jane Austen’s Novels: A Psychological Approach

Quiz

1. According to Bernard Paris, what are the two main schools of thought concerning characterization in literature, and how do they differ in their approach to literary characters?
2. How does Paris utilize Karen Horney’s psychological theories in his analysis of Jane Austen’s characters? Briefly describe one of Horney’s “solutions” to basic anxiety and how Paris applies it to a specific Austen character.
3. In his analysis of Mansfield Park, how does Paris explain the contrasting moral development of Tom Bertram and Henry Crawford, despite their initial similarities in privilege?
4. According to Paris, what are the primary motivations and characteristics of the “narcissistic” personality type, and how does he apply this framework to the character of Emma Woodhouse?
5. Describe Fanny Price’s opposition to the play Lovers’ Vows in Mansfield Park, according to Paris’s psychological interpretation. What underlying fears and motivations drive her resistance?
6. How does Paris explain Henry Crawford’s initial and evolving interest in Fanny Price? What does he suggest motivates Henry’s desire to win her affection?
7. According to Paris, what is the central psychological conflict that prevents Emma Woodhouse from readily embracing marriage, even with someone she comes to care for like Mr. Knightley?
8. Explain Elizabeth Bennet’s initial negative reaction to Mr. Darcy’s proposal in Pride and Prejudice, according to Paris’s analysis. What aspects of Darcy’s behavior and her own character contribute to this rejection?
9. How does Paris interpret Elizabeth Bennet’s eventual acceptance of Darcy’s second proposal? Does he believe it signifies a fundamental change in her personality, and what factors contribute to her change of heart?
10. In his discussion of Persuasion, how does Paris frame the central conflict regarding Anne Elliot’s decision to break off her engagement with Captain Wentworth? What are the key questions he poses about this situation?

Answer Key for Quiz

1. Paris identifies two main schools: the “purists” and the “realists.” Purists argue that literary characters are purely constructs of the author’s design, existing solely within the fictional world for formal and thematic purposes. Realists, however, believe that characters acquire a degree of independence during the narrative and can be analyzed as if they were real human beings with psychological depth.
2. Paris employs Horney’s theories, particularly the concepts of basic anxiety and neurotic needs and solutions (moving toward, against, and away from people). For example, he might apply the “self-effacing solution” (moving toward) to Fanny Price, explaining her behavior as driven by a need for affection and approval to combat feelings of helplessness and worthlessness in her embedded position.
3. Paris argues that Edmund’s goodness is partly due to his being a younger son, which necessitates struggle and discipline. In contrast, Tom’s privileged position and poor influences lead to “thoughtlessness and selfishness.” Similarly, Henry’s “early independence” and the bad example of the Admiral result in his lack of responsibility and self-indulgence.
4. The narcissistic personality, according to Paris (drawing on Horney), seeks mastery through self-admiration and charm, possessing an unquestioned belief in their greatness. Paris applies this to Emma, highlighting her pride in her social position and abilities, her need for admiration, and her overestimation of her own judgment and capacity to control situations.
5. Paris interprets Fanny’s opposition to the play as stemming from her deep respect for Sir Thomas’s authority and her fear of challenging it. The choice of Lovers’ Vows compounds this as she perceives it as “improper.” Her refusal to participate and her censoriousness serve as defenses to reassure herself of her own goodness and avoid Sir Thomas’s potential disapproval.
6. Paris suggests Henry is initially drawn to Fanny by her moral rectitude, as a self-condemning aspect of his personality seeks her approval. His initial plan is to hurt her pride, but he becomes genuinely attracted to her. His desire to marry her is partly due to his lack of success in flirting and his wish to possess the qualities he sees in her, such as her affection and gratitude.
7. According to Paris, Emma’s reluctance to marry is primarily rooted in her complex relationship with her father. She feels that accepting a husband would be a betrayal of her father, as if she would be “killing” him and ceasing to be the devoted daughter. This conflict creates a strong tendency toward detachment in her.
8. Paris explains Elizabeth’s rejection as a result of wounded pride at Darcy’s condescending proposal, where he emphasizes her family’s inferiority and his own sense of degradation. Her own expansive nature and her perception of Darcy’s mistreatment of Wickham and interference with Jane and Bingley fuel her indignation and lead her to denounce his character.
9. Paris argues that Elizabeth’s eventual acceptance is less about a fundamental personality change and more about a restoration and inflation of her pride due to Darcy’s continued affection and the honor of his proposal, especially after the events involving Lydia. While she gains some self-knowledge, her core expansive tendencies remain.
10. Paris frames the central questions around whether Lady Russell’s advice to Anne was good or bad, whether Anne was right or wrong to follow it, and whether Wentworth’s response was justified. He suggests that the answers to these questions determine the reconciliation of the lovers, the vindication of Anne’s character, and the understanding of Austen’s proposed attitude toward life.

Essay Format Questions

1. Explore Bernard Paris’s argument that understanding Jane Austen’s characters through the lens of psychological theories, such as Karen Horney’s, offers a richer and more nuanced interpretation of their motivations and conflicts than purely formal or thematic approaches. Use specific examples from at least two of Austen’s novels discussed in the source material.
2. Analyze Bernard Paris’s concept of “dominating fantasies” in Jane Austen’s novels. How does he suggest these fantasies manifest in the plots and character interactions of Mansfield Park, Emma, and Pride and Prejudice?
3. Discuss Bernard Paris’s assertion that Jane Austen’s “code” involves a tension between sensibility and worldliness. How do various characters in Sense and Sensibility, Pride and Prejudice, and Persuasion embody or deviate from this code, and what are the consequences of their adherence or transgression?
4. Compare and contrast Bernard Paris’s psychological analyses of two of Jane Austen’s heroines, such as Fanny Price and Emma Woodhouse, or Elizabeth Bennet and Anne Elliot. What are the key psychological needs, defenses, and conflicts that Paris identifies in each character, and how do these shape their actions and relationships?
5. Evaluate Bernard Paris’s claim that the romantic resolutions in Jane Austen’s novels, particularly in Pride and Prejudice and Persuasion, are often less about profound personal transformation and more about the restoration of pride and the fulfillment of certain psychological needs.

Glossary of Key Terms

• Basic Anxiety: (Drawing from Karen Horney) A fundamental feeling of insecurity, isolation, and helplessness in a potentially hostile world, which arises in childhood and can drive neurotic behavior.
• Neurotic Needs: (Drawing from Karen Horney) Irrational and compulsive desires developed as attempts to cope with basic anxiety. These needs are often exaggerated, indiscriminate, and lead to internal conflict.
• Neurotic Solutions: (Drawing from Karen Horney) Three primary strategies individuals employ to deal with basic anxiety and fulfill their neurotic needs:
• Moving Toward (Self-Effacing Solution): Seeking affection, approval, and dependence on others.
• Moving Against (Expansive/Aggressive Solution): Seeking power, control, superiority, and recognition through achievement or dominance (can manifest as narcissistic, perfectionistic, or arrogant-vindictive types).
• Moving Away (Detached Solution): Seeking independence, self-sufficiency, and emotional distance to avoid being hurt or controlled.
• Idealized Image: (Drawing from Karen Horney) An inflated and unrealistic self-perception that neurotic individuals create to compensate for feelings of inadequacy and self-hatred. They strive to live up to this impossible image.
• Search for Glory: (Drawing from Karen Horney) The neurotic drive to actualize the idealized image, leading to relentless pursuit of external validation and a distorted sense of self-worth.
• Self-Alienation: (Drawing from Karen Horney) The process by which individuals lose touch with their real selves as they invest their energies in maintaining their idealized image and living according to neurotic needs and solutions.
• Mimesis: In literary theory, the imitation or representation of reality. Paris discusses how Austen’s characters relate to real psychological types.
• Form: In literary analysis, the structure and organization of a literary work, including plot, narrative techniques, and genre conventions. Paris examines how Austen’s characterization interacts with comic form.
• Theme: The underlying ideas or messages explored in a literary work. Paris analyzes how psychological characterization contributes to and sometimes conflicts with Austen’s thematic concerns.
• Expansive Types: (Paris’s term, drawing from Horney’s “moving against”) Characters who adopt aggressive strategies to master life and overcome anxiety, often characterized by pride, ambition, and a need for superiority.
• Self-Effacing Types: (Paris’s term, aligning with Horney’s “moving toward”) Characters who seek security and validation through compliance, dependence, and suppressing their own needs.
• Detached Types: (Paris’s term, aligning with Horney’s “moving away”) Characters who cope with anxiety by withdrawing emotionally and seeking independence and self-sufficiency.
• Perfectionistic Types: (A sub-type of expansive, according to Paris) Characters driven by exceptionally high standards, both for themselves and others, using these standards as a basis for superiority and a means of controlling fate.
• Narcissistic Types: (A sub-type of expansive, according to Paris) Characters who seek mastery through self-admiration and charm, possessing an inflated sense of self-importance and a need for constant admiration.
• Arrogant-Vindictive Types: (A sub-type of expansive, according to Paris) Characters motivated by a need for triumph over rivals, seeking to exploit and outsmart others to enhance their own position.
• Worldliness: (In the context of Austen’s novels, as interpreted by Paris) A focus on social status, wealth, and superficial appearances, often leading to manipulative and self-serving behavior.
• Sensibility (Cult of): An 18th-century movement emphasizing feeling and emotional responsiveness. Paris discusses Austen’s nuanced view of sensibility in relation to her moral code.

Briefing Document: Character and Conflict in Jane Austen’s Novels: A Psychological Approach

Source: Excerpts from “Character and Conflict in Jane Austen’s Novels A PSYCHOLOGICAL APPROACH” by Bernard J. Paris (1978)

Overview:

Bernard J. Paris’s “Character and Conflict in Jane Austen’s Novels: A Psychological Approach” offers a distinct perspective on Austen’s works by analyzing her characters through the lens of Karen Horney’s psychoanalytic theories. Paris argues against purely formalist interpretations of literary characters, suggesting that they possess a psychological reality and can be understood as individuals with their own motivations, defenses, and inner conflicts. The book examines four of Austen’s major novels – Mansfield Park, Emma, Pride and Prejudice, and Persuasion – and concludes with a discussion of Jane Austen’s own “authorial personality” as reflected in her creations.

Main Themes and Important Ideas:

1. The Psychological Reality of Literary Characters:

• Paris positions himself against the “purist” school of thought, which views literary characters solely as elements of authorial design for formal and thematic purposes. He cites Martin Mudrick’s description of this view, where “any effort to extract them from their context and to discuss them as if they were real human beings is a sentimental misunderstanding of the nature of literature.”
• Instead, Paris aligns with the “realists,” who believe that characters develop a degree of independence within the narrative and can be analyzed as if they were real people with psychological complexities.
• He acknowledges the inherent tension between the author’s design and the characters’ perceived autonomy, stating, “They ‘run away,’ they ‘get out of hand’: they are creations inside a creation, and often inharmonious towards it; if they are given complete freedom they kick the book to pieces, and if they are kept too sternly in check, they revenge themselves by dying, and destroy it by intestinal decay.”

1. Karen Horney’s Psychoanalytic Theories as a Framework:

• Paris explicitly utilizes Horney’s concepts of basic anxiety, neurotic needs, and “solutions” (moving toward, against, and away from people) to understand the underlying motivations and behaviors of Austen’s characters.
• He introduces Horney’s three “aggressive types”: the narcissistic, the perfectionistic, and the arrogant-vindictive, explaining their core drives and manifestations. The narcissistic person seeks mastery through “self-admiration and the exercise of charm,” the perfectionistic through “high standards, moral and intellectual,” and the arrogant-vindictive through “vindictive triumphs.”
• He also describes the “basically detached person” who “worships freedom and strives to be independent of both outer and inner demands,” handling a threatening world by removing themselves emotionally.
• The concept of the “idealized image” is crucial, where individuals compensate for feelings of weakness and worthlessness by creating an exaggeratedly positive self-perception, leading to a “search for glory.”

1. Psychological Analysis of Individual Novels and Characters:

• Mansfield Park: Paris analyzes Fanny Price as a character employing “self-effacing” strategies to cope with her feelings of weakness and worthlessness in the Bertram household. Her opposition to the play is linked to her fear of disobeying Sir Thomas’s authority. Henry Crawford is depicted as someone who became “thoughtless and selfish from prosperity and bad example,” exhibiting narcissistic traits. Edmund’s goodness is partly attributed to his status as a younger son requiring him to strive for his place.
• Emma: Emma Woodhouse is examined as having both “narcissistic and perfectionistic trends” induced by her environment. Her matchmaking attempts stem from her pride and need for control. Her relationship with her father and her fear of disrupting it contribute to her detachment from romantic love. The Box Hill incident is analyzed as a result of her repressed contempt for her father being displaced onto Miss Bates. Her eventual submission to Knightley is seen not as maturation but as a shift in defensive strategies.
• “With insufferable vanity had she believed herself in the secret of everybody’s destiny. She was proved to have been universally mistaken.”
• ” ‘Were I to fall in love,’ ” she tells Harriet, ” ‘indeed, it would be a different thing! But I have never been in love: it is not my way or nature; and I do not think I ever shall.’ “
• Pride and Prejudice: Elizabeth Bennet, while possessing many admirable qualities, is analyzed for her “expansive” tendencies and her father’s influence on her detached and critical perspective. Her initial dislike of Darcy is attributed to her wounded pride. Darcy’s proud and self-indulgent manners are shown to stem from his upbringing. His transformation is driven by Elizabeth’s rejection, which forces him into self-examination and a painful dependency. Elizabeth’s eventual acceptance is partly linked to the restoration and inflation of her pride.
• ” ‘She is tolerable; but not handsome enough to tempt me; and I am in no humour at present to give consequence to young ladies who are slighted by other men.’ ” (Darcy’s initial remark about Elizabeth)
• ” ‘I was spoiled by my parents, who … allowed, encouraged, almost taught me to be selfish and over-bearing, to care for none beyond my own family circle, to think meanly of all the rest of the world.’ ” (Darcy’s self-assessment)
• Persuasion: Anne Elliot is portrayed as employing “self-effacing” strategies due to her past rejection and her family’s coldness. Her adherence to Lady Russell’s advice is explored in terms of its consequences for her happiness. Captain Wentworth is depicted as a “strong, masterful, self-assertive male” whose confidence is ultimately validated. Anne’s moral objections to Mr. Elliot highlight her internal values.
• Anne feels the application of Wentworth’s conversation about firmness to herself “in a nervous thrill all over”; and Wentworth gives her a “quick, conscious look.”

1. Jane Austen’s Authorial Personality:

• The final chapter delves into Austen’s own psychological makeup as inferred from her novels. Paris suggests that her works reflect a tension between “expansive” and “self-effacing” tendencies within her.
• He argues that Austen critiques characters who embody the extremes of the “cult of sensibility” (infantile self-indulgence) and “worldliness” (callous pursuit of self-interest).
• Her “code heroes and heroines” often possess strong egos and navigate the complexities of feeling and morality with prudence and principle.
• Paris identifies dominating fantasies in Austen’s novels, often involving the triumph of a deserving protagonist and the correction of pride and folly.

Quotes Highlighting Key Arguments:

• On the nature of literary characters: “For they have these numerous parallels with people like ourselves, they try to live their own lives and are con-sequently often engaged in treason against the main scheme of the book.”
• On the “purist” view of characterization: “any effort to extract them from their context and to discuss them as if they were real human beings is a sentimental misunderstanding of the nature of literature.”
• On the aggressive neurotic types: “They all ‘aim at mas-tering life. This is their way of conquering fears and anxieties: this gives meaning to their lives and gives them a certain zest for living.’”
• On the idealized image: “In this process he endows himself with unlimited powers and with exalted faculties; he becomes a hero, a genius, a supreme lover, a saint, a god.”
• On Emma’s narcissistic tendencies: “Narcissism means ‘being “in love with one’s idealized image.” ‘”
• On Darcy’s transformation: “Your reproof, so well applied, I shall never forget: ‘had you behaved in a more gentleman-like manner.’ Those were your words. You know not, you can scarcely conceive, how they have tortured me;-though it was some time, I confess, before I was reasonable enough to allow their justice.”
• On the limitations of purely aesthetic interpretation: “It does not do justice to a whole range of human qualities which make people with similar defenses very different from each other and quite variable in their attractiveness and humanity.”

Conclusion:

Paris’s psychological approach offers a rich and nuanced understanding of Jane Austen’s characters, moving beyond surface descriptions and plot functions to explore their underlying motivations and inner lives. By applying Horney’s theories, he illuminates the defensive strategies and neurotic trends that shape their behaviors and drive the conflicts within the novels. While acknowledging the author’s design, Paris emphasizes the psychological coherence and complexity of Austen’s creations, inviting readers to engage with them as individuals grappling with universal human anxieties and needs.

FAQ on Character and Conflict in Jane Austen’s Novels (Based on Bernard J. Paris’s “A Psychological Approach”)

1. What are the two main schools of thought regarding literary characterization, according to Martin Mudrick, and how does Bernard Paris position Jane Austen’s work in relation to them? The two main schools of thought are the “purists” and the “realists.” Purists argue that literary characters are creations entirely within the author’s design, determined by formal and thematic considerations, and should not be analyzed as if they were real people with independent psychological histories. Realists, conversely, insist that characters in the course of a narrative acquire a degree of independence and can be understood in ways analogous to real individuals. Bernard Paris, advocating for a psychological approach, aligns more with the realist perspective, arguing that understanding Austen’s characters as individuals with psychological motivations enhances our appreciation of her work. He believes that their internal lives and conflicts often operate with a logic that extends beyond mere thematic or formal requirements.

2. How does Bernard Paris utilize Karen Horney’s psychological theories to analyze Jane Austen’s characters and their conflicts? Paris employs Horney’s framework, particularly her concepts of neurotic needs, the three interpersonal trends (moving toward, against, and away from people), and the idealized self-image, to provide in-depth analyses of Austen’s characters. He examines how characters like Fanny Price, Emma Woodhouse, and Elizabeth Bennet develop defensive strategies to cope with basic anxiety and feelings of inadequacy. For instance, he identifies Emma’s narcissistic and perfectionistic trends as ways she attempts to master life through self-admiration and high standards. Similarly, he analyzes Fanny’s self-effacing tendencies as a means of navigating a threatening world by seeking love and approval. By applying these psychological lenses, Paris aims to uncover the underlying motivations and intrapsychic conflicts that drive the characters’ actions and relationships.

3. In his analysis of Mansfield Park, how does Paris explain the contrasting character development of Edmund Bertram and Henry Crawford through a psychological lens? Paris attributes the differences between Edmund and Henry to their early life circumstances and the development of their character structures. Edmund, as a younger son facing hardship and the need to earn his place, develops a stronger moral compass. Henry Crawford, on the other hand, is presented as someone “ruined by early independence,” whose prosperity and the bad example of the Admiral lead him to become “thoughtless and selfish.” Paris suggests that Henry’s lack of responsibility and developed moral sense stems from not having faced the same pressures and disciplines as Edmund. Even Henry’s attraction to Fanny is analyzed through this lens, as a fleeting admiration for her moral rectitude that ultimately cannot overcome his ingrained self-indulgence.

4. According to Paris, what are Emma Woodhouse’s primary psychological flaws, and how do they manifest in her behavior and relationships? Paris identifies Emma’s primary psychological flaws as narcissistic and perfectionistic trends stemming from her early environment as a favored and admired child. Her narcissism leads to an overinflated ego, a belief in her superior judgment, and a need for self-aggrandizement, manifesting in her matchmaking attempts and her conviction that she can control others’ destinies. Her perfectionism drives her to maintain high moral and intellectual standards, leading her to look down on others and experience intense self-hate when she recognizes her own errors. These flaws result in her misjudgments of character, her interference in Harriet Smith’s life, her insulting behavior towards Miss Bates, and her initial blindness to Mr. Knightley’s merits.

5. How does Paris interpret Elizabeth Bennet’s character, particularly her wit and charm, in relation to her underlying defensive strategies? While acknowledging Elizabeth’s positive qualities, Paris argues that her wit, charm, vitality, and intelligence also serve as defensive strategies. Drawing parallels with her father, Mr. Bennet, he suggests that Elizabeth employs detachment and a focus on the absurdities of others as a way to cope with her family’s social awkwardness and her mother’s lack of approval. Her pride and quick retorts, especially in her interactions with Darcy, are seen as ways to protect herself from feeling inferior and to assert her own worth. Despite these defenses, Paris emphasizes that Elizabeth is not fundamentally detached but rather expansive, with high self-esteem and expectations.

6. What is the significance of Darcy’s initial rejection of Elizabeth and her subsequent reactions from a psychological perspective, as analyzed by Paris? Darcy’s initial dismissive remark deeply wounds Elizabeth’s pride, particularly because she is an expansive person with a high opinion of herself and because the rejection comes from someone of his social standing. Elizabeth’s angry and defensive reactions, including her determination not to like him, are interpreted by Paris as a natural response to this mortification. Her later misperceptions of Darcy’s behavior at Netherfield and Rosings are also viewed through the lens of her wounded pride and her tendency to project her own feelings of superiority onto him. The proposal scene becomes a moment of triumph for Elizabeth, where she retaliates for past injuries and gratifies her pride by rejecting such a significant man.

7. In his chapter on Persuasion, how does Paris analyze Anne Elliot’s character in terms of self-effacement and her journey toward vindication? Paris portrays Anne Elliot as a basically self-effacing character who has internalized the negative judgments of her family and Lady Russell regarding her past engagement with Captain Wentworth. Her decision to break off the engagement, though seemingly prudent at the time, has led to years of regret and a diminished sense of self-worth. Paris highlights Anne’s tendency to prioritize the needs and opinions of others over her own, a hallmark of the self-effacing trend. The novel’s plot becomes her journey toward vindication, as Wentworth eventually recognizes her worth and the error of his own initial judgment. Her quiet strength and genuine sensibility are contrasted with the coldness and superficiality of her family, ultimately leading to her triumph and the validation of her character and her feelings.

8. What does Paris suggest about Jane Austen’s own “authorial personality” in relation to the characters and themes she portrays in her novels? Paris posits that Jane Austen’s authorial personality is complex and can be understood through the psychological dynamics reflected in her works. He identifies elements of detachment, irony, and a critical perspective in her narrative voice, suggesting that Austen herself may have employed similar defenses to navigate the social world. Her creation of a range of character types, from the expansive to the self-effacing, and her exploration of the conflicts arising from different psychological needs and defenses, reflect a keen understanding of human nature. Furthermore, Paris argues that Austen’s thematic concerns often revolve around the tension between societal expectations and individual desires, and the process by which characters learn self-knowledge and achieve a more balanced and realistic self-perception, potentially mirroring aspects of her own psychological development and understanding of the world.

Mimetic Characterization: Realism, Form, and Theme in Literature

Mimetic characterization is a type of character portrayal in literature that aims at verisimilitude and the realistic representation of human beings. According to Robert Scholes and Robert Kellogg, behind realistic fiction, there is a strong “psychological impulse” that “tends toward the presentation of highly individualized figures who resist abstraction and generalization”. When we encounter a fully drawn mimetic character, “we are justified in asking questions about his motivation based on our knowledge of the ways in which real people are motivated”.

The sources contrast mimetic characterization with other types:

• Aesthetic characters primarily serve technical functions or create formal patterns and dramatic impact.
• Illustrative characters are most important in works with a strong allegorical or thematic interest. They are “concepts in anthropoid shape or fragments of the human psyche parading as whole human beings”. We understand them through the principle they illustrate.

Jane Austen’s mature novels are noted for their mimetic characterization. Her protagonists, such as Elizabeth Bennet, Fanny Price, Emma Woodhouse, and Anne Elliot, are realistically portrayed women, each fascinating and comprehensible in terms of her own motivational system. The author takes over “the life by values as well as the life in time,” creating characters with “numerous parallels with people like ourselves”. Because of this lifelikeness and complexity, readers have always responded to these characters.

However, the source argues that mimetic characterization in realistic novels, including Austen’s, often creates tensions with form and theme.

• Conflict with Form: Comic structure, for example, follows the logic of desire and can involve manipulation and improbable resolutions. Realistic characterization, on the other hand, follows the logic of motivation, probability, and cause and effect. This can lead to a “disturbing sense of disjunction” for the reader when the world is manipulated for comic effect, as the reader expects a consistently realistic world for realistic characters.
• Conflict with Theme: Mimetic characters tend to escape the categories by which the author tries to understand them and can undermine the author’s evaluation of their life styles and solutions. The author’s understanding of a mimetic character is often oversimple, and seeing the character solely through the author’s eyes sacrifices their complexity. Furthermore, a reader’s judgment of a mimetic character, understood psychologically, may differ from the author’s.

To fully appreciate Austen’s genius in characterization, the source advocates approaching her major figures “as creations inside a creation” and trying to understand them as though they were real people. This involves employing the “realist’s” approach to characterization, which recognizes that fully realized characters can have a life of their own and should be understood in motivational terms.

The source proposes using psychological theory, particularly that of Karen Horney and other Third Force psychologists, to analyze Austen’s characters and understand their motivations, defense mechanisms, and inner conflicts. This approach allows for a detailed explication of the text by focusing on the psychological processes dramatized by the author, without relying on speculation beyond the text. Understanding Austen’s characters psychologically can reveal that the combination of mimetic characterization, comic action, and moral theme poses artistic problems, as the conventions of comedy and the logic of realistic motivation can be incompatible.

Austen’s Comic Structure and Mimetic Characterization

Comic structure in literature, as discussed in the source, follows a basic movement “from threatening complications to a happy ending”. According to Northrop Frye, whose theories are used to analyze comic structures, the happy ending in Jane Austen’s novels typically involves the heroine gaining the love of a good man, the security and prestige of a desirable marriage, and the recognition of personal worth she deserves. The obstacles to the heroine’s desire form the action of the comedy, and the overcoming of them constitutes the comic resolution.

Key elements of comic structure include:

• Manipulation: There is often a degree of manipulation involved in both creating and removing the blocking forces and in achieving the final resolution. Frye notes that “Happy endings do not impress us as true, but as desirable, and they are brought about by manipulation”. This can include unlikely conversions, miraculous transformations, and providential assistance, which are considered inseparable from comedy. Jane Austen, writing in a low mimetic mode (where the hero is “one of us”), disguises some of these irrationalities through displacement but also signals early on that the story operates within the conventions of comedy.
• Moralization of Comic Action: Jane Austen harmonizes form and theme by moralizing the comic action. Her satire targets personality traits, failures of judgment, and social distortions that hinder the happiness of good and sensitive people. Her moral norms are derived from the existing society at its best, and her conservative value system is reinforced by the comic apparatus of rewards and punishments.
• Liberalism vs. Conservatism: While comedy is generally liberal, celebrating the triumph of wish over reality, Austen’s comedy displays a displacement not only towards the plausible but also towards the moral. The wishes fulfilled in her novels are highly socialized, and primitive or selfish desires are rarely indulged. This can sometimes lead to the reader feeling less elation at the outcome, as sobriety and societal norms seem to triumph over youth and freedom.
• Role of Protagonist: The wish fulfillment aspect of comedy often works best when the protagonist has a certain neutrality, allowing them to represent desire. However, Jane Austen’s protagonists are highly individualized human beings, with whom readers may not readily identify, making it harder to fully embrace the comic resolution.

Tensions with Mimetic Characterization: As we discussed previously, Jane Austen is also a creator of brilliant mimetic characterizations, where characters are realistically portrayed with their own motivational systems. This creates a tension with the demands of comic structure.

• Conflicting Expectations: Readers who are sensitive to both comic form and realistic characterization may experience conflicting sets of expectations: one for the emotional satisfactions of overcoming obstacles and the triumph of desire (from the comic structure) and another for the pleasures of recognition derived from verisimilitude (from mimetic characterization).
• Manipulation vs. Motivation: While comic plots might be manipulated for a happy ending, Austen’s fully realized mimetic characters tend to remain true to their own natures. When the world of these realistic characters is manipulated for the sake of comic action, it can create a sense of disjunction for the reader. This problem would be less pronounced if the protagonists were simply neutral figures or stock types within the plot.

In summary, comic structure provides the framework for a journey from complications to a happy resolution in Jane Austen’s novels. However, her commitment to mimetic characterization and serious moral themes introduces complexities and potential tensions, as the demands of a conventional comic plot can sometimes clash with the realistic motivations and inherent natures of her deeply developed characters. The reader’s engagement with these realistic characters can lead to expectations that are not always fully satisfied by the often somewhat contrived nature of comic resolutions.

Jane Austen: Morality, Comedy, and Character

Moral theme is a central and pervasive aspect of Jane Austen’s novels, deeply intertwined with her comic structure and her creation of mimetic characters. Austen employs her narratives to explore and reinforce a strict and narrow notion of goodness, often using the comic apparatus of rewards and punishments to underscore her essentially conservative value system.

Here are key aspects of moral theme in Austen’s work, drawing from the sources:

• Moralization of Comic Action: Austen harmonizes form and theme by moralizing the comic action. The obstacles her heroines face and the journey towards a happy ending are often tied to failures of education and judgment or distortions of social customs that create pain and uncertainty for good individuals. The resolution of the comedy frequently involves characters learning moral lessons and adhering to societal norms.
• Conservative Value System: Austen’s moral framework is presented as conservative, where no happiness is possible outside of societal institutions and no deviation from its values is ultimately successful. She places a high value on individual fulfillment, but this is contingent upon first being good, according to her defined standards. The happy endings often reinforce this system through rewards for virtue and implicit or explicit punishments for vice.
• Satire of Moral Failings: Austen’s satire is directed at those traits of personality that lead to moral errors and social disharmony. This includes selfishness, stupidity, ill-nature, self-indulgence, pride, ambition, materialism, and vanity. Characters who embody these failings often serve as cautionary examples within the narrative.
• Education and Moral Growth: Several novels, particularly Mansfield Park and Emma, explore the theme of education as a process of moral development. Austen emphasizes the importance of nurture in shaping character, highlighting the contrast between spoiled and unspoiled children and the consequences of privilege versus hardship. While some characters seem inherently sensible, others need to learn and grow morally through experience, suffering, and good example.
• The Ideal of Goodness: Austen presents a specific ideal of goodness, often embodied in characters like Fanny Price and Elinor Dashwood. This ideal typically includes traits such as prudence, judgment, good sense, self-knowledge, sensitivity, perceptiveness, propriety, civility, self-control, sincerity, integrity, respect for authority, dutifulness, responsibility, unselfishness, consideration of others, self-denial, humility, and gratitude.
• Tensions with Comic Liberalism: While comedy is generally “on the side of desire” and celebrates the “triumph of wish over reality,” Austen’s moral conservatism introduces a displacement in the direction of the moral. The wishes that are fulfilled are often highly socialized, and the reader may sometimes find it difficult to feel elation at outcomes that prioritize sobriety and social propriety over youthful exuberance.
• Interaction with Mimetic Characterization: The source argues that Austen’s commitment to mimetic characterization can create tension with her moral themes. Her realistic characters, with their own complex motivations, may not always align neatly with the author’s moral framework or the demands of the comic plot. Readers who engage with these characters as “real people” may have different judgments about their actions and outcomes than the author intends. For instance, the source critiques the celebration of Fanny Price’s goodness, suggesting it stems from fear rather than genuine benevolence. Similarly, the analysis of Emma questions the completeness and healthiness of her moral growth.
• Austen’s Code of Values: The source identifies a consistent code of values and conduct that serves as the norm in Austen’s fiction. Characters are judged based on their adherence to this code, which encompasses various aspects of life, from family relations to social intercourse. Those who embrace or come to embrace this code generally gain Austen’s sympathy and approval.

In conclusion, moral theme is a foundational element of Jane Austen’s novels, shaping her comic structures and influencing the reader’s perception of her mimetic characters. While her works aim to reward virtue and uphold a conservative moral order, the depth and realism of her characterizations can sometimes lead to complex interpretations and potential tensions between the author’s intended moral message and the reader’s psychological understanding of her creations.

Fanny Price: Character Analysis in Mansfield Park

Fanny Price is the central protagonist of Jane Austen’s novel Mansfield Park, and her character is a complex subject of analysis when considering the novel’s comic structure, moral themes, and mimetic characterization.

• Fanny’s Role in the Comic Structure: Fanny functions as the heroine of the comic plot in Mansfield Park. The central action revolves around the creation and removal of obstacles to her desire for Edmund Bertram. Her primary obstacle is Edmund’s affection for Mary Crawford, which is resolved when Mary’s flawed character is revealed, allowing Edmund to transfer his affections to Fanny. From Fanny’s perspective, the story has a “miraculously happy ending” as she is united with the man she loves. Furthermore, the novel follows a “Cinderella story” archetype, where Fanny, initially treated as socially and personally inferior, eventually gains the esteem of Sir Thomas and Lady Bertram, the love of desirable men, and recognition for her virtue and perceptiveness. The happy ending brings her the “full acceptance for which she has yearned and the recognition and respect which she deserves”.
• Fanny as an Illustrative Character and Moral Theme: Thematically, Mansfield Park can be seen as a “novel of education,” although the source argues that it is not Fanny who is primarily educated, but rather the people around her who learn to appreciate her worth and share her values. Fanny largely remains the same, serving as a standard of goodness against which other characters are measured. The novel seems to glorify “early hardship and discipline” as formative influences, which Fanny embodies. Her “goodness” is consistently emphasized, and she is portrayed as having “some touches of the angel”. However, the source questions Austen’s “celebration of hardship, struggle, and suffering” and its supposed positive effects.
• Fanny as a Mimetic Character and Psychological Analysis: The source argues that Fanny is a “highly realized mimetic character” whose human qualities are “not compatible with her aesthetic and thematic roles”. Psychologically, Fanny is depicted as a product of a “pathogenic environment” at home, leading to insecurity, low self-esteem, and a lack of selfhood and spontaneity. She develops “socially sanctioned but personally crippling defensive strategies” in response. Key psychological traits of Fanny include:
• Self-effacing tendencies: She is “exceedingly timid and shy, and shrinking from notice”. She seeks to be “lowest and last” and avoids attention, competition, and triumph.
• Basic anxiety: She feels weak, worthless, inconsequential, and inadequate, living in constant fear and searching for a protector.
• Need for reassurance and protection: She seeks this by being useful and compliant, attaching herself to stronger figures like Edmund and eventually Sir Thomas.
• Suppressed emotions: She represses feelings like resentment and envy, often experiencing feelings she believes she should have rather than her genuine emotions.
• Embeddedness: She craves stability, peace, and order, clinging to familiar people and the environment of Mansfield Park.
• Tension Between Mimesis and Theme/Aesthetics: The source highlights a significant conflict between Austen’s portrayal of Fanny as a psychologically damaged individual and the novel’s rhetoric, which aims at her glorification. Many readers find it difficult to identify with or admire Fanny in the way the author intends, perceiving her as “insipid” or a “prig”. This difficulty arises because when Fanny is understood psychologically, her “goodness” appears to be the product of fear and a desperate need for acceptance rather than genuine benevolence. Austen seems to “glorify suffering” and believe in its positive formative effects, but her own portrayal of Fanny reveals the “crippling effects of Fanny’s childhood upon her personality”.
• Fanny’s Relationships:
• Edmund: He is Fanny’s “most consistent champion” from the beginning, recognizing her true worth and offering her kindness and support. She views him as her mentor, moral superior, friend, champion, and protector.
• Sir Thomas: Initially unsympathetic, Sir Thomas eventually becomes Fanny’s protector and comes to value her virtue. His approval is of paramount importance to Fanny.
• Mrs. Norris: Fanny’s “chief persecutor,” who constantly demeans and tries to subordinate her. Fanny is terrified of Mrs. Norris and tries to conform to her expectations.
• Henry Crawford: He is initially attracted to Fanny as a challenge and later appreciates her virtues, though he does not fully understand them. Fanny, however, is wary of his “corrupted mind” and cannot reconcile his moral character with her own values, ultimately refusing his proposal.
• Key Episodes:
• The Play: Fanny opposes the play due to her respect for Sir Thomas’s authority and her dread of exposing herself to attention.
• Refusal of Henry Crawford: This act, while morally consistent for Fanny, leads to Sir Thomas’s displeasure and intense distress for Fanny, highlighting her need for his approval.
• Visit to Portsmouth: This episode reveals Fanny’s “snobbish attitudes and unattractive behavior” toward her own family, stemming from her longing for the order and propriety of Mansfield Park and her resentment of her neglectful upbringing.
• Return to Mansfield Park: Fanny experiences “exquisite happiness” at her return, even amidst the disgrace of her cousins, highlighting her self-centeredness resulting from her past deprivations.
• Mansfield Park as Wish Fulfillment: The source suggests that Mansfield Park can be interpreted as a “wish fulfillment fantasy of embeddedness” for Fanny. She does not psychologically mature but finds security and acceptance in the familiar world of Mansfield Park, where her goodness is recognized, her persecutors are removed, and she achieves a desirable marriage.

In conclusion, Fanny Price is a complex character whose portrayal reveals a tension between the author’s thematic intentions and her insightful mimetic characterization. While Austen aims to present Fanny as a moral exemplar deserving of her happy ending, the psychological analysis suggests a deeply insecure individual whose “goodness” is a defense mechanism. This discrepancy can lead to a divergence between the author’s and the reader’s response to Fanny and the moral landscape of Mansfield Park.

Jane Austen: Tensions, Themes, and Character Psychology

Based on the sources and our conversation history, a discussion of Jane Austen reveals her as a highly skilled novelist whose works are rich with complex characterizations and explorations of social and moral themes, although they are not without internal tensions.

Here are some key aspects of Jane Austen as presented in the source:

• A Master of Multiple Dimensions: Jane Austen is recognized as a “great comic artist, a serious interpreter of life, and a creator of brilliant mimetic characterizations”. Some critics believe she achieves a unique balance among these aspects of her art.
• Tensions in Her Novels: The central thesis of the source is that Austen’s mature novels are “beset by tensions between form, theme, and mimesis”. This arises partly from the fact that her protagonists often serve aesthetic, illustrative, and mimetic functions simultaneously. As “creations inside a creation,” these characters can act in ways that are “often engaged in treason against the main scheme of the book”. Because they have “numerous parallels with people like ourselves,” they require understanding in terms of their motivations, similar to real individuals.
• Psychological Depth: The source emphasizes Austen’s “brilliant but least recognized achievement” in mimetic characterization. Characters like Elizabeth Bennet, Fanny Price, Emma Woodhouse, and Anne Elliot are portrayed as “realistically” and “fascinating” women, comprehensible through their own “motivational system”. To fully appreciate Austen’s genius, her major figures need to be understood as “creations inside a creation” and analyzed as if they were real people. The book utilizes Horneyan psychology to analyze these characters, focusing on their “strategies of defense and the structure of inner conflicts”.
• Moral and Social Themes: Austen’s novels are deeply concerned with moral themes and the relationship between the individual and society. She moralizes the comic action, directing her satire at “traits of personality, at those failures of education and judgment, and at those distortions of social customs and institutions which make daily life painful”. Her works often reinforce a conservative value system, where happiness is generally found within societal norms and individual fulfillment is linked to being “good” according to her defined standards.
• Comedy with Moral Underpinnings: While writing comedy, Austen’s moral conservatism can sometimes “diminish some of her comic effects”. Unlike typical comedy that celebrates the triumph of desire, Austen’s fulfilled wishes are often “highly socialized,” and primitive or selfish desires are rarely indulged. This can lead to situations where readers may not fully identify with the heroines’ desires or feel complete elation at the outcomes.
• The Authorial Personality: The source aims to reconstruct the “personality which can be inferred from all of Jane Austen’s writings,” referring to this as her “authorial personality”. This involves considering her “recurring preoccupations, the personal element in his fantasies, the kinds of characters he creates, and his rhetorical stance”. Critics hold diverse views of Austen, some emphasizing her “aggressive, satirical component,” others her “gentleness and conservatism,” and still others her “detached, ironic quality”. The source attempts to show how these diverse components are related within a structure of inner conflicts.
• Austen’s Code of Values: A “code of values and conduct” serves as the “norm by which all deviations are satirized and judged” in Austen’s fiction. Characters who align with or come to embrace this code generally receive Austen’s sympathy and approval. This code contrasts with the “cult of sensibility” and “worldliness,” both of which Austen critiques.
• Psychological Solutions: The source analyzes Austen’s characters through the lens of different Horneyan psychological “solutions”: expansive (aggressive), self-effacing (compliant), and detached. Austen displays a mixed attitude towards the expansive and detached solutions, while the self-effacing solution is often supported, though sometimes with irony towards simpler characters embodying it. The authorial personality is also described as having perfectionistic trends.
• Development and Dominating Fantasies: By examining Austen’s novels in chronological order of composition, the source identifies “striking shifts of direction” and suggests that each novel embodies a predominantly different fantasy related to these psychological solutions. For example, Pride and Prejudice embodies a predominantly expansive fantasy, while Mansfield Park glorifies the self-effacing solution.
• Reader Interpretation vs. Authorial Intention: The source acknowledges that readers may have interpretations of characters and outcomes that differ from Jane Austen’s explicit rhetoric. This is attributed to the mimetic depth of her characters, who can evoke responses based on psychological realism that may not align with the author’s formal or thematic goals. Our previous discussion of Fanny Price exemplifies this, where the source argues that Austen glorifies her self-effacing nature while a psychological analysis reveals a more complex and potentially unhealthy motivation.

In summary, Jane Austen is presented as a multifaceted author whose comedic novels delve into serious moral and social issues through richly developed, psychologically complex characters. The source highlights the inherent tensions within her works arising from the interplay between comic form, thematic intentions, and the mimetic realism of her characterizations. Furthermore, it explores the inferred complexities of Austen’s own personality as reflected in her diverse characters and narrative choices.

By Amjad Izhar
Contact: amjad.izhar@gmail.com
https://amjadizhar.blog

Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!

This text serves as a literary travel guide, highlighting various locations across the globe that hold significance to renowned authors and their works. It details historic houses, museums, libraries, hotels, pubs, and even natural landscapes that inspired literary creations or were frequented by famous writers. The guide provides information on visiting these sites, often including addresses, contact details, and descriptions of what makes them special. From Shakespeare’s birthplace to Hemingway’s favorite bars and the landscapes of Brontë’s novels, the source connects readers with the real-world settings behind beloved literature. Furthermore, it lists literary festivals, tours, and other related attractions for book enthusiasts. Essentially, it invites readers to embark on a journey to experience literature in a tangible way.

A Journey Through Literary Landmarks: A Study Guide

Quiz

1. Describe the significance of Shakespeare’s Birthplace in Stratford-upon-Avon. What types of artifacts might a visitor expect to see there?
2. Why is the Abbey Theatre in Dublin considered a symbol of the Irish literary revival? Name at least two of its co-founders and their goals for the theater.
3. Explain Henrik Ibsen’s importance to modern drama. What kind of social commentary did his plays often deliver, and what was the public’s reaction during his lifetime?
4. What inspired William Wordsworth to write many of his famous poems while living at Dove Cottage? Mention a key aspect of the lifestyle he and his sister Dorothy embraced there.
5. Describe the experiences of George Sand and Frédéric Chopin during their winter stay in the Valldemossa monastery in Majorca. How did this period affect Chopin’s health and his relationship with Sand?
6. What were Jack London’s aspirations for Beauty Ranch in Sonoma Valley? What principles of agriculture did he aim to implement on his property?
7. Explain the connection between Robert Burns and the Auld Kirk Alloway. How did the site inspire his poem “Tam o’ Shanter”?
8. Why did James Joyce choose the Martello tower at Sandycove Point as the setting for the opening of Ulysses? Who was residing in the tower when Joyce stayed there?
9. Discuss the contrasting perspectives of Jane Austen and her characters regarding the city of Bath. What might have contributed to Austen’s personal feelings about the town?
10. Describe the enduring legacy of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson at 221b Baker Street. What can visitors experience at the Sherlock Holmes Museum?

Answer Key

1. Shakespeare’s Birthplace is significant as the house where William Shakespeare was born and spent his early life. Visitors can expect to see original and replica furnishings from the Elizabethan era, providing a glimpse into his family life and the times he lived in, including his father’s glove-making workshop and a traditional English garden.
2. The Abbey Theatre is a symbol of the Irish literary revival because it was established with the goal of staging works reflecting Irish culture and fostering new Irish playwrights. Its co-founders included W. B. Yeats and Lady Augusta Gregory, who aimed to create a truly Irish national theatre.
3. Henrik Ibsen is regarded as a founding father of modern drama for his plays that delved into the human psyche and offered sharp social commentary, often challenging Victorian moral codes. He was a controversial figure during his lifetime, with some audiences scandalized by the themes explored in his work.
4. William Wordsworth was inspired by the natural beauty of the Lake District surrounding Grasmere to write many of his poems. He and his sister Dorothy embraced a lifestyle of “plain living, but high thinking,” finding inspiration in their daily walks and observations of nature.
5. George Sand and Frédéric Chopin endured a difficult winter in the damp and isolated Valldemossa monastery, suffering from poor health, social isolation, and the harsh weather. This period worsened Chopin’s already fragile health and strained his relationship with Sand.
6. Jack London envisioned Beauty Ranch as a “ranch of good intentions,” aiming to create a bucolic Eden using organic and sustainable agriculture techniques. He wanted the ranch to be a model of responsible farming, cultivating various crops and livestock.
7. The Auld Kirk Alloway was a significant place for Robert Burns as he heard ghost stories associated with the ruins during his childhood, which later inspired his poem “Tam o’ Shanter.” Additionally, his father was laid to rest in the churchyard, making it a site of personal and familial importance.
8. James Joyce chose the Martello tower at Sandycove Point as the setting for the opening of Ulysses because he had briefly stayed there himself, and it provided a unique and symbolic location for the beginning of his epic novel. Oliver St. John Gogarty, a friend of Joyce, was residing in the tower during Joyce’s stay.
9. Jane Austen expressed a personal dislike for Bath, finding it wearisome compared to her beloved Hampshire countryside. However, some of her characters, like Catherine Morland in Northanger Abbey, express great fondness for the social life and attractions of Bath, highlighting a contrast between the author’s and her characters’ experiences.
10. The Sherlock Holmes Museum at 221b Baker Street preserves the fictional lodgings of the famous detective and his companion, Dr. Watson, allowing visitors to step into their world. The Victorian-era rooms are recreated as described in Conan Doyle’s stories, complete with Holmes’s possessions, offering an immersive experience for fans.

Essay Format Questions

1. Explore the concept of “literary pilgrimage” as presented in the source material. Discuss why readers are drawn to visit the homes and haunts of their favorite authors, and analyze the significance of these sites in enhancing our understanding of their lives and works.
2. Choose three different literary destinations featured in the guide (e.g., Shakespeare’s Birthplace, Walden Pond, the Hemingway House) and compare how the visited spaces reflect the lives, themes, and legacies of the authors associated with them.
3. Analyze the role of specific geographical settings in shaping the creative output of at least two different authors mentioned in the text (e.g., the Yorkshire moors and the Brontës, Dublin and James Joyce, Key West and Ernest Hemingway). Consider how the environment influenced their writing.
4. Discuss the significance of literary landmarks as cultural heritage sites. How do these places contribute to our understanding of literary history, and what efforts are made to preserve and present them to the public?
5. The source material highlights various “drink, dine, and doze” locations associated with famous writers. Analyze the relationship between these social spaces and the literary figures who frequented them. How might these environments have influenced their work or provided insights into their lives?

Glossary of Key Terms

• Literary Landmark: A place that holds significance due to its association with a writer or a work of literature, such as an author’s birthplace, home, a setting in a novel, or a favorite gathering spot.
• Pilgrimage: A journey to a place considered sacred or significant, often undertaken for personal, spiritual, or in this context, literary reasons.
• Repertory Theatre: A theatre company that presents a rotating schedule of different plays rather than running one production for an extended period.
• Literary Revival: A period of renewed interest and activity in a nation’s literature, often characterized by a focus on national identity and cultural heritage, as seen with the Irish Literary Revival.
• Social Commentary: Writing that critiques aspects of society, such as its institutions, customs, or power structures, often with the aim of promoting social or political change, as evident in the works of Dickens and Ibsen.
• Romantic Era: A literary and artistic movement in the late 18th and early 19th centuries that emphasized emotion, imagination, individualism, and the beauty of nature, exemplified by writers like Wordsworth, Byron, and Keats.
• Modern Drama: A form of theatre that emerged in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, characterized by realism, psychological depth, and a focus on social issues, with Henrik Ibsen being a key figure.
• Gothic Literature: A genre of literature that combines elements of horror, romance, and the supernatural, often set in eerie or decaying settings, as seen in Dracula and some works by Hawthorne and the Brontës.
• Autobiographical: Relating to or based on the author’s own life and experiences, as seen in Dickens’s David Copperfield and Steinbeck’s East of Eden.
• Expatriate: A person who lives outside their native country, often for an extended period, as James Joyce did after leaving Dublin.

Briefing Document: Literary Landmarks from Jane Austen’s Bath to Ernest Hemingway’s Key West

Source: Excerpts from “Novel Destinations: Literary Landmarks from Jane Austen’s Bath to Ernest Hemingway’s Key West” by Shannon McKenna Schmidt and Joni Rendon (2008).

Main Theme: This book excerpt serves as a guidebook to literary landmarks, inviting readers to connect with their favorite authors and books by visiting significant locations associated with them. It highlights homes, museums, theaters, pubs, and even landscapes that inspired or were inhabited by renowned writers, spanning various eras and genres. The central idea is that these places offer a tangible link to the literary imagination and provide a deeper understanding of the authors’ lives and works.

Key Ideas and Facts:

• The Power of Place in Literary Imagination: The introduction suggests that while fictional universes may not always have a precise geographical location, the real-world places associated with their creation hold significance. The authors pose rhetorical questions about the settings of iconic literary works, then pivot to the importance of honoring the actual places that sparked these ideas. For example, they mention the bar stool where Beckett might have conceived Waiting for Godot and Melville’s Arrowhead home, where the view of Mount Greylock could have inspired the shape of the whale in Moby Dick.
• Quote: “Luckily, universes can fit on a head of a pin, and the pins are worth honoring, too.”
• Quote: “Sometimes a book invites a journey, sometimes we invite ourselves.”
• Shakespearean Pilgrimages: The excerpt emphasizes Stratford-upon-Avon, England, as a long-established pilgrimage site for “Bard fans.” It details Shakespeare’s Birthplace, highlighting the preservation of the Tudor house and garden, offering a “fascinating glimpse into Elizabethan life and times.” The Royal Shakespeare Company’s three theaters in Stratford are also mentioned as key attractions. Furthermore, the text points to Stratford, Ontario, Canada, as another significant location for Shakespeare enthusiasts, boasting North America’s largest classical repertory theatre.
• Honoring Playwrights: The document explores locations associated with other prominent playwrights, including Shaw’s Corner in Hertfordshire, England, the Abbey Theatre in Dublin (founded by Yeats and others to reflect “the deeper thoughts and emotions of Ireland”), and the Ibsen Museum in Oslo, Norway, preserving Ibsen’s final apartment where he uttered his famous last words: “On the contrary.” It also mentions other Ibsen museums in Norway.
• Wordsworth and the Lake District: Dove Cottage in Grasmere, Wordsworth’s “nest in a green dale,” is presented as a pivotal location for his most productive writing period, characterized by “plain living, but high thinking.” The adjacent museum displaying manuscripts like the original draft of “Daffodils” is also noted.
• Literary Exiles and Retreats: The excerpt delves into the contrasting experiences of George Sand and Frédéric Chopin in a Majorcan monastery, where the harsh conditions and isolation profoundly affected Chopin’s health and their relationship. Conversely, Jack London’s Beauty Ranch in Sonoma Valley, California, is portrayed as his “bucolic Eden,” a deliberate creation rooted in his success as a writer and his commitment to sustainable agriculture.
• Quote (Sand on Majorca): “Death seemed to hover over our heads to seize one of us, and we were alone in contending with him for his prey.”
• Quote (London on his ranch): “‘Next to my wife, the ranch is the dearest thing in the world to me.’”
• Scottish Literary Heritage: The focus shifts to Robert Burns, with descriptions of his birthplace, Burns Cottage, and the nearby Auld Kirk Alloway, which inspired his poem “Tam o’ Shanter.” The annual Burns Night Suppers are also mentioned as a global celebration of the poet.
• Yeats’s Ireland: County Sligo, Ireland, is highlighted as the landscape that deeply influenced the poetry of W. B. Yeats. The Lake Isle of Innisfree is specifically mentioned as inspiration for one of his early poems.
• Romantic Poets in Italy: The Keats-Shelley House in Rome is presented as a memorial to the Romantic poets who lived and died in Italy. It houses a collection of artifacts related to Keats and Shelley, as well as other literary figures. Byron’s Roman sojourn and his contrasting relationship with Keats are also touched upon.
• Quote (Byron on Rome): “‘As a whole, ancient and modern, it beats Greece, Constantinople, everything—at least that I have ever seen.’”
• American Literary Landmarks: The excerpt covers a range of American authors and their significant locations, including Carl Sandburg’s Connemara, Edna St. Vincent Millay’s Steepletop, Robert Frost’s homes in New Hampshire and Vermont, Emily Dickinson’s Homestead, Henry Wadsworth Longfellow’s Cambridge home, O. Henry’s Austin residence, Laura Ingalls Wilder’s Mansfield home, Edgar Allan Poe’s Philadelphia residences, Herman Melville’s Arrowhead, Washington Irving’s Sunnyside, Mark Twain’s birthplace in Florida, Missouri, and his boyhood home in Hannibal. These sections often include details about the preserved homes and museums.
• Quote (Melville on Arrowhead): “‘I have a sort of sea-feeling here in the country, now that the ground is all covered with snow…My room seems a ship’s cabin…’”
• Quote (Irving on Sunnyside): “‘It is a beautiful spot…capable of being made a little paradise.’”
• Quote (Twain on his birthplace): “‘The village contained a hundred people and I increased the population by one per cent.’”
• Dracula’s England and Romania: Whitby, England, is identified as the atmospheric inspiration for Bram Stoker’s Dracula, with descriptions of the harbor, Whitby Abbey, and St. Mary’s Church graveyard. Sighisoara, Romania, Vlad the Impaler’s birthplace, and Snagov Monastery, his reputed burial place, are also featured.
• Quote (Stoker on Whitby): “‘Masses of sea fog came drifting inland…so dank and damp and cold that it needed but little effort of imagination to think that the spirits of those lost at sea were touching their living brethren with the clammy hands of death.’”
• Russian Literary Giants: The excerpt visits the estate-museum of Leo Tolstoy at Yasnaya Polyana, Anton Chekhov’s house museum in Moscow, and Fyodor Dostoevsky’s childhood apartment, also in Moscow, highlighting their personal histories and literary connections to these places.
• Quote (Tolstoy on Yasnaya Polyana): “‘I could hardly imagine Russia, or my relationship with her, without my Yasnaya Polyana.’”
• Quote (Chekhov on his dual life): “‘Medicine is my lawful wife, and literature is my mistress. When I get fed up with one, I spend the night with the other.’”
• Mystery and Detective Fiction: The guidebook touches upon locations associated with mystery writers, including Dashiell Hammett’s San Francisco and the Sherlock Holmes Museum at 221b Baker Street in London, emphasizing the immersive experience offered to fans.
• Quote (Conan Doyle’s Holmes): “‘I have my eye on a suite on Baker Street.’”
• Literary Destinations Beyond Homes: The excerpt expands to include libraries like Trinity College in Dublin (housing the Book of Kells) and the British Library in London (displaying treasures like the Magna Carta and Shakespeare’s First Folio), emphasizing their importance in preserving literary history. It also mentions the use of Dunnottar Castle and Blackness Castle in Scotland as filming locations for Shakespeare’s Hamlet.
• Literary Hotels: Several hotels with literary connections are highlighted, including the Beau-Rivage Palace in Lausanne, which hosted Victor Hugo and Mark Twain, the Hotel d’Inghilterra in Rome (frequented by Henry James), and Pensione Wildner in Venice (also associated with James).
• Literary Pubs and Restaurants: The document lists various establishments that were frequented by famous writers, such as John’s Grill in San Francisco (Hammett), Rules in London (Dickens, Thackeray, Wells), Davy Byrnes Pub in Dublin (Joyce), and Dirty Dick’s in London (possible inspiration for Miss Havisham).
• Jane Austen’s Ambivalence Towards Bath: While Bath is mentioned in the title, the excerpt reveals Jane Austen’s personal dislike for the city, contrasting with the positive portrayal in Northanger Abbey. Her preference for rural life and her family’s move to Bath are discussed.
• Quote (Austen): “‘Bath is still Bath.’”
• Charles Dickens’s London: A significant portion is dedicated to Charles Dickens’s life and works in London, featuring the Charles Dickens Museum at his former Doughty Street residence, remnants of Marshalsea Debtors Prison, and his beloved Gad’s Hill Place in Kent. Various London locations mentioned in his novels and associated with his life are also highlighted, along with dining and drinking establishments he frequented.
• Quote (Dickens on David Copperfield): “‘I have in my heart of hearts a favorite child. And his name is David Copperfield.’”
• Quote (Dickens on Gad’s Hill Place): “‘The spot and the very house are literally ‘a dream of my childhood,’’”
• The Brontës’ Haworth: Haworth in West Yorkshire, England, the home of the Brontë sisters, is depicted as a place deeply intertwined with their literary creations. The Brontë Parsonage Museum and the surrounding moors are emphasized as essential for understanding their work.
• Quote (Virginia Woolf on Haworth and the Brontës): “‘Haworth expresses the Brontës; the Brontës express Haworth. They fit like a snail to its shell.’”
• Victor Hugo’s Paris: Notre-Dame Cathedral in Paris, the setting of The Hunchback of Notre-Dame, is described through Hugo’s eyes, emphasizing its architectural grandeur and the panoramic views of the city from its towers.
• Quote (Hugo on Notre-Dame): “‘No view in the world…could be more magical, more airy, more enchanting.’”
• James Joyce’s Dublin: Dublin is presented as central to the works of James Joyce, particularly Ulysses. Key locations like the James Joyce Museum in Sandycove, Davy Byrnes Pub, and sites referenced in the novel are highlighted, along with the annual Bloomsday celebration.
• Quote (Joyce on his portrayal of Dublin): “‘I want to give a picture of Dublin so complete that if the city suddenly disappeared from the earth it could be reconstructed out of my book.’”
• Franz Kafka’s Prague: Prague is portrayed as an intrinsic element of Franz Kafka’s haunting literary world, reflecting his personal struggles and the city’s unique atmosphere. While not explicitly named, Prague’s architecture and atmosphere are seen as embodied in his works.
• Quote (Kafka on his desire for peace): “‘I didn’t anymore believe in the possibility of real peace…but all the same I went in search of it.’”
• Quote (Kafka on his house in Golden Lane): “‘It suits me down to the ground…it is something special to have one’s own house, to shut in the face of the world the door, not of your room, not of your apartment, but of your own house.’”
• Nathaniel Hawthorne’s Salem: Salem, Massachusetts, particularly The House of the Seven Gables and the Custom House where Hawthorne worked, are discussed as significant influences on his writing.
• Quote (Hawthorne on The House of the Seven Gables): “‘The aspect of the venerable mansion has always affected me like a human countenance…It was itself like a great human heart, with a life of its own, and full of rich and sombre reminiscences.’”
• Ernest Hemingway’s Key West: Key West, Florida, is presented as a crucial location for Ernest Hemingway, where he wrote, fished on his boat Pilar, and developed his “Papa” persona. His house there is now a museum.
• Quote (London on his Key West home): “‘We have bought that old house with the iron rails and balconies opposite the lighthouse in K.W.’”
• Other Southern Writers: The excerpt briefly mentions Tennessee Williams’s connection to Key West and Harper Lee’s Monroeville, Alabama, the inspiration for To Kill a Mockingbird.
• John Steinbeck’s California: Monterey and Salinas, California, are highlighted as “Steinbeck Country,” the real-world settings that heavily influenced his novels like Cannery Row and East of Eden.
• Quote (Steinbeck on his intention with East of Eden): “‘My wish is that when my reader has finished with this book, he will have a sense of belonging in it. He will actually be a native of that Valley.’”

Overall Significance: This excerpt demonstrates the enduring connection between literature and place. By guiding readers to these literary landmarks, the book encourages a more immersive and personal engagement with the works and lives of these celebrated authors. It highlights how physical environments can shape creative output and how visiting these sites can enrich our understanding and appreciation of literature.

Literary Landmarks: Inspiration and Pilgrimage

Why might literary enthusiasts be interested in visiting the homes and haunts of famous authors?

Visiting literary landmarks allows readers to connect more deeply with their favorite books and authors. Seeing the places where authors lived and worked can provide insights into their inspirations, daily lives, and the social and physical environments that shaped their writing. These visits can transform the act of reading into a more tangible and personal experience, fostering a stronger appreciation for the creative process.

This text highlights numerous locations associated with William Shakespeare. What are some key sites mentioned and why are they significant?

The text emphasizes Stratford-upon-Avon, England, as Shakespeare’s birthplace and a long-standing pilgrimage site for Bard fans. Key sites include Shakespeare’s Birthplace itself, a Tudor house where he was born and likely lived with his wife, Anne Hathaway. Stratford also boasts the Royal Shakespeare Company with its three theaters on the River Avon, and the New Shakespeare Company at the enchanting open-air theater, a magical spot to experience his plays. These locations are significant because they offer a direct link to Shakespeare’s origins and the ongoing performance tradition of his works.

The establishment of the Abbey Theatre in Dublin is discussed in relation to W. B. Yeats. What were the motivations behind its founding?

W. B. Yeats and his co-founders established the Abbey Theatre with the aim of creating an Irish national theater that would stage works reflecting the “deeper thoughts and emotions of Ireland.” They sought to cultivate new Irish playwrights like J. M. Synge and Sean O’Casey and promote a renewed sense of national identity through pride in Gaelic culture. The theater became a symbol of the Irish literary revival.

Several authors, including Henrik Ibsen and James Joyce, are described as having lived in self-imposed exile or having left their homelands. How might this experience have influenced their writing?

Living in exile can provide authors with a unique perspective on their native culture and society, often leading to themes of displacement, identity, and belonging in their works. Distance can sharpen memories and offer a critical lens through which to examine their origins. For instance, while James Joyce wrote extensively about Dublin, he did so from abroad, suggesting a complex relationship with his homeland that likely infused his detailed and critical portrayals. Ibsen’s self-imposed exile might have contributed to the social commentary and critical examination of Victorian morality found in his plays.

The text explores the connection between Bram Stoker’s Dracula and the town of Whitby, England. What elements of Whitby inspired the novel?

Bram Stoker visited Whitby seeking a relaxing vacation but found inspiration in its “unpredictable North Sea climes, rugged cliffs, and dramatic location in the shadow of a ruined abbey.” The story of a shipwreck that ran aground in the harbor five years prior also fueled his imagination. These elements contributed to the ominous backdrop of Dracula‘s arrival in England via a shipwrecked vessel, with the titular character making his way to St. Mary’s Church and its ancient graveyard, becoming the setting for his first English victim.

Authors like Jack London and Edna St. Vincent Millay sought out specific rural locations for their homes. What aspects of these places were important to them?

Authors often seek environments that foster creativity and provide solace. Jack London envisioned his Sonoma Valley ranch, Beauty Ranch, as a “bucolic Eden” where he could pursue his agrarian dreams and use organic and sustainable agriculture. The tranquility and connection to nature were clearly important. Edna St. Vincent Millay and her husband bought Steepletop, a former blueberry farm, for its rural setting in eastern New York, suggesting a desire for peace and inspiration away from urban life. Robert Frost also sought a “Garden of Eden” in his Vermont stone cottage, emphasizing the importance of a connection with nature for his writing.

The text mentions several literary museums and historic houses dedicated to authors. What kinds of artifacts and experiences do these places typically offer to visitors?

Literary museums and historic houses often provide a glimpse into the lives and works of authors through preserved personal belongings, original manuscripts, first editions of their books, photographs, and furniture. Visitors can often tour the rooms where authors lived and wrote, gaining a sense of their daily routines and creative spaces. Some museums also offer guided tours, educational programs, and exhibits that contextualize the authors’ lives within their historical and literary periods. These sites aim to bring visitors closer to the authors and their creative processes.

The concept of literary pilgrimage appears throughout the text. What motivates readers to undertake these journeys?

Literary pilgrimage is driven by a desire to deepen one’s connection with beloved authors and their works by visiting places associated with them. It’s a way for readers to step into the worlds depicted in literature, to see the landscapes that inspired authors, and to feel a tangible link to their creative heroes. These journeys can be motivated by curiosity, a sense of reverence, and the hope of gaining a richer understanding of the author’s life and the context of their writing. The act of visiting these sites can feel like a form of homage and a way to make the literary experience more real and memorable.

Literary Landmarks: Connecting Readers and Author Places

The sources discuss a variety of literary landmarks, which are places significant due to their associations with authors, their lives, or their works. These landmarks offer readers a way to connect more deeply with the books and writers they cherish.

The book “Novel Destinations: Literary Landmarks from Jane Austen’s Bath to Ernest Hemingway’s Key West” itself serves as a guidebook to many of these locations. The contents page highlights several categories of literary landmarks, including:

• Author Houses and Museums: These are intimate places where writers lived, dreamed, drew inspiration, and spent their most creative hours, offering a glimpse into the moment of artistic creation. Examples include:
• Shakespeare’s Birthplace in Stratford-upon-Avon, England, now overseen by the Shakespeare Birthplace Trust. Charles Dickens and John Keats were early visitors.
• Abbotsford, the castle-like manor of Sir Walter Scott in Scotland, now a literary museum.
• Dove Cottage, the home of William Wordsworth in England.
• Arrowhead, the home of Herman Melville in western Massachusetts, where he wrote Moby Dick.
• The Wayside in Concord, Massachusetts, the home of Louisa May Alcott and later Nathaniel Hawthorne.
• The Ernest Hemingway Museum (La Finca Vigía) in Havana, Cuba.
• The Brontë Parsonage Museum in Haworth, West Yorkshire, England.
• The Dublin Writers Museum in Dublin, Ireland, which traces Ireland’s literary legacy.
• The National Steinbeck Center in Salinas, California, celebrating the life and work of John Steinbeck.
• The James Joyce Museum in the Martello tower at Sandycove Point, Dublin, which was featured in Ulysses.
• Atmospheric Literary Landscapes: Physical places that inspired authors and became settings in their works.
• The Scottish Border Country that inspired Sir Walter Scott.
• The Lake District in England, associated with William Wordsworth.
• Sligo in Ireland, which inspired the early works of W. B. Yeats, including Glencar Lake and Waterfall and Knocknarea (Sacred Hill).
• Cornwall in southwest England, which provided inspiration for Daphne du Maurier.
• Monroeville, Alabama, the small town that inspired Harper Lee‘s To Kill a Mockingbird.
• Monterey and Salinas, California, the setting for many of John Steinbeck‘s works.
• Bath, England, frequented by Jane Austen.
• London, England, associated with Charles Dickens.
• Paris, France, linked to Victor Hugo and Ernest Hemingway.
• Dublin, Ireland, immortalized by James Joyce.
• Literary Festivals, Tours, and More: Organized events and routes that allow enthusiasts to explore literary connections.
• Bloomsday in Dublin, an annual celebration of James Joyce’s Ulysses on June 16th.
• The Steinbeck Festival in Salinas, California.
• The Tennessee Williams/New Orleans Literary Festival.
• Literary walking tours in cities like Boston, New York (Greenwich Village), London, Paris (Hemingway’s Paris), and Dublin.
• Literary pub crawls in Dublin, London, and Edinburgh, visiting pubs frequented by famous writers.
• Booked Up: Literary Places to Drink, Dine, and Doze: Establishments like pubs, cafes, restaurants, and hotels that were frequented by authors or are mentioned in literature.
• Shakespeare and Company bookstore in Paris, a gathering place for expatriate writers like James Joyce and Ernest Hemingway.
• The Eagle and Child pub in Oxford, England, where The Inklings (including C. S. Lewis and J. R. R. Tolkien) met.
• La Rotonde and La Closerie des Lilas in Paris, cafes frequented by Ernest Hemingway and other literary figures.
• Harry’s Bar in Venice, Italy, a favorite of Ernest Hemingway and Truman Capote.
• The White Horse Tavern in Greenwich Village, a haunt of Dylan Thomas and Jack Kerouac.
• The Algonquin Hotel in New York City, where F. Scott Fitzgerald lodged and Dorothy Parker’s “Vicious Circle” met.
• The Hotel Monteleone in New Orleans, frequented by Southern writers like Eudora Welty, Truman Capote, and Tennessee Williams.
• John’s Grill in San Francisco, a favorite of Dashiell Hammett.
• Longfellow’s Wayside Inn in Sudbury, Massachusetts, which inspired Henry Wadsworth Longfellow’s poems.
• Westminster Abbey in London, the burial place of many distinguished literary figures, known as Poets’ Corner.

These literary landmarks serve as tangible connections to the world of literature, allowing readers to experience the places that shaped their favorite authors and stories. Whether it’s visiting an author’s home, walking the streets they described, or having a drink in their favorite pub, these destinations offer a unique way to engage with literary history.

Author Homes: Literary Landmarks and Museums

The sources discuss author homes extensively, primarily within the chapter titled “AUTHOR HOUSES AND MUSEUMS“. These are described as the intimate places where writers lived, dreamed, dozed, drew inspiration, and spent their most creative hours, offering readers a rare glimpse into the ephemeral moment of artistic creation.

The significance of author homes lies in the tangible connection they provide to the writers and their works [the initial summary]. Visiting these places allows readers to see the environments that shaped their favorite authors and stories [the initial summary, 5]. As the introduction notes, people seek out these literary places to gain a deeper perspective on the books they cherish. The mere mention of places like Ernest Hemingway’s Key West or Victor Hugo’s Paris can inspire travel for novel exploration, as many come to know these places through the eyes of these authors.

Many author homes have been preserved and turned into museums, allowing the public to visit and learn more about the authors’ lives and works. Some examples from the sources include:

• Shakespeare’s Birthplace in Stratford-upon-Avon, England, is overseen by the Shakespeare Birthplace Trust and was visited by early sightseers like Charles Dickens and John Keats. It displays many of the trees, flowers, and herbs mentioned in Shakespeare’s works, and an exhibition center illuminates his life.
• Abbotsford, the castle-like manor of Sir Walter Scott in Scotland, is now a literary museum showcasing his antique furnishings, weaponry, and a 7,000-volume library. It opened as one of the world’s first literary museums just five months after Scott’s death and was visited by figures like Queen Victoria and Charlotte Brontë.
• Dove Cottage, the home of William Wordsworth in England, along with an adjacent museum displaying portraits and manuscripts like the original draft of “Daffodils”.
• Arrowhead, the home of Herman Melville in western Massachusetts, where he wrote Moby Dick. The house is restored to its Melville-era appearance, and a window in his second-floor study offered views of Mount Greylock, said to resemble a whale.
• The Wayside in Concord, Massachusetts, the home of Louisa May Alcott and later Nathaniel Hawthorne.
• The Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum in Key West, Florida, Hemingway’s first home on U.S. soil after living abroad.
• The Brontë Parsonage Museum in Haworth, West Yorkshire, England, remains much as it did when the Brontë sisters lived there, allowing visitors to see the dining room where they brainstormed plot ideas.
• The Dublin Writers Museum in Dublin, Ireland, traces Ireland’s literary legacy and features items like Samuel Beckett’s custom-designed telephone.
• The National Steinbeck Center in Salinas, California, celebrates the life and work of John Steinbeck.
• The James Joyce Museum in the Martello tower at Sandycove Point, Dublin, featured in Ulysses, houses a collection of memorabilia, including letters and rare editions of his works.
• Tao House at the Eugene O’Neill National Historic Site in Danville, California, where O’Neill lived in seclusion and penned many of his acclaimed plays.
• The Eudora Welty House in Jackson, Mississippi, preserves the intensely private author’s personal and professional domains.
• Rowan Oak, William Faulkner’s home in Oxford, Mississippi, where the plot outline for A Fable is scrawled on the wall in his office.
• Longfellow House–Washington’s Headquarters National Historic Site in Cambridge, Massachusetts, home to Henry Wadsworth Longfellow for 40 years and General George Washington’s headquarters during the Siege of Boston.
• The restored Sinclair Lewis Boyhood Home in Sauk Centre, Minnesota, displays furniture and items owned by the author and his family.
• The Willa Cather Childhood Home in Red Cloud, Nebraska, is part of the Willa Cather Thematic Group, comprising several preserved buildings associated with her life and fiction.
• The O. Henry Museum in Austin, Texas, preserves the Lone Star State legacy of William Sydney Porter.
• The Ralph Waldo Emerson House in Concord, Massachusetts, Emerson’s residence for over 40 years, remains much as it did in his day.
• The Old Manse in Concord, Massachusetts, where Nathaniel Hawthorne penned stories and where a recreation of Henry David Thoreau’s vegetable garden for the Hawthornes flourishes.
• The Harriet Beecher Stowe Center in Hartford, Connecticut, showcases Stowe’s furnishings and artwork and the parlor table where she worked on Uncle Tom’s Cabin.
• Maison Jules Verne in Amiens, France, decorated with period furnishings and items owned by the writer.
• Château de Monte-Cristo, Alexandre Dumas’s countryside retreat outside Paris, featuring a smaller workspace called Château d’If.
• Maison de Victor Hugo in Place des Vosges, Paris, now a museum illuminating different periods of his life.
• Hauteville House on the isle of Guernsey, where Victor Hugo spent 14 years of his exile and completed Les Misérables.

In some instances, author homes have been transformed into literary lodgings or establishments where visitors can drink and dine, offering a more immersive experience:

• Garth Woodside Mansion in Hannibal, Missouri, where Mark Twain stayed as a guest, now offers a garden-view room he used.
• Bleak House in Broadstairs, Kent, Dickens’s summer retreat, is now a guest house where visitors can stay in the Charles Dickens Room.
• The Willa Cather Second Home in Red Cloud, Nebraska, is now a guest house with rooms named after towns in her novels.
• The Steinbeck House in Salinas, California, where John Steinbeck was born, is now a restaurant open for lunchtime dining and offers house tours.

These examples demonstrate the diverse ways in which author homes serve as literary landmarks, providing valuable insights into the lives and creative processes of the world’s greatest writers.

Literary Guidebooks and Literary Travel

The sources indicate that literary guidebooks serve as resources for “reading enthusiasts who also travel” and “actual literary pilgrims”, helping them explore places significant to authors and their works. The book “Novel Destinations: Literary Landmarks from Jane Austen’s Bath to Ernest Hemingway’s Key West” by Shannon McKenna Schmidt and Joni Rendon is itself presented as such a guidebook.

This guidebook aims to enhance the travel experiences of book lovers by providing information on literary landmarks. The Library of Congress cataloging information explicitly classifies it as a guidebook for literary landmarks in the United States and Great Britain and for the homes and haunts of American and English authors. The foreword by Matthew Pearl suggests that the book helps bridge the gap between fiction and real-world destinations associated with literature.

The structure of “Novel Destinations,” as revealed in its contents, implies a categorized approach to literary guidance:

• “READ ’EM AND SEE: AUTHOR HOUSES AND MUSEUMS” suggests a section dedicated to guiding readers to the preserved homes and museums of various authors.
• “ATMOSPHERIC LITERARY LANDSCAPES” likely guides readers to physical locations that inspired authors and became settings in their novels.
• “LITERARY FESTIVALS, TOURS, AND MORE” indicates a section guiding readers to organized literary events and routes for exploration.
• “BOOKED UP: LITERARY PLACES TO DRINK, DINE, AND DOZE” likely directs readers to establishments with literary connections, such as pubs and cafes frequented by authors.

Beyond comprehensive books like “Novel Destinations,” the sources also highlight other forms of literary guidance:

• Literary Walking Tours: These guided excursions in cities like Boston, Los Angeles (Raymond Chandler), Chicago, New York (Greenwich Village), New Orleans, Dublin, London, and St. Petersburg (Dostoyevsky) serve as localized guidebooks in action, highlighting specific literary sites and their significance.
• Self-Guided Tours and Maps: Edinburgh offers self-guided walking tour itineraries and apps related to its literary heritage. Baltimore has a self-guided Literary Heritage Tour map available online. Visitors to literary sites, like the National Steinbeck Center, might find maps and reading lists to further their exploration.
• Specific Books as Guides: “A Journey into Steinbeck’s California” by Susan Shillinglaw is mentioned as a handy guide for traversing the terrain associated with John Steinbeck.
• Museum Resources: Author house museums and literary centers often provide exhibits and information that guide visitors through the life and works of the featured writers [e.g., Shakespeare’s Birthplace, Abbotsford, The Brontë Parsonage Museum, The National Steinbeck Center, Dublin Writers Museum].

These various forms of literary guidebooks, whether comprehensive volumes or localized resources, cater to the desire of readers to connect more deeply with literature by experiencing the places and environments that shaped its creation. They transform reading from a solitary activity into a form of “travel by the book”, allowing enthusiasts to embark on “novel exploration”.

Literary Travel: Visiting Authors and Their Worlds

Travel for readers is presented in the sources as a way to deepen their connection with literature by experiencing the places associated with authors and their works. The book “Novel Destinations: Literary Landmarks from Jane Austen’s Bath to Ernest Hemingway’s Key West” caters specifically to “reading enthusiasts who also travel” and “actual literary pilgrims”. The foreword by Matthew Pearl suggests that such travel bridges the gap between fiction and real-world literary destinations.

The sources highlight several key aspects of travel for readers:

• Visiting Author Homes and Museums: This is a significant aspect, offering “a rare glimpse into the ephemeral moment of artistic creation”. These “intimate places where writers lived, dreamed, dozed, drew inspiration, and spent their most creative hours” are often preserved as museums. Examples include Shakespeare’s Birthplace, Abbotsford (Sir Walter Scott’s home), Dove Cottage (William Wordsworth), Arrowhead (Herman Melville), The Wayside (Louisa May Alcott and Nathaniel Hawthorne), the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum, the Brontë Parsonage Museum, the Dublin Writers Museum, the National Steinbeck Center, the James Joyce Museum, Tao House (Eugene O’Neill), the Eudora Welty House, Rowan Oak (William Faulkner), Longfellow House–Washington’s Headquarters National Historic Site, the restored Sinclair Lewis Boyhood Home, the Willa Cather Childhood Home, the O. Henry Museum, the Ralph Waldo Emerson House, the Old Manse (Nathaniel Hawthorne), the Harriet Beecher Stowe Center, Maison Jules Verne, Château de Monte-Cristo (Alexandre Dumas), Maison de Victor Hugo, and Hauteville House (Victor Hugo). These allow readers to see the environments that shaped their favorite authors and stories.
• Exploring Atmospheric Literary Landscapes: Readers can travel to the physical locations that inspired authors and became settings in their novels. The mere mention of places like Ernest Hemingway’s Key West or Victor Hugo’s Paris can inspire travel for “novel exploration”. Jane Austen’s Bath, Dickens’s London, Steinbeck’s California, and the Brontë Country are presented as such landscapes. For example, Hawai’i Volcanoes National Park is significant because Mark Twain witnessed and wrote about it. In Salinas, California, visitors can explore the landscape that inspired John Steinbeck. The Brontë Country in Yorkshire, England, offers walks to landmarks like the Brontë waterfall and Top Withens.
• Participating in Literary Festivals, Tours, and More: These organized events and routes provide opportunities for readers to connect with literature in a social and immersive way. Examples include the Jane Austen Festival in Bath, the Steinbeck Festival in Salinas, the Fowey Festival of Words and Music, and Zora! The Zora Neale Hurston Festival of the Arts and Humanities in Eatonville, FL. Literary walking tours are available in cities like Boston, Los Angeles (Raymond Chandler), Chicago, New Orleans, Dublin, London, and St. Petersburg (Dostoyevsky). Self-guided tours and maps are also available in places like Edinburgh and Baltimore.
• Staying in Literary Lodgings and Visiting Bookish Places to Eat and Drink: Some author homes and other establishments have been transformed into places where visitors can stay, eat, and drink, offering a more tangible connection to the literary world. Examples of literary lodgings in the U.S. include the Algonquin Hotel in New York (associated with F. Scott Fitzgerald and Dorothy Parker), the Hotel Union Square in San Francisco with a Dashiell Hammett Suite, Garth Woodside Mansion where Mark Twain stayed, and Bleak House Broadstairs, Dickens’s summer retreat now a guest house. Abroad, Farringford on the Isle of Wight was Tennyson’s home and now offers cottages and apartments. Bookish places to eat and drink include Shakespeare and Company bookshop in Paris, England’s best literary pubs, and Harry’s Bar in Venice, frequented by Hemingway and Capote. The Steinbeck House in Salinas is now a restaurant.
• Experiencing “Travel by the Book”: This phrase encapsulates the idea that novels can inspire travel and provide a new dimension to travel experiences. Conversely, seeking out literary places can give a deeper perspective on cherished books. Even celebrated writers like John Steinbeck felt the allure of following in the footsteps of admired authors.

In conclusion, travel for readers is a multifaceted activity that allows individuals to engage with literature beyond the page. By visiting significant locations, participating in literary events, and even staying in literary-themed accommodations, readers can forge a more personal and profound connection with the authors and stories they love. The sources provide numerous examples of destinations and resources available to those who wish to embark on such literary journeys.

Literary Destinations: A Guide to Bookish Places

Based on the sources, “bookish places” are locations that hold significance for readers and literary enthusiasts due to their connections to authors, their works, or the world of books in general. These places allow readers to deepen their engagement with literature by experiencing the real-world contexts that shaped it. The guidebook “Novel Destinations” serves as a guide to many such locations.

Here’s a breakdown of the bookish places discussed in the sources:

• Author Houses and Museums: These are “intimate places where writers lived, dreamed, dozed, drew inspiration, and spent their most creative hours”. Visiting these sites provides “a rare glimpse into the ephemeral moment of artistic creation”. The sources list numerous examples in the U.S. and abroad, including:
• Shakespeare’s Birthplace in Stratford-upon-Avon, England, a major tourist attraction even in the time of Dickens and Keats.
• Abbotsford, the castle-like home of Sir Walter Scott in Scotland, now a literary museum.
• Dove Cottage, William Wordsworth’s home in England.
• Robert Burns Birthplace Museum and Burns Cottage in Ayrshire, Scotland.
• Longfellow House–Washington’s Headquarters National Historic Site in Cambridge, MA.
• Maison Jules Verne in Amiens, France, the home of Jules Verne.
• Many more, such as the homes of Louisa May Alcott in Concord, MA, Nathaniel Hawthorne in Salem, MA, Ernest Hemingway in Key West, FL, Victor Hugo in Paris, France, James Joyce in Dublin, Ireland, Franz Kafka in Prague, Czech Republic, the Brontë sisters in Haworth, England, Mark Twain, Edith Wharton, Henry James, Pearl S. Buck, and many others.
• Atmospheric Literary Landscapes: These are the physical locations that inspired authors and became settings in their novels. Examples include:
• Jane Austen’s Bath, England, featured in Persuasion and Northanger Abbey.
• Charles Dickens’s London, England, the backdrop for many of his novels.
• The Brontë Country in Haworth, West Yorkshire, England, the landscape of Wuthering Heights and other Brontë novels.
• Victor Hugo’s Paris, France, immortalized in his works.
• James Joyce’s Dublin, Ireland, the setting of Ulysses.
• Ernest Hemingway’s Key West, Florida.
• John Steinbeck’s Monterey and Salinas, California, the setting for his California novels.
• Sir Walter Scott’s Scottish Border Country, including Abbotsford.
• Robert Burns Country in Ayrshire, Scotland.
• Hawai’i Volcanoes National Park, which Mark Twain wrote about.
• Lyme Regis, England, a setting in Jane Austen’s Persuasion.
• Literary Festivals, Tours, and More: These offer opportunities for readers to engage with literature in a communal and experiential way.
• Literary Festivals like the Bath Literature Festival, Hay Festival in Wales, the Edinburgh International Book Festival, the Fowey Festival of Words and Music (related to Daphne Du Maurier) in Cornwall, the Steinbeck Festival in Salinas, and Zora! The Zora Neale Hurston Festival of the Arts and Humanities in Eatonville, FL [not in source, mentioned in prior turn; you may want to verify this independently].
• Literary Walks and Tours are available in numerous cities, highlighting locations associated with specific authors or literary movements. Examples include tours in Boston focusing on 19th-century American writers, Los Angeles exploring Raymond Chandler’s world, Chicago, New York City (Greenwich Village Literary Pub Crawl, Algonquin Round Table Walking Tours), New Orleans focusing on Faulkner, Williams, and others, Dublin (Dublin Literary Pub Crawl, James Joyce Walking Tours), London (London Literary Pub Crawl, Bloomsbury walks, Dickens walks), and Edinburgh (Edinburgh Literary Pub Tour, Edinburgh Book Lovers’ Tour).
• Self-guided tours and maps are available for literary exploration in places like Edinburgh and Baltimore (Literary Heritage Tour).
• Booked Up: Literary Places to Drink, Dine, and Doze: These are establishments with literary associations, where authors frequented or that have literary themes.
• Literary Lodgings in the U.S. such as the Algonquin Hotel in New York, the Omni Parker House in Boston, the Alexander House Booklovers’ Bed & Breakfast in Princess Anne, MD, the Library Hotel in New York, the Spencer Hotel & Spa in Chautauqua, NY, the Heathman Hotel in Portland, OR, the Sylvia Beach Hotel in Newport, OR, and the Innsbrucker Inn in Leavenworth, WA.
• Literary Lodgings Abroad like Bleak House Broadstairs (Dickens’s retreat) in England, Lamb House (Henry James’s home) in Rye, England, the Savoy Hotel in London (associated with Zola and Wilde), Hôtel d’Europe in Avignon, France (visited by Twain and Fitzgerald), and Farringford (Tennyson’s home) on the Isle of Wight.
• Bookish Places to Sip and Sup, including Shakespeare and Company bookshop in Paris, England’s Best Literary Pubs like The Eagle and Child and The Spaniards Inn in Oxford and London respectively, Ye Olde Cheshire Cheese in London, and Davy Byrnes in Dublin. Big Apple Bars for Bibliophiles like Chumley’s. Parisian Cafés of the Literati such as Café de Flore and Les Deux Magots. Six Hemingway Watering Holes are also mentioned. Harry’s Bar in Venice, frequented by Hemingway and Capote.
• Libraries Worth Checking Out: These are libraries with significant literary collections or historical importance. Examples include:
• Trinity College Old Library in Dublin, home to the Book of Kells.
• British Library in London, housing treasures like the Magna Carta and Shakespeare’s First Folio, and Jane Austen’s writing desk.
• New York Public Library in New York City.
• Library of Congress in Washington, D.C..

These diverse “bookish places” cater to a wide range of literary interests, offering opportunities for travel by the book and a tangible connection to the literary world.

By Amjad Izhar
Contact: amjad.izhar@gmail.com
https://amjadizhar.blog

Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!

This source is an excerpt from a scholarly work analyzing Jane Austen’s novels in relation to Romantic literature, particularly the works of Wordsworth, Coleridge, Scott, and Byron. The author argues that Austen’s later novels demonstrate a shift in focus towards themes and techniques prevalent in Romanticism, such as the exploration of individual psychology, the significance of memory, the impact of social change, and a nuanced understanding of relationships. The text examines specific novels like Mansfield Park, Emma, and Persuasion, highlighting parallels and divergences between Austen’s narrative approaches and the literary innovations of her Romantic contemporaries. Ultimately, the work seeks to reposition Austen within a broader Romantic context, demonstrating how her engagement with contemporary literary trends shaped the evolution of her artistry.

Jane Austen and the Romantic Poets: A Study Guide

Quiz

1. According to the text, what specific visual detail in Mansfield Park suggests a connection to Wordsworth? Explain the reference.
2. How does Edward Ferrars’ description of a “fine country” in Sense and Sensibility contrast with more purely “picturesque” views of nature associated with Romanticism? What does this reveal about Austen’s perspective at that point in her career?
3. The text argues that Austen’s late novels demonstrate a different understanding of the mind compared to her earlier works. Briefly describe this shift, referencing the discussion of memory in Sense and Sensibility.
4. What is meant by the “forensic language” used in Darcy’s letter to Elizabeth in Pride and Prejudice? How does Edmund Bertram’s letter to Fanny in Mansfield Park differ in its approach to expressing feeling?
5. Explain the significance of the word “perfect” in Emma, according to the text. Provide an example of how this word is used in the novel.
6. How does Austen’s use of the word “harmonized” in Emma relate to a specific phrase in Wordsworth’s “Tintern Abbey”? What does this connection suggest about Austen’s artistic aims?
7. The text discusses Fanny Price’s frequent use of the word “no” in Mansfield Park. What does this characteristic usage signify about her character, according to the analysis?
8. What is the older meaning of the word “friend” that the text describes as prevalent in Austen’s time? How does John Dashwood’s use of the term in Sense and Sensibility reflect this meaning?
9. According to the text, how did Byron’s view of friendship differ from the classical tradition? How does Austen engage with this evolving understanding of friendship in Emma?
10. The conversation between Jane Fairfax and John Knightley at the dinner party in Emma is presented as uniquely characteristic of the novel’s interest in friendship. What is significant about this particular interaction?

Quiz Answer Key

1. The text points to “three transparencies” in Mansfield Park depicting Tintern Abbey between an Italian cave and a Cumberland lake. This alludes to Wordsworth’s poem “Tintern Abbey,” suggesting an awareness and perhaps engagement with his work and the popularization of the Wye Valley through picturesque tourism, notably influenced by Gilpin.
2. Edward’s ideal of a fine country prioritizes “beauty with utility,” admiring flourishing, straight trees and snug farmhouses over crooked trees and banditti. This contrasts with a purely aesthetic appreciation of wild or dramatic landscapes favored by some Romantic perspectives, suggesting Austen’s early focus on a more socially and morally grounded evaluation of nature.
3. The early novels, like Sense and Sensibility, present memory in a more schematic way, often tied to specific moral lessons and resolutions. The late novels, however, suggest a deeper and more complex understanding of memory’s role in shaping identity and the experience of time, moving beyond a purely instrumental function.
4. “Forensic language” in Darcy’s letter refers to its structured, analytical, and almost legalistic tone, focusing on presenting evidence and refuting Elizabeth’s charges without overt emotional expression. Edmund’s letter, in contrast, is characterized by its direct expression of intense feeling and a less formally structured outpouring of his thoughts.
5. In Emma, the word “perfect” is insistently undermined by qualification and irony, often associated with characters of questionable judgment like Mr. Weston. For example, Weston’s riddle equating “M. and A.” (Emma) with perfection highlights the novel’s critical examination of idealized notions and Emma’s own flawed self-perception.
6. Austen’s use of “harmonized” to describe the integration of past and present feelings echoes Wordsworth’s lines in “Tintern Abbey” about an “eye made quiet by the power / Of harmony” that allows one to “see into the life of things,” and memory as a dwelling place for “sweet sounds and harmonies.” This suggests Austen shared Wordsworth’s interest in the mind’s ability to synthesize experience and find deeper meaning.
7. Fanny’s frequent use of “no” signifies not a strong will but rather self-denial and a reluctance to assert her own desires. It highlights her subordinate position and her internal struggle to reconcile her own feelings with the expectations placed upon her by her family.
8. The older meaning of “friend” referred to a kinsman, near relation, or important associate, often carrying implications for social standing and familial obligations, particularly in matters of marriage. John Dashwood uses “friend” in this sense when discussing potential advantageous matches for Elinor, focusing on social and financial considerations rather than personal affection.
9. Byron positioned friendship as the “dear peculiar bond of youth,” suggesting it was a transient experience that faded with adulthood, contrasting with the classical ideal of a mature and virtuous connection. Austen engages with this by exploring the complexities of youthful friendship while also developing the ideal of a more mature, enduring friendship between equals, as seen in the relationship between Emma and Knightley.
10. The conversation is significant because it showcases two different styles of “friendship” existing simultaneously. John Knightley employs the older, formal style to express a personal hope for Jane’s future, which she receives kindly. Mr. Woodhouse’s interaction represents a more ceremonial and less personally insightful form of goodwill. This juxtaposition highlights the novel’s exploration of the evolving meanings and expressions of friendship within a community.

Essay Format Questions

1. Explore the argument that Jane Austen’s novels, particularly Emma, demonstrate an engagement with and development of Romantic ideas, focusing on the concept of friendship as presented in the text. Consider the influences of Wordsworth and Byron in your analysis.
2. Analyze the changing representation of the inner lives of Austen’s characters from her early to late novels, as discussed in the provided excerpts. How does the understanding and portrayal of memory contribute to this shift?
3. Discuss the significance of nature and the “picturesque” in Jane Austen’s novels, drawing on the examples and arguments presented in the text. How does Austen’s approach to nature compare with that of the Romantic poets mentioned?
4. Examine the concept of “ambiguous relationships” as it is developed in Emma, particularly focusing on the evolving dynamic between Emma and Mr. Knightley. How does the novel redefine the term “friendship” and what are the implications of this redefinition?
5. Consider the role of social and historical context in understanding Jane Austen’s novels, particularly Persuasion. How does the text connect Austen’s work to the Napoleonic Wars and the evolving social landscape of England?

Glossary of Key Terms

• Picturesque: An aesthetic ideal, popular in the late 18th and early 19th centuries, emphasizing a type of beauty found in rugged, irregular, and varied landscapes, often with elements of the sublime but on a smaller, more domesticated scale.
• Sensibility: An 18th-century cultural and literary movement that emphasized feeling, emotion, and refined sensitivity as moral guides. Characters often displayed exaggerated emotional responses.
• Utility: The quality of being useful or practical. In the context of the text, it is contrasted with purely aesthetic appreciation, suggesting a value placed on the functional aspects of the landscape and social arrangements.
• Forensic Language: Language characterized by its formal, analytical, and logical structure, resembling that used in legal arguments or investigations.
• Fetish (in this context): Not solely in the Freudian psychoanalytic sense, but also referring to objects (including ideas or social conventions) that are invested with disproportionate value or veneration, sometimes obscuring or replacing the reality they represent.
• Harmonized (in relation to memory): The process by which past experiences and present feelings are integrated and reconciled in the mind, creating a sense of wholeness and understanding.
• Affective Individualism: A social and cultural shift emphasizing the importance of personal feelings and affections as the primary basis for relationships and individual identity, rather than lineage or social status alone.
• Litotes: A figure of speech involving understatement in which an affirmative is expressed by the negative of its contrary (e.g., “not bad” meaning “good”).
• Meta-ambiguity: A level of ambiguity that encompasses or arises from other ambiguities, in this case, the relationship between Emma and Knightley embodying a space where different ambiguous forms of friendship intersect.
• Romantic Poets (in this context): Primarily referring to William Wordsworth, Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Lord Byron, and Sir Walter Scott, influential figures in the Romantic literary movement of the late 18th and early 19th centuries, known for their emphasis on emotion, nature, imagination, and individualism.

Briefing Document: Jane Austen and the Romantic Poets by William Deresiewicz

This briefing document summarizes the main themes and important ideas presented in William Deresiewicz’s “Jane Austen and the Romantic Poets.” The book explores the significant, yet often overlooked, influence of Romantic poets, particularly Wordsworth, Byron, and Coleridge, on Jane Austen’s novels. Deresiewicz argues that Austen engaged deeply with the aesthetic and philosophical concerns of the Romantic era, adapting and subverting them within her own unique novelistic framework.

Main Themes:

• Wordsworthian Influence: Deresiewicz posits a strong and pervasive influence of Wordsworth on Austen, particularly in her exploration of memory, the relationship between humanity and nature, and the development of character through inner feeling and reflection. He argues that even when Austen diverges from Wordsworth, her work often grows out of or reacts to his ideas.
• Memory and Inner Life: Austen, particularly in Sense and Sensibility, portrays recollection as a crucial element in moral development, echoing Wordsworth’s emphasis on “serious recollection.” Marianne Dashwood’s recovery involves a process of “recollection, judgment, mortification, a resolution to judge and act better.” However, Deresiewicz notes that in Austen’s early novels, memory is often confined to a specific moral function, unlike the more fluid and impactful sense of time found in Wordsworth.
• Nature and Perception: While Austen’s engagement with nature differs from the Romantic poets’ sublime appreciation, she does engage with contemporary aesthetic debates, particularly regarding the picturesque. Edward Ferrars’ preference for a “fine country” that “unites beauty with utility” contrasts with Marianne’s more passionate, Romantic sensibility, suggesting Austen’s own evolving perspective. In Pride and Prejudice, the planned visit to the Lake District highlights the Romantic appreciation of nature, even though it is ultimately deferred.
• Influence on Later Novels: Deresiewicz contends that the “unmistakable imprint of Wordsworthian ideas and concerns” can be seen throughout Austen’s work, with later novels developing these themes within a novelistic context that introduces its own aesthetic considerations.
• Byronic Influence: The study also highlights Byron’s impact on Austen, particularly on her understanding and portrayal of friendship, youth, and intense feeling.
• Revaluation of Friendship: Byron’s Romantic idealization of youthful friendship as a “dear peculiar bond of youth” influenced Austen’s exploration of this relationship, particularly in Emma. The novel grapples with different conceptions of friendship, contrasting the older sense of “friends” as important associates with the emerging modern sense of friendship based on affection and shared intimacy.
• Emotional Intensity: Characters like Marianne Dashwood exhibit “effusions derived from Thomson, Cowper, and Scott,” aligning with the Romantic emphasis on passionate feeling. However, Austen often critiques the unrestrained expression of sensibility.
• Ambiguity in Relationships: Austen’s development of ambiguous relationships, particularly the central friendship between Emma and Knightley, can be seen in the context of the Romantic interest in complex emotional connections.
• Evolution of Austen’s Novelistic Form: Deresiewicz argues that Austen’s work shows a clear development from her early to her major phase, marked by a deeper engagement with inner experience, a more nuanced portrayal of character, and a greater complexity in her exploration of social and personal relationships.
• Shift in Focus: The early novels, like Sense and Sensibility, often focus on categorizing characters based on qualities like “amiable” and “gentlemanliness.” The later novels, however, delve into more profound ambiguities and complexities of character and relationship.
• Narrative Voice and Interiority: The later novels exhibit a greater access to the characters’ inner thoughts and feelings, moving beyond simple categorization to explore the dynamics of their minds. The letters in Pride and Prejudice and Mansfield Park (Darcy’s and Edmund’s) serve as examples of how Austen uses writing to reveal the complexities of thought and feeling, though in contrasting ways. Darcy’s letter is “forensic” and controlled, while Edmund’s is driven by “intense feeling.”
• The Significance of Language: Austen’s careful use of language, particularly words like “friend” and “perfect,” reveals her engagement with the evolving meanings of social and emotional terms in the Romantic era. The ironic undermining of “perfect” in Emma and the nuanced exploration of “friendship” demonstrate this.
• Friendship as a Central Theme: The concept of friendship undergoes a significant transformation in Austen’s novels, reflecting the changing social and cultural landscape of the time and the influence of Romantic ideals.
• From Social Utility to Affective Bond: Austen navigates the shift from “friend” as a term denoting important social connections and familial allies (as seen in John Dashwood’s usage in Sense and Sensibility) to “friend” as someone connected by affection and shared values (as emphasized by Mrs. Dashwood and the novel’s overall trajectory).
• Ambiguity and Fluidity: In Emma, friendship becomes the “characteristically modern form of relationship,” marked by ambiguity and flexibility, transcending traditional social roles like neighbor, teacher, or family member. Knightley’s role in Emma’s life exemplifies this multifaceted nature of modern friendship.
• Friendship and Marriage: Austen explores the potential for friendship within marriage, culminating in the relationship between Emma and Knightley, which Deresiewicz sees as a “meta-ambiguity” where different forms of friendship merge into a sexual union.
• The Fetish in Austen: Deresiewicz introduces the concept of the “fetish,” drawing on both economic and Freudian interpretations, to analyze the significance of material objects and idealized images in Austen’s novels.
• Social Fetishism: Austen critiques the tendency to venerate “trinkets and luxuries” as symbols of wealth and status, aligning with contemporary social critiques of consumerism.
• Psychological Fetishism: Drawing on Wordsworth’s concern with the mind’s tendency to believe in its own figurative creations, Deresiewicz suggests that characters can become attached to idealized images or substitutes, sometimes at the expense of genuine connection. Fanny Price’s attachment to her East Room in Mansfield Park is analyzed through this lens, suggesting it becomes a “substitute for the body.”
• Persuasion: Widowhood and Waterloo: The analysis of Persuasion connects the novel to specific historical and Romantic contexts, particularly the aftermath of the Napoleonic Wars and the influence of Byron and Scott.
• National and Personal Loss: The novel is situated in a post-war England, grappling with themes of loss, change, and national identity. The sea becomes a powerful symbol, representing both the dangers of war and the connection to England’s maritime history.
• Influence of Byron’s “Turkish Tales”: Deresiewicz argues that Persuasion engages with the themes of memory, loss, and hidden secrets found in Byron’s popular “Turkish Tales,” particularly The Giaour.
• Scott’s Historical Romances: The novel’s temporal setting and its engagement with national concerns also place it in dialogue with the historical romances of Walter Scott, though Austen ultimately focuses more on the personal and domestic sphere.

Important Ideas and Facts:

• The three transparencies in Sense and Sensibility depicting Tintern Abbey and the Lake District explicitly point to Wordsworth’s influence on Austen’s early engagement with landscape.
• Edward Ferrars’ pragmatic view of nature in Sense and Sensibility represents Austen’s early critique of unrestrained Romantic sensibility.
• Sir Thomas Bertram’s rigid patriarchal authority in Mansfield Park ultimately “shatters” due to his inability to adapt to the changing desires and independent spirits of his children.
• The forensic language and structure of Darcy’s letter in Pride and Prejudice contrast sharply with the emotionally driven nature of Edmund’s letter in Mansfield Park, highlighting different approaches to expressing inner feeling through writing.
• The repeated use of the word “kind” in Emma signifies the novel’s emphasis on a common human community and horizontal social connections.
• Knightley’s role in Emma evolves beyond traditional social categories, ultimately solidifying as “friend,” representing a modern ideal of ambiguous and multifaceted relationships.
• The obsolete meaning of “friend” as a kinsman or important associate is still present in Austen’s novels, particularly in the speech of characters like John Dashwood in Sense and Sensibility.
• Byron’s poetry, particularly his early works focusing on youthful friendship, provides a key context for understanding Austen’s exploration of this theme in Emma.
• The handshake between Emma and Frank Churchill, and its near transformation into a kiss, serves as a physical manifestation of the ambiguities inherent in their evolving relationship.
• Emma and Knightley’s final reconciliation hinges on their redefinition and embrace of “friendship” as a foundation for their romantic relationship.
• The imagery of the sea in Persuasion connects to themes of loss, memory, and England’s national identity in the wake of the Napoleonic Wars, echoing Byronic and Scottian concerns.

Quotes:

• On Wordsworth’s influence: “as we make our way through this system of changes, we will find that attribute after attribute bears the unmistakable imprint of Wordsworthian ideas and concerns.”
• Edward Ferrars’ view of nature: “[M]y idea of a fine country,” he says, is one that “unites beauty with utility . . . I do not like crooked, twisted, blasted trees. I admire them much more if they are tall, straight, and flourishing . . . I have more pleasure in a snug farm-house than a watch-tower—and a troop of tidy, happy villagers please me better than the finest banditti in the world.”
• On Darcy’s letter: “Two offenses of a very different nature, and by no means of equal magnitude, you last night laid to my charge.”
• On the undermining of “perfect” in Emma: “Of the dozens of times it or its derivatives appear, almost none is without qualification or irony…”
• On the modern form of friendship: “Friendship has become the relationship in terms of which all others are understood, against which they are all measured, into which they have all dissolved. It has become, in other words, the characteristically modern form of relationship.”
• Emma’s internal recognition of her flawed friendship with Harriet: “I have been but half a friend to her.”
• Knightley’s initial recoil from “brother and sister”: “Brother and sister! no, indeed,” he exclaims.
• Knightley’s initial recoil from “friend”: “ ‘As a friend!’—repeated Mr. Knightley.—‘Emma, that I fear is a word—No, I have no wish—’.”
• Byron on youthful friendship: “Friendship, the dear peculiar bond of youth.”
• The narrator on the symbolic importance of the descent to Lyme in Persuasion: “descending the long hill into Lyme . . . entering upon the still steeper street of the town itself . . . passing down . . . and still descending—to the sea.”
• The Giaour on memory: “My memory now is but the tomb / Of joys long dead.”

Deresiewicz’s work provides a compelling argument for understanding Jane Austen within the intellectual and aesthetic context of Romanticism, revealing a deeper layer of engagement with the major literary and philosophical currents of her time. His analysis of themes like memory, nature, friendship, and the evolving self offers fresh perspectives on Austen’s enduring literary significance.

Austen and the Romantic Poets: Influences and Engagements

Frequently Asked Questions: Jane Austen and the Romantic Poets

1. How does the book define the relationship between Jane Austen and the Romantic poets? The book argues that Jane Austen engaged deeply with the ideas and concerns of the Romantic poets, particularly Wordsworth, Byron, and Coleridge, although her engagement was often subtle and transformative rather than a direct imitation. She absorbed fundamental orientations and aesthetics from them, adapting and integrating these influences within her own novelistic framework, which necessarily involved different artistic and social considerations.

2. In what specific ways did Wordsworth influence Jane Austen’s work, according to the text? Wordsworth’s influence is seen in several aspects of Austen’s novels. This includes the exploration of memory and recollection, particularly the idea of past feelings shaping present experience, as seen in Sense and Sensibility. Austen also engages with Wordsworthian ideas of nature and its moral significance, although sometimes to critique or present alternative perspectives, such as Edward Ferrars’s view of landscape prioritizing utility over the purely picturesque. Furthermore, the development of ambiguous relationships, particularly friendship, in Austen’s later novels like Emma, is linked to Wordsworth’s exploration of complex bonds in poems like the Matthew poems.

3. How did Byron’s Romanticism manifest in Austen’s novels, as discussed in the source? Byron’s influence is particularly evident in the exploration of friendship in Austen’s work. Austen engages with the Byronic concept of friendship as the “dear peculiar bond of youth,” reflecting a shift from the classical ideal of friendship as a mature, virtuous connection. This is seen in the emphasis on youthful friendships and the anxieties surrounding their potential loss or change. Additionally, the Romantic fascination with intense feeling and memory, themes prevalent in Byron’s work, find echoes in Austen’s exploration of characters’ emotional lives, particularly in Persuasion.

4. The text highlights the evolving concept of “friendship” in Austen’s novels. How does it change, and what influences this shift? The concept of friendship evolves from an older sense, where “friend” could denote a kinsman or important associate, particularly in the context of marriage, to a more modern understanding of friendship based on affection, shared values, and mutual support. This shift is influenced by broader cultural changes and the Romantic emphasis on individual feeling and intimacy. In Emma, friendship becomes a central theme, explored in its various forms and ambiguities, ultimately emerging as a new relational ideal.

5. What is the significance of the relationship between Emma and Knightley in the context of friendship, according to the book? The relationship between Emma and Knightley is presented as the apotheosis of the evolving concept of friendship in Austen’s work. It moves beyond fixed social roles and traditional expectations, becoming an ambiguous relationship characterized by intellectual equality, mutual respect, and the possibility of growth. Their journey culminates in a marriage that incorporates this deep and complex friendship, suggesting a modern ideal where romantic partnership is founded on a strong and evolving friendship.

6. How does the theme of memory function in Austen’s novels, and how does it relate to the Romantic poets’ treatment of memory? Memory in Austen’s novels is not merely a passive recollection of events but actively shapes characters’ understanding of themselves and their relationships. In early novels like Sense and Sensibility, memory serves a more schematic, almost curative role. However, in later works like Emma and Persuasion, memory becomes more nuanced, influencing the sense of time and allowing for the harmonization of past experiences into present understanding, echoing Wordsworth’s exploration of memory’s power in poems like “Tintern Abbey.”

7. What is the role of nature and the picturesque in Austen’s novels, particularly in relation to Romantic ideals? Austen engages with the Romantic appreciation for nature and the picturesque, but often with a critical or nuanced perspective. While characters like Marianne Dashwood express sensibility through effusions aligned with picturesque conventions and poets like Thomson and Cowper, Austen also presents alternative views, such as Edward Ferrars’s preference for a landscape combining beauty with utility. In Pride and Prejudice, the planned visit to the Lake District is almost an afterthought, suggesting a deliberate swerve away from a central engagement with sublime nature, unlike the intense focus found in some Romantic poetry.

8. How does the book connect the historical context of the Napoleonic Wars and a sense of national identity to Austen’s novel Persuasion? Persuasion is analyzed as a novel deeply engaged with its historical context, particularly the aftermath of the Napoleonic Wars and the rise of naval power. The sea, a significant setting, is not just a backdrop but symbolizes England’s history and identity as an island nation. The novel contrasts the landed gentry with the emergent professional class represented by naval officers, suggesting a shift in social values and the potential for national renewal after the wars. The themes of loss, memory, and the intertwining of personal and national life are also connected to the historical period.

Jane Austen’s Novels: Early and Major Phases

Jane Austen’s novels can be broadly categorized into two phases: the early phase, comprising Northanger Abbey, Sense and Sensibility, and Pride and Prejudice; and the major phase, consisting of Mansfield Park, Emma, and Persuasion.

Early Phase Novels:

• These novels are characterized as brilliant, cutting, and breathtakingly assured, but essentially straightforward marriage plots.
• While intricately designed, they are considered morally and emotionally unambiguous.
• The younger Austen was fond of narrative set-pieces which were markedly performative. Examples include conversations during dances or sparring matches between characters.
• In these early works, emotions and motives are less complex, and relationships are similarly unambiguous, shifting in a step-wise fashion.
• Memory plays a crucial role in the heroine’s transformation but exhibits a narrower conception compared to the later novels. For instance, Elizabeth Bennet’s self-recognition in Pride and Prejudice is strikingly swift, triggered by Darcy’s letter.
• The conceptual landscape of the early novels is dominated by an abstract moral vocabulary, focusing on terms like “amiable,” “agreeable,” “gentlemanliness,” and “elegance”. Austen employs a powerful categorizing intelligence in these works.
• Austen, in her early phase, can be seen as an “artist of being,” focusing on static characters and abstract qualities.
• The ethical doctrine at the center of these novels is that feeling can and ought to be shaped, controlled, and educated by thought. The plots, irony, and narrators’ self-assurance reinforce this idea. The errors of the early heroines are often errors of reason.
• Austen satirizes the way the works of authors like Cowper, Gilpin, Radcliffe, and Burney were read or misread, rather than the works themselves, in novels like Sense and Sensibility and Northanger Abbey.

Major Phase Novels:

• These novels are described as deeper, denser, more complex, and more confounding than the earlier ones.
• In this phase, Austen discards her allegiance to reason and resolution to explore uncharted and disturbingly equivocal regions of selfhood and relatedness. She transitions from a “maker of marriages” to an investigator into “the delicate anatomy of the human heart”.
• The novels of the major phase show a new receptivity to nature and attitude toward natural connection.
• The nature of time is different in the later novels, with a greater emphasis on the past shaping the present. The inner realm of feeling, reflection, recollection, relatedness, and personal transformation becomes more significant.
• Austen becomes an “artist of becoming,” focusing on the evolving nature of characters.
• The language of the late novels exhibits greater “subtlety and flexibility”. Austen’s notation of mental life becomes more prominent.
• The mature Austen is no longer primarily concerned with what ought to be but with what is, becoming an explorer of emotions, an observer of relational possibilities, and a connoisseur of process.
• The center of Austen’s attention shifts away from the courtship plot, which functions more as a framework for deeper explorations of emotional structures and modes of relatedness.

Influence of Romantic Poets:

• The shift between Austen’s early and major phases is attributed, in part, to her encounter with the Romantic poets: Wordsworth, Coleridge, Scott, and Byron.
• Their new poetry, focusing on the growth of the mind through feeling, memory, loss, interiority, solitude, ambivalence, and openness, influenced Austen’s later works.
• Austen absorbed fundamental orientations from these poets, reflected in the form, language, and themes of her major phase novels.
• While direct allusions are not always obvious, Persuasion is the sole novel with clear Romantic allusions. However, more subtle allusions to Wordsworth are found in Mansfield Park and Emma.
• Austen’s later novels display concerns drawn from the poets, such as “substitution” in Mansfield Park, “ambiguous relationships” in Emma, and “widowhood” in Persuasion.

Specific Novel Insights:

• Mansfield Park: Explores the concern of “substitution,” deeply informed by Wordsworthian themes of loss and compensation. The novel delves into the complexities of social relations and obligations.
• Emma: Investigates “ambiguous relationships,” drawing ideas about new possibilities for intimate connections from Wordsworth, Coleridge, and Byron, emphasizing complexity, depth, and freedom from conventional social roles. The novel also explores the concept of friendship in a complex historical context.
• Persuasion: Centers on “widowhood” as a process of bereavement and overcoming loss. It also functions as a meditation on historical transitions, reflecting the shift from an old order to a new one led by professions rather than nobility. The novel displays a new emphasis on nature and its connection to feeling.

In summary, Jane Austen’s artistic development shows a significant shift from the more straightforward and morally clear marriage plots of her early phase to the deeper, more psychologically complex explorations of her major phase, influenced by the changing literary landscape and her engagement with the works of the Romantic poets.

Austen’s Major Novels: Romantic Poet Influence

The provided source, “Jane Austen and the Romantic Poets,” argues for a significant influence of the Romantic poets (Wordsworth, Coleridge, Scott, and Byron) on Jane Austen’s novels, particularly those of her major phase (Mansfield Park, Emma, and Persuasion).

The source posits that while Austen’s early novels (Northanger Abbey, Sense and Sensibility, and Pride and Prejudice) are brilliant and assured, they are essentially straightforward marriage plots with morally unambiguous characters and relationships. The encounter with the Romantic poets, whose careers began to gain significant attention in the early 19th century (Byron bursting onto the scene in 1812), deepened Austen’s art, making it more intuitive, ambiguous, and unsettled, as well as more bold and mature. This influence pushed her towards new recognitions that her longer experience of life had prepared her for.

The shift between Austen’s early and major phases is characterized by several key changes attributed to the Romantics’ influence:

• A new receptivity to nature and a different attitude toward natural connection.
• A changed nature of time, with a greater emphasis on the past shaping the present and the significance of inner feeling, reflection, and recollection.
• Austen transitions from an “artist of being,” focused on static characters and abstract qualities, to an “artist of becoming,” exploring the evolving nature of characters.
• Her language gains greater “subtlety and flexibility,” with a more prominent notation of mental life.
• The focus shifts from what ought to be to what is, making Austen an explorer of emotions and relational possibilities.
• The courtship plot becomes more of a framework for deeper explorations of emotional structures.

The source argues that Austen absorbed fundamental orientations from the Romantic poets, reflected in the form, language, and themes of her later novels. While direct allusions are not always obvious (except in Persuasion), the influence is seen in her exploration of specific concerns drawn from these poets:

• Mansfield Park: Explores “substitution,” a set of psychic processes of adjusting to loss, which is deeply informed by Wordsworthian themes of loss and compensation. The novel subtly alludes to Wordsworth’s “Tintern Abbey,” playing a “double game” by also alluding to other authors.
• Emma: Investigates “ambiguous relationships,” drawing ideas about complex and deep intimate connections, free from conventional social roles, from Wordsworth, Coleridge, and Byron. The novel also delves into the concept of friendship within a complex historical context, engaging with the classical-romantic tradition and Byron’s impassioned engagement with the theme. Again, subtle allusions to “Tintern Abbey” are noted.
• Persuasion: Centers on “widowhood” as a process of bereavement and overcoming loss. It also functions as a meditation on historical transitions, particularly in the context of the Napoleonic Wars, influenced by Scott and Byron, who are explicitly mentioned and alluded to in the novel. The novel displays a new emphasis on nature, a theme prominent in Romantic poetry.

The author clarifies that this argument is not about definitively labeling Austen as a “Romantic” or applying a checklist of Romantic attributes to her work. Instead, it focuses on the specific impact the works of Wordsworth, Coleridge, Scott, and Byron available to her had on her writing after she encountered them. The ideas and impulses of the Romantic era were, according to the source, in the air because these poets put them there.

While the standard view once held that Austen probably did not read or think much of Wordsworth and Coleridge, the source argues for her familiarity with their work through subtle allusions and references, particularly to Wordsworth’s “Tintern Abbey” in Mansfield Park and Emma. Scott and Byron are more explicitly mentioned in her letters and novels, especially in Persuasion.

In conclusion, the source contends that Austen’s engagement with the Romantic poets led to a significant transformation in her writing, moving her beyond the conventions of her earlier works into a deeper exploration of human psychology, relationships, and the impact of time and feeling, marking a key development in her artistic career.

Austen’s Evolving Theme of Home: Early to Late Novels

The theme of home undergoes a significant evolution in Jane Austen’s novels, particularly when comparing her early phase (Northanger Abbey, Sense and Sensibility, Pride and Prejudice) to her major phase (Mansfield Park, Emma, and Persuasion). According to the source, the idea of place as the shaper of self is intimately connected with the idea of home in Austen’s late novels, mirroring a similar concept found in the works of the Romantic poets.

In the early novels, home is not depicted as a psychic necessity or a place that profoundly shapes the self. While these novels focus intensely on finding heroines suitable husbands, this quest does not necessarily involve finding them a suitable home, nor does it console them for the loss of an existing one.

• Catherine Morland’s home in Northanger Abbey is practically non-existent.
• Elizabeth Bennet’s home, Longbourn in Pride and Prejudice, is portrayed as something she is eager to leave. Pemberley, while described in detail for its beauties and comforts, functions more as a socioeconomic unit reflecting its master’s character rather than a place that formed him; for Elizabeth, it is a place to be “mistress of,” not inherently to dwell in.
• The Dashwoods’ loss of Norland in Sense and Sensibility is a significant event, but Barton Cottage, while a decent house, develops little resonance as a home. Its proximity to Barton Park even makes it almost as inhospitable as Longbourn is to Elizabeth. The places where the early heroines eventually settle, like Henry’s parsonage or the implied residences of Elinor and Marianne, are only briefly touched upon. Even though Sense and Sensibility comes closest to preserving the home of their youth for Elinor and Marianne, their relationship remains uneasy, suggesting their common “home” can only hope for an absence of tension.

By contrast, in the late novels, the idea of home as a psychic necessity and the loss of home as an irreparable psychic wound become central. For the mature Austen, as for the Romantic poets, home is a singular place that has made you who you are.

• For Fanny Price in Mansfield Park, home is vital to her emotional health. Her misery at leaving Portsmouth for Mansfield and then leaving Mansfield to revisit Portsmouth confirms this. Ironically, while the Crawfords’ instability and everything else about them are a product of their London upbringing, it highlights the novel’s investment in the idea of place as the shaper of self.
• Emma Woodhouse’s rootedness to place, though not explicitly emphasized, is fundamental to the very form of her novel. She never has to leave her home. The importance of home in Emma is such that it even overshadows the romance plot.
• Anne Elliot in Persuasion experiences homelessness and the effort to create a home away from home. The novel explores the nature and meaning of home, comparing different domestic settings like the jovial Uppercross, the cold Elliot lodgings in Bath, and the Harville lodgings in Lyme, which are described as a “picture of repose and domestic happiness”. The ability to make a home away from home becomes a key characteristic. Even the nation’s naval officers after the peace are described as “wanting a home”. While Anne and Wentworth find a metaphorical home in each other, the novel strikingly never specifies where they will finally live, suggesting their home will remain “unsettled”.

The source argues that the absence of the strong theme of home in the early novels is related to the portrayal of the self. In these early works, the self is not depicted as being “shaped” by place; instead, characters undergo abrupt changes of consciousness. Missing is the Wordsworthian theme of childhood as a formative influence, which is closely linked to the idea of home. For instance, Elizabeth Bennet’s past is largely absent from the narrative.

In the late novels, however, Austen’s focus shifts to the continuous modification of personality influenced by factors like place and memory, aligning with Romantic themes. The idea of home as a place deeply intertwined with personal history and memory, as seen in Fanny Price’s East room, mirrors Wordsworth’s depiction of the Wye valley in “Tintern Abbey,” where the space becomes a physical projection of the inner self, uniquely nourishing and making it whole. The East room transforms into a “palimpsest of personal history,” grounding the self in time through memory, much like the Wye valley functions for Wordsworth.

Therefore, the theme of home evolves from a relatively 배경 element in Austen’s early novels, primarily related to social standing and marriage prospects, to a profound exploration of its psychic significance in her later works, where it becomes intertwined with the formation of self, memory, and the experience of loss, reflecting a notable Romantic literary influence.

Austen’s Friendship: Evolution in Emma

The concept of friendship is a central and complex theme explored throughout Jane Austen’s works, and the provided source delves deeply into its various facets, particularly as it is presented and reimagined in her novel Emma. The source argues that the meaning and significance of friendship were undergoing a period of rapid change during Austen’s time, influenced by historical shifts, social ideals, and the writings of the British Romantic poets, especially Wordsworth and Byron.

Here’s a discussion of the key concepts of friendship highlighted in the source:

• Historical Evolution of “Friend”: The term “friend” carried different connotations in Austen’s England. One sense, which was fading but still present, denoted important associates and even elder kin or benefactors, particularly in the context of marriage decisions [46-47, 85, 172n15]. Another common meaning equated “friends” with neighbors, implying goodwill and mutual responsibility, though often lacking deep intimacy [61, 86, 93-94, 182n34]. The more modern understanding of a “friend” as a familiar companion for whom one feels affection and shares intimacies was also current [48, 86, 174n19]. Austen’s novels, especially Sense and Sensibility, reflect this semantic range.
• Friendship and Marriage: Austen consistently valued friendship as the highest social ideal and the desired foundation for marriage [87, 89, 171n12]. The concept of companionate marriage, where husband and wife are “companions and equals,” gained ideological importance in the 18th century, with figures like Mary Wollstonecraft arguing for marriage based on the lasting ties of friendship rather than mere erotic attraction [52-53, 86, 99, 180n24]. Austen is seen as revolutionizing this idea, depicting lovers becoming friends before marriage, emphasizing mutual knowledge and responsiveness.
• Classical-Romantic Tradition of Friendship: This tradition, rooted in figures like Aristotle, Cicero, and Montaigne, viewed friendship as a rare and exalted bond based on virtue and the pursuit of goodness, typically between men of equal standing and mature wisdom [61-63, 86, 101-102, 182n34]. It often paralleled the rhetoric of erotic love, suggesting friendship as a higher alternative. However, this tradition often excluded women. The Romantic era saw a revival and transformation of this ideal.
• Romantic Poets’ Influence on Friendship:
• Byron emphasized friendship as “the dear peculiar bond of youth,” associating it with innocence, candor, and spontaneity, contrasting it with the corruptions of the adult world. His view highlights the transience of such youthful bonds. Austen’s Emma reflects an awareness of this Byronic ideal, though Emma’s early pursuit of friendship seems to miss the mark of genuine youthful intimacy.
• Wordsworth attempted to carry the energies and feelings of youth into adulthood through friendship, exemplified by his relationship with his sister in “Tintern Abbey” and his connection with his older schoolteacher in the Matthew poems. He also imbued “friend” with a sense of democratic equality and social sympathy, as seen in Lyrical Ballads, where the term is applied to both kin and strangers, suggesting a basis for a revivified human collectivity. Austen’s Emma similarly explores friendship as a potentially democratizing and leveling force, where horizontal ties can supersede vertical ones.
• Friendship in Austen’s Early Novels: Austen’s early works contrast “good” forms of friendship (like Catherine and Eleanor Tilney) with “bad” forms (faux-sentimental friendships like Catherine and Isabella Thorpe, or mercenary “friends” in Sense and Sensibility). They also present friendship as a foundation for a profound conjugal relationship [89, 193n60].
• Friendship and “Ambiguous Relationships” in Emma: The source argues that Emma deeply explores the complexity and ambiguity of relationships, with friendship emerging as the “ambiguous relationship par excellence”. Austen tests and stretches the possibilities of friendship through various characters and their interactions.
• Mr. Woodhouse and Miss Bates represent friendship as generalized neighborliness, a more traditional, less intimate form.
• Mrs. Elton embodies a vulgar, overly familiar, and hierarchical notion of friendship, contrasting with the ideals of social sympathy.
• Emma’s pursuit of friendship with Harriet is flawed by inequality and Emma’s desire to act as a patron, misconstruing the meaning of true friendship.
• The potential friendship between Emma and Jane Fairfax is hindered by Emma’s vanity and the threat of an equal intimacy.
• Emma’s friendship with Frank Churchill, a male-female connection outside of marriage expectations, is presented as a significant and revolutionary exploration of amicable feelings, dissolving potential romantic love into “true disinterested friendship”. The ambiguity of “friendship” at the time allowed for such transitions.
• The relationship between Emma and Knightley ultimately defines the novel’s ideal of friendship, where their deep understanding, mutual respect, and willingness to offer counsel form the bedrock of their love and future marriage. Their journey shows friendship becoming the path to its own transfiguration into love, blurring the lines between different forms of affection and even transgressing conventional social boundaries like age and gender hierarchies.
• The Modernity of Friendship in Emma: By the end of Emma, friendship, particularly as exemplified by the bond between Emma and Knightley, emerges as a supremely flexible and inclusive form of relationship, anticipating the modern understanding where friendship can encompass various degrees of intimacy and serve as a basis for or coexist with other types of connections. The novel suggests a move towards a society where “we are friends with everyone,” reflecting a shift towards horizontal, egalitarian ties characteristic of modernity.

In essence, the source argues that Austen, influenced by the evolving social landscape and the intellectual currents of her time, particularly the Romantic re-evaluation of feeling and relationship, uses Emma to conduct a profound investigation into the meaning of friendship. She moves beyond simplistic notions of friendly connections to explore its complexities, ambiguities, and its potential to form the foundation for deep personal bonds, including love and marriage, ultimately contributing to our modern understanding of this essential human experience.

Widowhood and Loss in Austen’s Persuasion

The themes of widowhood and loss are significantly explored in the provided source, particularly in the context of Jane Austen’s novel Persuasion and its relationship to the works of Romantic poets.

In Austen’s early novels, the concept of widowhood is treated differently than in her later works. For characters like Lady Catherine de Bourgh, Mrs. Jennings, and Mrs. Norris, widowhood is associated with power, independence, and stature rather than bereavement. Mrs. Norris even consoles herself for her husband’s death by thinking she is better off without him. Similarly, Mr. Woodhouse and General Tilney do not appear to be affected by the loss of their wives.

However, in Persuasion, widowhood becomes a central fact in the lives of many characters, representing grief, memory, wrenching adjustments, and the painful attempt to move forward. The novel can be seen as a meditation on the dimensions and implications of widowhood and loss.

The source identifies numerous characters in Persuasion who are literally or figuratively widowed:

• Literally widowed: Sir Walter Elliot, Lady Russell, William Walter Elliot, Mrs. Smith, Mrs. Clay, and the Dowager Viscountess Dalrymple. Captain Benwick is also included by extension.
• Figuratively widowed: Anne Elliot (bereaved of Wentworth) and Wentworth himself are clearly marked as such. Charles Hayter experiences a brief figurative bereavement.
• Widowed through other losses: The three Elliot sisters (loss of their mother), Captain Harville (loss of the sister Captain Benwick was to marry), and Mr. and Mrs. Musgrove (loss of their son Richard) are also considered widows in a broader sense of the term.

The novel delves into how these characters cope with their losses:

• Anne’s grief for Wentworth is described as a state of “wan hopelessness and perpetual regret,” akin to the self-imposed isolation of Byron’s Giaour. Her memories are closely allied with her grief. However, she believes that “time had softened down much” of her attachment.
• Sir Walter’s widowhood is portrayed as a “psychic stasis” of “stunned numbness” rather than intense passion. He resists the natural aging process after his wife’s death.
• Lady Russell, also a widow, remains a paired remnant with Sir Walter, both unable to move forward from Lady Elliot’s demise.
• Mrs. Musgrove’s demonstrative grief for her son Richard is initially presented satirically, but the source suggests there is something powerful about her grief, highlighting how grief can grow over time and be startled back into consciousness. This resonates with Wordsworth’s insight in “Two April Mornings” about the persistence of grief.
• Captain Benwick’s indulgence in grief after the death of Fanny Harville is also examined. While some might see it as foretelling inconstancy, Austen uses a “vegetative metaphor” to suggest that mourning is a natural process with a cycle of growth and renewal.

The source emphasizes that for Austen, mourning is a natural process with its own cycle. The mourning that violates nature, according to the text, is Anne’s prolonged and suppressed grief. A proper change of scenery might have allowed her to form a “second attachment,” which is seen as “thoroughly natural”.

Persuasion is also linked to the works of Byron and Scott, where the theme of survival after loss is central. The novel’s synchronization of the personal drama of Anne and Wentworth with the national drama of war and peace (related to the Napoleonic Wars and the Battle of Waterloo) mirrors Byron’s juxtaposition of personal and national bereavement in his Turkish Tales and Childe Harold. The source suggests that the novel, with its focus on widows, might have been Austen’s way of addressing England’s own “widowed” state after years of war.

Furthermore, the loss and recovery of home is presented as a significant parallel process in Persuasion, linked to the theme of widowhood. Anne’s search for a home after the loss of Kellynch mirrors the desire of naval officers for a home after the peace. Ultimately, Anne and Wentworth find a metaphorical home in each other.

In conclusion, the source argues that widowhood in Persuasion becomes a central metaphor for a great array of losses, and bereavement and mourning serve as the template for the process of loss and recovery as such, understood as an essentially natural process. While Austen’s early novels treat widowhood with a different emphasis, Persuasion delves deeply into its emotional and psychological impact, drawing connections with Romantic literary themes of loss, memory, and the possibility of renewal. The novel ultimately explores how individuals and even a nation can navigate the aftermath of significant loss and attempt to “live again”. However, the source also subtly hints at the enduring nature of loss, noting that even Anne and Wentworth’s reunion is temporary, as one will inevitably be widowed again.

By Amjad Izhar
Contact: amjad.izhar@gmail.com
https://amjadizhar.blog

Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!

The provided text presents a psychological analysis of Jane Austen’s novels, focusing on character motivations and the author’s underlying values. It examines mimetic characterization, particularly in Mansfield Park, suggesting that Fanny Price embodies a self-effacing solution to basic anxiety, which the novel seems to glorify. The analysis contrasts this with Emma, where the protagonist’s narcissism and perfectionism are explored as defensive mechanisms, ultimately leading to a flawed “education.” Finally, the text considers Pride and Prejudice as a wish-fulfillment fantasy of an “expansive solution” and Persuasion as a nuanced exploration of duty and romance, while also categorizing Austen’s works through the lens of Horneyan psychology and her own potential personality trends.

A Study Guide to Bernard J. Paris’s Character and Conflict in Jane Austen’s Novels: A Psychological Approach

Quiz

1. According to Bernard Paris, what are the two main schools of thought concerning characterization in literature, and how do they differ in their approach to literary characters?
2. How does Paris utilize Karen Horney’s psychological theories in his analysis of Jane Austen’s characters? Briefly describe one of Horney’s “solutions” to basic anxiety and how Paris applies it to a specific Austen character.
3. In his analysis of Mansfield Park, how does Paris explain the contrasting moral development of Tom Bertram and Henry Crawford, despite their initial similarities in privilege?
4. According to Paris, what are the primary motivations and characteristics of the “narcissistic” personality type, and how does he apply this framework to the character of Emma Woodhouse?
5. Describe Fanny Price’s opposition to the play Lovers’ Vows in Mansfield Park, according to Paris’s psychological interpretation. What underlying fears and motivations drive her resistance?
6. How does Paris explain Henry Crawford’s initial and evolving interest in Fanny Price? What does he suggest motivates Henry’s desire to win her affection?
7. According to Paris, what is the central psychological conflict that prevents Emma Woodhouse from readily embracing marriage, even with someone she comes to care for like Mr. Knightley?
8. Explain Elizabeth Bennet’s initial negative reaction to Mr. Darcy’s proposal in Pride and Prejudice, according to Paris’s analysis. What aspects of Darcy’s behavior and her own character contribute to this rejection?
9. How does Paris interpret Elizabeth Bennet’s eventual acceptance of Darcy’s second proposal? Does he believe it signifies a fundamental change in her personality, and what factors contribute to her change of heart?
10. In his discussion of Persuasion, how does Paris frame the central conflict regarding Anne Elliot’s decision to break off her engagement with Captain Wentworth? What are the key questions he poses about this situation?

Answer Key for Quiz

1. Paris identifies two main schools: the “purists” and the “realists.” Purists argue that literary characters are purely constructs of the author’s design, existing solely within the fictional world for formal and thematic purposes. Realists, however, believe that characters acquire a degree of independence during the narrative and can be analyzed as if they were real human beings with psychological depth.
2. Paris employs Horney’s theories, particularly the concepts of basic anxiety and neurotic needs and solutions (moving toward, against, and away from people). For example, he might apply the “self-effacing solution” (moving toward) to Fanny Price, explaining her behavior as driven by a need for affection and approval to combat feelings of helplessness and worthlessness in her embedded position.
3. Paris argues that Edmund’s goodness is partly due to his being a younger son, which necessitates struggle and discipline. In contrast, Tom’s privileged position and poor influences lead to “thoughtlessness and selfishness.” Similarly, Henry’s “early independence” and the bad example of the Admiral result in his lack of responsibility and self-indulgence.
4. The narcissistic personality, according to Paris (drawing on Horney), seeks mastery through self-admiration and charm, possessing an unquestioned belief in their greatness. Paris applies this to Emma, highlighting her pride in her social position and abilities, her need for admiration, and her overestimation of her own judgment and capacity to control situations.
5. Paris interprets Fanny’s opposition to the play as stemming from her deep respect for Sir Thomas’s authority and her fear of challenging it. The choice of Lovers’ Vows compounds this as she perceives it as “improper.” Her refusal to participate and her censoriousness serve as defenses to reassure herself of her own goodness and avoid Sir Thomas’s potential disapproval.
6. Paris suggests Henry is initially drawn to Fanny by her moral rectitude, as a self-condemning aspect of his personality seeks her approval. His initial plan is to hurt her pride, but he becomes genuinely attracted to her. His desire to marry her is partly due to his lack of success in flirting and his wish to possess the qualities he sees in her, such as her affection and gratitude.
7. According to Paris, Emma’s reluctance to marry is primarily rooted in her complex relationship with her father. She feels that accepting a husband would be a betrayal of her father, as if she would be “killing” him and ceasing to be the devoted daughter. This conflict creates a strong tendency toward detachment in her.
8. Paris explains Elizabeth’s rejection as a result of wounded pride at Darcy’s condescending proposal, where he emphasizes her family’s inferiority and his own sense of degradation. Her own expansive nature and her perception of Darcy’s mistreatment of Wickham and interference with Jane and Bingley fuel her indignation and lead her to denounce his character.
9. Paris argues that Elizabeth’s eventual acceptance is less about a fundamental personality change and more about a restoration and inflation of her pride due to Darcy’s continued affection and the honor of his proposal, especially after the events involving Lydia. While she gains some self-knowledge, her core expansive tendencies remain.
10. Paris frames the central questions around whether Lady Russell’s advice to Anne was good or bad, whether Anne was right or wrong to follow it, and whether Wentworth’s response was justified. He suggests that the answers to these questions determine the reconciliation of the lovers, the vindication of Anne’s character, and the understanding of Austen’s proposed attitude toward life.

Essay Format Questions

1. Explore Bernard Paris’s argument that understanding Jane Austen’s characters through the lens of psychological theories, such as Karen Horney’s, offers a richer and more nuanced interpretation of their motivations and conflicts than purely formal or thematic approaches. Use specific examples from at least two of Austen’s novels discussed in the source material.
2. Analyze Bernard Paris’s concept of “dominating fantasies” in Jane Austen’s novels. How does he suggest these fantasies manifest in the plots and character interactions of Mansfield Park, Emma, and Pride and Prejudice?
3. Discuss Bernard Paris’s assertion that Jane Austen’s “code” involves a tension between sensibility and worldliness. How do various characters in Sense and Sensibility, Pride and Prejudice, and Persuasion embody or deviate from this code, and what are the consequences of their adherence or transgression?
4. Compare and contrast Bernard Paris’s psychological analyses of two of Jane Austen’s heroines, such as Fanny Price and Emma Woodhouse, or Elizabeth Bennet and Anne Elliot. What are the key psychological needs, defenses, and conflicts that Paris identifies in each character, and how do these shape their actions and relationships?
5. Evaluate Bernard Paris’s claim that the romantic resolutions in Jane Austen’s novels, particularly in Pride and Prejudice and Persuasion, are often less about profound personal transformation and more about the restoration of pride and the fulfillment of certain psychological needs.

Glossary of Key Terms

• Basic Anxiety: (Drawing from Karen Horney) A fundamental feeling of insecurity, isolation, and helplessness in a potentially hostile world, which arises in childhood and can drive neurotic behavior.
• Neurotic Needs: (Drawing from Karen Horney) Irrational and compulsive desires developed as attempts to cope with basic anxiety. These needs are often exaggerated, indiscriminate, and lead to internal conflict.
• Neurotic Solutions: (Drawing from Karen Horney) Three primary strategies individuals employ to deal with basic anxiety and fulfill their neurotic needs:
• Moving Toward (Self-Effacing Solution): Seeking affection, approval, and dependence on others.
• Moving Against (Expansive/Aggressive Solution): Seeking power, control, superiority, and recognition through achievement or dominance (can manifest as narcissistic, perfectionistic, or arrogant-vindictive types).
• Moving Away (Detached Solution): Seeking independence, self-sufficiency, and emotional distance to avoid being hurt or controlled.
• Idealized Image: (Drawing from Karen Horney) An inflated and unrealistic self-perception that neurotic individuals create to compensate for feelings of inadequacy and self-hatred. They strive to live up to this impossible image.
• Search for Glory: (Drawing from Karen Horney) The neurotic drive to actualize the idealized image, leading to relentless pursuit of external validation and a distorted sense of self-worth.
• Self-Alienation: (Drawing from Karen Horney) The process by which individuals lose touch with their real selves as they invest their energies in maintaining their idealized image and living according to neurotic needs and solutions.
• Mimesis: In literary theory, the imitation or representation of reality. Paris discusses how Austen’s characters relate to real psychological types.
• Form: In literary analysis, the structure and organization of a literary work, including plot, narrative techniques, and genre conventions. Paris examines how Austen’s characterization interacts with comic form.
• Theme: The underlying ideas or messages explored in a literary work. Paris analyzes how psychological characterization contributes to and sometimes conflicts with Austen’s thematic concerns.
• Expansive Types: (Paris’s term, drawing from Horney’s “moving against”) Characters who adopt aggressive strategies to master life and overcome anxiety, often characterized by pride, ambition, and a need for superiority.
• Self-Effacing Types: (Paris’s term, aligning with Horney’s “moving toward”) Characters who seek security and validation through compliance, dependence, and suppressing their own needs.
• Detached Types: (Paris’s term, aligning with Horney’s “moving away”) Characters who cope with anxiety by withdrawing emotionally and seeking independence and self-sufficiency.
• Perfectionistic Types: (A sub-type of expansive, according to Paris) Characters driven by exceptionally high standards, both for themselves and others, using these standards as a basis for superiority and a means of controlling fate.
• Narcissistic Types: (A sub-type of expansive, according to Paris) Characters who seek mastery through self-admiration and charm, possessing an inflated sense of self-importance and a need for constant admiration.
• Arrogant-Vindictive Types: (A sub-type of expansive, according to Paris) Characters motivated by a need for triumph over rivals, seeking to exploit and outsmart others to enhance their own position.
• Worldliness: (In the context of Austen’s novels, as interpreted by Paris) A focus on social status, wealth, and superficial appearances, often leading to manipulative and self-serving behavior.
• Sensibility (Cult of): An 18th-century movement emphasizing feeling and emotional responsiveness. Paris discusses Austen’s nuanced view of sensibility in relation to her moral code.

Briefing Document: Character and Conflict in Jane Austen’s Novels: A Psychological Approach

Source: Excerpts from “Character and Conflict in Jane Austen’s Novels A PSYCHOLOGICAL APPROACH” by Bernard J. Paris (1978)

Overview:

Bernard J. Paris’s “Character and Conflict in Jane Austen’s Novels: A Psychological Approach” offers a distinct perspective on Austen’s works by analyzing her characters through the lens of Karen Horney’s psychoanalytic theories. Paris argues against purely formalist interpretations of literary characters, suggesting that they possess a psychological reality and can be understood as individuals with their own motivations, defenses, and inner conflicts. The book examines four of Austen’s major novels – Mansfield Park, Emma, Pride and Prejudice, and Persuasion – and concludes with a discussion of Jane Austen’s own “authorial personality” as reflected in her creations.

Main Themes and Important Ideas:

1. The Psychological Reality of Literary Characters:

• Paris positions himself against the “purist” school of thought, which views literary characters solely as elements of authorial design for formal and thematic purposes. He cites Martin Mudrick’s description of this view, where “any effort to extract them from their context and to discuss them as if they were real human beings is a sentimental misunderstanding of the nature of literature.”
• Instead, Paris aligns with the “realists,” who believe that characters develop a degree of independence within the narrative and can be analyzed as if they were real people with psychological complexities.
• He acknowledges the inherent tension between the author’s design and the characters’ perceived autonomy, stating, “They ‘run away,’ they ‘get out of hand’: they are creations inside a creation, and often inharmonious towards it; if they are given complete freedom they kick the book to pieces, and if they are kept too sternly in check, they revenge themselves by dying, and destroy it by intestinal decay.”

1. Karen Horney’s Psychoanalytic Theories as a Framework:

• Paris explicitly utilizes Horney’s concepts of basic anxiety, neurotic needs, and “solutions” (moving toward, against, and away from people) to understand the underlying motivations and behaviors of Austen’s characters.
• He introduces Horney’s three “aggressive types”: the narcissistic, the perfectionistic, and the arrogant-vindictive, explaining their core drives and manifestations. The narcissistic person seeks mastery through “self-admiration and the exercise of charm,” the perfectionistic through “high standards, moral and intellectual,” and the arrogant-vindictive through “vindictive triumphs.”
• He also describes the “basically detached person” who “worships freedom and strives to be independent of both outer and inner demands,” handling a threatening world by removing themselves emotionally.
• The concept of the “idealized image” is crucial, where individuals compensate for feelings of weakness and worthlessness by creating an exaggeratedly positive self-perception, leading to a “search for glory.”

1. Psychological Analysis of Individual Novels and Characters:

• Mansfield Park: Paris analyzes Fanny Price as a character employing “self-effacing” strategies to cope with her feelings of weakness and worthlessness in the Bertram household. Her opposition to the play is linked to her fear of disobeying Sir Thomas’s authority. Henry Crawford is depicted as someone who became “thoughtless and selfish from prosperity and bad example,” exhibiting narcissistic traits. Edmund’s goodness is partly attributed to his status as a younger son requiring him to strive for his place.
• Emma: Emma Woodhouse is examined as having both “narcissistic and perfectionistic trends” induced by her environment. Her matchmaking attempts stem from her pride and need for control. Her relationship with her father and her fear of disrupting it contribute to her detachment from romantic love. The Box Hill incident is analyzed as a result of her repressed contempt for her father being displaced onto Miss Bates. Her eventual submission to Knightley is seen not as maturation but as a shift in defensive strategies.
• “With insufferable vanity had she believed herself in the secret of everybody’s destiny. She was proved to have been universally mistaken.”
• ” ‘Were I to fall in love,’ ” she tells Harriet, ” ‘indeed, it would be a different thing! But I have never been in love: it is not my way or nature; and I do not think I ever shall.’ “
• Pride and Prejudice: Elizabeth Bennet, while possessing many admirable qualities, is analyzed for her “expansive” tendencies and her father’s influence on her detached and critical perspective. Her initial dislike of Darcy is attributed to her wounded pride. Darcy’s proud and self-indulgent manners are shown to stem from his upbringing. His transformation is driven by Elizabeth’s rejection, which forces him into self-examination and a painful dependency. Elizabeth’s eventual acceptance is partly linked to the restoration and inflation of her pride.
• ” ‘She is tolerable; but not handsome enough to tempt me; and I am in no humour at present to give consequence to young ladies who are slighted by other men.’ ” (Darcy’s initial remark about Elizabeth)
• ” ‘I was spoiled by my parents, who … allowed, encouraged, almost taught me to be selfish and over-bearing, to care for none beyond my own family circle, to think meanly of all the rest of the world.’ ” (Darcy’s self-assessment)
• Persuasion: Anne Elliot is portrayed as employing “self-effacing” strategies due to her past rejection and her family’s coldness. Her adherence to Lady Russell’s advice is explored in terms of its consequences for her happiness. Captain Wentworth is depicted as a “strong, masterful, self-assertive male” whose confidence is ultimately validated. Anne’s moral objections to Mr. Elliot highlight her internal values.
• Anne feels the application of Wentworth’s conversation about firmness to herself “in a nervous thrill all over”; and Wentworth gives her a “quick, conscious look.”

1. Jane Austen’s Authorial Personality:

• The final chapter delves into Austen’s own psychological makeup as inferred from her novels. Paris suggests that her works reflect a tension between “expansive” and “self-effacing” tendencies within her.
• He argues that Austen critiques characters who embody the extremes of the “cult of sensibility” (infantile self-indulgence) and “worldliness” (callous pursuit of self-interest).
• Her “code heroes and heroines” often possess strong egos and navigate the complexities of feeling and morality with prudence and principle.
• Paris identifies dominating fantasies in Austen’s novels, often involving the triumph of a deserving protagonist and the correction of pride and folly.

Quotes Highlighting Key Arguments:

• On the nature of literary characters: “For they have these numerous parallels with people like ourselves, they try to live their own lives and are con-sequently often engaged in treason against the main scheme of the book.”
• On the “purist” view of characterization: “any effort to extract them from their context and to discuss them as if they were real human beings is a sentimental misunderstanding of the nature of literature.”
• On the aggressive neurotic types: “They all ‘aim at mas-tering life. This is their way of conquering fears and anxieties: this gives meaning to their lives and gives them a certain zest for living.’”
• On the idealized image: “In this process he endows himself with unlimited powers and with exalted faculties; he becomes a hero, a genius, a supreme lover, a saint, a god.”
• On Emma’s narcissistic tendencies: “Narcissism means ‘being “in love with one’s idealized image.” ‘”
• On Darcy’s transformation: “Your reproof, so well applied, I shall never forget: ‘had you behaved in a more gentleman-like manner.’ Those were your words. You know not, you can scarcely conceive, how they have tortured me;-though it was some time, I confess, before I was reasonable enough to allow their justice.”
• On the limitations of purely aesthetic interpretation: “It does not do justice to a whole range of human qualities which make people with similar defenses very different from each other and quite variable in their attractiveness and humanity.”

Conclusion:

Paris’s psychological approach offers a rich and nuanced understanding of Jane Austen’s characters, moving beyond surface descriptions and plot functions to explore their underlying motivations and inner lives. By applying Horney’s theories, he illuminates the defensive strategies and neurotic trends that shape their behaviors and drive the conflicts within the novels. While acknowledging the author’s design, Paris emphasizes the psychological coherence and complexity of Austen’s creations, inviting readers to engage with them as individuals grappling with universal human anxieties and needs.

FAQ on Character and Conflict in Jane Austen’s Novels (Based on Bernard J. Paris’s “A Psychological Approach”)

1. What are the two main schools of thought regarding literary characterization, according to Martin Mudrick, and how does Bernard Paris position Jane Austen’s work in relation to them? The two main schools of thought are the “purists” and the “realists.” Purists argue that literary characters are creations entirely within the author’s design, determined by formal and thematic considerations, and should not be analyzed as if they were real people with independent psychological histories. Realists, conversely, insist that characters in the course of a narrative acquire a degree of independence and can be understood in ways analogous to real individuals. Bernard Paris, advocating for a psychological approach, aligns more with the realist perspective, arguing that understanding Austen’s characters as individuals with psychological motivations enhances our appreciation of her work. He believes that their internal lives and conflicts often operate with a logic that extends beyond mere thematic or formal requirements.

2. How does Bernard Paris utilize Karen Horney’s psychological theories to analyze Jane Austen’s characters and their conflicts? Paris employs Horney’s framework, particularly her concepts of neurotic needs, the three interpersonal trends (moving toward, against, and away from people), and the idealized self-image, to provide in-depth analyses of Austen’s characters. He examines how characters like Fanny Price, Emma Woodhouse, and Elizabeth Bennet develop defensive strategies to cope with basic anxiety and feelings of inadequacy. For instance, he identifies Emma’s narcissistic and perfectionistic trends as ways she attempts to master life through self-admiration and high standards. Similarly, he analyzes Fanny’s self-effacing tendencies as a means of navigating a threatening world by seeking love and approval. By applying these psychological lenses, Paris aims to uncover the underlying motivations and intrapsychic conflicts that drive the characters’ actions and relationships.

3. In his analysis of Mansfield Park, how does Paris explain the contrasting character development of Edmund Bertram and Henry Crawford through a psychological lens? Paris attributes the differences between Edmund and Henry to their early life circumstances and the development of their character structures. Edmund, as a younger son facing hardship and the need to earn his place, develops a stronger moral compass. Henry Crawford, on the other hand, is presented as someone “ruined by early independence,” whose prosperity and the bad example of the Admiral lead him to become “thoughtless and selfish.” Paris suggests that Henry’s lack of responsibility and developed moral sense stems from not having faced the same pressures and disciplines as Edmund. Even Henry’s attraction to Fanny is analyzed through this lens, as a fleeting admiration for her moral rectitude that ultimately cannot overcome his ingrained self-indulgence.

4. According to Paris, what are Emma Woodhouse’s primary psychological flaws, and how do they manifest in her behavior and relationships? Paris identifies Emma’s primary psychological flaws as narcissistic and perfectionistic trends stemming from her early environment as a favored and admired child. Her narcissism leads to an overinflated ego, a belief in her superior judgment, and a need for self-aggrandizement, manifesting in her matchmaking attempts and her conviction that she can control others’ destinies. Her perfectionism drives her to maintain high moral and intellectual standards, leading her to look down on others and experience intense self-hate when she recognizes her own errors. These flaws result in her misjudgments of character, her interference in Harriet Smith’s life, her insulting behavior towards Miss Bates, and her initial blindness to Mr. Knightley’s merits.

5. How does Paris interpret Elizabeth Bennet’s character, particularly her wit and charm, in relation to her underlying defensive strategies? While acknowledging Elizabeth’s positive qualities, Paris argues that her wit, charm, vitality, and intelligence also serve as defensive strategies. Drawing parallels with her father, Mr. Bennet, he suggests that Elizabeth employs detachment and a focus on the absurdities of others as a way to cope with her family’s social awkwardness and her mother’s lack of approval. Her pride and quick retorts, especially in her interactions with Darcy, are seen as ways to protect herself from feeling inferior and to assert her own worth. Despite these defenses, Paris emphasizes that Elizabeth is not fundamentally detached but rather expansive, with high self-esteem and expectations.

6. What is the significance of Darcy’s initial rejection of Elizabeth and her subsequent reactions from a psychological perspective, as analyzed by Paris? Darcy’s initial dismissive remark deeply wounds Elizabeth’s pride, particularly because she is an expansive person with a high opinion of herself and because the rejection comes from someone of his social standing. Elizabeth’s angry and defensive reactions, including her determination not to like him, are interpreted by Paris as a natural response to this mortification. Her later misperceptions of Darcy’s behavior at Netherfield and Rosings are also viewed through the lens of her wounded pride and her tendency to project her own feelings of superiority onto him. The proposal scene becomes a moment of triumph for Elizabeth, where she retaliates for past injuries and gratifies her pride by rejecting such a significant man.

7. In his chapter on Persuasion, how does Paris analyze Anne Elliot’s character in terms of self-effacement and her journey toward vindication? Paris portrays Anne Elliot as a basically self-effacing character who has internalized the negative judgments of her family and Lady Russell regarding her past engagement with Captain Wentworth. Her decision to break off the engagement, though seemingly prudent at the time, has led to years of regret and a diminished sense of self-worth. Paris highlights Anne’s tendency to prioritize the needs and opinions of others over her own, a hallmark of the self-effacing trend. The novel’s plot becomes her journey toward vindication, as Wentworth eventually recognizes her worth and the error of his own initial judgment. Her quiet strength and genuine sensibility are contrasted with the coldness and superficiality of her family, ultimately leading to her triumph and the validation of her character and her feelings.

8. What does Paris suggest about Jane Austen’s own “authorial personality” in relation to the characters and themes she portrays in her novels? Paris posits that Jane Austen’s authorial personality is complex and can be understood through the psychological dynamics reflected in her works. He identifies elements of detachment, irony, and a critical perspective in her narrative voice, suggesting that Austen herself may have employed similar defenses to navigate the social world. Her creation of a range of character types, from the expansive to the self-effacing, and her exploration of the conflicts arising from different psychological needs and defenses, reflect a keen understanding of human nature. Furthermore, Paris argues that Austen’s thematic concerns often revolve around the tension between societal expectations and individual desires, and the process by which characters learn self-knowledge and achieve a more balanced and realistic self-perception, potentially mirroring aspects of her own psychological development and understanding of the world.

Mimetic Characterization: Realism, Form, and Theme in Literature

Mimetic characterization is a type of character portrayal in literature that aims at verisimilitude and the realistic representation of human beings. According to Robert Scholes and Robert Kellogg, behind realistic fiction, there is a strong “psychological impulse” that “tends toward the presentation of highly individualized figures who resist abstraction and generalization”. When we encounter a fully drawn mimetic character, “we are justified in asking questions about his motivation based on our knowledge of the ways in which real people are motivated”.

The sources contrast mimetic characterization with other types:

• Aesthetic characters primarily serve technical functions or create formal patterns and dramatic impact.
• Illustrative characters are most important in works with a strong allegorical or thematic interest. They are “concepts in anthropoid shape or fragments of the human psyche parading as whole human beings”. We understand them through the principle they illustrate.

Jane Austen’s mature novels are noted for their mimetic characterization. Her protagonists, such as Elizabeth Bennet, Fanny Price, Emma Woodhouse, and Anne Elliot, are realistically portrayed women, each fascinating and comprehensible in terms of her own motivational system. The author takes over “the life by values as well as the life in time,” creating characters with “numerous parallels with people like ourselves”. Because of this lifelikeness and complexity, readers have always responded to these characters.

However, the source argues that mimetic characterization in realistic novels, including Austen’s, often creates tensions with form and theme.

• Conflict with Form: Comic structure, for example, follows the logic of desire and can involve manipulation and improbable resolutions. Realistic characterization, on the other hand, follows the logic of motivation, probability, and cause and effect. This can lead to a “disturbing sense of disjunction” for the reader when the world is manipulated for comic effect, as the reader expects a consistently realistic world for realistic characters.
• Conflict with Theme: Mimetic characters tend to escape the categories by which the author tries to understand them and can undermine the author’s evaluation of their life styles and solutions. The author’s understanding of a mimetic character is often oversimple, and seeing the character solely through the author’s eyes sacrifices their complexity. Furthermore, a reader’s judgment of a mimetic character, understood psychologically, may differ from the author’s.

To fully appreciate Austen’s genius in characterization, the source advocates approaching her major figures “as creations inside a creation” and trying to understand them as though they were real people. This involves employing the “realist’s” approach to characterization, which recognizes that fully realized characters can have a life of their own and should be understood in motivational terms.

The source proposes using psychological theory, particularly that of Karen Horney and other Third Force psychologists, to analyze Austen’s characters and understand their motivations, defense mechanisms, and inner conflicts. This approach allows for a detailed explication of the text by focusing on the psychological processes dramatized by the author, without relying on speculation beyond the text. Understanding Austen’s characters psychologically can reveal that the combination of mimetic characterization, comic action, and moral theme poses artistic problems, as the conventions of comedy and the logic of realistic motivation can be incompatible.

Austen’s Comic Structure and Mimetic Characterization

Comic structure in literature, as discussed in the source, follows a basic movement “from threatening complications to a happy ending”. According to Northrop Frye, whose theories are used to analyze comic structures, the happy ending in Jane Austen’s novels typically involves the heroine gaining the love of a good man, the security and prestige of a desirable marriage, and the recognition of personal worth she deserves. The obstacles to the heroine’s desire form the action of the comedy, and the overcoming of them constitutes the comic resolution.

Key elements of comic structure include:

• Manipulation: There is often a degree of manipulation involved in both creating and removing the blocking forces and in achieving the final resolution. Frye notes that “Happy endings do not impress us as true, but as desirable, and they are brought about by manipulation”. This can include unlikely conversions, miraculous transformations, and providential assistance, which are considered inseparable from comedy. Jane Austen, writing in a low mimetic mode (where the hero is “one of us”), disguises some of these irrationalities through displacement but also signals early on that the story operates within the conventions of comedy.
• Moralization of Comic Action: Jane Austen harmonizes form and theme by moralizing the comic action. Her satire targets personality traits, failures of judgment, and social distortions that hinder the happiness of good and sensitive people. Her moral norms are derived from the existing society at its best, and her conservative value system is reinforced by the comic apparatus of rewards and punishments.
• Liberalism vs. Conservatism: While comedy is generally liberal, celebrating the triumph of wish over reality, Austen’s comedy displays a displacement not only towards the plausible but also towards the moral. The wishes fulfilled in her novels are highly socialized, and primitive or selfish desires are rarely indulged. This can sometimes lead to the reader feeling less elation at the outcome, as sobriety and societal norms seem to triumph over youth and freedom.
• Role of Protagonist: The wish fulfillment aspect of comedy often works best when the protagonist has a certain neutrality, allowing them to represent desire. However, Jane Austen’s protagonists are highly individualized human beings, with whom readers may not readily identify, making it harder to fully embrace the comic resolution.

Tensions with Mimetic Characterization: As we discussed previously, Jane Austen is also a creator of brilliant mimetic characterizations, where characters are realistically portrayed with their own motivational systems. This creates a tension with the demands of comic structure.

• Conflicting Expectations: Readers who are sensitive to both comic form and realistic characterization may experience conflicting sets of expectations: one for the emotional satisfactions of overcoming obstacles and the triumph of desire (from the comic structure) and another for the pleasures of recognition derived from verisimilitude (from mimetic characterization).
• Manipulation vs. Motivation: While comic plots might be manipulated for a happy ending, Austen’s fully realized mimetic characters tend to remain true to their own natures. When the world of these realistic characters is manipulated for the sake of comic action, it can create a sense of disjunction for the reader. This problem would be less pronounced if the protagonists were simply neutral figures or stock types within the plot.

In summary, comic structure provides the framework for a journey from complications to a happy resolution in Jane Austen’s novels. However, her commitment to mimetic characterization and serious moral themes introduces complexities and potential tensions, as the demands of a conventional comic plot can sometimes clash with the realistic motivations and inherent natures of her deeply developed characters. The reader’s engagement with these realistic characters can lead to expectations that are not always fully satisfied by the often somewhat contrived nature of comic resolutions.

Jane Austen: Morality, Comedy, and Character

Moral theme is a central and pervasive aspect of Jane Austen’s novels, deeply intertwined with her comic structure and her creation of mimetic characters. Austen employs her narratives to explore and reinforce a strict and narrow notion of goodness, often using the comic apparatus of rewards and punishments to underscore her essentially conservative value system.

Here are key aspects of moral theme in Austen’s work, drawing from the sources:

• Moralization of Comic Action: Austen harmonizes form and theme by moralizing the comic action. The obstacles her heroines face and the journey towards a happy ending are often tied to failures of education and judgment or distortions of social customs that create pain and uncertainty for good individuals. The resolution of the comedy frequently involves characters learning moral lessons and adhering to societal norms.
• Conservative Value System: Austen’s moral framework is presented as conservative, where no happiness is possible outside of societal institutions and no deviation from its values is ultimately successful. She places a high value on individual fulfillment, but this is contingent upon first being good, according to her defined standards. The happy endings often reinforce this system through rewards for virtue and implicit or explicit punishments for vice.
• Satire of Moral Failings: Austen’s satire is directed at those traits of personality that lead to moral errors and social disharmony. This includes selfishness, stupidity, ill-nature, self-indulgence, pride, ambition, materialism, and vanity. Characters who embody these failings often serve as cautionary examples within the narrative.
• Education and Moral Growth: Several novels, particularly Mansfield Park and Emma, explore the theme of education as a process of moral development. Austen emphasizes the importance of nurture in shaping character, highlighting the contrast between spoiled and unspoiled children and the consequences of privilege versus hardship. While some characters seem inherently sensible, others need to learn and grow morally through experience, suffering, and good example.
• The Ideal of Goodness: Austen presents a specific ideal of goodness, often embodied in characters like Fanny Price and Elinor Dashwood. This ideal typically includes traits such as prudence, judgment, good sense, self-knowledge, sensitivity, perceptiveness, propriety, civility, self-control, sincerity, integrity, respect for authority, dutifulness, responsibility, unselfishness, consideration of others, self-denial, humility, and gratitude.
• Tensions with Comic Liberalism: While comedy is generally “on the side of desire” and celebrates the “triumph of wish over reality,” Austen’s moral conservatism introduces a displacement in the direction of the moral. The wishes that are fulfilled are often highly socialized, and the reader may sometimes find it difficult to feel elation at outcomes that prioritize sobriety and social propriety over youthful exuberance.
• Interaction with Mimetic Characterization: The source argues that Austen’s commitment to mimetic characterization can create tension with her moral themes. Her realistic characters, with their own complex motivations, may not always align neatly with the author’s moral framework or the demands of the comic plot. Readers who engage with these characters as “real people” may have different judgments about their actions and outcomes than the author intends. For instance, the source critiques the celebration of Fanny Price’s goodness, suggesting it stems from fear rather than genuine benevolence. Similarly, the analysis of Emma questions the completeness and healthiness of her moral growth.
• Austen’s Code of Values: The source identifies a consistent code of values and conduct that serves as the norm in Austen’s fiction. Characters are judged based on their adherence to this code, which encompasses various aspects of life, from family relations to social intercourse. Those who embrace or come to embrace this code generally gain Austen’s sympathy and approval.

In conclusion, moral theme is a foundational element of Jane Austen’s novels, shaping her comic structures and influencing the reader’s perception of her mimetic characters. While her works aim to reward virtue and uphold a conservative moral order, the depth and realism of her characterizations can sometimes lead to complex interpretations and potential tensions between the author’s intended moral message and the reader’s psychological understanding of her creations.

Fanny Price: Character Analysis in Mansfield Park

Fanny Price is the central protagonist of Jane Austen’s novel Mansfield Park, and her character is a complex subject of analysis when considering the novel’s comic structure, moral themes, and mimetic characterization.

• Fanny’s Role in the Comic Structure: Fanny functions as the heroine of the comic plot in Mansfield Park. The central action revolves around the creation and removal of obstacles to her desire for Edmund Bertram. Her primary obstacle is Edmund’s affection for Mary Crawford, which is resolved when Mary’s flawed character is revealed, allowing Edmund to transfer his affections to Fanny. From Fanny’s perspective, the story has a “miraculously happy ending” as she is united with the man she loves. Furthermore, the novel follows a “Cinderella story” archetype, where Fanny, initially treated as socially and personally inferior, eventually gains the esteem of Sir Thomas and Lady Bertram, the love of desirable men, and recognition for her virtue and perceptiveness. The happy ending brings her the “full acceptance for which she has yearned and the recognition and respect which she deserves”.
• Fanny as an Illustrative Character and Moral Theme: Thematically, Mansfield Park can be seen as a “novel of education,” although the source argues that it is not Fanny who is primarily educated, but rather the people around her who learn to appreciate her worth and share her values. Fanny largely remains the same, serving as a standard of goodness against which other characters are measured. The novel seems to glorify “early hardship and discipline” as formative influences, which Fanny embodies. Her “goodness” is consistently emphasized, and she is portrayed as having “some touches of the angel”. However, the source questions Austen’s “celebration of hardship, struggle, and suffering” and its supposed positive effects.
• Fanny as a Mimetic Character and Psychological Analysis: The source argues that Fanny is a “highly realized mimetic character” whose human qualities are “not compatible with her aesthetic and thematic roles”. Psychologically, Fanny is depicted as a product of a “pathogenic environment” at home, leading to insecurity, low self-esteem, and a lack of selfhood and spontaneity. She develops “socially sanctioned but personally crippling defensive strategies” in response. Key psychological traits of Fanny include:
• Self-effacing tendencies: She is “exceedingly timid and shy, and shrinking from notice”. She seeks to be “lowest and last” and avoids attention, competition, and triumph.
• Basic anxiety: She feels weak, worthless, inconsequential, and inadequate, living in constant fear and searching for a protector.
• Need for reassurance and protection: She seeks this by being useful and compliant, attaching herself to stronger figures like Edmund and eventually Sir Thomas.
• Suppressed emotions: She represses feelings like resentment and envy, often experiencing feelings she believes she should have rather than her genuine emotions.
• Embeddedness: She craves stability, peace, and order, clinging to familiar people and the environment of Mansfield Park.
• Tension Between Mimesis and Theme/Aesthetics: The source highlights a significant conflict between Austen’s portrayal of Fanny as a psychologically damaged individual and the novel’s rhetoric, which aims at her glorification. Many readers find it difficult to identify with or admire Fanny in the way the author intends, perceiving her as “insipid” or a “prig”. This difficulty arises because when Fanny is understood psychologically, her “goodness” appears to be the product of fear and a desperate need for acceptance rather than genuine benevolence. Austen seems to “glorify suffering” and believe in its positive formative effects, but her own portrayal of Fanny reveals the “crippling effects of Fanny’s childhood upon her personality”.
• Fanny’s Relationships:
• Edmund: He is Fanny’s “most consistent champion” from the beginning, recognizing her true worth and offering her kindness and support. She views him as her mentor, moral superior, friend, champion, and protector.
• Sir Thomas: Initially unsympathetic, Sir Thomas eventually becomes Fanny’s protector and comes to value her virtue. His approval is of paramount importance to Fanny.
• Mrs. Norris: Fanny’s “chief persecutor,” who constantly demeans and tries to subordinate her. Fanny is terrified of Mrs. Norris and tries to conform to her expectations.
• Henry Crawford: He is initially attracted to Fanny as a challenge and later appreciates her virtues, though he does not fully understand them. Fanny, however, is wary of his “corrupted mind” and cannot reconcile his moral character with her own values, ultimately refusing his proposal.
• Key Episodes:
• The Play: Fanny opposes the play due to her respect for Sir Thomas’s authority and her dread of exposing herself to attention.
• Refusal of Henry Crawford: This act, while morally consistent for Fanny, leads to Sir Thomas’s displeasure and intense distress for Fanny, highlighting her need for his approval.
• Visit to Portsmouth: This episode reveals Fanny’s “snobbish attitudes and unattractive behavior” toward her own family, stemming from her longing for the order and propriety of Mansfield Park and her resentment of her neglectful upbringing.
• Return to Mansfield Park: Fanny experiences “exquisite happiness” at her return, even amidst the disgrace of her cousins, highlighting her self-centeredness resulting from her past deprivations.
• Mansfield Park as Wish Fulfillment: The source suggests that Mansfield Park can be interpreted as a “wish fulfillment fantasy of embeddedness” for Fanny. She does not psychologically mature but finds security and acceptance in the familiar world of Mansfield Park, where her goodness is recognized, her persecutors are removed, and she achieves a desirable marriage.

In conclusion, Fanny Price is a complex character whose portrayal reveals a tension between the author’s thematic intentions and her insightful mimetic characterization. While Austen aims to present Fanny as a moral exemplar deserving of her happy ending, the psychological analysis suggests a deeply insecure individual whose “goodness” is a defense mechanism. This discrepancy can lead to a divergence between the author’s and the reader’s response to Fanny and the moral landscape of Mansfield Park.

Jane Austen: Tensions, Themes, and Character Psychology

Based on the sources and our conversation history, a discussion of Jane Austen reveals her as a highly skilled novelist whose works are rich with complex characterizations and explorations of social and moral themes, although they are not without internal tensions.

Here are some key aspects of Jane Austen as presented in the source:

• A Master of Multiple Dimensions: Jane Austen is recognized as a “great comic artist, a serious interpreter of life, and a creator of brilliant mimetic characterizations”. Some critics believe she achieves a unique balance among these aspects of her art.
• Tensions in Her Novels: The central thesis of the source is that Austen’s mature novels are “beset by tensions between form, theme, and mimesis”. This arises partly from the fact that her protagonists often serve aesthetic, illustrative, and mimetic functions simultaneously. As “creations inside a creation,” these characters can act in ways that are “often engaged in treason against the main scheme of the book”. Because they have “numerous parallels with people like ourselves,” they require understanding in terms of their motivations, similar to real individuals.
• Psychological Depth: The source emphasizes Austen’s “brilliant but least recognized achievement” in mimetic characterization. Characters like Elizabeth Bennet, Fanny Price, Emma Woodhouse, and Anne Elliot are portrayed as “realistically” and “fascinating” women, comprehensible through their own “motivational system”. To fully appreciate Austen’s genius, her major figures need to be understood as “creations inside a creation” and analyzed as if they were real people. The book utilizes Horneyan psychology to analyze these characters, focusing on their “strategies of defense and the structure of inner conflicts”.
• Moral and Social Themes: Austen’s novels are deeply concerned with moral themes and the relationship between the individual and society. She moralizes the comic action, directing her satire at “traits of personality, at those failures of education and judgment, and at those distortions of social customs and institutions which make daily life painful”. Her works often reinforce a conservative value system, where happiness is generally found within societal norms and individual fulfillment is linked to being “good” according to her defined standards.
• Comedy with Moral Underpinnings: While writing comedy, Austen’s moral conservatism can sometimes “diminish some of her comic effects”. Unlike typical comedy that celebrates the triumph of desire, Austen’s fulfilled wishes are often “highly socialized,” and primitive or selfish desires are rarely indulged. This can lead to situations where readers may not fully identify with the heroines’ desires or feel complete elation at the outcomes.
• The Authorial Personality: The source aims to reconstruct the “personality which can be inferred from all of Jane Austen’s writings,” referring to this as her “authorial personality”. This involves considering her “recurring preoccupations, the personal element in his fantasies, the kinds of characters he creates, and his rhetorical stance”. Critics hold diverse views of Austen, some emphasizing her “aggressive, satirical component,” others her “gentleness and conservatism,” and still others her “detached, ironic quality”. The source attempts to show how these diverse components are related within a structure of inner conflicts.
• Austen’s Code of Values: A “code of values and conduct” serves as the “norm by which all deviations are satirized and judged” in Austen’s fiction. Characters who align with or come to embrace this code generally receive Austen’s sympathy and approval. This code contrasts with the “cult of sensibility” and “worldliness,” both of which Austen critiques.
• Psychological Solutions: The source analyzes Austen’s characters through the lens of different Horneyan psychological “solutions”: expansive (aggressive), self-effacing (compliant), and detached. Austen displays a mixed attitude towards the expansive and detached solutions, while the self-effacing solution is often supported, though sometimes with irony towards simpler characters embodying it. The authorial personality is also described as having perfectionistic trends.
• Development and Dominating Fantasies: By examining Austen’s novels in chronological order of composition, the source identifies “striking shifts of direction” and suggests that each novel embodies a predominantly different fantasy related to these psychological solutions. For example, Pride and Prejudice embodies a predominantly expansive fantasy, while Mansfield Park glorifies the self-effacing solution.
• Reader Interpretation vs. Authorial Intention: The source acknowledges that readers may have interpretations of characters and outcomes that differ from Jane Austen’s explicit rhetoric. This is attributed to the mimetic depth of her characters, who can evoke responses based on psychological realism that may not align with the author’s formal or thematic goals. Our previous discussion of Fanny Price exemplifies this, where the source argues that Austen glorifies her self-effacing nature while a psychological analysis reveals a more complex and potentially unhealthy motivation.

In summary, Jane Austen is presented as a multifaceted author whose comedic novels delve into serious moral and social issues through richly developed, psychologically complex characters. The source highlights the inherent tensions within her works arising from the interplay between comic form, thematic intentions, and the mimetic realism of her characterizations. Furthermore, it explores the inferred complexities of Austen’s own personality as reflected in her diverse characters and narrative choices.

By Amjad Izhar
Contact: amjad.izhar@gmail.com
https://amjadizhar.blog

Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!

This excerpt from “Jane Austen Education” recounts the author’s unexpected journey of encountering Jane Austen’s novels and how they profoundly impacted his understanding of love, friendship, and life’s significant aspects. Initially resistant to nineteenth-century British fiction, the author describes how Austen’s work, particularly Emma, challenged his intellectual arrogance and self-centeredness, leading to significant personal growth. He reflects on how reading Austen’s stories taught him about character, conduct, and the importance of observing and understanding others. Through his engagement with Austen’s world and characters, the author illustrates a transformative educational experience that extended far beyond the realm of literature.

A Study Guide to “A Jane Austen Education”

Review Questions

1. According to Deresiewicz, what was his initial impression of Jane Austen and why did he hold this view?
2. What is the significance of “minute particulars” in Austen’s writing, as Deresiewicz comes to understand it through reading Emma?
3. Explain the concept of the “Janeite” as described in the text. What does becoming a “Janeite” signify?
4. How did Austen’s personal life and family relationships influence the subject matter of her novels, according to the author? Provide specific examples.
5. What does Deresiewicz mean when he states that Austen taught him a “new kind of moral seriousness”? How does this differ from his previous understanding?
6. In the chapter on Pride and Prejudice, what aspects of Elizabeth Bennet’s character resonated most with Deresiewicz?
7. How does Deresiewicz interpret Austen’s portrayal of maturity in her heroines? What role does suffering play in their development?
8. Explain Deresiewicz’s argument against the “Brontëan” critique of Austen’s novels. Did Austen ignore passion and feeling?
9. According to the text, what is Austen’s perspective on the importance of friendship? How does she portray friendship in relation to family?
10. What was the “big, huge thing” that Deresiewicz felt was missing in his life before delving into Sense and Sensibility? How did Austen’s exploration of love influence his understanding?

Short Answer Quiz

1. Initially, Deresiewicz viewed Jane Austen as a writer of “silly romantic fairy tales” due to his preoccupation with modernist literature, which he perceived as complex, difficult, and rebellious. He associated Austen with conventionality and a lack of intellectual depth, fitting his self-image as an alienated young man.
2. “Minute particulars,” as Deresiewicz learns from Emma, refer to the small, seemingly insignificant details of daily life and conversation that Austen meticulously portrays. She demonstrates that these everyday matters—gossip, arrangements, and minor occurrences—are the very fabric of human experience and hold significant meaning.
3. A “Janeite” is a devoted and enthusiastic admirer of Jane Austen and her novels, forming a kind of literary “club” with shared appreciation. Becoming a “Janeite,” according to the text, signifies a deep understanding and valuing of Austen’s subtle artistry and profound insights into human nature.
4. Austen’s personal life, though seemingly uneventful, provided rich material for her novels. Her close relationship with her sister Cassandra, her brothers’ naval careers, and her knowledge of her extended family’s experiences in India and society informed her understanding of social dynamics and human relationships.
5. Deresiewicz explains that Austen’s “new kind of moral seriousness” involves taking responsibility for one’s immediate surroundings and personal conduct, rather than focusing solely on grand, abstract issues. It emphasizes the ethical significance of everyday interactions and self-awareness.
6. Deresiewicz was drawn to Elizabeth Bennet’s brilliance, wit, fun-loving nature, and her spirited independence, including her willingness to defy social expectations and protect her loved ones. He admired her resilience in the face of a difficult family and her initial disinterest in marriage.
7. Deresiewicz argues that Austen’s heroines achieve maturity not through easy lessons but through experiencing genuine suffering, particularly humiliation for their unjust actions witnessed by those whose opinions they value. This painful self-recognition forces them to confront their flaws and grow.
8. Deresiewicz counters the “Brontëan” critique by asserting that Austen did not ignore feelings but rather valued them without advocating for their uncritical worship. He points to characters like Lydia and Elizabeth themselves as evidence of passion within Austen’s world, arguing that Austen simply believed in the importance of reason and self-control alongside emotion.
9. Austen, according to the text, considered friendship a vital and chosen form of family, sometimes even more meaningful than biological ties. Her novels depict intricate networks of friends and family, where genuine connection, mutual understanding, and support form the bedrock of a fulfilling life.
10. The “big, huge thing” missing in Deresiewicz’s life was a meaningful romantic relationship. Austen’s exploration of love in Sense and Sensibility and her other novels helped him understand the complexities of romantic connection, the importance of genuine feeling over societal pressures, and the possibility of finding true intimacy.

Essay Format Questions

1. Explore William Deresiewicz’s initial biases against Jane Austen and analyze how his reading of Emma led to a significant shift in his perception. What specific elements of the novel and Austen’s writing style contributed to this change?
2. Discuss Deresiewicz’s interpretation of Austen’s social world. How does she portray issues of class, gender, and social expectations, and what insights did Deresiewicz gain about his own social milieu through her novels?
3. Analyze Deresiewicz’s claim that Austen taught him about “growing up.” In what specific ways did reading Austen’s novels challenge his youthful arrogance and contribute to his emotional and intellectual maturation?
4. Examine the significance of friendship in Austen’s novels as presented by Deresiewicz. How does Austen portray the complexities and importance of platonic relationships, and what did Deresiewicz learn about the nature of true friendship from her work?
5. Deresiewicz argues that Austen’s novels offer profound insights into “the things that really matter.” Based on the excerpts, discuss what these essential values are and how Austen’s narratives illuminate their importance in navigating life and relationships.

Glossary of Key Terms

• Minute Particulars: This term, highlighted in the context of Emma, refers to the small, seemingly insignificant details of daily life, conversation, and social interactions that Austen meticulously observes and portrays in her novels, revealing their underlying significance.
• Janeite: A term used to describe a devoted and enthusiastic admirer of Jane Austen and her works, often indicating a deep appreciation for her subtle artistry, wit, and insightful commentary on human nature and society.
• Valetudinarian: A person who is in poor health or constantly concerned with their health; often used in the text to describe Mr. Woodhouse in Emma and his tendency to use his perceived weakness to control others.
• Picturesque: A contemporary aesthetic vogue during Austen’s time that emphasized landscapes and scenes that conformed to specific artistic principles of visual beauty, often involving elements like ruins, gnarled trees, and dramatic lighting.
• Dilettante: A person who cultivates an interest in an art or other field without real commitment or knowledge; used in the text to describe characters like Henry Crawford in Mansfield Park who dabble in various pursuits without genuine purpose.
• Worldliness: Having or showing much experience and knowledge of the world and of fashionable life; in the context of Mansfield Park, it often carries a negative connotation, associated with the superficiality and moral ambiguity of the Crawford siblings.
• Usefulness: A key concept discussed in relation to Mansfield Park, representing the value of having a purpose and contributing meaningfully to the lives of others, in contrast to a life of mere self-indulgence.
• Constancy (in love): The quality of being faithful and unwavering in one’s affections or loyalties, a theme explored in the discussion of Persuasion and the debate between Anne Elliot and Captain Harville.
• Self-Consequence: A sense of one’s own importance or status; in the excerpt from Northanger Abbey, it is used negatively to describe the pretentious attitudes of those who look down on novels.
• Crossidentify: The act of identifying with a character of a different gender than oneself, a point raised in the text regarding the common experience of female readers engaging with male literary protagonists.

Briefing Document: “A Jane Austen Education” by William Deresiewicz

Source: Excerpts from “0031-A Jane Austen Education_ How Six Novels Taught Me About Love, Friendship, and the Things That Really Matter ( PDFDrive ) (1).pdf” by William Deresiewicz.

Date: October 26, 2023

Prepared For: [Intended Audience – e.g., Personal Review, Literary Discussion Group]

Prepared By: [Your Name/AI Assistant]

Overview:

This briefing document summarizes the main themes and important ideas presented in the provided excerpts from William Deresiewicz’s “A Jane Austen Education.” The excerpts detail the author’s personal journey of engaging with Jane Austen’s six major novels and how these literary encounters led to significant insights and transformations in his understanding of love, friendship, morality, and the complexities of human relationships. Initially dismissive of Austen, the author comes to appreciate the profound wisdom embedded within her seemingly simple narratives of domestic life.

Main Themes and Important Ideas:

1. Transformation Through Austen:

• The book chronicles the author’s evolution from a self-absorbed, intellectually arrogant young man to someone more empathetic and attuned to the nuances of everyday life. He initially favored modernist literature, viewing Austen as “silly romantic fairy tales” that made him “sleepy.”
• His engagement with Austen, starting with Emma, becomes a catalyst for self-reflection and personal growth. He realizes his own shortcomings, such as his obliviousness to the feelings of others and his need to constantly assert intellectual superiority.
• Quote: “Like so many guys, I thought that a good conversation meant holding forth about all the supposedly important things I knew: books, history, politics, whatever. But I wasn’t just aggressively certain of myself—though of course I never let anyone finish a sentence and delivered my opinions as if they’d come direct from Sinai. I was also oblivious to the feelings of the people around me, a bulldozer stuck in overdrive, because it had never occurred to me to imagine how things might look from someone else’s point of view.”

2. The Significance of “Everyday Matters” (Theme of Emma):

• Deresiewicz highlights how Austen elevates the “gossipy texture of daily life” to the level of serious artistic concern. He contrasts his previous focus on grand, abstract ideas with Austen’s meticulous portrayal of “little affairs, arrangements, perplexities, and pleasures.”
• He initially finds Austen’s language plain and unremarkable (“No metaphors, no images, no flights of lyricism. This hardly seemed like writing at all.”), but later appreciates her subtle mastery in revealing character and power dynamics through seemingly simple descriptions.
• Quote: “While she plotted her schemes and dreamed her dreams, her ‘daily happiness’ was right there in front of her, in ‘affairs, arrangements, perplexities, and pleasures’—the hourly ordinary, in all its granular specificity.”
• He notes Austen’s ability to reveal character through seemingly insignificant details, such as Mr. Woodhouse’s controlling nature subtly conveyed through pronoun usage.
• He acknowledges the historical and contemporary undervaluing of “women’s language” and “minute particulars,” which form the core of Austen’s narrative focus. He sees Austen’s work as a triumph in making these “long histories of private matters” compelling and insightful.
• Quote: “‘Your friend Harriet will make a much longer history when you see her,’ he said. ‘She will give you all the minute particulars, which only woman’s language can make interesting.—In our communications we deal only in the great.’”

3. The Process of “Growing Up” Through Humiliation (Theme of Pride and Prejudice):

• His reading of Pride and Prejudice coincides with his own academic and personal challenges. He identifies with Elizabeth Bennet’s wit and initial resistance to societal expectations.
• He emphasizes the importance of learning from mistakes and the role of humiliation in achieving maturity in Austen’s novels. The heroines don’t grow up until they face the consequences of their actions and are forced to confront their flawed perceptions.
• Quote: “Austen’s heroines, I discovered that summer, had their mistakes pointed out to them over and over again, only it never did them any good. They didn’t grow up until something terrible finally happened. When maturity came to them, it came through suffering: through loss, through pain, above all, through humiliation.”
• He reflects on his own tendency to be condescending and how Austen’s characters helped him recognize this flaw.

4. Critique of Romanticism and the Value of Self-Knowledge:

• Deresiewicz touches upon the Romantic movement’s emphasis on feeling and passion, contrasting it with Austen’s more nuanced view. While Austen acknowledges feelings, she doesn’t advocate for their uncritical worship.
• He recounts his own youthful embrace of Romantic ideals of rebellion and individualistic isolation, which he eventually recognizes as foolish.
• Quote: “The most important word in popular music today is not “love,” it’s “I.” And the second most important is “wanna.” Popular music is one giant shout of desire, one great rallying cry for freedom and pleasure. Pop psychology sends us the same signals, and so does advertising. “Trust your feelings,” we are told. “Listen to your heart.” “If it feels good, do it.””
• He notes Brontë’s criticism of Austen for not delving into the “Passions,” but argues that Austen’s focus is on the understanding and management of those passions within a social context.

5. Learning to Learn (Theme of Northanger Abbey):

• The excerpts briefly mention Northanger Abbey in the context of Austen’s defense of the novel as a literary form worthy of respect.
• Austen criticizes the snobbery of those who dismiss novels as trivial and “feminine,” asserting that they can display “the greatest powers of the mind.”
• Quote: “Yes, novels; for I will not adopt that ungenerous and impolitic custom so common with novel-writers, of degrading by their contemptuous censure the very performances, to the number of which they are themselves adding…”
• The author also learns about the difference between acquiring knowledge as a status symbol (as exemplified by his father) and truly engaging with and understanding it. He highlights a professor who embodies a genuine love of learning and encourages students to spend time with “extraordinary people.”

6. Being Good (Theme of Mansfield Park):

• The excerpts introduce Mansfield Park and the character of Fanny Price, initially finding her and Edmund “proper and priggish.”
• He explores the theme of hypocrisy through characters like the Crawfords and Edmund’s shifting stance on the play.
• He notes the societal pressures and the marriage market prevalent in Austen’s time, where pragmatic considerations often outweighed love.
• The concept of “usefulness” is highlighted as a key value in Mansfield Park, contrasting with the dilettantism of characters like Henry Crawford.
• Quote: “‘It is everybody’s duty,’ Mary said, ‘to do as well for themselves as they can.’ But the novel’s most important word of all was ‘useful.’”
• The importance of genuine listening and empathy in human connection is emphasized through Edmund’s interactions with Fanny.

7. True Friends (Theme of Persuasion):

• The theme of friendship takes center stage with Persuasion. The author recognizes Austen’s portrayal of friendship as a chosen family and as an essential element within family relationships.
• He discusses the blurring lines between friendship and family in Austen’s world and in his own life experiences.
• He highlights Austen’s progressive view of friendship between men and women, exemplified by the relationships between Anne Elliot and Captain Benwick and Captain Harville. Austen challenges the notion that such friendships are inherently romantic or impossible.
• Quote: “Men have had every advantage of us in telling their own story. Education has been theirs in so much higher a degree; the pen has been in their hands. I will not allow books to prove anything.” (Anne Elliot’s feminist declaration).
• The author’s personal experiences of navigating friendships, including a difficult but ultimately positive interaction with a friend struggling with alcoholism, are linked to the lessons learned from Persuasion.

8. Falling in Love (Theme of Sense and Sensibility):

• The excerpts touch on the complexities of love and the societal pressures surrounding marriage in Sense and Sensibility.
• Austen critiques the purely transactional view of marriage prevalent in her time, where financial security and social status often overshadowed genuine affection.
• The author notes Austen’s subtle treatment of sexuality and her awareness of the physical aspects of relationships, despite not explicitly depicting them.
• His own journey towards finding love is subtly hinted at, with a reference to meeting someone at a party.
• The importance of mutual vulnerability and the ability to apologize and learn from mistakes within a relationship is highlighted.

Conclusion:

The provided excerpts from “A Jane Austen Education” reveal a compelling account of personal and intellectual growth spurred by a deep engagement with Jane Austen’s novels. Deresiewicz demonstrates how Austen’s focus on seemingly ordinary lives and “minute particulars” can yield profound insights into human nature, morality, love, and friendship. By examining each of her six major novels, he uncovers timeless lessons that challenged his own preconceptions and ultimately led to a more nuanced and empathetic understanding of himself and the world around him. The author’s personal anecdotes effectively illustrate the enduring relevance and transformative power of Austen’s literary genius.

Discovering Austen: A Literary Journey and Personal Reflection

Questions & Answers

# What sparked the author’s initial interest in Jane Austen after a period of literary rebellion?

Initially, the author, a graduate student immersed in modernist literature, viewed Jane Austen as representative of a dull and narrow literary tradition, preferring the complexity and revolutionary spirit of writers like Joyce and Conrad. However, a course requirement forced him to read Austen’s Emma, which unexpectedly captivated him. He found himself drawn into the seemingly ordinary lives and “minute particulars” Austen meticulously depicted, realizing that her work held a depth and insight into human nature that he had previously overlooked.

# How did reading Emma challenge the author’s self-perception and understanding of daily life?

Reading Emma prompted a significant shift in the author’s self-perception. He had previously identified with rebellious, isolated figures in literature, but through Emma, he began to see his own tendencies towards arrogance, obliviousness to others’ feelings, and a focus on grand ideas over the “daily happiness” found in ordinary life. He recognized his similarities to characters like Emma and Miss Bates, realizing he was not an isolated rebel but a regular person whose everyday experiences held value and significance.

# What did the author learn about “moral seriousness” from reading Austen?

Austen taught the author a new understanding of moral seriousness. He had previously equated it with concern for large-scale issues like politics and social justice, often engaging in theoretical debates without genuine emotional investment. Through Austen, he learned that true moral seriousness lies in taking responsibility for one’s own “little world” and for oneself, paying attention to the impact of one’s actions and words on those around them.

# How did the author’s encounter with Pride and Prejudice influence his understanding of personal growth and maturity?

Pride and Prejudice, particularly the character of Elizabeth Bennet, resonated deeply with the author due to her wit, intelligence, and initial resistance to societal expectations. However, the novel also highlighted the importance of acknowledging one’s own mistakes and the painful but necessary process of humiliation in achieving maturity. The author recognized his own tendency to believe in his intellectual superiority, much like Elizabeth’s initial misjudgment of Darcy, and understood that genuine growth comes from recognizing and confronting one’s flaws.

# What does the author identify as a key lesson from Mansfield Park regarding usefulness and self-deception?

Mansfield Park taught the author about the value of being “useful” and the dangers of self-deception, particularly through the contrasting characters of Fanny Price and the Crawfords. Fanny’s quiet integrity and commitment to duty are juxtaposed with the Crawfords’ worldliness and self-serving motivations. The author came to see that true worth lies in contributing meaningfully to the world and to others, rather than in superficial charm or the pursuit of fleeting pleasures, and recognized how easily one can rationalize selfish behavior.

# According to the author’s reading of Austen, what is the true significance of friendship and family?

Austen’s novels emphasized the profound importance of both friendship and family, often blurring the lines between the two. The author learned that friends are the family one chooses, but also that family members can be true friends. Austen depicts communities formed through genuine affection, mutual understanding, and shared experiences, highlighting friendship as a vital source of support, happiness, and moral guidance, and demonstrating that these bonds are essential for navigating life’s challenges.

# What did the author discover about the portrayal of men-women relationships in Austen, particularly in Persuasion, that challenged conventional romantic narratives?

Through Persuasion, the author realized that Austen challenged the conventional romantic narrative that insists on sexual attraction as the primary basis for connection between men and women. The relationships between Anne Elliot and Captain Benwick, and Anne and Captain Harville, demonstrated that men and women could form deep, meaningful friendships built on mutual respect, understanding, and shared intellectual and emotional space, without romantic entanglement. Austen, according to the author, advocated for the possibility of genuine platonic relationships between the sexes.

# How did the author’s personal experiences intertwine with and illuminate his understanding of Austen’s themes of love and relationships in Sense and Sensibility?

Reading Sense and Sensibility while navigating his own evolving relationships helped the author understand Austen’s nuanced portrayal of love and the complexities of romantic choices. He saw how societal pressures and pragmatic considerations could conflict with genuine affection, as depicted in the choices of characters like Charlotte Lucas and Mary Crawford. Moreover, reflecting on his own difficulties in expressing vulnerability and offering sincere apologies mirrored the emotional journeys of Austen’s characters, highlighting the importance of emotional honesty and the willingness to learn and grow within relationships.

The Enduring Influence of Jane Austen

Jane Austen’s influence can be seen in how her novels have been received by readers and critics over time, her impact on the development of the novel as a genre, and the lessons about love, friendship, and personal growth that her works impart.

Initially, Austen’s novels were met with reactions that suggested they were “trifling,” lacking in imagination and narrative, and “too natural to be interesting”. Even Madame de Staël considered her work “vulgaire”. However, despite these early criticisms, Austen garnered a dedicated readership who felt like they had joined a “secret club” by “getting” her work. Some even considered a real appreciation of Emma “the final test of citizenship in her kingdom”. Writers like Rudyard Kipling celebrated this phenomenon. Conversely, some, like Mark Twain, expressed strong dislike for her writing. This divide highlights the powerful and often deeply personal connection that readers have with Austen’s novels.

One of Austen’s significant influences lies in her ability to make readers see themselves in her characters and learn from their experiences. The author recounts his own initial boredom with Emma, only to realize that Austen had deliberately created a heroine whose feelings mirrored his own in order to expose his own “ugly face”. Austen wrote about everyday things not because she lacked other material, but because she wanted to show their true importance. Her “littleness” was an “optical illusion,” a test for the reader to see the deeper meaning in the commonplace. Her language, seemingly simple, worked subtly to establish character and power dynamics. She presented ordinary people with such masterful arrangement and balance that they became vivid and meaningful, mirroring the complexities of real life.

Austen’s influence also extends to the themes and structure of novels. She shifted the focus from grand events to the intricacies of “domestic Life in Country Villages”. She gave a “long history of private matters,” elevating “woman’s friendship and woman’s feelings” as worthy subjects of literature. Unlike the traditional comic plot where external obstacles keep lovers apart, Austen placed the obstacle “on the inside,” arguing that we ourselves are often what stands in the way of our happiness. She championed reason as liberation and personal growth as true freedom.

Furthermore, Austen challenged the Romantic emphasis on unchecked emotion, advocating for the triumph of reason over feeling, as seen in Pride and Prejudice. While she understood and portrayed feelings and passions, she did not believe they should be worshipped. Her works invite readers to question their instincts and intuitions, urging them to engage reason and objectivity. She taught through showing rather than telling, refusing to insert authorial essays or opinions into her narratives.

Austen’s exploration of relationships, particularly love and friendship, has also been highly influential. She presents friends as the family we choose and suggests that family members can also be friends. Her concept of true friendship involves putting a friend’s welfare first, even if it means pointing out their mistakes. She also challenged the notion that men and women can only be interested in each other sexually, portraying deep and meaningful friendships between them. Austen’s definition of true love often begins in friendship and adheres to the principles of friendship, emphasizing esteem, respect, and a shared desire for personal growth. She suggests that love is not a sudden strike but a gradual development.

Finally, Austen’s influence can be seen in her feminist perspective. She gave voice to female experiences and intellect, challenging the societal limitations placed on women. Through characters like Anne Elliot, she asserted the power of women’s perspectives and the equality possible between men and women.

In conclusion, Jane Austen’s influence is multifaceted, impacting how readers engage with literature, shaping the themes and structures of novels, and offering enduring insights into human relationships and personal development. Her ability to weave profound observations into seemingly ordinary narratives has cemented her place as a significant figure in literary history.

Learning, Character, and the Mentoring Mind

The sources discuss learning and education in several key ways, highlighting a shift from a focus on acquiring knowledge to developing character, the importance of questioning and critical thinking, and the role of mentors in guiding this process.

Initially, the author approached literary education with the goal of “fill[ing] the gaps” in his knowledge, focusing on prestigious literature. However, his early encounter with Jane Austen’s Emma challenged his preconceived notions, as the novel seemed to consist of trivial subjects and commonplace characters. Despite his initial repulsion, the author eventually came to appreciate Austen’s work, realizing that her “littleness” was a test to uncover deeper meanings. This personal journey reflects a form of learning that goes beyond simply accumulating information.

The source emphasizes that true growing up and education have “nothing to do with knowledge or skills” but rather “everything to do with character and conduct”. According to Austen, you don’t improve your character by memorizing facts or developing self-confidence alone; instead, “growing up means making mistakes”. This suggests that learning involves personal experience and the development of moral understanding.

The role of teachers and mentors is presented as crucial in the educational process. The author’s experience with a particular professor is highlighted as transformative. This professor taught by asking profound questions that challenged students’ assumptions and forced them to think for themselves. He exemplified a teaching style that encouraged curiosity and humility, rather than professional certainty. This approach contrasts with the author’s initial attempts at teaching, where he tried to force students to arrive at pre-determined answers. The professor, much like Henry Tilney in Northanger Abbey, acted as a “surrogate” for Austen, prompting students to reconsider their mental categories and conventions. Austen herself taught without being didactic, preferring to show rather than tell, and allowing her readers to arrive at their own understandings. She valued intelligent conversation and being informed about the world, but she ridiculed the mere acquisition of facts without deeper comprehension, as exemplified by the character of Mary Bennet.

The source also touches upon the idea of “miseducation,” where one’s mind is filled with elaborate theories that bear no relation to reality. True learning involves opening one’s eyes to what is actually in front of them and questioning acquired concepts. This is illustrated by Catherine Morland’s experience with the picturesque, where she learns the theory but misses the actual beauty around her.

Learning is portrayed as a lifelong habit, extending beyond formal education. The author’s professor suggested that just as Catherine could learn to love a hyacinth, individuals can keep learning to love new things throughout their lives. This includes learning to understand and appreciate others by paying attention to their “minute particulars” and listening to their stories. The act of conversing about daily life, seemingly trivial, is actually a way of attaching oneself to life and weaving the fabric of community.

The author contrasts his father’s view of education as the acquisition of facts and a means of cultural pride with the deeper understanding he gained through his literary studies. He learned that real strength lies not in certainty but in the willingness to learn, even from others.

Ultimately, the source suggests that the goal of education is not simply to transfer information but to “incite” students to discover their own potential and to foster critical thinking. A good learning environment is one where both the student and the teacher can learn and be surprised. This requires a shift in the teacher’s role from an authority figure to a facilitator who encourages students to think beyond them. The lessons learned from literature, particularly from Austen, can be applied directly to life, helping individuals to develop character, understand relationships, and engage with the world in a more meaningful way.

A Jane Austen Education: Growing Up

Growing up, or maturation, is a central theme explored in the provided excerpts from “A Jane Austen Education”. The author reflects on his own journey of growth through reading Austen’s novels, highlighting that it is a remarkable process that goes beyond physical development. It involves becoming “fit for human company, let alone capable of love”.

Austen’s perspective, as interpreted by the author, is that growing up has “nothing to do with knowledge or skills,” but rather “everything to do with character and conduct”. It is not about external achievements like “passing tests, gaining admissions, accumulating credentials”, or even developing self-confidence and self-esteem, which Austen views as potential obstacles. Instead, “growing up means making mistakes”. However, simply making mistakes is not enough; like Elizabeth Bennet, one might repeat the same errors. Even having mistakes pointed out is insufficient, as individuals often rationalize their actions.

True maturation, according to Austen, often comes through suffering, including loss, pain, and, above all, humiliation. It occurs when individuals do something “really awful” and are forced to recognize the gravity of their actions, often in front of someone whose opinion they value. Examples from Austen’s novels, such as Emma insulting Miss Bates and Elizabeth making false accusations, illustrate these painful but transformative moments. The author connects this to his own experiences of feeling shame and recognizing his own shortcomings. He learns that it is not enough to know you have done wrong; you must also feel it. Furthermore, maturation involves refusing to forget past mistakes, using the memory of them as a continuous lesson.

A key aspect of growing up is learning to see oneself “from the outside, as one very limited person,” realizing that one is not the center of the universe. This involves a shift from relying solely on feelings to also engaging reason and logic to evaluate one’s impulses. Austen’s Sense and Sensibility illustrates this contrast between feeling and reason. The heroines of Austen’s novels often initially trust their feelings too much and need to learn to doubt themselves. Elizabeth Bennet’s journey in Pride and Prejudice exemplifies this process of learning to put thinking above feeling.

The author also emphasizes that growing up is an ongoing process that “never stops”. There is a danger in becoming complacent and self-satisfied, as seen in the character of Elizabeth’s father. To continue growing, one needs to “stay on [their] toes”.

Relationships play a significant role in maturation. True friendship, in Austen’s view, involves putting a friend’s welfare first, even if it means pointing out their mistakes. Similarly, love, for Austen, is an agent of socialization, where partners challenge each other to become better people. Choosing a life partner is a crucial aspect of personal growth, and it is suggested that compatibility can develop through shared values and familiarity, a gradual “growing in love” rather than a sudden infatuation. The choice of a partner can significantly impact one’s character and soul.

Despite the seriousness of maturation, Austen also values youth as a time of openness to new experiences. Her novels, while depicting characters growing up, often focus on young people and their concerns. There is a suggestion that one can “get older…but still remain young” by staying open to learning and change. This involves learning to appreciate the beauty of the world and maintaining a capacity for love.

Mentors, like the author’s professor and characters like Henry Tilney, play a vital role in guiding the process of growing up by challenging assumptions and encouraging critical thinking. They teach by example and by prompting individuals to see beyond their current understanding.

Ultimately, the author’s journey through Austen’s novels reveals that growing up is a complex process involving self-awareness, learning from mistakes, balancing emotions with reason, cultivating meaningful relationships, and maintaining a lifelong commitment to personal development. It is about taking responsibility for one’s “little world” and oneself.

Austen’s Insights on Love, Friendship, and Growth

Our sources offer a rich exploration of relationships and love, contrasting the author’s initial immature understandings with the more profound insights he gains from reading Jane Austen. The discussion touches upon both romantic love and friendship, highlighting how Austen views these connections as crucial for personal growth and happiness.

Initially, the author’s approach to relationships was flawed and self-centered. He admits to having a romantic life that was “never been particularly happy”. His relationships were marked by “fights, sulks, head games, tears”. He reveals a period where he pursued a “steady supply of sex, with no strings attached,” driven by a “teenage boy’s idea of paradise”. However, he eventually recognized the emptiness of this approach. His interactions with women were often characterized by a lack of respect and a need to “hold forth as usual,” driven by his sense of intellectual superiority as a graduate student. He lacked insight into himself and others, and even when confronted with a friend’s concerns about intimacy, he was bewildered, demonstrating a profound lack of understanding about meaningful connection.

Through his engagement with Austen’s novels, the author begins to develop a more nuanced understanding of relationships and love. A central theme is the idea that love often begins in friendship. Austen portrays relationships built on mutual respect, esteem, gratitude, and genuine interest in the other person’s welfare. The author initially struggles with this concept, having different notions of what constitutes a romantic relationship.

Austen challenges the purely romantic and passionate ideal of love, often exemplified by the relationship between Marianne and Willoughby in Sense and Sensibility. While such passionate connections are often celebrated, Austen suggests that more enduring love is rooted in qualities like good character, worth, heart, and understanding, akin to the relationship between Elinor and Edward. The author comes to see that Elinor and Edward’s “tepid relationship” is presented as the novel’s idea of true love, validating Elinor’s sensible approach over Marianne’s impulsiveness.

True love, according to Austen, is not simply a feeling but something you have to prepare yourself for. It is not a magical force that transforms you, but rather something that works with who you already are. The author realizes that before one can truly love another, they must come to know themselves and grow up. The development of love is often gradual, a “growing on so gradually” that one hardly knows when it began.

Furthermore, Austen suggests that a healthy relationship involves a degree of challenge and disagreement, contributing to personal growth. A “friction-free relationship” is likened to a desert, implying that conflict, when handled constructively, can lead to deeper understanding and development. This contrasts with the author’s earlier experiences of “fights” that were destructive rather than growth-oriented.

The source also emphasizes the importance of “minute particulars” and listening to each other’s stories in building intimacy and connection. This act of paying attention to the details of someone’s life and valuing their experiences is presented as a high form of caring. The author’s own budding relationship later in the narrative reflects this, with hours spent on the phone “learning about each other, and respecting each other, by listening to each other’s stories”. This “conversation of souls” highlights a deeper level of connection beyond mere physical attraction.

Austen also explores the possibility of genuine friendship between men and women, challenging the prevailing notion that sex will always “get in the way”. The relationships between Anne Elliot and Captain Benwick, and Anne and Captain Harville in Persuasion, demonstrate intellectual and emotional connection without sexual interest.

The role of true friends is presented as crucial for navigating relationships and personal growth. Austen’s idea of true friendship involves putting a friend’s welfare before your own, which includes being willing to point out their mistakes, even at the risk of conflict. The author reflects on how a friend who was “on his case for all those years” was ultimately trying to help him become a better person. This aligns with the idea that growing up often requires having one’s errors acknowledged.

In conclusion, the author’s journey through Austen’s works reveals a shift from a superficial and self-serving view of relationships to an appreciation for connections built on friendship, mutual respect, shared values, and a commitment to personal growth. Austen’s novels highlight that true and lasting love is not a sudden, passionate event but a gradual development rooted in character and a willingness to understand and support one another, even through disagreements and challenges.

Jane Austen’s Social Commentary

The excerpts from “A Jane Austen Education” offer significant insights into Jane Austen’s social commentary, as perceived by the author. His journey of understanding Austen’s work involves recognizing that what initially seemed like trivial stories of everyday life were, in fact, subtle yet powerful critiques of the social norms and values of her time.

Initially, the author dismissed Austen’s novels as “silly romantic fairy tales” focused on “who was sick, who had had a card party the night before”. He saw the lives depicted as “trivial” compared to the grand themes of modernism. However, he eventually realized that Austen was writing about these everyday things precisely to show how important they really are. The “trivia” wasn’t just marking time; it was the point, revealing the fabric of their lives and, by extension, the values of their society.

One key aspect of Austen’s social commentary is her portrayal of the marriage market. The novel Sense and Sensibility illustrates how marriage was often viewed as a matter of financial prudence and social standing rather than love. Characters like John Dashwood exemplify this mercenary approach, calculating the financial worth of potential spouses. Austen highlights how deeply ingrained these values were, with young people often acting as if their parents still arranged marriages, despite having a choice. This commentary on societal pressures around marriage connects to our previous discussion on relationships, showing how societal norms could overshadow genuine affection.

Austen also offers a critique of social hierarchies and class consciousness. The author notes his own past adherence to the “oldest myth” that upper-class people are inherently urbane and cultured. However, through Austen’s portrayal of characters like the Bertrams and the Crawfords in Mansfield Park, he recognizes that elegant manners and active minds are distinct, and wealth does not necessarily equate to intellect or virtue. Mary Crawford’s inability to understand priorities outside of London demonstrates a “special kind of provincialism” common among those who consider themselves cosmopolitan. This social commentary relates to the theme of growing up, as the author sheds his own naive assumptions about social status.

Furthermore, Austen critiques the superficiality and moral failings within the upper classes. The discontinuation of daily prayers at the Rushworth estate and Mary Crawford’s flippant attitude towards religion and morality (“How could anyone take words like ‘duty’ and ‘conduct’ and ‘principle’ seriously?”) serve as examples of this critique. This connects to the discussion on maturation, as Austen values “duty” and “usefulness” as important aspects of a well-developed character, contrasting with the self-indulgence of some of her upper-class figures.

Austen’s commentary extends to gender roles and expectations. Mr. Knightley’s remark in Emma that women’s language deals with “minute particulars” while men deal “only in the great” initially seems to reflect a societal view. However, the author realizes that Austen uses this to highlight her own artistic triumph in making these “minute particulars” the very substance of her novels, focusing on “woman’s friendship and woman’s feelings”. Moreover, in Persuasion, Anne Elliot’s powerful assertion that “Men have had every advantage of us in telling their own story. Education has been theirs in so much higher a degree; the pen has been in their hands. I will not allow books to prove anything” is seen as Austen’s “crowning declaration as a writer, the feminist flag she planted on the ground of English fiction”. This challenges the societal imbalance in narrative power and connects to the theme of relationships by showing Austen’s advocacy for equality and mutual respect between men and women.

The author also notes Austen’s satire of didacticism and pedantry, as seen in the characters of Mary Bennet and Mr. Collins in Pride and Prejudice. Austen’s own writing avoids explicit lecturing, allowing her social commentary to emerge through character and plot rather than direct authorial intrusion.

In essence, the author’s evolving understanding reveals that Jane Austen was a keen observer of her society, using her novels to subtly critique its values, particularly concerning marriage, social class, morality, and gender roles. Her focus on the everyday lives of her characters became a powerful tool for social commentary, prompting readers to consider the deeper implications of seemingly ordinary interactions and societal norms. This aligns with the broader theme of the book, where engagement with Austen’s novels leads to personal growth and a more insightful understanding of the world.

By Amjad Izhar
Contact: amjad.izhar@gmail.com
https://amjadizhar.blog

Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!

This text serves as a literary travel guide, highlighting various locations across the globe that hold significance to renowned authors and their works. It details historic houses, museums, libraries, hotels, pubs, and even natural landscapes that inspired literary creations or were frequented by famous writers. The guide provides information on visiting these sites, often including addresses, contact details, and descriptions of what makes them special. From Shakespeare’s birthplace to Hemingway’s favorite bars and the landscapes of Brontë’s novels, the source connects readers with the real-world settings behind beloved literature. Furthermore, it lists literary festivals, tours, and other related attractions for book enthusiasts. Essentially, it invites readers to embark on a journey to experience literature in a tangible way.

A Journey Through Literary Landmarks: A Study Guide

Quiz

1. Describe the significance of Shakespeare’s Birthplace in Stratford-upon-Avon. What types of artifacts might a visitor expect to see there?
2. Why is the Abbey Theatre in Dublin considered a symbol of the Irish literary revival? Name at least two of its co-founders and their goals for the theater.
3. Explain Henrik Ibsen’s importance to modern drama. What kind of social commentary did his plays often deliver, and what was the public’s reaction during his lifetime?
4. What inspired William Wordsworth to write many of his famous poems while living at Dove Cottage? Mention a key aspect of the lifestyle he and his sister Dorothy embraced there.
5. Describe the experiences of George Sand and Frédéric Chopin during their winter stay in the Valldemossa monastery in Majorca. How did this period affect Chopin’s health and his relationship with Sand?
6. What were Jack London’s aspirations for Beauty Ranch in Sonoma Valley? What principles of agriculture did he aim to implement on his property?
7. Explain the connection between Robert Burns and the Auld Kirk Alloway. How did the site inspire his poem “Tam o’ Shanter”?
8. Why did James Joyce choose the Martello tower at Sandycove Point as the setting for the opening of Ulysses? Who was residing in the tower when Joyce stayed there?
9. Discuss the contrasting perspectives of Jane Austen and her characters regarding the city of Bath. What might have contributed to Austen’s personal feelings about the town?
10. Describe the enduring legacy of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson at 221b Baker Street. What can visitors experience at the Sherlock Holmes Museum?

Answer Key

1. Shakespeare’s Birthplace is significant as the house where William Shakespeare was born and spent his early life. Visitors can expect to see original and replica furnishings from the Elizabethan era, providing a glimpse into his family life and the times he lived in, including his father’s glove-making workshop and a traditional English garden.
2. The Abbey Theatre is a symbol of the Irish literary revival because it was established with the goal of staging works reflecting Irish culture and fostering new Irish playwrights. Its co-founders included W. B. Yeats and Lady Augusta Gregory, who aimed to create a truly Irish national theatre.
3. Henrik Ibsen is regarded as a founding father of modern drama for his plays that delved into the human psyche and offered sharp social commentary, often challenging Victorian moral codes. He was a controversial figure during his lifetime, with some audiences scandalized by the themes explored in his work.
4. William Wordsworth was inspired by the natural beauty of the Lake District surrounding Grasmere to write many of his poems. He and his sister Dorothy embraced a lifestyle of “plain living, but high thinking,” finding inspiration in their daily walks and observations of nature.
5. George Sand and Frédéric Chopin endured a difficult winter in the damp and isolated Valldemossa monastery, suffering from poor health, social isolation, and the harsh weather. This period worsened Chopin’s already fragile health and strained his relationship with Sand.
6. Jack London envisioned Beauty Ranch as a “ranch of good intentions,” aiming to create a bucolic Eden using organic and sustainable agriculture techniques. He wanted the ranch to be a model of responsible farming, cultivating various crops and livestock.
7. The Auld Kirk Alloway was a significant place for Robert Burns as he heard ghost stories associated with the ruins during his childhood, which later inspired his poem “Tam o’ Shanter.” Additionally, his father was laid to rest in the churchyard, making it a site of personal and familial importance.
8. James Joyce chose the Martello tower at Sandycove Point as the setting for the opening of Ulysses because he had briefly stayed there himself, and it provided a unique and symbolic location for the beginning of his epic novel. Oliver St. John Gogarty, a friend of Joyce, was residing in the tower during Joyce’s stay.
9. Jane Austen expressed a personal dislike for Bath, finding it wearisome compared to her beloved Hampshire countryside. However, some of her characters, like Catherine Morland in Northanger Abbey, express great fondness for the social life and attractions of Bath, highlighting a contrast between the author’s and her characters’ experiences.
10. The Sherlock Holmes Museum at 221b Baker Street preserves the fictional lodgings of the famous detective and his companion, Dr. Watson, allowing visitors to step into their world. The Victorian-era rooms are recreated as described in Conan Doyle’s stories, complete with Holmes’s possessions, offering an immersive experience for fans.

Essay Format Questions

1. Explore the concept of “literary pilgrimage” as presented in the source material. Discuss why readers are drawn to visit the homes and haunts of their favorite authors, and analyze the significance of these sites in enhancing our understanding of their lives and works.
2. Choose three different literary destinations featured in the guide (e.g., Shakespeare’s Birthplace, Walden Pond, the Hemingway House) and compare how the visited spaces reflect the lives, themes, and legacies of the authors associated with them.
3. Analyze the role of specific geographical settings in shaping the creative output of at least two different authors mentioned in the text (e.g., the Yorkshire moors and the Brontës, Dublin and James Joyce, Key West and Ernest Hemingway). Consider how the environment influenced their writing.
4. Discuss the significance of literary landmarks as cultural heritage sites. How do these places contribute to our understanding of literary history, and what efforts are made to preserve and present them to the public?
5. The source material highlights various “drink, dine, and doze” locations associated with famous writers. Analyze the relationship between these social spaces and the literary figures who frequented them. How might these environments have influenced their work or provided insights into their lives?

Glossary of Key Terms

• Literary Landmark: A place that holds significance due to its association with a writer or a work of literature, such as an author’s birthplace, home, a setting in a novel, or a favorite gathering spot.
• Pilgrimage: A journey to a place considered sacred or significant, often undertaken for personal, spiritual, or in this context, literary reasons.
• Repertory Theatre: A theatre company that presents a rotating schedule of different plays rather than running one production for an extended period.
• Literary Revival: A period of renewed interest and activity in a nation’s literature, often characterized by a focus on national identity and cultural heritage, as seen with the Irish Literary Revival.
• Social Commentary: Writing that critiques aspects of society, such as its institutions, customs, or power structures, often with the aim of promoting social or political change, as evident in the works of Dickens and Ibsen.
• Romantic Era: A literary and artistic movement in the late 18th and early 19th centuries that emphasized emotion, imagination, individualism, and the beauty of nature, exemplified by writers like Wordsworth, Byron, and Keats.
• Modern Drama: A form of theatre that emerged in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, characterized by realism, psychological depth, and a focus on social issues, with Henrik Ibsen being a key figure.
• Gothic Literature: A genre of literature that combines elements of horror, romance, and the supernatural, often set in eerie or decaying settings, as seen in Dracula and some works by Hawthorne and the Brontës.
• Autobiographical: Relating to or based on the author’s own life and experiences, as seen in Dickens’s David Copperfield and Steinbeck’s East of Eden.
• Expatriate: A person who lives outside their native country, often for an extended period, as James Joyce did after leaving Dublin.

Briefing Document: Literary Landmarks from Jane Austen’s Bath to Ernest Hemingway’s Key West

Source: Excerpts from “Novel Destinations: Literary Landmarks from Jane Austen’s Bath to Ernest Hemingway’s Key West” by Shannon McKenna Schmidt and Joni Rendon (2008).

Main Theme: This book excerpt serves as a guidebook to literary landmarks, inviting readers to connect with their favorite authors and books by visiting significant locations associated with them. It highlights homes, museums, theaters, pubs, and even landscapes that inspired or were inhabited by renowned writers, spanning various eras and genres. The central idea is that these places offer a tangible link to the literary imagination and provide a deeper understanding of the authors’ lives and works.

Key Ideas and Facts:

• The Power of Place in Literary Imagination: The introduction suggests that while fictional universes may not always have a precise geographical location, the real-world places associated with their creation hold significance. The authors pose rhetorical questions about the settings of iconic literary works, then pivot to the importance of honoring the actual places that sparked these ideas. For example, they mention the bar stool where Beckett might have conceived Waiting for Godot and Melville’s Arrowhead home, where the view of Mount Greylock could have inspired the shape of the whale in Moby Dick.
• Quote: “Luckily, universes can fit on a head of a pin, and the pins are worth honoring, too.”
• Quote: “Sometimes a book invites a journey, sometimes we invite ourselves.”
• Shakespearean Pilgrimages: The excerpt emphasizes Stratford-upon-Avon, England, as a long-established pilgrimage site for “Bard fans.” It details Shakespeare’s Birthplace, highlighting the preservation of the Tudor house and garden, offering a “fascinating glimpse into Elizabethan life and times.” The Royal Shakespeare Company’s three theaters in Stratford are also mentioned as key attractions. Furthermore, the text points to Stratford, Ontario, Canada, as another significant location for Shakespeare enthusiasts, boasting North America’s largest classical repertory theatre.
• Honoring Playwrights: The document explores locations associated with other prominent playwrights, including Shaw’s Corner in Hertfordshire, England, the Abbey Theatre in Dublin (founded by Yeats and others to reflect “the deeper thoughts and emotions of Ireland”), and the Ibsen Museum in Oslo, Norway, preserving Ibsen’s final apartment where he uttered his famous last words: “On the contrary.” It also mentions other Ibsen museums in Norway.
• Wordsworth and the Lake District: Dove Cottage in Grasmere, Wordsworth’s “nest in a green dale,” is presented as a pivotal location for his most productive writing period, characterized by “plain living, but high thinking.” The adjacent museum displaying manuscripts like the original draft of “Daffodils” is also noted.
• Literary Exiles and Retreats: The excerpt delves into the contrasting experiences of George Sand and Frédéric Chopin in a Majorcan monastery, where the harsh conditions and isolation profoundly affected Chopin’s health and their relationship. Conversely, Jack London’s Beauty Ranch in Sonoma Valley, California, is portrayed as his “bucolic Eden,” a deliberate creation rooted in his success as a writer and his commitment to sustainable agriculture.
• Quote (Sand on Majorca): “Death seemed to hover over our heads to seize one of us, and we were alone in contending with him for his prey.”
• Quote (London on his ranch): “‘Next to my wife, the ranch is the dearest thing in the world to me.’”
• Scottish Literary Heritage: The focus shifts to Robert Burns, with descriptions of his birthplace, Burns Cottage, and the nearby Auld Kirk Alloway, which inspired his poem “Tam o’ Shanter.” The annual Burns Night Suppers are also mentioned as a global celebration of the poet.
• Yeats’s Ireland: County Sligo, Ireland, is highlighted as the landscape that deeply influenced the poetry of W. B. Yeats. The Lake Isle of Innisfree is specifically mentioned as inspiration for one of his early poems.
• Romantic Poets in Italy: The Keats-Shelley House in Rome is presented as a memorial to the Romantic poets who lived and died in Italy. It houses a collection of artifacts related to Keats and Shelley, as well as other literary figures. Byron’s Roman sojourn and his contrasting relationship with Keats are also touched upon.
• Quote (Byron on Rome): “‘As a whole, ancient and modern, it beats Greece, Constantinople, everything—at least that I have ever seen.’”
• American Literary Landmarks: The excerpt covers a range of American authors and their significant locations, including Carl Sandburg’s Connemara, Edna St. Vincent Millay’s Steepletop, Robert Frost’s homes in New Hampshire and Vermont, Emily Dickinson’s Homestead, Henry Wadsworth Longfellow’s Cambridge home, O. Henry’s Austin residence, Laura Ingalls Wilder’s Mansfield home, Edgar Allan Poe’s Philadelphia residences, Herman Melville’s Arrowhead, Washington Irving’s Sunnyside, Mark Twain’s birthplace in Florida, Missouri, and his boyhood home in Hannibal. These sections often include details about the preserved homes and museums.
• Quote (Melville on Arrowhead): “‘I have a sort of sea-feeling here in the country, now that the ground is all covered with snow…My room seems a ship’s cabin…’”
• Quote (Irving on Sunnyside): “‘It is a beautiful spot…capable of being made a little paradise.’”
• Quote (Twain on his birthplace): “‘The village contained a hundred people and I increased the population by one per cent.’”
• Dracula’s England and Romania: Whitby, England, is identified as the atmospheric inspiration for Bram Stoker’s Dracula, with descriptions of the harbor, Whitby Abbey, and St. Mary’s Church graveyard. Sighisoara, Romania, Vlad the Impaler’s birthplace, and Snagov Monastery, his reputed burial place, are also featured.
• Quote (Stoker on Whitby): “‘Masses of sea fog came drifting inland…so dank and damp and cold that it needed but little effort of imagination to think that the spirits of those lost at sea were touching their living brethren with the clammy hands of death.’”
• Russian Literary Giants: The excerpt visits the estate-museum of Leo Tolstoy at Yasnaya Polyana, Anton Chekhov’s house museum in Moscow, and Fyodor Dostoevsky’s childhood apartment, also in Moscow, highlighting their personal histories and literary connections to these places.
• Quote (Tolstoy on Yasnaya Polyana): “‘I could hardly imagine Russia, or my relationship with her, without my Yasnaya Polyana.’”
• Quote (Chekhov on his dual life): “‘Medicine is my lawful wife, and literature is my mistress. When I get fed up with one, I spend the night with the other.’”
• Mystery and Detective Fiction: The guidebook touches upon locations associated with mystery writers, including Dashiell Hammett’s San Francisco and the Sherlock Holmes Museum at 221b Baker Street in London, emphasizing the immersive experience offered to fans.
• Quote (Conan Doyle’s Holmes): “‘I have my eye on a suite on Baker Street.’”
• Literary Destinations Beyond Homes: The excerpt expands to include libraries like Trinity College in Dublin (housing the Book of Kells) and the British Library in London (displaying treasures like the Magna Carta and Shakespeare’s First Folio), emphasizing their importance in preserving literary history. It also mentions the use of Dunnottar Castle and Blackness Castle in Scotland as filming locations for Shakespeare’s Hamlet.
• Literary Hotels: Several hotels with literary connections are highlighted, including the Beau-Rivage Palace in Lausanne, which hosted Victor Hugo and Mark Twain, the Hotel d’Inghilterra in Rome (frequented by Henry James), and Pensione Wildner in Venice (also associated with James).
• Literary Pubs and Restaurants: The document lists various establishments that were frequented by famous writers, such as John’s Grill in San Francisco (Hammett), Rules in London (Dickens, Thackeray, Wells), Davy Byrnes Pub in Dublin (Joyce), and Dirty Dick’s in London (possible inspiration for Miss Havisham).
• Jane Austen’s Ambivalence Towards Bath: While Bath is mentioned in the title, the excerpt reveals Jane Austen’s personal dislike for the city, contrasting with the positive portrayal in Northanger Abbey. Her preference for rural life and her family’s move to Bath are discussed.
• Quote (Austen): “‘Bath is still Bath.’”
• Charles Dickens’s London: A significant portion is dedicated to Charles Dickens’s life and works in London, featuring the Charles Dickens Museum at his former Doughty Street residence, remnants of Marshalsea Debtors Prison, and his beloved Gad’s Hill Place in Kent. Various London locations mentioned in his novels and associated with his life are also highlighted, along with dining and drinking establishments he frequented.
• Quote (Dickens on David Copperfield): “‘I have in my heart of hearts a favorite child. And his name is David Copperfield.’”
• Quote (Dickens on Gad’s Hill Place): “‘The spot and the very house are literally ‘a dream of my childhood,’’”
• The Brontës’ Haworth: Haworth in West Yorkshire, England, the home of the Brontë sisters, is depicted as a place deeply intertwined with their literary creations. The Brontë Parsonage Museum and the surrounding moors are emphasized as essential for understanding their work.
• Quote (Virginia Woolf on Haworth and the Brontës): “‘Haworth expresses the Brontës; the Brontës express Haworth. They fit like a snail to its shell.’”
• Victor Hugo’s Paris: Notre-Dame Cathedral in Paris, the setting of The Hunchback of Notre-Dame, is described through Hugo’s eyes, emphasizing its architectural grandeur and the panoramic views of the city from its towers.
• Quote (Hugo on Notre-Dame): “‘No view in the world…could be more magical, more airy, more enchanting.’”
• James Joyce’s Dublin: Dublin is presented as central to the works of James Joyce, particularly Ulysses. Key locations like the James Joyce Museum in Sandycove, Davy Byrnes Pub, and sites referenced in the novel are highlighted, along with the annual Bloomsday celebration.
• Quote (Joyce on his portrayal of Dublin): “‘I want to give a picture of Dublin so complete that if the city suddenly disappeared from the earth it could be reconstructed out of my book.’”
• Franz Kafka’s Prague: Prague is portrayed as an intrinsic element of Franz Kafka’s haunting literary world, reflecting his personal struggles and the city’s unique atmosphere. While not explicitly named, Prague’s architecture and atmosphere are seen as embodied in his works.
• Quote (Kafka on his desire for peace): “‘I didn’t anymore believe in the possibility of real peace…but all the same I went in search of it.’”
• Quote (Kafka on his house in Golden Lane): “‘It suits me down to the ground…it is something special to have one’s own house, to shut in the face of the world the door, not of your room, not of your apartment, but of your own house.’”
• Nathaniel Hawthorne’s Salem: Salem, Massachusetts, particularly The House of the Seven Gables and the Custom House where Hawthorne worked, are discussed as significant influences on his writing.
• Quote (Hawthorne on The House of the Seven Gables): “‘The aspect of the venerable mansion has always affected me like a human countenance…It was itself like a great human heart, with a life of its own, and full of rich and sombre reminiscences.’”
• Ernest Hemingway’s Key West: Key West, Florida, is presented as a crucial location for Ernest Hemingway, where he wrote, fished on his boat Pilar, and developed his “Papa” persona. His house there is now a museum.
• Quote (London on his Key West home): “‘We have bought that old house with the iron rails and balconies opposite the lighthouse in K.W.’”
• Other Southern Writers: The excerpt briefly mentions Tennessee Williams’s connection to Key West and Harper Lee’s Monroeville, Alabama, the inspiration for To Kill a Mockingbird.
• John Steinbeck’s California: Monterey and Salinas, California, are highlighted as “Steinbeck Country,” the real-world settings that heavily influenced his novels like Cannery Row and East of Eden.
• Quote (Steinbeck on his intention with East of Eden): “‘My wish is that when my reader has finished with this book, he will have a sense of belonging in it. He will actually be a native of that Valley.’”

Overall Significance: This excerpt demonstrates the enduring connection between literature and place. By guiding readers to these literary landmarks, the book encourages a more immersive and personal engagement with the works and lives of these celebrated authors. It highlights how physical environments can shape creative output and how visiting these sites can enrich our understanding and appreciation of literature.

Literary Landmarks: Inspiration and Pilgrimage

Why might literary enthusiasts be interested in visiting the homes and haunts of famous authors?

Visiting literary landmarks allows readers to connect more deeply with their favorite books and authors. Seeing the places where authors lived and worked can provide insights into their inspirations, daily lives, and the social and physical environments that shaped their writing. These visits can transform the act of reading into a more tangible and personal experience, fostering a stronger appreciation for the creative process.

This text highlights numerous locations associated with William Shakespeare. What are some key sites mentioned and why are they significant?

The text emphasizes Stratford-upon-Avon, England, as Shakespeare’s birthplace and a long-standing pilgrimage site for Bard fans. Key sites include Shakespeare’s Birthplace itself, a Tudor house where he was born and likely lived with his wife, Anne Hathaway. Stratford also boasts the Royal Shakespeare Company with its three theaters on the River Avon, and the New Shakespeare Company at the enchanting open-air theater, a magical spot to experience his plays. These locations are significant because they offer a direct link to Shakespeare’s origins and the ongoing performance tradition of his works.

The establishment of the Abbey Theatre in Dublin is discussed in relation to W. B. Yeats. What were the motivations behind its founding?

W. B. Yeats and his co-founders established the Abbey Theatre with the aim of creating an Irish national theater that would stage works reflecting the “deeper thoughts and emotions of Ireland.” They sought to cultivate new Irish playwrights like J. M. Synge and Sean O’Casey and promote a renewed sense of national identity through pride in Gaelic culture. The theater became a symbol of the Irish literary revival.

Several authors, including Henrik Ibsen and James Joyce, are described as having lived in self-imposed exile or having left their homelands. How might this experience have influenced their writing?

Living in exile can provide authors with a unique perspective on their native culture and society, often leading to themes of displacement, identity, and belonging in their works. Distance can sharpen memories and offer a critical lens through which to examine their origins. For instance, while James Joyce wrote extensively about Dublin, he did so from abroad, suggesting a complex relationship with his homeland that likely infused his detailed and critical portrayals. Ibsen’s self-imposed exile might have contributed to the social commentary and critical examination of Victorian morality found in his plays.

The text explores the connection between Bram Stoker’s Dracula and the town of Whitby, England. What elements of Whitby inspired the novel?

Bram Stoker visited Whitby seeking a relaxing vacation but found inspiration in its “unpredictable North Sea climes, rugged cliffs, and dramatic location in the shadow of a ruined abbey.” The story of a shipwreck that ran aground in the harbor five years prior also fueled his imagination. These elements contributed to the ominous backdrop of Dracula‘s arrival in England via a shipwrecked vessel, with the titular character making his way to St. Mary’s Church and its ancient graveyard, becoming the setting for his first English victim.

Authors like Jack London and Edna St. Vincent Millay sought out specific rural locations for their homes. What aspects of these places were important to them?

Authors often seek environments that foster creativity and provide solace. Jack London envisioned his Sonoma Valley ranch, Beauty Ranch, as a “bucolic Eden” where he could pursue his agrarian dreams and use organic and sustainable agriculture. The tranquility and connection to nature were clearly important. Edna St. Vincent Millay and her husband bought Steepletop, a former blueberry farm, for its rural setting in eastern New York, suggesting a desire for peace and inspiration away from urban life. Robert Frost also sought a “Garden of Eden” in his Vermont stone cottage, emphasizing the importance of a connection with nature for his writing.

The text mentions several literary museums and historic houses dedicated to authors. What kinds of artifacts and experiences do these places typically offer to visitors?

Literary museums and historic houses often provide a glimpse into the lives and works of authors through preserved personal belongings, original manuscripts, first editions of their books, photographs, and furniture. Visitors can often tour the rooms where authors lived and wrote, gaining a sense of their daily routines and creative spaces. Some museums also offer guided tours, educational programs, and exhibits that contextualize the authors’ lives within their historical and literary periods. These sites aim to bring visitors closer to the authors and their creative processes.

The concept of literary pilgrimage appears throughout the text. What motivates readers to undertake these journeys?

Literary pilgrimage is driven by a desire to deepen one’s connection with beloved authors and their works by visiting places associated with them. It’s a way for readers to step into the worlds depicted in literature, to see the landscapes that inspired authors, and to feel a tangible link to their creative heroes. These journeys can be motivated by curiosity, a sense of reverence, and the hope of gaining a richer understanding of the author’s life and the context of their writing. The act of visiting these sites can feel like a form of homage and a way to make the literary experience more real and memorable.

Literary Landmarks: Connecting Readers and Author Places

The sources discuss a variety of literary landmarks, which are places significant due to their associations with authors, their lives, or their works. These landmarks offer readers a way to connect more deeply with the books and writers they cherish.

The book “Novel Destinations: Literary Landmarks from Jane Austen’s Bath to Ernest Hemingway’s Key West” itself serves as a guidebook to many of these locations. The contents page highlights several categories of literary landmarks, including:

• Author Houses and Museums: These are intimate places where writers lived, dreamed, drew inspiration, and spent their most creative hours, offering a glimpse into the moment of artistic creation. Examples include:
• Shakespeare’s Birthplace in Stratford-upon-Avon, England, now overseen by the Shakespeare Birthplace Trust. Charles Dickens and John Keats were early visitors.
• Abbotsford, the castle-like manor of Sir Walter Scott in Scotland, now a literary museum.
• Dove Cottage, the home of William Wordsworth in England.
• Arrowhead, the home of Herman Melville in western Massachusetts, where he wrote Moby Dick.
• The Wayside in Concord, Massachusetts, the home of Louisa May Alcott and later Nathaniel Hawthorne.
• The Ernest Hemingway Museum (La Finca Vigía) in Havana, Cuba.
• The Brontë Parsonage Museum in Haworth, West Yorkshire, England.
• The Dublin Writers Museum in Dublin, Ireland, which traces Ireland’s literary legacy.
• The National Steinbeck Center in Salinas, California, celebrating the life and work of John Steinbeck.
• The James Joyce Museum in the Martello tower at Sandycove Point, Dublin, which was featured in Ulysses.
• Atmospheric Literary Landscapes: Physical places that inspired authors and became settings in their works.
• The Scottish Border Country that inspired Sir Walter Scott.
• The Lake District in England, associated with William Wordsworth.
• Sligo in Ireland, which inspired the early works of W. B. Yeats, including Glencar Lake and Waterfall and Knocknarea (Sacred Hill).
• Cornwall in southwest England, which provided inspiration for Daphne du Maurier.
• Monroeville, Alabama, the small town that inspired Harper Lee‘s To Kill a Mockingbird.
• Monterey and Salinas, California, the setting for many of John Steinbeck‘s works.
• Bath, England, frequented by Jane Austen.
• London, England, associated with Charles Dickens.
• Paris, France, linked to Victor Hugo and Ernest Hemingway.
• Dublin, Ireland, immortalized by James Joyce.
• Literary Festivals, Tours, and More: Organized events and routes that allow enthusiasts to explore literary connections.
• Bloomsday in Dublin, an annual celebration of James Joyce’s Ulysses on June 16th.
• The Steinbeck Festival in Salinas, California.
• The Tennessee Williams/New Orleans Literary Festival.
• Literary walking tours in cities like Boston, New York (Greenwich Village), London, Paris (Hemingway’s Paris), and Dublin.
• Literary pub crawls in Dublin, London, and Edinburgh, visiting pubs frequented by famous writers.
• Booked Up: Literary Places to Drink, Dine, and Doze: Establishments like pubs, cafes, restaurants, and hotels that were frequented by authors or are mentioned in literature.
• Shakespeare and Company bookstore in Paris, a gathering place for expatriate writers like James Joyce and Ernest Hemingway.
• The Eagle and Child pub in Oxford, England, where The Inklings (including C. S. Lewis and J. R. R. Tolkien) met.
• La Rotonde and La Closerie des Lilas in Paris, cafes frequented by Ernest Hemingway and other literary figures.
• Harry’s Bar in Venice, Italy, a favorite of Ernest Hemingway and Truman Capote.
• The White Horse Tavern in Greenwich Village, a haunt of Dylan Thomas and Jack Kerouac.
• The Algonquin Hotel in New York City, where F. Scott Fitzgerald lodged and Dorothy Parker’s “Vicious Circle” met.
• The Hotel Monteleone in New Orleans, frequented by Southern writers like Eudora Welty, Truman Capote, and Tennessee Williams.
• John’s Grill in San Francisco, a favorite of Dashiell Hammett.
• Longfellow’s Wayside Inn in Sudbury, Massachusetts, which inspired Henry Wadsworth Longfellow’s poems.
• Westminster Abbey in London, the burial place of many distinguished literary figures, known as Poets’ Corner.

These literary landmarks serve as tangible connections to the world of literature, allowing readers to experience the places that shaped their favorite authors and stories. Whether it’s visiting an author’s home, walking the streets they described, or having a drink in their favorite pub, these destinations offer a unique way to engage with literary history.

Author Homes: Literary Landmarks and Museums

The sources discuss author homes extensively, primarily within the chapter titled “AUTHOR HOUSES AND MUSEUMS“. These are described as the intimate places where writers lived, dreamed, dozed, drew inspiration, and spent their most creative hours, offering readers a rare glimpse into the ephemeral moment of artistic creation.

The significance of author homes lies in the tangible connection they provide to the writers and their works [the initial summary]. Visiting these places allows readers to see the environments that shaped their favorite authors and stories [the initial summary, 5]. As the introduction notes, people seek out these literary places to gain a deeper perspective on the books they cherish. The mere mention of places like Ernest Hemingway’s Key West or Victor Hugo’s Paris can inspire travel for novel exploration, as many come to know these places through the eyes of these authors.

Many author homes have been preserved and turned into museums, allowing the public to visit and learn more about the authors’ lives and works. Some examples from the sources include:

• Shakespeare’s Birthplace in Stratford-upon-Avon, England, is overseen by the Shakespeare Birthplace Trust and was visited by early sightseers like Charles Dickens and John Keats. It displays many of the trees, flowers, and herbs mentioned in Shakespeare’s works, and an exhibition center illuminates his life.
• Abbotsford, the castle-like manor of Sir Walter Scott in Scotland, is now a literary museum showcasing his antique furnishings, weaponry, and a 7,000-volume library. It opened as one of the world’s first literary museums just five months after Scott’s death and was visited by figures like Queen Victoria and Charlotte Brontë.
• Dove Cottage, the home of William Wordsworth in England, along with an adjacent museum displaying portraits and manuscripts like the original draft of “Daffodils”.
• Arrowhead, the home of Herman Melville in western Massachusetts, where he wrote Moby Dick. The house is restored to its Melville-era appearance, and a window in his second-floor study offered views of Mount Greylock, said to resemble a whale.
• The Wayside in Concord, Massachusetts, the home of Louisa May Alcott and later Nathaniel Hawthorne.
• The Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum in Key West, Florida, Hemingway’s first home on U.S. soil after living abroad.
• The Brontë Parsonage Museum in Haworth, West Yorkshire, England, remains much as it did when the Brontë sisters lived there, allowing visitors to see the dining room where they brainstormed plot ideas.
• The Dublin Writers Museum in Dublin, Ireland, traces Ireland’s literary legacy and features items like Samuel Beckett’s custom-designed telephone.
• The National Steinbeck Center in Salinas, California, celebrates the life and work of John Steinbeck.
• The James Joyce Museum in the Martello tower at Sandycove Point, Dublin, featured in Ulysses, houses a collection of memorabilia, including letters and rare editions of his works.
• Tao House at the Eugene O’Neill National Historic Site in Danville, California, where O’Neill lived in seclusion and penned many of his acclaimed plays.
• The Eudora Welty House in Jackson, Mississippi, preserves the intensely private author’s personal and professional domains.
• Rowan Oak, William Faulkner’s home in Oxford, Mississippi, where the plot outline for A Fable is scrawled on the wall in his office.
• Longfellow House–Washington’s Headquarters National Historic Site in Cambridge, Massachusetts, home to Henry Wadsworth Longfellow for 40 years and General George Washington’s headquarters during the Siege of Boston.
• The restored Sinclair Lewis Boyhood Home in Sauk Centre, Minnesota, displays furniture and items owned by the author and his family.
• The Willa Cather Childhood Home in Red Cloud, Nebraska, is part of the Willa Cather Thematic Group, comprising several preserved buildings associated with her life and fiction.
• The O. Henry Museum in Austin, Texas, preserves the Lone Star State legacy of William Sydney Porter.
• The Ralph Waldo Emerson House in Concord, Massachusetts, Emerson’s residence for over 40 years, remains much as it did in his day.
• The Old Manse in Concord, Massachusetts, where Nathaniel Hawthorne penned stories and where a recreation of Henry David Thoreau’s vegetable garden for the Hawthornes flourishes.
• The Harriet Beecher Stowe Center in Hartford, Connecticut, showcases Stowe’s furnishings and artwork and the parlor table where she worked on Uncle Tom’s Cabin.
• Maison Jules Verne in Amiens, France, decorated with period furnishings and items owned by the writer.
• Château de Monte-Cristo, Alexandre Dumas’s countryside retreat outside Paris, featuring a smaller workspace called Château d’If.
• Maison de Victor Hugo in Place des Vosges, Paris, now a museum illuminating different periods of his life.
• Hauteville House on the isle of Guernsey, where Victor Hugo spent 14 years of his exile and completed Les Misérables.

In some instances, author homes have been transformed into literary lodgings or establishments where visitors can drink and dine, offering a more immersive experience:

• Garth Woodside Mansion in Hannibal, Missouri, where Mark Twain stayed as a guest, now offers a garden-view room he used.
• Bleak House in Broadstairs, Kent, Dickens’s summer retreat, is now a guest house where visitors can stay in the Charles Dickens Room.
• The Willa Cather Second Home in Red Cloud, Nebraska, is now a guest house with rooms named after towns in her novels.
• The Steinbeck House in Salinas, California, where John Steinbeck was born, is now a restaurant open for lunchtime dining and offers house tours.

These examples demonstrate the diverse ways in which author homes serve as literary landmarks, providing valuable insights into the lives and creative processes of the world’s greatest writers.

Literary Guidebooks and Literary Travel

The sources indicate that literary guidebooks serve as resources for “reading enthusiasts who also travel” and “actual literary pilgrims”, helping them explore places significant to authors and their works. The book “Novel Destinations: Literary Landmarks from Jane Austen’s Bath to Ernest Hemingway’s Key West” by Shannon McKenna Schmidt and Joni Rendon is itself presented as such a guidebook.

This guidebook aims to enhance the travel experiences of book lovers by providing information on literary landmarks. The Library of Congress cataloging information explicitly classifies it as a guidebook for literary landmarks in the United States and Great Britain and for the homes and haunts of American and English authors. The foreword by Matthew Pearl suggests that the book helps bridge the gap between fiction and real-world destinations associated with literature.

The structure of “Novel Destinations,” as revealed in its contents, implies a categorized approach to literary guidance:

• “READ ’EM AND SEE: AUTHOR HOUSES AND MUSEUMS” suggests a section dedicated to guiding readers to the preserved homes and museums of various authors.
• “ATMOSPHERIC LITERARY LANDSCAPES” likely guides readers to physical locations that inspired authors and became settings in their novels.
• “LITERARY FESTIVALS, TOURS, AND MORE” indicates a section guiding readers to organized literary events and routes for exploration.
• “BOOKED UP: LITERARY PLACES TO DRINK, DINE, AND DOZE” likely directs readers to establishments with literary connections, such as pubs and cafes frequented by authors.

Beyond comprehensive books like “Novel Destinations,” the sources also highlight other forms of literary guidance:

• Literary Walking Tours: These guided excursions in cities like Boston, Los Angeles (Raymond Chandler), Chicago, New York (Greenwich Village), New Orleans, Dublin, London, and St. Petersburg (Dostoyevsky) serve as localized guidebooks in action, highlighting specific literary sites and their significance.
• Self-Guided Tours and Maps: Edinburgh offers self-guided walking tour itineraries and apps related to its literary heritage. Baltimore has a self-guided Literary Heritage Tour map available online. Visitors to literary sites, like the National Steinbeck Center, might find maps and reading lists to further their exploration.
• Specific Books as Guides: “A Journey into Steinbeck’s California” by Susan Shillinglaw is mentioned as a handy guide for traversing the terrain associated with John Steinbeck.
• Museum Resources: Author house museums and literary centers often provide exhibits and information that guide visitors through the life and works of the featured writers [e.g., Shakespeare’s Birthplace, Abbotsford, The Brontë Parsonage Museum, The National Steinbeck Center, Dublin Writers Museum].

These various forms of literary guidebooks, whether comprehensive volumes or localized resources, cater to the desire of readers to connect more deeply with literature by experiencing the places and environments that shaped its creation. They transform reading from a solitary activity into a form of “travel by the book”, allowing enthusiasts to embark on “novel exploration”.

Literary Travel: Visiting Authors and Their Worlds

Travel for readers is presented in the sources as a way to deepen their connection with literature by experiencing the places associated with authors and their works. The book “Novel Destinations: Literary Landmarks from Jane Austen’s Bath to Ernest Hemingway’s Key West” caters specifically to “reading enthusiasts who also travel” and “actual literary pilgrims”. The foreword by Matthew Pearl suggests that such travel bridges the gap between fiction and real-world literary destinations.

The sources highlight several key aspects of travel for readers:

• Visiting Author Homes and Museums: This is a significant aspect, offering “a rare glimpse into the ephemeral moment of artistic creation”. These “intimate places where writers lived, dreamed, dozed, drew inspiration, and spent their most creative hours” are often preserved as museums. Examples include Shakespeare’s Birthplace, Abbotsford (Sir Walter Scott’s home), Dove Cottage (William Wordsworth), Arrowhead (Herman Melville), The Wayside (Louisa May Alcott and Nathaniel Hawthorne), the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum, the Brontë Parsonage Museum, the Dublin Writers Museum, the National Steinbeck Center, the James Joyce Museum, Tao House (Eugene O’Neill), the Eudora Welty House, Rowan Oak (William Faulkner), Longfellow House–Washington’s Headquarters National Historic Site, the restored Sinclair Lewis Boyhood Home, the Willa Cather Childhood Home, the O. Henry Museum, the Ralph Waldo Emerson House, the Old Manse (Nathaniel Hawthorne), the Harriet Beecher Stowe Center, Maison Jules Verne, Château de Monte-Cristo (Alexandre Dumas), Maison de Victor Hugo, and Hauteville House (Victor Hugo). These allow readers to see the environments that shaped their favorite authors and stories.
• Exploring Atmospheric Literary Landscapes: Readers can travel to the physical locations that inspired authors and became settings in their novels. The mere mention of places like Ernest Hemingway’s Key West or Victor Hugo’s Paris can inspire travel for “novel exploration”. Jane Austen’s Bath, Dickens’s London, Steinbeck’s California, and the Brontë Country are presented as such landscapes. For example, Hawai’i Volcanoes National Park is significant because Mark Twain witnessed and wrote about it. In Salinas, California, visitors can explore the landscape that inspired John Steinbeck. The Brontë Country in Yorkshire, England, offers walks to landmarks like the Brontë waterfall and Top Withens.
• Participating in Literary Festivals, Tours, and More: These organized events and routes provide opportunities for readers to connect with literature in a social and immersive way. Examples include the Jane Austen Festival in Bath, the Steinbeck Festival in Salinas, the Fowey Festival of Words and Music, and Zora! The Zora Neale Hurston Festival of the Arts and Humanities in Eatonville, FL. Literary walking tours are available in cities like Boston, Los Angeles (Raymond Chandler), Chicago, New Orleans, Dublin, London, and St. Petersburg (Dostoyevsky). Self-guided tours and maps are also available in places like Edinburgh and Baltimore.
• Staying in Literary Lodgings and Visiting Bookish Places to Eat and Drink: Some author homes and other establishments have been transformed into places where visitors can stay, eat, and drink, offering a more tangible connection to the literary world. Examples of literary lodgings in the U.S. include the Algonquin Hotel in New York (associated with F. Scott Fitzgerald and Dorothy Parker), the Hotel Union Square in San Francisco with a Dashiell Hammett Suite, Garth Woodside Mansion where Mark Twain stayed, and Bleak House Broadstairs, Dickens’s summer retreat now a guest house. Abroad, Farringford on the Isle of Wight was Tennyson’s home and now offers cottages and apartments. Bookish places to eat and drink include Shakespeare and Company bookshop in Paris, England’s best literary pubs, and Harry’s Bar in Venice, frequented by Hemingway and Capote. The Steinbeck House in Salinas is now a restaurant.
• Experiencing “Travel by the Book”: This phrase encapsulates the idea that novels can inspire travel and provide a new dimension to travel experiences. Conversely, seeking out literary places can give a deeper perspective on cherished books. Even celebrated writers like John Steinbeck felt the allure of following in the footsteps of admired authors.

In conclusion, travel for readers is a multifaceted activity that allows individuals to engage with literature beyond the page. By visiting significant locations, participating in literary events, and even staying in literary-themed accommodations, readers can forge a more personal and profound connection with the authors and stories they love. The sources provide numerous examples of destinations and resources available to those who wish to embark on such literary journeys.

Literary Destinations: A Guide to Bookish Places

Based on the sources, “bookish places” are locations that hold significance for readers and literary enthusiasts due to their connections to authors, their works, or the world of books in general. These places allow readers to deepen their engagement with literature by experiencing the real-world contexts that shaped it. The guidebook “Novel Destinations” serves as a guide to many such locations.

Here’s a breakdown of the bookish places discussed in the sources:

• Author Houses and Museums: These are “intimate places where writers lived, dreamed, dozed, drew inspiration, and spent their most creative hours”. Visiting these sites provides “a rare glimpse into the ephemeral moment of artistic creation”. The sources list numerous examples in the U.S. and abroad, including:
• Shakespeare’s Birthplace in Stratford-upon-Avon, England, a major tourist attraction even in the time of Dickens and Keats.
• Abbotsford, the castle-like home of Sir Walter Scott in Scotland, now a literary museum.
• Dove Cottage, William Wordsworth’s home in England.
• Robert Burns Birthplace Museum and Burns Cottage in Ayrshire, Scotland.
• Longfellow House–Washington’s Headquarters National Historic Site in Cambridge, MA.
• Maison Jules Verne in Amiens, France, the home of Jules Verne.
• Many more, such as the homes of Louisa May Alcott in Concord, MA, Nathaniel Hawthorne in Salem, MA, Ernest Hemingway in Key West, FL, Victor Hugo in Paris, France, James Joyce in Dublin, Ireland, Franz Kafka in Prague, Czech Republic, the Brontë sisters in Haworth, England, Mark Twain, Edith Wharton, Henry James, Pearl S. Buck, and many others.
• Atmospheric Literary Landscapes: These are the physical locations that inspired authors and became settings in their novels. Examples include:
• Jane Austen’s Bath, England, featured in Persuasion and Northanger Abbey.
• Charles Dickens’s London, England, the backdrop for many of his novels.
• The Brontë Country in Haworth, West Yorkshire, England, the landscape of Wuthering Heights and other Brontë novels.
• Victor Hugo’s Paris, France, immortalized in his works.
• James Joyce’s Dublin, Ireland, the setting of Ulysses.
• Ernest Hemingway’s Key West, Florida.
• John Steinbeck’s Monterey and Salinas, California, the setting for his California novels.
• Sir Walter Scott’s Scottish Border Country, including Abbotsford.
• Robert Burns Country in Ayrshire, Scotland.
• Hawai’i Volcanoes National Park, which Mark Twain wrote about.
• Lyme Regis, England, a setting in Jane Austen’s Persuasion.
• Literary Festivals, Tours, and More: These offer opportunities for readers to engage with literature in a communal and experiential way.
• Literary Festivals like the Bath Literature Festival, Hay Festival in Wales, the Edinburgh International Book Festival, the Fowey Festival of Words and Music (related to Daphne Du Maurier) in Cornwall, the Steinbeck Festival in Salinas, and Zora! The Zora Neale Hurston Festival of the Arts and Humanities in Eatonville, FL [not in source, mentioned in prior turn; you may want to verify this independently].
• Literary Walks and Tours are available in numerous cities, highlighting locations associated with specific authors or literary movements. Examples include tours in Boston focusing on 19th-century American writers, Los Angeles exploring Raymond Chandler’s world, Chicago, New York City (Greenwich Village Literary Pub Crawl, Algonquin Round Table Walking Tours), New Orleans focusing on Faulkner, Williams, and others, Dublin (Dublin Literary Pub Crawl, James Joyce Walking Tours), London (London Literary Pub Crawl, Bloomsbury walks, Dickens walks), and Edinburgh (Edinburgh Literary Pub Tour, Edinburgh Book Lovers’ Tour).
• Self-guided tours and maps are available for literary exploration in places like Edinburgh and Baltimore (Literary Heritage Tour).
• Booked Up: Literary Places to Drink, Dine, and Doze: These are establishments with literary associations, where authors frequented or that have literary themes.
• Literary Lodgings in the U.S. such as the Algonquin Hotel in New York, the Omni Parker House in Boston, the Alexander House Booklovers’ Bed & Breakfast in Princess Anne, MD, the Library Hotel in New York, the Spencer Hotel & Spa in Chautauqua, NY, the Heathman Hotel in Portland, OR, the Sylvia Beach Hotel in Newport, OR, and the Innsbrucker Inn in Leavenworth, WA.
• Literary Lodgings Abroad like Bleak House Broadstairs (Dickens’s retreat) in England, Lamb House (Henry James’s home) in Rye, England, the Savoy Hotel in London (associated with Zola and Wilde), Hôtel d’Europe in Avignon, France (visited by Twain and Fitzgerald), and Farringford (Tennyson’s home) on the Isle of Wight.
• Bookish Places to Sip and Sup, including Shakespeare and Company bookshop in Paris, England’s Best Literary Pubs like The Eagle and Child and The Spaniards Inn in Oxford and London respectively, Ye Olde Cheshire Cheese in London, and Davy Byrnes in Dublin. Big Apple Bars for Bibliophiles like Chumley’s. Parisian Cafés of the Literati such as Café de Flore and Les Deux Magots. Six Hemingway Watering Holes are also mentioned. Harry’s Bar in Venice, frequented by Hemingway and Capote.
• Libraries Worth Checking Out: These are libraries with significant literary collections or historical importance. Examples include:
• Trinity College Old Library in Dublin, home to the Book of Kells.
• British Library in London, housing treasures like the Magna Carta and Shakespeare’s First Folio, and Jane Austen’s writing desk.
• New York Public Library in New York City.
• Library of Congress in Washington, D.C..

These diverse “bookish places” cater to a wide range of literary interests, offering opportunities for travel by the book and a tangible connection to the literary world.

By Amjad Izhar
Contact: amjad.izhar@gmail.com
https://amjadizhar.blog

Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!

This source is an excerpt from a scholarly work analyzing Jane Austen’s novels in relation to Romantic literature, particularly the works of Wordsworth, Coleridge, Scott, and Byron. The author argues that Austen’s later novels demonstrate a shift in focus towards themes and techniques prevalent in Romanticism, such as the exploration of individual psychology, the significance of memory, the impact of social change, and a nuanced understanding of relationships. The text examines specific novels like Mansfield Park, Emma, and Persuasion, highlighting parallels and divergences between Austen’s narrative approaches and the literary innovations of her Romantic contemporaries. Ultimately, the work seeks to reposition Austen within a broader Romantic context, demonstrating how her engagement with contemporary literary trends shaped the evolution of her artistry.

Jane Austen and the Romantic Poets: A Study Guide

Quiz

1. According to the text, what specific visual detail in Mansfield Park suggests a connection to Wordsworth? Explain the reference.
2. How does Edward Ferrars’ description of a “fine country” in Sense and Sensibility contrast with more purely “picturesque” views of nature associated with Romanticism? What does this reveal about Austen’s perspective at that point in her career?
3. The text argues that Austen’s late novels demonstrate a different understanding of the mind compared to her earlier works. Briefly describe this shift, referencing the discussion of memory in Sense and Sensibility.
4. What is meant by the “forensic language” used in Darcy’s letter to Elizabeth in Pride and Prejudice? How does Edmund Bertram’s letter to Fanny in Mansfield Park differ in its approach to expressing feeling?
5. Explain the significance of the word “perfect” in Emma, according to the text. Provide an example of how this word is used in the novel.
6. How does Austen’s use of the word “harmonized” in Emma relate to a specific phrase in Wordsworth’s “Tintern Abbey”? What does this connection suggest about Austen’s artistic aims?
7. The text discusses Fanny Price’s frequent use of the word “no” in Mansfield Park. What does this characteristic usage signify about her character, according to the analysis?
8. What is the older meaning of the word “friend” that the text describes as prevalent in Austen’s time? How does John Dashwood’s use of the term in Sense and Sensibility reflect this meaning?
9. According to the text, how did Byron’s view of friendship differ from the classical tradition? How does Austen engage with this evolving understanding of friendship in Emma?
10. The conversation between Jane Fairfax and John Knightley at the dinner party in Emma is presented as uniquely characteristic of the novel’s interest in friendship. What is significant about this particular interaction?

Quiz Answer Key

1. The text points to “three transparencies” in Mansfield Park depicting Tintern Abbey between an Italian cave and a Cumberland lake. This alludes to Wordsworth’s poem “Tintern Abbey,” suggesting an awareness and perhaps engagement with his work and the popularization of the Wye Valley through picturesque tourism, notably influenced by Gilpin.
2. Edward’s ideal of a fine country prioritizes “beauty with utility,” admiring flourishing, straight trees and snug farmhouses over crooked trees and banditti. This contrasts with a purely aesthetic appreciation of wild or dramatic landscapes favored by some Romantic perspectives, suggesting Austen’s early focus on a more socially and morally grounded evaluation of nature.
3. The early novels, like Sense and Sensibility, present memory in a more schematic way, often tied to specific moral lessons and resolutions. The late novels, however, suggest a deeper and more complex understanding of memory’s role in shaping identity and the experience of time, moving beyond a purely instrumental function.
4. “Forensic language” in Darcy’s letter refers to its structured, analytical, and almost legalistic tone, focusing on presenting evidence and refuting Elizabeth’s charges without overt emotional expression. Edmund’s letter, in contrast, is characterized by its direct expression of intense feeling and a less formally structured outpouring of his thoughts.
5. In Emma, the word “perfect” is insistently undermined by qualification and irony, often associated with characters of questionable judgment like Mr. Weston. For example, Weston’s riddle equating “M. and A.” (Emma) with perfection highlights the novel’s critical examination of idealized notions and Emma’s own flawed self-perception.
6. Austen’s use of “harmonized” to describe the integration of past and present feelings echoes Wordsworth’s lines in “Tintern Abbey” about an “eye made quiet by the power / Of harmony” that allows one to “see into the life of things,” and memory as a dwelling place for “sweet sounds and harmonies.” This suggests Austen shared Wordsworth’s interest in the mind’s ability to synthesize experience and find deeper meaning.
7. Fanny’s frequent use of “no” signifies not a strong will but rather self-denial and a reluctance to assert her own desires. It highlights her subordinate position and her internal struggle to reconcile her own feelings with the expectations placed upon her by her family.
8. The older meaning of “friend” referred to a kinsman, near relation, or important associate, often carrying implications for social standing and familial obligations, particularly in matters of marriage. John Dashwood uses “friend” in this sense when discussing potential advantageous matches for Elinor, focusing on social and financial considerations rather than personal affection.
9. Byron positioned friendship as the “dear peculiar bond of youth,” suggesting it was a transient experience that faded with adulthood, contrasting with the classical ideal of a mature and virtuous connection. Austen engages with this by exploring the complexities of youthful friendship while also developing the ideal of a more mature, enduring friendship between equals, as seen in the relationship between Emma and Knightley.
10. The conversation is significant because it showcases two different styles of “friendship” existing simultaneously. John Knightley employs the older, formal style to express a personal hope for Jane’s future, which she receives kindly. Mr. Woodhouse’s interaction represents a more ceremonial and less personally insightful form of goodwill. This juxtaposition highlights the novel’s exploration of the evolving meanings and expressions of friendship within a community.

Essay Format Questions

1. Explore the argument that Jane Austen’s novels, particularly Emma, demonstrate an engagement with and development of Romantic ideas, focusing on the concept of friendship as presented in the text. Consider the influences of Wordsworth and Byron in your analysis.
2. Analyze the changing representation of the inner lives of Austen’s characters from her early to late novels, as discussed in the provided excerpts. How does the understanding and portrayal of memory contribute to this shift?
3. Discuss the significance of nature and the “picturesque” in Jane Austen’s novels, drawing on the examples and arguments presented in the text. How does Austen’s approach to nature compare with that of the Romantic poets mentioned?
4. Examine the concept of “ambiguous relationships” as it is developed in Emma, particularly focusing on the evolving dynamic between Emma and Mr. Knightley. How does the novel redefine the term “friendship” and what are the implications of this redefinition?
5. Consider the role of social and historical context in understanding Jane Austen’s novels, particularly Persuasion. How does the text connect Austen’s work to the Napoleonic Wars and the evolving social landscape of England?

Glossary of Key Terms

• Picturesque: An aesthetic ideal, popular in the late 18th and early 19th centuries, emphasizing a type of beauty found in rugged, irregular, and varied landscapes, often with elements of the sublime but on a smaller, more domesticated scale.
• Sensibility: An 18th-century cultural and literary movement that emphasized feeling, emotion, and refined sensitivity as moral guides. Characters often displayed exaggerated emotional responses.
• Utility: The quality of being useful or practical. In the context of the text, it is contrasted with purely aesthetic appreciation, suggesting a value placed on the functional aspects of the landscape and social arrangements.
• Forensic Language: Language characterized by its formal, analytical, and logical structure, resembling that used in legal arguments or investigations.
• Fetish (in this context): Not solely in the Freudian psychoanalytic sense, but also referring to objects (including ideas or social conventions) that are invested with disproportionate value or veneration, sometimes obscuring or replacing the reality they represent.
• Harmonized (in relation to memory): The process by which past experiences and present feelings are integrated and reconciled in the mind, creating a sense of wholeness and understanding.
• Affective Individualism: A social and cultural shift emphasizing the importance of personal feelings and affections as the primary basis for relationships and individual identity, rather than lineage or social status alone.
• Litotes: A figure of speech involving understatement in which an affirmative is expressed by the negative of its contrary (e.g., “not bad” meaning “good”).
• Meta-ambiguity: A level of ambiguity that encompasses or arises from other ambiguities, in this case, the relationship between Emma and Knightley embodying a space where different ambiguous forms of friendship intersect.
• Romantic Poets (in this context): Primarily referring to William Wordsworth, Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Lord Byron, and Sir Walter Scott, influential figures in the Romantic literary movement of the late 18th and early 19th centuries, known for their emphasis on emotion, nature, imagination, and individualism.

Briefing Document: Jane Austen and the Romantic Poets by William Deresiewicz

This briefing document summarizes the main themes and important ideas presented in William Deresiewicz’s “Jane Austen and the Romantic Poets.” The book explores the significant, yet often overlooked, influence of Romantic poets, particularly Wordsworth, Byron, and Coleridge, on Jane Austen’s novels. Deresiewicz argues that Austen engaged deeply with the aesthetic and philosophical concerns of the Romantic era, adapting and subverting them within her own unique novelistic framework.

Main Themes:

• Wordsworthian Influence: Deresiewicz posits a strong and pervasive influence of Wordsworth on Austen, particularly in her exploration of memory, the relationship between humanity and nature, and the development of character through inner feeling and reflection. He argues that even when Austen diverges from Wordsworth, her work often grows out of or reacts to his ideas.
• Memory and Inner Life: Austen, particularly in Sense and Sensibility, portrays recollection as a crucial element in moral development, echoing Wordsworth’s emphasis on “serious recollection.” Marianne Dashwood’s recovery involves a process of “recollection, judgment, mortification, a resolution to judge and act better.” However, Deresiewicz notes that in Austen’s early novels, memory is often confined to a specific moral function, unlike the more fluid and impactful sense of time found in Wordsworth.
• Nature and Perception: While Austen’s engagement with nature differs from the Romantic poets’ sublime appreciation, she does engage with contemporary aesthetic debates, particularly regarding the picturesque. Edward Ferrars’ preference for a “fine country” that “unites beauty with utility” contrasts with Marianne’s more passionate, Romantic sensibility, suggesting Austen’s own evolving perspective. In Pride and Prejudice, the planned visit to the Lake District highlights the Romantic appreciation of nature, even though it is ultimately deferred.
• Influence on Later Novels: Deresiewicz contends that the “unmistakable imprint of Wordsworthian ideas and concerns” can be seen throughout Austen’s work, with later novels developing these themes within a novelistic context that introduces its own aesthetic considerations.
• Byronic Influence: The study also highlights Byron’s impact on Austen, particularly on her understanding and portrayal of friendship, youth, and intense feeling.
• Revaluation of Friendship: Byron’s Romantic idealization of youthful friendship as a “dear peculiar bond of youth” influenced Austen’s exploration of this relationship, particularly in Emma. The novel grapples with different conceptions of friendship, contrasting the older sense of “friends” as important associates with the emerging modern sense of friendship based on affection and shared intimacy.
• Emotional Intensity: Characters like Marianne Dashwood exhibit “effusions derived from Thomson, Cowper, and Scott,” aligning with the Romantic emphasis on passionate feeling. However, Austen often critiques the unrestrained expression of sensibility.
• Ambiguity in Relationships: Austen’s development of ambiguous relationships, particularly the central friendship between Emma and Knightley, can be seen in the context of the Romantic interest in complex emotional connections.
• Evolution of Austen’s Novelistic Form: Deresiewicz argues that Austen’s work shows a clear development from her early to her major phase, marked by a deeper engagement with inner experience, a more nuanced portrayal of character, and a greater complexity in her exploration of social and personal relationships.
• Shift in Focus: The early novels, like Sense and Sensibility, often focus on categorizing characters based on qualities like “amiable” and “gentlemanliness.” The later novels, however, delve into more profound ambiguities and complexities of character and relationship.
• Narrative Voice and Interiority: The later novels exhibit a greater access to the characters’ inner thoughts and feelings, moving beyond simple categorization to explore the dynamics of their minds. The letters in Pride and Prejudice and Mansfield Park (Darcy’s and Edmund’s) serve as examples of how Austen uses writing to reveal the complexities of thought and feeling, though in contrasting ways. Darcy’s letter is “forensic” and controlled, while Edmund’s is driven by “intense feeling.”
• The Significance of Language: Austen’s careful use of language, particularly words like “friend” and “perfect,” reveals her engagement with the evolving meanings of social and emotional terms in the Romantic era. The ironic undermining of “perfect” in Emma and the nuanced exploration of “friendship” demonstrate this.
• Friendship as a Central Theme: The concept of friendship undergoes a significant transformation in Austen’s novels, reflecting the changing social and cultural landscape of the time and the influence of Romantic ideals.
• From Social Utility to Affective Bond: Austen navigates the shift from “friend” as a term denoting important social connections and familial allies (as seen in John Dashwood’s usage in Sense and Sensibility) to “friend” as someone connected by affection and shared values (as emphasized by Mrs. Dashwood and the novel’s overall trajectory).
• Ambiguity and Fluidity: In Emma, friendship becomes the “characteristically modern form of relationship,” marked by ambiguity and flexibility, transcending traditional social roles like neighbor, teacher, or family member. Knightley’s role in Emma’s life exemplifies this multifaceted nature of modern friendship.
• Friendship and Marriage: Austen explores the potential for friendship within marriage, culminating in the relationship between Emma and Knightley, which Deresiewicz sees as a “meta-ambiguity” where different forms of friendship merge into a sexual union.
• The Fetish in Austen: Deresiewicz introduces the concept of the “fetish,” drawing on both economic and Freudian interpretations, to analyze the significance of material objects and idealized images in Austen’s novels.
• Social Fetishism: Austen critiques the tendency to venerate “trinkets and luxuries” as symbols of wealth and status, aligning with contemporary social critiques of consumerism.
• Psychological Fetishism: Drawing on Wordsworth’s concern with the mind’s tendency to believe in its own figurative creations, Deresiewicz suggests that characters can become attached to idealized images or substitutes, sometimes at the expense of genuine connection. Fanny Price’s attachment to her East Room in Mansfield Park is analyzed through this lens, suggesting it becomes a “substitute for the body.”
• Persuasion: Widowhood and Waterloo: The analysis of Persuasion connects the novel to specific historical and Romantic contexts, particularly the aftermath of the Napoleonic Wars and the influence of Byron and Scott.
• National and Personal Loss: The novel is situated in a post-war England, grappling with themes of loss, change, and national identity. The sea becomes a powerful symbol, representing both the dangers of war and the connection to England’s maritime history.
• Influence of Byron’s “Turkish Tales”: Deresiewicz argues that Persuasion engages with the themes of memory, loss, and hidden secrets found in Byron’s popular “Turkish Tales,” particularly The Giaour.
• Scott’s Historical Romances: The novel’s temporal setting and its engagement with national concerns also place it in dialogue with the historical romances of Walter Scott, though Austen ultimately focuses more on the personal and domestic sphere.

Important Ideas and Facts:

• The three transparencies in Sense and Sensibility depicting Tintern Abbey and the Lake District explicitly point to Wordsworth’s influence on Austen’s early engagement with landscape.
• Edward Ferrars’ pragmatic view of nature in Sense and Sensibility represents Austen’s early critique of unrestrained Romantic sensibility.
• Sir Thomas Bertram’s rigid patriarchal authority in Mansfield Park ultimately “shatters” due to his inability to adapt to the changing desires and independent spirits of his children.
• The forensic language and structure of Darcy’s letter in Pride and Prejudice contrast sharply with the emotionally driven nature of Edmund’s letter in Mansfield Park, highlighting different approaches to expressing inner feeling through writing.
• The repeated use of the word “kind” in Emma signifies the novel’s emphasis on a common human community and horizontal social connections.
• Knightley’s role in Emma evolves beyond traditional social categories, ultimately solidifying as “friend,” representing a modern ideal of ambiguous and multifaceted relationships.
• The obsolete meaning of “friend” as a kinsman or important associate is still present in Austen’s novels, particularly in the speech of characters like John Dashwood in Sense and Sensibility.
• Byron’s poetry, particularly his early works focusing on youthful friendship, provides a key context for understanding Austen’s exploration of this theme in Emma.
• The handshake between Emma and Frank Churchill, and its near transformation into a kiss, serves as a physical manifestation of the ambiguities inherent in their evolving relationship.
• Emma and Knightley’s final reconciliation hinges on their redefinition and embrace of “friendship” as a foundation for their romantic relationship.
• The imagery of the sea in Persuasion connects to themes of loss, memory, and England’s national identity in the wake of the Napoleonic Wars, echoing Byronic and Scottian concerns.

Quotes:

• On Wordsworth’s influence: “as we make our way through this system of changes, we will find that attribute after attribute bears the unmistakable imprint of Wordsworthian ideas and concerns.”
• Edward Ferrars’ view of nature: “[M]y idea of a fine country,” he says, is one that “unites beauty with utility . . . I do not like crooked, twisted, blasted trees. I admire them much more if they are tall, straight, and flourishing . . . I have more pleasure in a snug farm-house than a watch-tower—and a troop of tidy, happy villagers please me better than the finest banditti in the world.”
• On Darcy’s letter: “Two offenses of a very different nature, and by no means of equal magnitude, you last night laid to my charge.”
• On the undermining of “perfect” in Emma: “Of the dozens of times it or its derivatives appear, almost none is without qualification or irony…”
• On the modern form of friendship: “Friendship has become the relationship in terms of which all others are understood, against which they are all measured, into which they have all dissolved. It has become, in other words, the characteristically modern form of relationship.”
• Emma’s internal recognition of her flawed friendship with Harriet: “I have been but half a friend to her.”
• Knightley’s initial recoil from “brother and sister”: “Brother and sister! no, indeed,” he exclaims.
• Knightley’s initial recoil from “friend”: “ ‘As a friend!’—repeated Mr. Knightley.—‘Emma, that I fear is a word—No, I have no wish—’.”
• Byron on youthful friendship: “Friendship, the dear peculiar bond of youth.”
• The narrator on the symbolic importance of the descent to Lyme in Persuasion: “descending the long hill into Lyme . . . entering upon the still steeper street of the town itself . . . passing down . . . and still descending—to the sea.”
• The Giaour on memory: “My memory now is but the tomb / Of joys long dead.”

Deresiewicz’s work provides a compelling argument for understanding Jane Austen within the intellectual and aesthetic context of Romanticism, revealing a deeper layer of engagement with the major literary and philosophical currents of her time. His analysis of themes like memory, nature, friendship, and the evolving self offers fresh perspectives on Austen’s enduring literary significance.

Austen and the Romantic Poets: Influences and Engagements

Frequently Asked Questions: Jane Austen and the Romantic Poets

1. How does the book define the relationship between Jane Austen and the Romantic poets? The book argues that Jane Austen engaged deeply with the ideas and concerns of the Romantic poets, particularly Wordsworth, Byron, and Coleridge, although her engagement was often subtle and transformative rather than a direct imitation. She absorbed fundamental orientations and aesthetics from them, adapting and integrating these influences within her own novelistic framework, which necessarily involved different artistic and social considerations.

2. In what specific ways did Wordsworth influence Jane Austen’s work, according to the text? Wordsworth’s influence is seen in several aspects of Austen’s novels. This includes the exploration of memory and recollection, particularly the idea of past feelings shaping present experience, as seen in Sense and Sensibility. Austen also engages with Wordsworthian ideas of nature and its moral significance, although sometimes to critique or present alternative perspectives, such as Edward Ferrars’s view of landscape prioritizing utility over the purely picturesque. Furthermore, the development of ambiguous relationships, particularly friendship, in Austen’s later novels like Emma, is linked to Wordsworth’s exploration of complex bonds in poems like the Matthew poems.

3. How did Byron’s Romanticism manifest in Austen’s novels, as discussed in the source? Byron’s influence is particularly evident in the exploration of friendship in Austen’s work. Austen engages with the Byronic concept of friendship as the “dear peculiar bond of youth,” reflecting a shift from the classical ideal of friendship as a mature, virtuous connection. This is seen in the emphasis on youthful friendships and the anxieties surrounding their potential loss or change. Additionally, the Romantic fascination with intense feeling and memory, themes prevalent in Byron’s work, find echoes in Austen’s exploration of characters’ emotional lives, particularly in Persuasion.

4. The text highlights the evolving concept of “friendship” in Austen’s novels. How does it change, and what influences this shift? The concept of friendship evolves from an older sense, where “friend” could denote a kinsman or important associate, particularly in the context of marriage, to a more modern understanding of friendship based on affection, shared values, and mutual support. This shift is influenced by broader cultural changes and the Romantic emphasis on individual feeling and intimacy. In Emma, friendship becomes a central theme, explored in its various forms and ambiguities, ultimately emerging as a new relational ideal.

5. What is the significance of the relationship between Emma and Knightley in the context of friendship, according to the book? The relationship between Emma and Knightley is presented as the apotheosis of the evolving concept of friendship in Austen’s work. It moves beyond fixed social roles and traditional expectations, becoming an ambiguous relationship characterized by intellectual equality, mutual respect, and the possibility of growth. Their journey culminates in a marriage that incorporates this deep and complex friendship, suggesting a modern ideal where romantic partnership is founded on a strong and evolving friendship.

6. How does the theme of memory function in Austen’s novels, and how does it relate to the Romantic poets’ treatment of memory? Memory in Austen’s novels is not merely a passive recollection of events but actively shapes characters’ understanding of themselves and their relationships. In early novels like Sense and Sensibility, memory serves a more schematic, almost curative role. However, in later works like Emma and Persuasion, memory becomes more nuanced, influencing the sense of time and allowing for the harmonization of past experiences into present understanding, echoing Wordsworth’s exploration of memory’s power in poems like “Tintern Abbey.”

7. What is the role of nature and the picturesque in Austen’s novels, particularly in relation to Romantic ideals? Austen engages with the Romantic appreciation for nature and the picturesque, but often with a critical or nuanced perspective. While characters like Marianne Dashwood express sensibility through effusions aligned with picturesque conventions and poets like Thomson and Cowper, Austen also presents alternative views, such as Edward Ferrars’s preference for a landscape combining beauty with utility. In Pride and Prejudice, the planned visit to the Lake District is almost an afterthought, suggesting a deliberate swerve away from a central engagement with sublime nature, unlike the intense focus found in some Romantic poetry.

8. How does the book connect the historical context of the Napoleonic Wars and a sense of national identity to Austen’s novel Persuasion? Persuasion is analyzed as a novel deeply engaged with its historical context, particularly the aftermath of the Napoleonic Wars and the rise of naval power. The sea, a significant setting, is not just a backdrop but symbolizes England’s history and identity as an island nation. The novel contrasts the landed gentry with the emergent professional class represented by naval officers, suggesting a shift in social values and the potential for national renewal after the wars. The themes of loss, memory, and the intertwining of personal and national life are also connected to the historical period.

Jane Austen’s Novels: Early and Major Phases

Jane Austen’s novels can be broadly categorized into two phases: the early phase, comprising Northanger Abbey, Sense and Sensibility, and Pride and Prejudice; and the major phase, consisting of Mansfield Park, Emma, and Persuasion.

Early Phase Novels:

• These novels are characterized as brilliant, cutting, and breathtakingly assured, but essentially straightforward marriage plots.
• While intricately designed, they are considered morally and emotionally unambiguous.
• The younger Austen was fond of narrative set-pieces which were markedly performative. Examples include conversations during dances or sparring matches between characters.
• In these early works, emotions and motives are less complex, and relationships are similarly unambiguous, shifting in a step-wise fashion.
• Memory plays a crucial role in the heroine’s transformation but exhibits a narrower conception compared to the later novels. For instance, Elizabeth Bennet’s self-recognition in Pride and Prejudice is strikingly swift, triggered by Darcy’s letter.
• The conceptual landscape of the early novels is dominated by an abstract moral vocabulary, focusing on terms like “amiable,” “agreeable,” “gentlemanliness,” and “elegance”. Austen employs a powerful categorizing intelligence in these works.
• Austen, in her early phase, can be seen as an “artist of being,” focusing on static characters and abstract qualities.
• The ethical doctrine at the center of these novels is that feeling can and ought to be shaped, controlled, and educated by thought. The plots, irony, and narrators’ self-assurance reinforce this idea. The errors of the early heroines are often errors of reason.
• Austen satirizes the way the works of authors like Cowper, Gilpin, Radcliffe, and Burney were read or misread, rather than the works themselves, in novels like Sense and Sensibility and Northanger Abbey.

Major Phase Novels:

• These novels are described as deeper, denser, more complex, and more confounding than the earlier ones.
• In this phase, Austen discards her allegiance to reason and resolution to explore uncharted and disturbingly equivocal regions of selfhood and relatedness. She transitions from a “maker of marriages” to an investigator into “the delicate anatomy of the human heart”.
• The novels of the major phase show a new receptivity to nature and attitude toward natural connection.
• The nature of time is different in the later novels, with a greater emphasis on the past shaping the present. The inner realm of feeling, reflection, recollection, relatedness, and personal transformation becomes more significant.
• Austen becomes an “artist of becoming,” focusing on the evolving nature of characters.
• The language of the late novels exhibits greater “subtlety and flexibility”. Austen’s notation of mental life becomes more prominent.
• The mature Austen is no longer primarily concerned with what ought to be but with what is, becoming an explorer of emotions, an observer of relational possibilities, and a connoisseur of process.
• The center of Austen’s attention shifts away from the courtship plot, which functions more as a framework for deeper explorations of emotional structures and modes of relatedness.

Influence of Romantic Poets:

• The shift between Austen’s early and major phases is attributed, in part, to her encounter with the Romantic poets: Wordsworth, Coleridge, Scott, and Byron.
• Their new poetry, focusing on the growth of the mind through feeling, memory, loss, interiority, solitude, ambivalence, and openness, influenced Austen’s later works.
• Austen absorbed fundamental orientations from these poets, reflected in the form, language, and themes of her major phase novels.
• While direct allusions are not always obvious, Persuasion is the sole novel with clear Romantic allusions. However, more subtle allusions to Wordsworth are found in Mansfield Park and Emma.
• Austen’s later novels display concerns drawn from the poets, such as “substitution” in Mansfield Park, “ambiguous relationships” in Emma, and “widowhood” in Persuasion.

Specific Novel Insights:

• Mansfield Park: Explores the concern of “substitution,” deeply informed by Wordsworthian themes of loss and compensation. The novel delves into the complexities of social relations and obligations.
• Emma: Investigates “ambiguous relationships,” drawing ideas about new possibilities for intimate connections from Wordsworth, Coleridge, and Byron, emphasizing complexity, depth, and freedom from conventional social roles. The novel also explores the concept of friendship in a complex historical context.
• Persuasion: Centers on “widowhood” as a process of bereavement and overcoming loss. It also functions as a meditation on historical transitions, reflecting the shift from an old order to a new one led by professions rather than nobility. The novel displays a new emphasis on nature and its connection to feeling.

In summary, Jane Austen’s artistic development shows a significant shift from the more straightforward and morally clear marriage plots of her early phase to the deeper, more psychologically complex explorations of her major phase, influenced by the changing literary landscape and her engagement with the works of the Romantic poets.

Austen’s Major Novels: Romantic Poet Influence

The provided source, “Jane Austen and the Romantic Poets,” argues for a significant influence of the Romantic poets (Wordsworth, Coleridge, Scott, and Byron) on Jane Austen’s novels, particularly those of her major phase (Mansfield Park, Emma, and Persuasion).

The source posits that while Austen’s early novels (Northanger Abbey, Sense and Sensibility, and Pride and Prejudice) are brilliant and assured, they are essentially straightforward marriage plots with morally unambiguous characters and relationships. The encounter with the Romantic poets, whose careers began to gain significant attention in the early 19th century (Byron bursting onto the scene in 1812), deepened Austen’s art, making it more intuitive, ambiguous, and unsettled, as well as more bold and mature. This influence pushed her towards new recognitions that her longer experience of life had prepared her for.

The shift between Austen’s early and major phases is characterized by several key changes attributed to the Romantics’ influence:

• A new receptivity to nature and a different attitude toward natural connection.
• A changed nature of time, with a greater emphasis on the past shaping the present and the significance of inner feeling, reflection, and recollection.
• Austen transitions from an “artist of being,” focused on static characters and abstract qualities, to an “artist of becoming,” exploring the evolving nature of characters.
• Her language gains greater “subtlety and flexibility,” with a more prominent notation of mental life.
• The focus shifts from what ought to be to what is, making Austen an explorer of emotions and relational possibilities.
• The courtship plot becomes more of a framework for deeper explorations of emotional structures.

The source argues that Austen absorbed fundamental orientations from the Romantic poets, reflected in the form, language, and themes of her later novels. While direct allusions are not always obvious (except in Persuasion), the influence is seen in her exploration of specific concerns drawn from these poets:

• Mansfield Park: Explores “substitution,” a set of psychic processes of adjusting to loss, which is deeply informed by Wordsworthian themes of loss and compensation. The novel subtly alludes to Wordsworth’s “Tintern Abbey,” playing a “double game” by also alluding to other authors.
• Emma: Investigates “ambiguous relationships,” drawing ideas about complex and deep intimate connections, free from conventional social roles, from Wordsworth, Coleridge, and Byron. The novel also delves into the concept of friendship within a complex historical context, engaging with the classical-romantic tradition and Byron’s impassioned engagement with the theme. Again, subtle allusions to “Tintern Abbey” are noted.
• Persuasion: Centers on “widowhood” as a process of bereavement and overcoming loss. It also functions as a meditation on historical transitions, particularly in the context of the Napoleonic Wars, influenced by Scott and Byron, who are explicitly mentioned and alluded to in the novel. The novel displays a new emphasis on nature, a theme prominent in Romantic poetry.

The author clarifies that this argument is not about definitively labeling Austen as a “Romantic” or applying a checklist of Romantic attributes to her work. Instead, it focuses on the specific impact the works of Wordsworth, Coleridge, Scott, and Byron available to her had on her writing after she encountered them. The ideas and impulses of the Romantic era were, according to the source, in the air because these poets put them there.

While the standard view once held that Austen probably did not read or think much of Wordsworth and Coleridge, the source argues for her familiarity with their work through subtle allusions and references, particularly to Wordsworth’s “Tintern Abbey” in Mansfield Park and Emma. Scott and Byron are more explicitly mentioned in her letters and novels, especially in Persuasion.

In conclusion, the source contends that Austen’s engagement with the Romantic poets led to a significant transformation in her writing, moving her beyond the conventions of her earlier works into a deeper exploration of human psychology, relationships, and the impact of time and feeling, marking a key development in her artistic career.

Austen’s Evolving Theme of Home: Early to Late Novels

The theme of home undergoes a significant evolution in Jane Austen’s novels, particularly when comparing her early phase (Northanger Abbey, Sense and Sensibility, Pride and Prejudice) to her major phase (Mansfield Park, Emma, and Persuasion). According to the source, the idea of place as the shaper of self is intimately connected with the idea of home in Austen’s late novels, mirroring a similar concept found in the works of the Romantic poets.

In the early novels, home is not depicted as a psychic necessity or a place that profoundly shapes the self. While these novels focus intensely on finding heroines suitable husbands, this quest does not necessarily involve finding them a suitable home, nor does it console them for the loss of an existing one.

• Catherine Morland’s home in Northanger Abbey is practically non-existent.
• Elizabeth Bennet’s home, Longbourn in Pride and Prejudice, is portrayed as something she is eager to leave. Pemberley, while described in detail for its beauties and comforts, functions more as a socioeconomic unit reflecting its master’s character rather than a place that formed him; for Elizabeth, it is a place to be “mistress of,” not inherently to dwell in.
• The Dashwoods’ loss of Norland in Sense and Sensibility is a significant event, but Barton Cottage, while a decent house, develops little resonance as a home. Its proximity to Barton Park even makes it almost as inhospitable as Longbourn is to Elizabeth. The places where the early heroines eventually settle, like Henry’s parsonage or the implied residences of Elinor and Marianne, are only briefly touched upon. Even though Sense and Sensibility comes closest to preserving the home of their youth for Elinor and Marianne, their relationship remains uneasy, suggesting their common “home” can only hope for an absence of tension.

By contrast, in the late novels, the idea of home as a psychic necessity and the loss of home as an irreparable psychic wound become central. For the mature Austen, as for the Romantic poets, home is a singular place that has made you who you are.

• For Fanny Price in Mansfield Park, home is vital to her emotional health. Her misery at leaving Portsmouth for Mansfield and then leaving Mansfield to revisit Portsmouth confirms this. Ironically, while the Crawfords’ instability and everything else about them are a product of their London upbringing, it highlights the novel’s investment in the idea of place as the shaper of self.
• Emma Woodhouse’s rootedness to place, though not explicitly emphasized, is fundamental to the very form of her novel. She never has to leave her home. The importance of home in Emma is such that it even overshadows the romance plot.
• Anne Elliot in Persuasion experiences homelessness and the effort to create a home away from home. The novel explores the nature and meaning of home, comparing different domestic settings like the jovial Uppercross, the cold Elliot lodgings in Bath, and the Harville lodgings in Lyme, which are described as a “picture of repose and domestic happiness”. The ability to make a home away from home becomes a key characteristic. Even the nation’s naval officers after the peace are described as “wanting a home”. While Anne and Wentworth find a metaphorical home in each other, the novel strikingly never specifies where they will finally live, suggesting their home will remain “unsettled”.

The source argues that the absence of the strong theme of home in the early novels is related to the portrayal of the self. In these early works, the self is not depicted as being “shaped” by place; instead, characters undergo abrupt changes of consciousness. Missing is the Wordsworthian theme of childhood as a formative influence, which is closely linked to the idea of home. For instance, Elizabeth Bennet’s past is largely absent from the narrative.

In the late novels, however, Austen’s focus shifts to the continuous modification of personality influenced by factors like place and memory, aligning with Romantic themes. The idea of home as a place deeply intertwined with personal history and memory, as seen in Fanny Price’s East room, mirrors Wordsworth’s depiction of the Wye valley in “Tintern Abbey,” where the space becomes a physical projection of the inner self, uniquely nourishing and making it whole. The East room transforms into a “palimpsest of personal history,” grounding the self in time through memory, much like the Wye valley functions for Wordsworth.

Therefore, the theme of home evolves from a relatively 배경 element in Austen’s early novels, primarily related to social standing and marriage prospects, to a profound exploration of its psychic significance in her later works, where it becomes intertwined with the formation of self, memory, and the experience of loss, reflecting a notable Romantic literary influence.

Austen’s Friendship: Evolution in Emma

The concept of friendship is a central and complex theme explored throughout Jane Austen’s works, and the provided source delves deeply into its various facets, particularly as it is presented and reimagined in her novel Emma. The source argues that the meaning and significance of friendship were undergoing a period of rapid change during Austen’s time, influenced by historical shifts, social ideals, and the writings of the British Romantic poets, especially Wordsworth and Byron.

Here’s a discussion of the key concepts of friendship highlighted in the source:

• Historical Evolution of “Friend”: The term “friend” carried different connotations in Austen’s England. One sense, which was fading but still present, denoted important associates and even elder kin or benefactors, particularly in the context of marriage decisions [46-47, 85, 172n15]. Another common meaning equated “friends” with neighbors, implying goodwill and mutual responsibility, though often lacking deep intimacy [61, 86, 93-94, 182n34]. The more modern understanding of a “friend” as a familiar companion for whom one feels affection and shares intimacies was also current [48, 86, 174n19]. Austen’s novels, especially Sense and Sensibility, reflect this semantic range.
• Friendship and Marriage: Austen consistently valued friendship as the highest social ideal and the desired foundation for marriage [87, 89, 171n12]. The concept of companionate marriage, where husband and wife are “companions and equals,” gained ideological importance in the 18th century, with figures like Mary Wollstonecraft arguing for marriage based on the lasting ties of friendship rather than mere erotic attraction [52-53, 86, 99, 180n24]. Austen is seen as revolutionizing this idea, depicting lovers becoming friends before marriage, emphasizing mutual knowledge and responsiveness.
• Classical-Romantic Tradition of Friendship: This tradition, rooted in figures like Aristotle, Cicero, and Montaigne, viewed friendship as a rare and exalted bond based on virtue and the pursuit of goodness, typically between men of equal standing and mature wisdom [61-63, 86, 101-102, 182n34]. It often paralleled the rhetoric of erotic love, suggesting friendship as a higher alternative. However, this tradition often excluded women. The Romantic era saw a revival and transformation of this ideal.
• Romantic Poets’ Influence on Friendship:
• Byron emphasized friendship as “the dear peculiar bond of youth,” associating it with innocence, candor, and spontaneity, contrasting it with the corruptions of the adult world. His view highlights the transience of such youthful bonds. Austen’s Emma reflects an awareness of this Byronic ideal, though Emma’s early pursuit of friendship seems to miss the mark of genuine youthful intimacy.
• Wordsworth attempted to carry the energies and feelings of youth into adulthood through friendship, exemplified by his relationship with his sister in “Tintern Abbey” and his connection with his older schoolteacher in the Matthew poems. He also imbued “friend” with a sense of democratic equality and social sympathy, as seen in Lyrical Ballads, where the term is applied to both kin and strangers, suggesting a basis for a revivified human collectivity. Austen’s Emma similarly explores friendship as a potentially democratizing and leveling force, where horizontal ties can supersede vertical ones.
• Friendship in Austen’s Early Novels: Austen’s early works contrast “good” forms of friendship (like Catherine and Eleanor Tilney) with “bad” forms (faux-sentimental friendships like Catherine and Isabella Thorpe, or mercenary “friends” in Sense and Sensibility). They also present friendship as a foundation for a profound conjugal relationship [89, 193n60].
• Friendship and “Ambiguous Relationships” in Emma: The source argues that Emma deeply explores the complexity and ambiguity of relationships, with friendship emerging as the “ambiguous relationship par excellence”. Austen tests and stretches the possibilities of friendship through various characters and their interactions.
• Mr. Woodhouse and Miss Bates represent friendship as generalized neighborliness, a more traditional, less intimate form.
• Mrs. Elton embodies a vulgar, overly familiar, and hierarchical notion of friendship, contrasting with the ideals of social sympathy.
• Emma’s pursuit of friendship with Harriet is flawed by inequality and Emma’s desire to act as a patron, misconstruing the meaning of true friendship.
• The potential friendship between Emma and Jane Fairfax is hindered by Emma’s vanity and the threat of an equal intimacy.
• Emma’s friendship with Frank Churchill, a male-female connection outside of marriage expectations, is presented as a significant and revolutionary exploration of amicable feelings, dissolving potential romantic love into “true disinterested friendship”. The ambiguity of “friendship” at the time allowed for such transitions.
• The relationship between Emma and Knightley ultimately defines the novel’s ideal of friendship, where their deep understanding, mutual respect, and willingness to offer counsel form the bedrock of their love and future marriage. Their journey shows friendship becoming the path to its own transfiguration into love, blurring the lines between different forms of affection and even transgressing conventional social boundaries like age and gender hierarchies.
• The Modernity of Friendship in Emma: By the end of Emma, friendship, particularly as exemplified by the bond between Emma and Knightley, emerges as a supremely flexible and inclusive form of relationship, anticipating the modern understanding where friendship can encompass various degrees of intimacy and serve as a basis for or coexist with other types of connections. The novel suggests a move towards a society where “we are friends with everyone,” reflecting a shift towards horizontal, egalitarian ties characteristic of modernity.

In essence, the source argues that Austen, influenced by the evolving social landscape and the intellectual currents of her time, particularly the Romantic re-evaluation of feeling and relationship, uses Emma to conduct a profound investigation into the meaning of friendship. She moves beyond simplistic notions of friendly connections to explore its complexities, ambiguities, and its potential to form the foundation for deep personal bonds, including love and marriage, ultimately contributing to our modern understanding of this essential human experience.

Widowhood and Loss in Austen’s Persuasion

The themes of widowhood and loss are significantly explored in the provided source, particularly in the context of Jane Austen’s novel Persuasion and its relationship to the works of Romantic poets.

In Austen’s early novels, the concept of widowhood is treated differently than in her later works. For characters like Lady Catherine de Bourgh, Mrs. Jennings, and Mrs. Norris, widowhood is associated with power, independence, and stature rather than bereavement. Mrs. Norris even consoles herself for her husband’s death by thinking she is better off without him. Similarly, Mr. Woodhouse and General Tilney do not appear to be affected by the loss of their wives.

However, in Persuasion, widowhood becomes a central fact in the lives of many characters, representing grief, memory, wrenching adjustments, and the painful attempt to move forward. The novel can be seen as a meditation on the dimensions and implications of widowhood and loss.

The source identifies numerous characters in Persuasion who are literally or figuratively widowed:

• Literally widowed: Sir Walter Elliot, Lady Russell, William Walter Elliot, Mrs. Smith, Mrs. Clay, and the Dowager Viscountess Dalrymple. Captain Benwick is also included by extension.
• Figuratively widowed: Anne Elliot (bereaved of Wentworth) and Wentworth himself are clearly marked as such. Charles Hayter experiences a brief figurative bereavement.
• Widowed through other losses: The three Elliot sisters (loss of their mother), Captain Harville (loss of the sister Captain Benwick was to marry), and Mr. and Mrs. Musgrove (loss of their son Richard) are also considered widows in a broader sense of the term.

The novel delves into how these characters cope with their losses:

• Anne’s grief for Wentworth is described as a state of “wan hopelessness and perpetual regret,” akin to the self-imposed isolation of Byron’s Giaour. Her memories are closely allied with her grief. However, she believes that “time had softened down much” of her attachment.
• Sir Walter’s widowhood is portrayed as a “psychic stasis” of “stunned numbness” rather than intense passion. He resists the natural aging process after his wife’s death.
• Lady Russell, also a widow, remains a paired remnant with Sir Walter, both unable to move forward from Lady Elliot’s demise.
• Mrs. Musgrove’s demonstrative grief for her son Richard is initially presented satirically, but the source suggests there is something powerful about her grief, highlighting how grief can grow over time and be startled back into consciousness. This resonates with Wordsworth’s insight in “Two April Mornings” about the persistence of grief.
• Captain Benwick’s indulgence in grief after the death of Fanny Harville is also examined. While some might see it as foretelling inconstancy, Austen uses a “vegetative metaphor” to suggest that mourning is a natural process with a cycle of growth and renewal.

The source emphasizes that for Austen, mourning is a natural process with its own cycle. The mourning that violates nature, according to the text, is Anne’s prolonged and suppressed grief. A proper change of scenery might have allowed her to form a “second attachment,” which is seen as “thoroughly natural”.

Persuasion is also linked to the works of Byron and Scott, where the theme of survival after loss is central. The novel’s synchronization of the personal drama of Anne and Wentworth with the national drama of war and peace (related to the Napoleonic Wars and the Battle of Waterloo) mirrors Byron’s juxtaposition of personal and national bereavement in his Turkish Tales and Childe Harold. The source suggests that the novel, with its focus on widows, might have been Austen’s way of addressing England’s own “widowed” state after years of war.

Furthermore, the loss and recovery of home is presented as a significant parallel process in Persuasion, linked to the theme of widowhood. Anne’s search for a home after the loss of Kellynch mirrors the desire of naval officers for a home after the peace. Ultimately, Anne and Wentworth find a metaphorical home in each other.

In conclusion, the source argues that widowhood in Persuasion becomes a central metaphor for a great array of losses, and bereavement and mourning serve as the template for the process of loss and recovery as such, understood as an essentially natural process. While Austen’s early novels treat widowhood with a different emphasis, Persuasion delves deeply into its emotional and psychological impact, drawing connections with Romantic literary themes of loss, memory, and the possibility of renewal. The novel ultimately explores how individuals and even a nation can navigate the aftermath of significant loss and attempt to “live again”. However, the source also subtly hints at the enduring nature of loss, noting that even Anne and Wentworth’s reunion is temporary, as one will inevitably be widowed again.

By Amjad Izhar
Contact: amjad.izhar@gmail.com
https://amjadizhar.blog

Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!

By Amjad Izhar
Contact: amjad.izhar@gmail.com
https://amjadizhar.blog

Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!

By Amjad Izhar
Contact: amjad.izhar@gmail.com
https://amjadizhar.blog

Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!