Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!
This guide provides a comprehensive walkthrough on filing a nil income tax return for the tax year 2025 in Pakistan, specifically tailored for individuals with no income such as housewives, students, or unemployed persons. It details the step-by-step process on the FBR IRIS portal, covering login procedures, password resets, and navigation through the tax return forms. The explanation extensively covers reporting various deductions and assets, including details for adjustable tax, different types of properties (agricultural, residential), and other personal possessions, and ends with the submission process and how to address unreconciled amounts for a successful filing.
To discuss Nil Tax Filing, it is important to understand what a Nil Income Tax Return is, who is eligible to file it, and the detailed process involved according to the provided sources.
A Nil Income Tax Return is filed by individuals who have no source of income for a given tax year, such as housewives, students, or unemployed persons. The purpose of filing a nil return is that the individual has no income to declare.
Here is a comprehensive breakdown of the Nil Tax Filing process:
Accessing the FBR Portal and Login To begin, you must go to the FBR IRIS portal by searching “GRS FBR” on Google and clicking the first link, irs.fbr.gov.pk. Upon reaching the IRIS website, you may encounter a pop-up for IRIS login authentication, which you can close. You will then provide your login credentials: your CNIC in the registration number field and your password. If your password has expired, which happens after 60 days due to recent changes, you will be prompted to reset it. The password reset requires entering your old password, followed by a new password and its confirmation. Once the password is reset, you can log in with your new password.
Opening the Income Tax Return Form After logging in, the IRIS dashboard will appear. You have two options to open the income tax return form: either by selecting “File your income tax return” under “Required Documents For normal return” or by clicking on “Simplified IT Returns for Non Business Individuals”. For a nil return, selecting the “File your income tax return” option is suitable. The system automatically sets the Tax Period to 2025, which typically runs from July 1st to June 30th. For the Tax Year 2025, the period is from July 1st, 2024, to June 30th, 2025, with a filing deadline of September 30th, 2025.
Residential Status The system will ask if you were present in Pakistan for 183 days or more during the Tax Year 2025. If you were, you are considered a resident and will file as such. A resident person pays tax on both Pakistani and foreign source income, whereas a non-resident only pays tax on local income earned in Pakistan. For filing a nil income tax return, if the person was in Pakistan for 183 days or more, you would select “yes”.
Sources of Income The system then indicates if its records show any preselected income sources for the tax year. For a nil income tax return, none of the income categories like salary, pension, rent from property, or payment for services should be selected because there is no income. If tax had been deducted against any of these, the respective tab would automatically be selected. Since you are filing a nil return, you would uncheck any preselected options. However, if you click on “Payment for Service” intending to proceed, the system will redirect you to an older version of the return form because the simplified form is specifically for salary, pension, and rent from property. To proceed with a nil return, which is considered outside these specific categories, you will click “Accept and Continue” to go to the older version.
The Older Version of the Returns Form In the older version, various tabs are available, but for a nil return, the primary concern will be “Tax Chargeable / Payments”. Other income heads like salary, property, business, capital gain, other source, foreign source, or agricultural income are not relevant.
Adjustable Tax Even when filing a nil income tax return, you must address the “Adjustable Tax” section. This is because taxes might have been deducted on various transactions despite having no formal income. These can include:
Tax on cash withdrawal from a bank account (0.6% for non-filers withdrawing over PKR 500).
Motor Vehicle Registration Fee under Section 231B, if you bought a car.
Private Vehicle Tax under Section 234, if you paid token tax on a car.
Cellphone bill under Section 236 subsection one and clause A, as tax is often deducted on mobile SIM usage.
Sale/Transfer of immovable property under Section 236C, if property was sold or purchased within the tax year.
Remitting amounts abroad through credit/debit/prepaid cards under Section 236, as tax is deducted on foreign payments (e.g., Google storage, Facebook ads).
To enter details for a cellphone bill, you need a tax deduction certificate, which can be obtained from the mobile app of your network provider, a franchise, or by emailing/calling them. The certificate will show the amount of tax collected. You will click the plus sign next to “Cellphone bill under section 236 subsection one and clause a”. You then enter your cell number as the utility reference/consumer number. In the “Contents” box, you select “prepaid” and mention your network provider (e.g., Mobiling, Jazz). After submitting, you enter the “receipt/value” (the amount against which tax was deducted, e.g., PKR 4404 for mobile usage) and the “tax collected/deducted” amount (e.g., PKR 645). After entering, you click “calculate”. The system may automatically fetch details of tax deducted from the FBR, adding them to the adjustable or final fix tab.
Checking Deducted Taxes (MIS Section) If you are unsure which taxes have been deducted, you can check the MIS (Management Information System) section of the IRIS dashboard. To do this, close the draft return by clicking the “close” button (you may lose unsaved changes). From the IRIS dashboard, navigate to “MIS” (often a small blue bar on the right side next to “invoice management”). Under “All Options Information Center,” click on “Payment Details”. You can then specify the tax year (e.g., 2025) and click “search” to see details of deducted taxes like cash withdrawal and tax on remitting amounts abroad. You can also download an Excel template of these details. The Excel sheet will show details like the section under which tax was deducted, taxable amount, paid amount (tax amount), payment date, and source of payment.
Wealth Statement After completing the income and tax details, the second part of the income tax return is the “Wealth Statement”. This section requires details of personal expenses and personal assets/liabilities.
Personal Expenses: You will click on “Personal Expenses”. Common expenses include rent, rates/taxes/charges, vehicle running/maintenance, traveling, electricity bills, water bills, gas bills, and telephone bills. For a nil income tax return, even if you do not have exact figures for all expenses, you can add a clubbed amount under “Other Personal / Household Expenses”. For example, if household expenses are PKR 100,000, you enter that. Since you have nil income, the system expects family members to contribute to these expenses. If, for instance, a family member contributed PKR 150,000, and your expenses were PKR 101,404, the difference (PKR 45,596) will be shown in surplus, increasing your cash in hand or assets.
Personal Assets / Liabilities: This section requires you to declare details of your assets and liabilities.
Agricultural Property: If you own agricultural land, click the plus sign to add details. You will need to provide the property address, specify it as “agri land,” its area (e.g., in canals), tehsil, and district. If the property was inherited, its value will be zero as no cost was borne to acquire it; you should write “inherited” in the contents. Otherwise, you will declare its cost. The fair market value can be determined using FBR property valuation tables or DC rates.
Commercial/Industrial/Residential Property Non-Business: For residential properties like a house, flat, or plot, or commercial properties like a shop or plaza. Click the plus sign, enter the complete address, specify if it’s commercial/residential/plot, its area (e.g., in marlas), and the city. If inherited, its value will be zero.
Equipment Non-Business: Small pieces of equipment not used for business (e.g., grass cutting machine, mechanical ladders). You just enter the value; there is no plus tab for further details.
Animal Non-Business: Animals not used for business (e.g., cows/buffaloes for homemade milk, expensive pets). You enter their value.
Investment Non-Business Account / NT / Bond / Certificate / Debenture / Deposit / Fund / Instrument / Policy / Shares / Stock / Unit Etc.: This includes savings or current bank accounts. Click the plus sign, provide the IBAN or account number, account type, bank name, branch, and city. The closing balance from your bank statement as of June 30th of the tax year should be entered as the value.
Non-Business Advance / Loan / Deposit / Prepayment / Receivable / Security: If you have given a loan to someone, provided security, or made prepayments (e.g., for a plot), you can add details. This requires the CNIC/registration number of the person/company, their name, and a description of the transaction.
Motor Vehicle Non-Business: Vehicles for personal use (bike, car, van). Click the plus sign, enter the vehicle’s registration number, and in the contents, specify if it’s private/commercial, make, model, and engine capacity. Then enter its value.
Precious Possession: Gemstones, jewelry (gold, silver, diamond). Click the plus sign, state the nature of the asset (e.g., “Jewellery”), and in contents, describe it (e.g., “Gold 10 Tola”). If it was received as dowry or gift, its value will be zero as no cost was incurred. You can edit the description to include “Dori” (dowry).
Household Effect: Furniture, kitchen items, dishes, personal items, furnishing. You enter an estimated value for these items.
Personal Items: Mobile, laptop, airpods, airbuds. Enter their value.
Cash Nonce Business: Cash held after deducting all expenses. Enter the value.
Any Other Assets: Any asset not covered in the above categories, such as a plot being paid for in installments. Click plus, add details in the content (e.g., “Five Marla Plot on Installment, Society Name”), and enter the amount of installments already paid.
Assets Held on Others Name: Assets bought in the name of a spouse or dependents. Click plus, enter the dependent’s CNIC/name, and a description of the asset.
Assets Held Outside Pakistan: For non-residents, this could include foreign bank accounts or properties.
Capital / Voting Rights in Foreign Company: Shares bought in a foreign company. Requires company name, incorporation number, country, date of incorporation, percentage of shares, and declared income.
Credit Non-Business Advance / Borrowing / Credit / Deposit Loan / Mortgage / Overdraft / Payable: Loans taken from family members, banks, or leased assets. Click plus, enter creditor’s CNIC/registration number, name of creditor, bank/branch name, type of loan (e.g., house loan, car loan), and the loan amount.
Reconciliation of Net Assets This section calculates your “Net Assets” (Assets minus Liabilities). For a first-time filer, “Net Assets Previous Year” will be nil. The goal is to make the “Unreconciled amount” zero. If there is an unreconciled amount (e.g., from an opening balance not accounted for from a previous year’s return), you must adjust it. For first-time filers, you can copy the unreconciled amount and paste it into “Net Assets Previous Year” to balance it out.
Inflows and Outflows The reconciliation section also accounts for inflows and outflows.
Foreigner Remittance: Money received from abroad (e.g., from family members). You can mention the amount, and a Proceeds Realization Certificate (PRC) can be obtained from the bank for verification.
Inheritance/Gift: If you received inherited property or gifts, their value (often zero for inheritance if no cost was borne, or the value of the gift if it’s declared by the giver in their returns) can be mentioned.
Gain/Loss on Disposal of Assets: Gains or losses from selling movable assets (excluding immovable property which falls under capital gains).
Personal Expenses (Outflows): This links to the personal expenses sheet and may show a negative amount if family contributions exceeded declared expenses.
Adjustments in Outflows: Losses due to unforeseen events (e.g., fire, damaged mobile).
Assets Transfer/Sold/Gifted/Donated during the Year: Value of assets donated, gifted, or sold.
Capital Assets (Section 7E) If you own any property, you also need to fill the “Capital Assets” form, specifically dealing with Section 7E of the Income Tax Ordinance.
Definition of Capital Asset: Generally, it includes property of any kind, whether used for business or not. However, it excludes stock-in-trade, raw materials for business, shares/stocks/securities, properties subject to depreciation/amortization deduction, and movable assets like vehicles. Essentially, it primarily refers to immovable property.
Taxability under Section 7E: Section 7E applies from Tax Year 2022 onwards. A resident person is deemed to have derived income equal to 5% of the fair market value of capital assets situated in Pakistan and held on the last day of the tax year. This deemed income is taxed at a rate specified in Division 8C of Part One of the First Schedule (effectively 1% of the fair market value, as 5% of the fair market value is taxed at 20%).
Exclusions from Section 7E: Certain properties are exempt:
A single capital asset owned by the resident person (e.g., one house or one plot).
Self-owned business premises from where business is carried out and the person is on the Active Tax Payer List (ATL).
Self-owned agricultural land where agricultural activity is carried out (excluding farmhouses).
Capital assets allotted to martyrs’ dependents of Pakistan Armed Forces, or persons who die in service of federal/provincial governments or armed forces, or war-wounded persons.
Ex-servicemen and serving personnel of armed forces, or federal/provincial government employees, who are original allottees of the capital assets.
Any property from which income is chargeable to tax under the ordinance (e.g., rented property already taxed).
Capital assets acquired in the first year of acquisition where tax under Section 236 (e.g., property purchase tax) has been paid.
Aggregate fair market value of capital assets (excluding the above clauses) does not exceed PKR 25 million (PKR 2.5 crore).
Capital assets owned by provincial/local governments, local authorities, development authorities, builders, and developers (if registered with Directorate General of Designated Non Financial Businesses and Professions).
Declaring Capital Assets: For each property, you need to provide measurement unit (e.g., marla, acre, canal), total area, complete address, town/tehsil, and city/district. You must also declare whether it is exempt from tax under Section 7E and provide the reason for exemption. You will declare its “Cost / Declared Value” and “Fair Market Value”. The fair market value can be determined using FBR Property Valuation Excel files, which provide rates for major cities. If the fair market value of a non-exempt property exceeds PKR 25 million, deemed income under Section 7E will be calculated.
Final Steps After completing all sections, including adjustable tax, wealth statement (personal expenses, assets, liabilities, and reconciliation), and capital assets, you click “Calculate”. Then, proceed to the “Attribute” section. For a nil income tax return, business sectors should be left blank. You must select your “Residence Status” (resident or non-resident) based on your presence in Pakistan. Finally, save the return and click “Submit”. You will be prompted to verify and confirm your undertaking that the information provided is correct. Enter your four-digit PIN (received from FBR when your NTN was created) and click “Submit”. Once submitted, your return moves from “Draft” to “Complete Task” on the IRIS dashboard. You can view and print your submitted return from the “Declaration” section under “Complete Task”.
Pakistan Income Tax Filing Guide for Nil Income
Filing an Income Tax Return involves a detailed process for individuals in Pakistan, even for those with “nil” income, such as housewives, students, or unemployed individuals. The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) mandates regular changes, for instance, requiring password resets every 60 days for its online portal.
Overview of Income Tax Return Filing
The process typically begins on the FBR’s IRS portal. After logging in with National Tax Number (NTN) credentials (CNIC and password), individuals access the Ayres dashboard. From here, they can select to file their income tax return, often choosing the “Normal Return” option for individuals.
The tax period for most individuals usually runs from July 1st to June 30th. For Tax Year 2025, this period is from July 1st, 2024, to June 30th, 2025, with a filing deadline of September 30th, 2025.
An important aspect to determine before proceeding is the filer’s residency status. An individual is considered a resident if they were present in Pakistan for 183 days or more during the tax year. Residents are liable to pay tax on both Pakistani and foreign sources of income. Conversely, a non-resident is someone who was outside Pakistan for 183 days or more and is only required to pay tax on income earned within Pakistan. For “nil income tax” filers, if they were in Pakistan for 183 days or more, they select “yes” for resident status.
Upon proceeding, the system may indicate pre-selected income sources based on FBR records, such as salary, pension, rent from property, or payment for services, if tax was deducted against them. However, for “nil income tax” returns, these options are typically unchecked. If “Payment for Service” is selected (even for “nil” filers to access an appropriate return version), the system may redirect the user to an older version of the return form, which is necessary for business income, service income, or “nil” returns.
Key Sections of the Income Tax Return Form
Once redirected to the old version of the return form, several tabs become accessible. For “nil income tax” filers, the focus is generally not on traditional income heads like salary, property, business, capital gain, other sources, or foreign/agricultural income, as there is no income to declare. Instead, the key tabs for a “nil” return are:
Tax Chargeable / Payments: This section is crucial for reporting any adjustable taxes. Even without traditional income, tax might have been deducted on various transactions. These adjustable taxes can include:
Cash withdrawals from banks (e.g., 0.6% for non-filers withdrawing over PKR 50,000).
Motor vehicle registration fees.
Private vehicle token tax.
Cellphone bills (tax collected under Section 236 subsection one and Clause A). Tax deduction certificates can be obtained from mobile apps, franchises, or via email/call. The tax deduction certificate shows details like the amount collected, the period, and the section under which tax was deducted. When entering cellphone bill details, the cell number, utility type (prepaid), and network provider (e.g., Mobilink, Zong, Telenor) are required.
Sale/transfer of immovable property.
Purchase/transfer of immovable property.
Amounts remitted abroad through credit/debit/prepaid cards (e.g., for Google storage, Facebook/Google ads). The system may automatically fetch details of taxes deducted by the FBR for these transactions.
To verify which taxes have been deducted, users can navigate to the “MIS” (Management Information System) section on the IRS dashboard, then to “Payment Details”, and search by tax year. This provides an Excel template download of all tax deduction details, including the section under which tax was deducted and the paid amount.
Computations: After filling in adjustable taxes, this tab displays the total income (which will be zero for a “nil” return), deductible allowances, and normal income tax chargeable. Importantly, any withholding income tax (from cash withdrawals, foreign payments, cellphone bills) will appear here as a “Refundable Income Tax” amount, as there is no liability against it.
Wealth Statement (Section 116): This is a critical part of the return, requiring individuals to detail personal expenses, personal assets/liabilities, and reconcile their net assets.
Personal Expenses: This includes various expenditures like rent, vehicle running/maintenance, travel, utility bills (electricity, water, gas, telephone), asset insurance, medical expenses, educational fees, club memberships, functions, donations, Zakat, markup on loans, life insurance premiums, and other personal/household expenses (e.g., groceries). Even if an individual has “nil” income, they are expected to declare household expenses, which are often covered by family contributions.
Personal Assets / Liabilities: This section requires declaration of various assets and liabilities:
Agricultural property. When adding inherited property, its value is declared as zero because no cost was incurred to acquire it.
Commercial, industrial, or residential property (non-business), including houses, flats, or plots. Similar to inherited agricultural land, inherited residential/commercial properties are also declared with a zero value.
Business capital (not applicable for “nil” filers).
Equipment non-business (e.g., grass cutting machine, mechanical ladders used for personal use).
Animals non-business (e.g., cows, buffaloes for milk, expensive pets).
Investments non-business (e.g., savings accounts, current accounts, bonds, certificates, shares, policies). Bank account details, including IBAN and closing balance as of June 30th, are added here.
Non-business advances, deposits, prepayments, or receivables (loans given to others, security deposits).
Motor vehicles non-business (cars, bikes, vans for personal use).
Precious possessions (gemstones, jewelry like gold, silver, diamonds). Gold received as dowry (string) is declared with a zero value as no cost was incurred.
Any other assets not fitting previous categories (e.g., plot installments).
Assets held in others’ names (e.g., property purchased in spouse’s or children’s names, with installments paid by the filer).
Assets held outside Pakistan (for non-residents, includes bank accounts, cash, foreign property, shares in foreign companies).
Liabilities: This includes non-business credits, advances, borrowings, deposits, loans (e.g., car loan from a bank), mortgages, or overdrafts. Foreign liabilities are also declared here. The “Net Assets” are calculated as assets minus liabilities.
Reconciliation of Net Assets: This section reconciles the current year’s net assets with the previous year’s, accounting for inflows and outflows.
Inflows: This includes income declared, foreign remittances (money received from abroad, often requiring a Proceeds Realization Certificate or EPRC), inheritances (zero value if no cost incurred), gifts received (e.g., property or cash from family, where the value is declared), gains on disposal of assets (excluding immovable property, like selling a car or household items), and other receipts.
Outflows: This primarily lists personal expenses (taken from the personal expenses sheet), adjustments, gifts given (assets or cheques to close relatives), loss on disposal of assets (e.g., selling a house at a loss), and assets transferred/sold/gifted/donated during the year.
The goal is to make the “Unreconciled amount” zero. If the previous year’s return was not filed, the “Net Assets Previous Year” may appear as zero, leading to a large unreconciled amount. This can be resolved by copying the unreconciled amount (without the minus sign) into the “Net Assets Previous Year” field, essentially bringing the opening balance to a reconciled state for a first-time filer.
Capital Assets (Section 7E): This form is specifically for declaring any property owned by the filer that is situated in Pakistan. This section is crucial if one intends to sell a property later, as a Section 7E certificate is required.
Definition: A capital asset generally refers to property of any kind, whether connected with a business or not, but explicitly excludes stock-in-trade, raw materials for business, shares/stocks/securities, assets subject to depreciation/amortization, and movable assets like vehicles. Essentially, for Section 7E, “capital asset” primarily means immovable property.
Tax Imposition: Section 7E imposes a tax at 20% on 5% of the fair market value of capital assets held on the last day of the tax year by resident persons. This effectively means a 1% tax on the fair market value.
Exemptions: Several exclusions apply to Section 7E tax:
Owning only one capital asset (e.g., one house or plot).
Self-owned business premises where business is conducted and the person is on the Active Taxpayer List (ATL).
Self-owned agricultural land where agricultural activity is carried out (excluding farmhouses). A farmhouse is defined by a minimum area of 2000 square yards and a covered area of 5000 sq ft.
Capital assets allotted to martyrs or their dependents from Pakistan Armed Forces, Federal, or Provincial Governments.
Capital assets allotted to war-wounded persons from Armed Forces, Federal, or Provincial Governments.
Original allotments of capital assets to ex-servicemen or serving personnel of Armed Forces, Federal, or Provincial Governments.
Any property from which income is already chargeable to tax under the Income Tax Ordinance (e.g., rental property).
Property acquired during the year if tax has been paid under Section 236.
Where the aggregate fair market value of capital assets (excluding the exempted clauses) does not exceed PKR 25 million (2.5 crores).
Capital assets owned by Provincial Governments or Local Governments.
Capital assets owned by local authorities, development authorities, builders, and developers for land development and construction, provided they are registered with the Directorate General of Designated Non-Financial Businesses and Professions (DNFBP).
Valuation: The fair market value of properties can be determined using either the Deputy Commissioner (DC) rate (for rural/far-flung areas) or the FBR Property Valuation Excel file (for 40 major cities), which provides FBR-defined rates per marla or acre.
Attribute: This section is used to declare details such as the number of children (for home educational fees, though this field is left blank for “nil” filers) and, most importantly, the “Residence Status”. As established earlier, resident status is selected if the individual was in Pakistan for 183 days or more.
Submission of the Return
After completing all relevant sections and ensuring the reconciliation of net assets is zero, the return is saved. The final step is to click “Submit” and enter a four-digit PIN that was received from FBR during NTN creation. Once submitted, the return moves from “Draft” status to “Complete Task,” and a printable PDF version of the return becomes available.
Understanding Tax Deductions for Nil Income Filers
In discussing Tax Deductions, it’s important to understand several related concepts and how they are handled in the Income Tax Return filing process, especially for individuals with nil income [i].
For individuals filing a nil income tax return, while they may not have traditional income, tax might still have been deducted on various transactions. These deductions are often referred to as “Adjustable Tax” or “Withholding Income Tax” [i, k]. The system might even pre-select certain income sources if tax was deducted against them, such as salary, pension, rent from property, or payment for services [i].
Here are the key aspects of Tax Deductions:
Adjustable Tax: This is a crucial section in the Income Tax Return form where individuals report any taxes that have been deducted from their transactions [i, k]. Even if you have no declared income, tax could have been withheld on various activities [i, k].
Common Examples of Adjustable Taxes:
Cash Withdrawals from Banks: If you are a non-filer and withdraw PKR 50,000 or more from a bank, a 0.6% tax is withheld [i, l]. The details of this deduction, including the amount and the section (e.g., Section 231A), must be entered [i, l].
Motor Vehicle Registration Fee: Advance tax is levied on motor vehicle registration, and its amount needs to be declared [i, l].
Private Vehicle Token Tax: If you’ve paid token tax for your vehicle, these details must be mentioned [i, l].
Cellphone Bills: Tax is collected under Section 236, subsection one, and Clause A on cellphone usage [i, l]. Tax deduction certificates for cellphone bills can be obtained from mobile apps, franchises, or by emailing/calling the network provider [i, l]. When entering these details, you need to provide the cell number, utility type (e.g., prepaid), and network provider (e.g., Mobilink, Zong, Telenor) [i, l]. The certificate will show the collected amount, period, and section of deduction [i, l].
Sale/Transfer of Immovable Property: Tax deducted on the sale of property needs to be reported [i, l].
Purchase/Transfer of Immovable Property: Similarly, tax deducted on the purchase of property is declared here [i, l].
Amounts Remitted Abroad Through Credit/Debit/Prepaid Cards: For foreign payments, such as for Google storage, Facebook ads, or Google ads, tax is deducted by your bank under Section 236 [i, l]. The system may automatically fetch these details, but they can also be added manually [i, l].
Verifying Tax Deductions: To verify which taxes have been deducted against your name, you can access the Management Information System (MIS) section on the FBR’s IRS dashboard [i, l].
Navigate to “Payment Details” within MIS [i, l].
You can search by tax year to view all tax deduction details [i, l].
An Excel template download is available, providing information on the section under which tax was deducted, the paid amount, and other relevant details [i, l]. For instance, it will show cash withdrawals or tax on remitting amounts abroad [i, l]. This downloaded data can then be used to populate the adjustable tax section in your return [i, l].
Withholding Income Tax in Computations: After entering all adjustable taxes, the “Computations” tab will display the total income (which will be zero for a nil return) and any deductible allowances [i, m]. Significantly, any withholding income tax (from cash withdrawals, foreign payments, cellphone bills) will appear as a “Refundable Income Tax” amount [i, m]. This is because for a nil income filer, there is no tax liability against which these deductions can be offset, making them eligible for a refund or carried forward if there were a liability [i, m]. For example, if 1380 PKR was withheld from cash withdrawals, foreign payments, and cellphone bills, this amount will be shown as refundable income tax [i, m].
Auto-Fetching of Deductions: The FBR system has started automatically populating details of taxes deducted into the adjustable or final fixed tax tabs [i, k]. However, it is still crucial to review these and manually add any missing deductions.
In essence, even without taxable income, individuals must meticulously declare all taxes deducted at source on various transactions to ensure a complete and accurate Income Tax Return [i, k].
Property Declarations and Capital Assets for Income Tax
Property Declarations are a crucial part of filing your Income Tax Return, as they detail all immovable assets you own, their value, and any associated tax implications. These declarations are typically made in two key sections of the tax return: the Wealth Statement’s Personal Assets/Liabilities section and the Capital Assets section.
Here’s a comprehensive discussion of property declarations:
I. Property Declarations in the Wealth Statement (Personal Assets/Liabilities)
The Wealth Statement is where individuals declare their personal assets and liabilities. This includes various types of property.
Types of Property Declared:
Agricultural Property: If you own agricultural land, its details must be provided. This includes the address (village, mouja, field, Khatuni number), the area (in acres or canals), and the district/city.
Commercial, Industrial, Residential Property (Non-Business): This category covers houses, flats, plots, shops, plazas, or factory buildings not primarily used for business purposes. You need to provide the complete address, the type of property (commercial, residential, or plot), its area (e.g., in marlas), and the city.
Other Assets (e.g., Plots on Installment): If you’ve acquired a plot in a society and are paying for it in installments, you can declare its details here, specifically noting that it’s “on installment”.
Valuation of Property:
For purchased properties, you declare the cost or declared value.
For inherited properties, you must specifically state “inherited” in the contents, and their declared value for tax purposes will be zero, as no cost was incurred to acquire them.
Properties gifted to you should also have their value mentioned, and if you gift a property, it would exit your personal assets.
Properties with Special Ownership Conditions:
Assets held in others’ names: If you’ve purchased assets like plots in the name of your spouse or dependents but are paying for them, you need to declare their value. This requires providing the CNIC of the dependent, their name, and a description of the asset.
Assets held outside Pakistan: For non-residents or individuals with foreign property, details of these assets can be declared in this section.
Changes in Property Ownership:
The form also allows you to declare assets transferred, sold, gifted, or donated during the year, indicating changes in your property portfolio.
II. Property Declarations in the Capital Assets Section (Section 7E)
The Capital Assets section is specifically designed to declare properties that may be subject to Section 7E of the Income Tax Ordinance, which deals with tax on deemed income from certain capital assets. This section is mandatory for any property in your name.
What Constitutes a Capital Asset for 7E:
A “Capital Asset” generally includes property of any kind held by a person, whether or not connected with a business.
Exclusions from Capital Asset Definition for 7E:
Stock-in-trade, raw materials for business.
Shares, stocks, or securities.
Property eligible for depreciation or amortization deductions.
Movable assets not included in the above clauses (e.g., vehicles).
Essentially, Section 7E primarily applies to immovable property.
Details Required in Capital Assets Form:
For each property, you need to declare:
Measurement and Total Area (e.g., Marla, acre, canal, square yard, square feet).
Complete Address, including town/tehsil and city/district.
Cost or Declared Value.
Fair Market Value: For properties in major cities, the FBR Property Valuation Excel tool provides standardized rates, and you may need to refer to relevant SROs (Statutory Regulatory Orders) for precise per marla/acre rates in your city.
Whether Exempted from Tax under Section 7E: You must select “Yes” or “No” and provide a “Reason for Exemption” if applicable.
Construction Status and Covered Area (for constructed properties).
Key Exemptions and Exclusions from Section 7E Tax:
Ownership of a Single Capital Asset: If you own only one house or one plot, it is typically exempt from 7E tax.
Self-Owned Business Premises: Industrial or commercial property used for business, provided your name appears on the Active Taxpayer List (ATL).
Self-Owned Agricultural Land: If agricultural activities are genuinely carried out on the land, it is generally exempt, but farmhouses built on such land are not exempt. A farmhouse has a specific definition regarding minimum area and covered area.
Properties Allotted to Specific Individuals: Capital assets allotted to martyrs, their dependents, war-wounded persons, ex-servicemen, or serving personnel of Armed Forces, Federal, or Provincial Governments (if original allotments) are exempt.
Properties with Existing Tax Liability: Any property from which income is already chargeable to tax under the Ordinance (e.g., rental income where tax is paid) is exempt.
Newly Acquired Property (First Year): Property acquired during the tax year where tax under Section 236 (on purchase) has been paid is exempt for that first year.
Aggregate Value Threshold: If the aggregate fair market value of your capital assets (excluding certain defined clauses) does not exceed PKR 25 million (2.5 crore rupees), they are exempt from 7E tax.
Government-Owned Properties: Capital assets owned by Provincial Governments, Local Governments, or Development Authorities are exempt.
Builder/Developer Properties: Capital assets held by builders and developers for land development and construction are exempt, provided they are registered with the Directorate General of Designated Non-Financial Businesses and Professions (DNFBP).
Tax Calculation on Deemed Income (Section 7E):
If a property is subject to Section 7E, a deemed income equal to 5% of its fair market value is calculated.
Tax is then imposed at a rate of 20% on this deemed income, which effectively translates to 1% of the fair market value of the taxable capital asset.
This tax is only applied if the fair market value of the capital assets (not covered by exclusions) exceeds the PKR 25 million threshold.
If your tax liability arises, you would generate a PSID (Payment Slip ID) to deposit the tax.
III. Verification of Deducted Taxes on Property Transactions
While not a declaration of property ownership itself, it’s important to report any taxes already deducted on property transactions within the Adjustable Tax section of your return.
This includes tax withheld on sale/transfer of immovable property (Section 236C) and purchase/transfer of immovable property (Section 236).
You can verify all taxes deducted against your name by accessing the Management Information System (MIS) section on the FBR’s IRS dashboard, under “Payment Details”. An Excel template can be downloaded from MIS to view details like the section under which tax was deducted and the amount paid.
Wealth Statement: Asset Reconciliation Explained
Asset reconciliation is a fundamental aspect of preparing your income tax return, specifically within the Wealth Statement. This process ensures that the net assets you declare at the end of the current tax year align logically with your net assets from the previous year, adjusted by your reported inflows and outflows during the year.
The primary goal of asset reconciliation is to achieve a zero “unreconciled amount”, as your tax return cannot be submitted until this balance is achieved. This section essentially acts as a check to ensure the consistency and accuracy of your financial declarations.
Here’s a breakdown of the key components involved in asset reconciliation:
I. Net Assets Calculation
Net Assets Current Year: This figure represents your total assets minus your total liabilities for the current tax year. It is automatically derived from the “Personal Assets/Liabilities” section of your Wealth Statement where all your properties, bank balances, vehicles, and other valuable possessions are listed, along with any loans or payables.
Net Assets Previous Year: This amount should automatically populate from the wealth statement filed in the preceding tax year. However, if it is your first time filing an income tax return, this field will show as zero. The system will bring forward the previous year’s net assets if a return was previously submitted.
II. Adjustments in Inflows
These are the increases in your net assets that have occurred during the tax year.
Foreign Remittance: If you have received money from abroad, for example, from parents, a spouse, or relatives living in another country, this amount is declared here. The sources mention that a “Proceeds Realization Certificate” (PRC) or bank statements can serve as proof for these remittances.
Inheritance: Assets or money received through inheritance are included here. While inherited property has a zero value in the personal assets section because no cost was incurred, the value of the inheritance still contributes to your inflows in reconciliation.
Gift: Any gifts received, whether cash or property, must be declared. For property gifts, details such as the giver’s CNIC and a description of the gifted asset are typically required.
Gain on Disposal of Assets (excluding immovable property capital gains): This refers to any profit made from selling movable assets like vehicles, household effects, or personal items. Profits from the sale of shares are usually reported under “capital gains” elsewhere and are excluded from this category.
Income Attributable to Receipts: This category can include various receipts. For instance, it specifically mentions income for builders and developers, but also “others,” like government support price received by farmers.
III. Adjustments in Outflows
These are the decreases in your net assets during the tax year.
Personal Expenses: This figure is directly carried over from the “Personal Expenses” section of your Wealth Statement. It represents your total declared living expenses for the year, such as rent, utilities, vehicle maintenance, medical, and household expenses. It can sometimes appear as a negative value if the family’s contributions to expenses exceed the stated expenses.
Loss on Disposal of Assets: If you sold any assets at a loss (e.g., selling a car for less than its purchase price, or if property or jewelry was lost due to fire or damage), that loss is declared here.
Gift: If you have gifted any property, assets, or money to someone (e.g., close relatives like parents, siblings, or children), the value of this gift is recorded here. This effectively removes the asset from your declared personal assets.
Assets Transfer / Sold / Gifted / Donated during the year: This is a general category for assets that have left your possession through various means like sale, gift, or donation. For charitable donations to NGOs, the details would be mentioned here.
IV. Unreconciled Amount and its Resolution
The “unreconciled amount” is the difference between your net assets from the previous year plus total inflows, and your current year’s net assets plus total outflows.
Goal: The target is always to make this figure zero. Your return cannot be successfully submitted until it reaches zero.
Resolution Strategy: If a positive unreconciled amount appears, it means you have more assets than your declared income and sources can logically explain. A common method to balance this, especially for first-time filers with a zero previous year net asset, is to adjust the “Cash Non-Business” field within your personal assets. The system allows you to copy the unreconciled amount and paste it into “Cash Non-Business” to reconcile the statement. Conversely, if the amount is negative, implying more outflows or liabilities than explained, adjustments may also be made to “Cash Non-Business” or other asset values to balance it.
By meticulously tracking and accurately reporting all these inflows and outflows, the reconciliation of net assets provides a comprehensive financial overview and helps ensure compliance with tax regulations.
How to File Nil Income Tax return 2025 | Zero Income Tax Return 2025 Nil | Income Tax Return Filing
Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!
This instructional document provides a detailed guide for filing tax returns in Pakistan for the 2025 tax year, specifically addressing how to report bank profits. It explains that the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has enabled the 2025 tax return form for submission, differing from previous availability for review only. The core of the guidance focuses on distinguishing between bank profits below and above 5 million Pakistani Rupees, illustrating where to input these amounts within the online tax form and how the tax rates (15% fixed vs. normal tax slab) apply to each scenario. The document also clarifies the abolition of Section 7B and the new process for accounting for bank profit, emphasizing that the system now automatically applies the correct tax treatment based on the declared profit amount, and instructs users on properly entering withheld taxes.
FBR Tax Return Guide 2025: Bank Profit Taxation
The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has enabled the form for filing tax returns for the tax year 2025, meaning that you can now submit your tax return. Previously, until July 18, 2025, the form was only available for review, and submission was not permitted. This change took effect on July 19, 2025.
When filing your FBR tax return, you will encounter various tabs and five main heads of income:
Income from Salary
Income from Property
Income from Business
Income from Capital Gains
Income from Other Sources
You are required to add your income under the relevant head. For instance, if you receive a salary, you would enter your full year’s salary under the Income from Salary head and calculate it.
A significant aspect of the tax filing process discussed in the sources is how to enter bank profit, especially given that Section 7B, which previously dealt with tax on bank profit, has been abolished. Bank profit must be entered in two places: on your income side and on your tax side.
Here’s how bank profit is handled based on the amount:
Bank Profit More Than Rs. 5 Million (50 Lakhs):
Entry: You must add this amount under “Other Source” and then select “Profit on debt”. For example, if your profit is Rs. 5.1 million (51 lakhs), you would enter 51 lakhs here and calculate it.
Taxation: When your bank profit exceeds Rs. 5 million, the normal tax rate or normal tax slab (also referred to as the business rate or business lab rate) will be applicable. The system will pick up this amount and designate it as “subject to normal tax”. For an amount like Rs. 51 lakh, the system might apply a tax of ₹14,100 based on the normal business slab tax rate.
Adjustable Tax: Although the normal tax rate applies, the bank would have initially deducted tax at a 15% rate. You need to account for this deducted tax under “adjustable tax” by selecting “Profit on day under section 151B from bank accounts deposit”. You will add your bank account details, the total profit amount (e.g., 51 lakhs), and the 15% amount the bank deducted (e.g., ₹9 lakhs). The system will then show any remaining tax liability that you need to pay. For instance, if your total normal tax was ₹14,100 but the bank already deducted ₹9 lakhs, you would then pay the remaining amount.
Wealth Declaration: This profit also needs to be added to your wealth statement under the normal tax slab and normal return.
Bank Profit Less Than Rs. 5 Million (50 Lakhs):
Entry: Similar to larger profits, you add this amount under “Other Source” and then select “Profit on debt”. For example, if your profit is Rs. 4.95 million (49.5 lakhs), you would enter this amount.
Taxation: If your bank profit is less than Rs. 5 million, a final and fixed tax of 15% will be levied on it. The system will automatically categorize this amount as “exempt from tax or subject to final and fixed tax”.
Fixed and Final Tax Section: To calculate this tax, you need to go to the “tax chargeable” section, open the “fix and final tax” tab. Here, you will find “Profit on Day under Section 151 Sub Section One B” with a clear indication for amounts “not exceeding 5 million” at 15%. You will enter your profit (e.g., Rs. 49 lakh) and calculate it. The system will then generate the 15% fixed tax, for example, ₹742,500 on Rs. 49 lakh.
Bank Deductions: You then enter the amount of tax the bank has already deducted from this profit in the designated column. If the bank has deducted the full tax amount, you will have no further tax liability for this profit.
Wealth Declaration: This profit must also be included in your wealth statement under “income attributable to received declared as return for the year subject to final and fixed tax”.
It is important to note that the FBR now only displays any tax payable on your computation page; it no longer shows how much tax you have already paid or how much was due previously.
For those looking to learn more about tax, there is a complete playlist available regarding the return filing for Tax 2025, offering practical videos to help you learn tax filing free of cost.
Understanding FBR tax filing is like navigating a detailed roadmap to financial compliance. Just as a GPS guides you through specific turns and routes based on your destination and current location, the FBR system directs you to the correct sections and applies the appropriate tax rules—whether it’s a fixed toll or a variable rate—based on your income streams and their respective thresholds.
FBR Tax: Bank Profit Filing Guidelines 2025
The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has enabled the form for filing tax returns for the tax year 2025, allowing for submissions since July 19, 2025. This is a significant update, as previously, until July 18, 2025, the form was only available for review. A key area of concern for taxpayers, especially with the abolition of Section 7B which previously dealt with tax on bank profit, is how to properly enter bank profit.
When filing your FBR tax return, bank profit needs to be entered in two distinct places: on your income side and on your tax side.
Here’s a detailed breakdown of how bank profit is handled based on the amount:
Bank Profit More Than Rs. 5 Million (50 Lakhs):
Income Side Entry: You must add this amount under the “Other Source” head, specifically by selecting “Profit on debt”. For instance, if your bank profit is Rs. 5.1 million (51 lakhs), you would enter this amount here and calculate it. The system will then pick up this amount and designate it as “subject to normal tax”.
Taxation: When your bank profit exceeds Rs. 5 million, the normal tax rate or normal tax slab (also referred to as the business rate or business lab rate) will be applicable. The system might apply a tax, such as ₹14,100, based on the normal business slab tax rate for an amount like Rs. 51 lakh.
Adjustable Tax: Although the normal tax rate applies, the bank would have initially deducted tax at a 15% rate. To account for this, you need to go to the “adjustable tax” section. Here, you will find an option for “Profit on day under section 151B from bank accounts deposit” at a 15% rate, which reflects the tax already deducted by the bank. You will add your bank account number, the total profit amount (e.g., 51 lakhs), and the 15% amount the bank deducted (e.g., ₹9 lakhs). The system will then show any remaining tax liability that you need to pay; for example, if your total normal tax was ₹14,100 but the bank already deducted ₹9 lakhs, you would then pay any additional amount due.
Wealth Declaration: This profit also needs to be added to your wealth statement under the normal tax slab and normal return.
Bank Profit Less Than Rs. 5 Million (50 Lakhs):
Income Side Entry: Similar to larger profits, you add this amount under “Other Source” and then select “Profit on debt”. For example, if your profit is Rs. 4.95 million (49.5 lakhs), you would enter this amount.
Taxation: If your bank profit is less than Rs. 5 million, a final and fixed tax of 15% will be levied on it. The system will automatically categorize this amount as “exempt from tax or subject to final and fixed tax”.
Fixed and Final Tax Section: To calculate this fixed tax, you need to go to the “tax chargeable” section and open the “fix and final tax” tab. Here, you will find “Profit on Day under Section 151 Sub Section One B” with a clear indication for amounts “not exceeding 5 million” at 15%. You will enter your profit (e.g., Rs. 49 lakh) and calculate it. The system will then generate the 15% fixed tax, for example, ₹742,500 on Rs. 49 lakh.
Bank Deductions: You then enter the amount of tax the bank has already deducted from this profit in the designated column. If the bank has deducted the full tax amount, you will have no further tax liability for this profit.
Wealth Declaration: This profit must also be included in your wealth statement under “income attributable to received declared as return for the year subject to final and fixed tax”.
It is important to note that the FBR’s computation page now only displays any tax payable; it no longer shows how much tax you have already paid or how much was due previously. For those looking to learn more about tax filing, a complete playlist for the Tax 2025 return filing is available, offering practical videos to help you learn free of cost.
Understanding how to enter bank profit in FBR tax filing is akin to a chef precisely measuring ingredients for a recipe. Just as each ingredient’s quantity determines the final dish’s taste, the specific amount of your bank profit dictates which tax “recipe” (normal tax slab or fixed/final tax) applies, ensuring your financial “dish” is perfectly compliant and balanced.
Navigating Taxable Income and FBR Filings for 2025
While the provided sources do not offer a direct, general definition of “taxable income,” they illustrate how various income streams are categorized and subjected to different taxation methods within the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) tax filing system for the tax year 2025.
Here’s how income becomes “taxable” according to the sources:
Heads of Income: All income must first be declared under one of the five main heads:
Income from Salary
Income from Property
Income from Business
Income from Capital Gains
Income from Other Sources You are required to add your income under the relevant head, such as entering a full year’s salary under the “Income from Salary” head. Once income is added under these heads, it becomes subject to the FBR’s tax computation rules.
Bank Profit Treatment (Illustrating Different Taxable Categories): The sources provide a detailed example of how bank profit is treated, which serves as a key illustration of different forms of “taxable income” based on thresholds, especially after the abolition of Section 7B:
Bank Profit More Than Rs. 5 Million (50 Lakhs):
If your bank profit exceeds Rs. 5 million, it is categorized as “subject to normal tax” or the “normal tax slab”. This means it will be included in the general tax computation and taxed at the normal tax rate (also referred to as the business rate or business lab rate).
For example, a profit of Rs. 5.1 million (51 lakhs) would be entered under “Other Source” as “Profit on debt” and calculated. The system would pick up this amount and designate it as “subject to normal tax,” applying a tax based on the normal business slab tax rate (e.g., ₹14,100 for Rs. 51 lakh).
Although the normal tax rate applies, the bank would have initially deducted tax at a 15% rate. This deducted amount is then accounted for under “adjustable tax” by selecting “Profit on day under section 151B from bank accounts deposit,” allowing the system to show any remaining tax liability. This profit is also declared in your wealth statement under the normal tax slab and normal return.
Bank Profit Less Than Rs. 5 Million (50 Lakhs):
If your bank profit is less than Rs. 5 million, it is subject to a final and fixed tax of 15%. The system will automatically categorize this amount as “exempt from tax or subject to final and fixed tax”.
For instance, a profit of Rs. 4.95 million (49.5 lakhs) would be entered under “Other Source” as “Profit on debt”. To apply the fixed tax, you go to the “tax chargeable” section, open the “fix and final tax” tab, and select “Profit on Day under Section 151 Sub Section One B” for amounts “not exceeding 5 million” at 15%. The system then generates the 15% fixed tax (e.g., ₹742,500 on Rs. 49 lakh).
Any tax already deducted by the bank is entered in the designated column, and if the full amount has been deducted, there will be no further tax liability for this specific profit. This profit must also be included in your wealth statement under “income attributable to received declared as return for the year subject to final and fixed tax”.
In essence, “taxable income” within the FBR context, as demonstrated by the sources, refers to income that, once declared under the appropriate head, becomes liable for tax under either the normal tax slab (where rates vary based on income brackets) or a fixed and final tax (a specific percentage that settles the tax liability for that particular income). The FBR’s computation page will only display any tax still “payable”.
Understanding what constitutes “taxable income” is like discerning which items in a grocery cart will be charged tax and at what rate. While all items are in the cart (declared income), some (like bank profit above a threshold) go through the regular checkout line with variable pricing (normal tax slab), while others (like bank profit below a threshold) go through a special express lane with a fixed, pre-determined price (fixed and final tax), but in both cases, they are ultimately subject to a charge (tax).
Fixed Tax Rates: Bank Profit and The 5 Million Threshold
Fixed tax rates, as discussed in the sources, refer to a specific percentage of tax levied on certain income streams that, once paid, finalizes the tax liability for that particular income, meaning no further tax is due on it. This is distinct from the normal tax slab where rates can vary based on income brackets.
Here’s a detailed breakdown of fixed tax rates based on the provided information, primarily focusing on bank profit:
Application to Bank Profit: The primary instance of a fixed tax rate in the sources is applied to bank profit.
The Rs. 5 Million Threshold: A critical factor in determining if a fixed tax rate applies to bank profit is a threshold of Rs. 5 million (50 lakhs).
If your bank profit is less than Rs. 5 million (50 lakhs), then a final and fixed tax of 15% will be levied on it.
The system automatically categorizes this amount as “exempt from tax or subject to final and fixed tax,” indicating that once this fixed tax is paid, no more tax is owed on that profit.
Entering and Calculating Fixed Tax for Bank Profit:
When your bank profit is, for example, Rs. 4.95 million (49.5 lakhs), you first enter this amount under the “Other Source” head, specifically selecting “Profit on debt”.
To calculate the 15% fixed tax, you need to navigate to the “tax chargeable” section in the FBR tax return form and then open the “fix and final tax” tab.
Within this section, you will find an option specifically for “Profit on Day under Section 151 Sub Section One B” for amounts “not exceeding 5 million” at 15%.
Upon entering your profit (e.g., Rs. 49 lakh) and calculating it, the system will generate the 15% fixed tax amount (e.g., ₹742,500 on Rs. 49 lakh).
Accounting for Bank Deductions: The bank would likely have already deducted tax from your profit. You must enter the amount of tax the bank has already deducted from this profit in the designated column. If the bank has deducted the full 15% fixed tax amount, you will have no further tax liability for that specific profit. The FBR’s computation page will only display any tax still “payable” to the FBR; it no longer shows how much tax you have already paid or was previously due.
Wealth Statement Declaration: Bank profit subject to fixed and final tax must also be included in your wealth statement under the category “income attributable to received declared as return for the year subject to final and fixed tax”.
In essence, a fixed tax rate simplifies taxation for specific income types by applying a set percentage, making the tax liability predictable and conclusive for that particular income.
Understanding fixed tax rates is like buying an item with a clear, pre-set price tag: if your bank profit is below a certain amount, it has a “fixed price” of 15% tax, regardless of your other income, and once you pay that amount, the transaction is complete, with no further charges applied to that specific profit.
Wealth Reconciliation of Bank Profit: Fixed vs. Normal Tax
Wealth reconciliation, as discussed in the sources, is a crucial step in the tax filing process that occurs after you have entered all your income and tax details. It involves declaring how your income, specifically bank profit in this context, integrates into your overall financial standing or “wealth statement”. This process ensures consistency between your declared income and your assets.
The manner in which your bank profit is declared in your wealth statement depends entirely on whether it was subject to normal tax or fixed and final tax, which in turn is determined by the Rs. 5 million threshold.
Here’s how bank profit is handled in wealth reconciliation:
For Bank Profit Less Than Rs. 5 Million (50 Lakhs):
If your bank profit is less than Rs. 5 million (e.g., Rs. 49 lakh 50 thousand), it is subject to a final and fixed tax of 15%.
When reconciling your wealth for this type of income, you must add it under the category: “income attributable to received declared as return for the year subject to final and fixed tax”. This signifies that the income has been fully taxed at a fixed rate and is now being accounted for in your wealth statement.
For Bank Profit More Than Rs. 5 Million (50 Lakhs):
If your bank profit exceeds Rs. 5 million (e.g., Rs. 5.1 million or 51 lakhs), it is categorized as “subject to normal tax” or the “normal tax slab”.
In your wealth statement, this amount will be declared under the “normal tax slab and normal return”. It means this income contributes to your general taxable income and is subjected to the variable rates of the normal tax slab.
Essentially, wealth reconciliation provides a comprehensive picture of your financial inflows and their integration into your assets, distinguishing between income streams that have been fully settled via fixed taxation and those that contribute to your general income for normal tax computation. It’s a critical step to ensure that your declared income aligns with your overall financial position reported to the FBR.
Think of wealth reconciliation like balancing your personal ledger after receiving different types of income. Some income (like bank profit under Rs. 5 million) comes with a “final stamp” (fixed tax) that clearly marks it as settled and then gets recorded in a specific part of your ledger. Other income (like bank profit over Rs. 5 million) is added to your general pool of earnings, contributing to your overall financial status before the final tax bill (normal tax slab) is calculated, and then it is recorded in a different part of your ledger as part of your overall assets.
Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!
The provided text offers an overview and critical analysis of the Finance Act 2025’s amendments to the Income Tax Ordinance in Pakistan. The speaker, Tahir Mahmood Butt, discusses the government’s push towards digitalization and automation of the tax system, highlighting new definitions for e-commerce and digitally delivered services. He examines specific changes like the taxation of online transactions, adjustments to pension income, and the introduction of disallowances for purchases from unregistered National Tax Number holders. Furthermore, the speaker raises concerns about the practicality of these amendments, their potential impact on taxpayers, and the need for a shift in mindset from both taxpayers and tax authorities. The discussion also touches upon changes in tax rates, audit selection criteria, and recovery procedures, emphasizing the broader implications for the nation’s tax framework.
Pakistan’s Finance Act 2025: A Tax Policy Overhaul
The Finance Act 2025 introduces what is described as a “huge shift in policy” for income tax in Pakistan, with the government aiming to move towards a more automated and technology-driven taxation system. The overall effort is to integrate technology for tax collection and base the structure of the taxation system on proper use of technology.
However, the speaker, Tahir Mahmood Butt, a former Senior Vice President of the Pakistan Tax Bar Association, expresses a fundamental concern: while taxpayers and consultants are urged to change their mindset from individuality to teamwork, he questions if the tax board is ready to change its mindset to fulfill the intent of the new laws. He emphasizes the need for a clear policy line for the future rather than just focusing on daily income or transactional-based collection through withholding systems. He believes there isn’t a proper policy for developing a sustainable taxation system, suggesting the focus is solely on increasing recovery rather than facilitating taxpayers or building a foundational system with continuity.
Here are some of the key amendments and changes introduced by the Finance Act 2025:
Changes in Definitions (Section 2):
The definition of a banking company will now align with its meaning in the Banking Company Ordinance.
Digitally delivered services (Clause 17C) and e-commerce (Clause 19A) have been defined, reflecting the shift towards digital taxation.
The online marketplace has also been defined.
Recreational Clubs: Clubs with membership up to ₹1 lakh have been removed from non-profit organization status and their income will now be assessed as normal business income under Section 18, meaning they will no longer receive non-profit credit.
Tax on Digital Transactions (New Section 6A):
A new charging section provides for tax on payments received for digitally ordered goods or services delivered from within Pakistan via locally operated online platforms, including online marketplaces and websites.
Special tax rates are defined: 1% if payment is made through banking channels/digital means, and 2% for cash on delivery transactions.
This tax is to be collected by the person delivering the goods and is declared as a final tax under Section 8. The speaker notes a potential flaw here, as Section 8 typically implies finality for income arising from the transaction, whereas here it’s on the transaction value, leading to ambiguity for traders who also do counter sales and need to apportion profit and expenses between final and normal tax categories.
Withholding Tax for Courier Services (Section 153):
New sub-sections (2A, M, and N) have been inserted in Section 153, making courier organizations and payment intermediaries prescribed persons for withholding tax purposes.
These entities will deduct tax (at 1% or 2%) from payments received for goods delivered through online platforms and remit the balance to the seller, with this tax being finalized.
A concern is raised regarding Section 111, sub-section 4, which might impose a condition of audited accounts if taxable income exceeds imputable income, potentially affecting those whose digital sales are subject to final tax.
Furnishing Information on Online Platforms (New Section 165C): A new section specifically details the procedure for courier service providers and online platform operators to furnish information and file withholding statements.
Tax Rates and Reliefs:
Salary Income Tax: The tax rate for salary income has been reduced from 10% to 9%.
Super Tax: Rates have been reduced by 0.5% in most categories for the tax year 2026.
Tax Credit for Property Sale (New Class 104A, Second Schedule): A new concession provides a tax credit for gains from the sale of personal-use property that has been owned and declared in the balance statement (under Section 116) for the last 15 years, and whose address has appeared in the taxpayer’s profile. This credit is available only once in 15 years. The speaker points out that current societal structures might make it difficult for many to benefit from this condition.
Pension Income (Section 12 Amendment):
Pension income has been moved from direct exemption and is now treated as a separate block of income under Section 12.
There will be no tax on pension up to ₹1 crore.
A 5% tax will be levied on pension income exceeding ₹1 crore.
Crucially, this concession only applies to individuals above 70 years of age; for those under 70, pension income will be part of their salary income and taxed at normal salary rates.
Disallowance of Expenses (Section 21 – Amendments):
New Clause U: This clause dictates that 10% of expenses attributable to purchases made from a person who is not a “holder of National Tax Number (NTN)” will be disallowed and added back to taxable income. The speaker critiques the wording “Holder of National Tax Number” as ambiguous, noting that since 2015, a CNIC can be treated as an NTN for individuals, potentially allowing non-filers to escape this provision if they simply provide their CNIC.
New Clause R: This is a significant amendment, providing for 50% disallowance of expenditure claimed against sales where the taxpayer has received payment of more than ₹200,000 otherwise than through a banking channel or digital means against a single invoice. The speaker strongly criticizes this provision, citing:
Unrealistic limit: ₹200,000 is considered too low in the current inflationary environment and for everyday business transactions, potentially impacting small shopkeepers, manufacturers, and traders.
Ground realities: The speaker argues that the policy makers, sitting in urban centers, do not understand the practical difficulties faced by common people and businesses in adopting digital payments, given the literacy rate and the manual nature of many transactions.
Impact on theft/compliance: He suggests that such restrictions might drive businesses towards the “auto book” (unofficial economy) rather than reducing theft.
Single Invoice: The wording “single invoice” (as opposed to “aggregate” sales) is noted, implying that businesses might simply issue multiple invoices below the ₹2 lakh limit to circumvent the rule.
Digital Means definition: The definition of “digital means” includes “over the counter digital payment services or facilities,” which raises questions about whether cash deposits by a buyer into a seller’s bank account via a bank counter would count as a digital payment, potentially providing a loophole.
Depreciation Allowance (Section 22): If tax is not deducted at the time of purchasing a new asset, the depreciation allowance for that asset will not be available.
Intangibles (Section 24): The life span for intangibles has been restricted to 25-50 years, compared to up to 25 years previously.
Gift, Loan, Advance (Section 39): Besides banking channels and cross cheques, digital means are now also validated for receiving gifts, loans, or advances.
Business Loss Adjustment (Section 56): Business losses can no longer be adjusted against property income.
Group Companies (Section 59B): A unit within group companies will not be part of the common taxable income if its taxation is based on a final tax regime rather than the normal tax rate (e.g., 29% for companies).
Tax Credit for Low-Cost Investment (Section 63A): A new tax credit is offered for investment in low-cost housing built with loans.
Mining Project Tax Credits (Class 65): Tax credits for mining projects, previously without income reference, are now linked with income.
Asset Purchase (Section 75): The facility of digital means is extended for purchasing assets beyond a certain amount.
Second Schedule Part One (Section 100C): The two parts of Second Schedule Part One (which provided state exemption or required fulfilling conditions) have been merged into one. This means all categories now must fulfill the conditions of Section 100C, which involves fresh registration and reports from four to five agencies for entitlement.
Tax Credit for Turnover (Section 113): The period for adjusting tax on turnover (when it’s higher than tax on taxable income) has been reduced from three years to two years.
Restrictions on Ineligible Persons (New Section 114C):
This section restricts ineligible persons from purchasing property above ₹100 million, motor vehicles above ₹7 million, opening bank accounts above ₹50 million, or withdrawing cash above a certain amount.
Eligible persons are defined as those who file returns and explain their sources of investment.
A new condition states that for any investment, the taxpayer must have 130% of the investment amount available, which includes cash and other liquid or immovable assets.
A non-resident person will still be eligible to buy a car or property, open a bank account, but cannot withdraw cash more than a certain amount if they are not in the eligible category.
Assessment Order (Section 120, Section 2A): Section 2A states that an assessment order under Section 120 is deemed complete only after maximum possible verifications of declarations. However, this provision is not yet operational because the board has not notified it in the official gazette, and issues exist with government departments not inputting data into the online system for verification.
Limitation Period (Section 122): The limitation period for notices has been extended from 180 days to one year, effective from July 1, 2025.
Appeal Effect Orders (Section 124): If an officer’s order is amended by the Commissioner of Appeal or High Court, the officer is mandated to issue an appeal effect order; recovery cannot proceed until this order is issued.
Recovery Proceedings (Sections 138, 140): Recovery proceedings can now only commence after the decision of at least three forums (Commission, Tribunal, and High Court) has gone against the taxpayer.
Information Sharing by Financial Institutions: Banking companies and other financial institutions are now restricted and mandated to share details of every taxpayer directly with the relevant tax authorities. This means taxpayers will have to manage their banking activities carefully.
Officer Posting (Section 56C): An officer can be posted to monitor specific areas like production, supply of goods, renting of services, and stock of goods, but their jurisdiction is limited to these four aspects.
Online Marketplace Registration (Section 181): Courier companies and delivery services are now prohibited from working with any person who is not registered for income tax. Heavy penalties are imposed on courier companies that transport goods for unregistered individuals.
Audit Selection (Section 105A): The criteria for audit selection have changed; a person will not be selected for audit if their income tax case has been selected for audit in the last three years (previously four years).
The speaker frequently highlights the disconnect between the policy intentions and the ground realities of Pakistan, criticizing the government’s approach of taxing businesses heavily while labeling them as “thieves” and expressing concerns that overly restrictive policies could push businesses into the unofficial economy or even out of the country. He consistently calls for the tax board to clarify ambiguous provisions through circulars.
Pakistan’s Finance Act 2025: Taxation Shift and Reforms
The Finance Act 2025 introduces significant amendments to the Income Tax Ordinance, signaling what is described as a “huge shift in policy” towards a more automated and technology-driven taxation system in Pakistan. The government’s objective is to build the structure of the taxation system on the proper use of technology.
However, Tahir Mahmood Butt, former Senior Vice President of the Pakistan Tax Bar Association, expresses a fundamental concern: while taxpayers and consultants are urged to adapt to this change and move from individuality to teamwork, he questions if the tax board is ready to change its mindset to align with the intent of the new laws. He emphasizes the lack of a clear, foundational policy line for the future, suggesting the focus remains on daily income or transactional-based collection through withholding systems, rather than developing a sustainable taxation system that facilitates taxpayers.
Here are the key amendments and changes introduced, along with expert commentary:
Definitions (Section 2):
The definition of a banking company will now align with its meaning in the Banking Company Ordinance, replacing the previous income tax specific definition.
New definitions have been introduced for digitally delivered services (Clause 17C), e-commerce (Clause 19A), and online marketplace, reflecting the shift towards digital taxation.
Recreational Clubs: Clubs with membership up to ₹1 lakh have been removed from non-profit organization status. Their income will now be assessed as normal business income under Section 18, losing non-profit credit.
Tax on Digital Transactions (New Section 6A):
A new charging section levies tax on payments received for digitally ordered goods or services delivered from within Pakistan via locally operated online platforms, including online marketplaces and websites.
Special tax rates apply: 1% if payment is made through banking channels or digital means, and 2% for cash on delivery transactions.
This tax is to be collected by the person delivering the goods and is declared as a final tax under Section 8.
Critique: Tahir Mahmood Butt notes a potential flaw: Section 8 typically implies finality for income arising from a transaction, but here it’s on the transaction value. This creates ambiguity for traders with both online and counter sales, as they face challenges in apportioning profit and expenses between final and normal tax categories in their returns. He hopes the Board will issue an explanatory circular for clarification.
Withholding Tax for Courier Services (Section 153):
New sub-sections (2A, M, N) make courier organizations and payment intermediaries “prescribed persons” for withholding tax. These entities will deduct tax (1% or 2%) from payments received for goods delivered through online platforms and remit the balance to the seller, with this tax being finalized.
Concern: This might interact with Section 111, sub-section 4, potentially requiring audited accounts if taxable income exceeds imputable income, even for those whose digital sales are subject to final tax.
Furnishing Information on Online Platforms (New Section 165C): This new section outlines the procedure for courier service providers and online platform operators to furnish information and file withholding statements.
Tax Rates and Reliefs:
Salary Income Tax: The tax rate for salary income has been reduced from 10% to 9%. Tahir Mahmood Butt questions the government’s approach of consistently favoring salary class taxpayers while labeling business class as “thieves,” imposing higher rates and surcharges on them.
Super Tax: Rates have been reduced by 0.5% in most categories for the tax year 2026.
Tax Credit for Property Sale (New Class 104A, Second Schedule): A new concession provides a tax credit for gains from the sale of personal-use property. To qualify, the property must have been:
In the personal use of the taxpayer and owned for the last 15 years.
Declared in the taxpayer’s last balance statement (under Section 116) for the last 15 years.
Its address must have appeared as the taxpayer’s address in their profile.
This credit is available only once in 15 years.
Critique: The speaker notes that current societal structures might make it very difficult for many to meet the 15-year ownership and declaration conditions, making the benefit largely inaccessible.
Pension Income (Section 12 Amendment):
Pension income has been moved from direct exemption and is now treated as a separate block of income under Section 12.
There will be no tax on pension up to ₹1 crore.
A 5% tax will be levied on pension income exceeding ₹1 crore.
Crucially, this concession only applies to individuals above 70 years of age; for those under 70, pension income will be part of their salary income and taxed at normal salary rates.
Disallowance of Expenses (Section 21 – Amendments):
New Clause U (Purchases from non-NTN holders): 10% of expenses attributable to purchases made from a person who is not a “holder of National Tax Number (NTN)” will be disallowed and added back to taxable income.
Critique: Tahir Mahmood Butt highlights ambiguity, noting that since 2015, a CNIC can be treated as an NTN for individuals, potentially allowing non-filers who provide their CNIC to escape this provision. He suggests the word selection is “poor”.
New Clause R (Cash Payments): This is a significant amendment, providing for 50% disallowance of expenditure claimed against sales where the taxpayer has received payment of more than ₹200,000 otherwise than through a banking channel or digital means against a single invoice (containing one or more transactions).
Strong Criticism: The speaker vehemently criticizes this provision, citing:
Unrealistic limit: ₹200,000 is deemed too low in the current inflationary environment and for everyday business transactions, impacting small shopkeepers, manufacturers, and traders.
Ground Realities: Policy makers are criticized for not understanding the practical difficulties and low literacy rates in adopting digital payments, suggesting such restrictions might drive businesses towards the “auto book” (unofficial economy) rather than reducing “theft”.
“Single Invoice” vs. “Aggregate”: The wording “single invoice” is noted, implying that businesses might simply issue multiple invoices below the ₹2 lakh limit to circumvent the rule.
“Over the Counter Digital Payment Services”: The definition of “digital means” includes this, raising questions about whether cash deposits by a buyer into a seller’s bank account via a bank counter would count as a digital payment, potentially providing a loophole.
Depreciation Allowance (Section 22): If tax is not deducted at the time of purchasing a new asset, the depreciation allowance for that asset will not be available.
Intangibles (Section 24): The life span for intangibles has been restricted to 25-50 years (previously up to 25 years).
Gift, Loan, Advance (Section 39): In addition to banking channels and cross cheques, digital means are now also validated for receiving gifts, loans, or advances.
Business Loss Adjustment (Section 56): Business losses can no longer be adjusted against property income.
Group Companies (Section 59B): A unit within group companies will not be part of the common taxable income if its taxation is based on a final tax regime rather than the normal tax rate (e.g., 29% for companies).
Tax Credit for Low-Cost Investment (Section 63A): A new tax credit is offered for investment in low-cost housing built with loans.
Mining Project Tax Credits (Class 65): Tax credits for mining projects, previously without income reference, are now linked with income.
Asset Purchase (Section 75): The facility of digital means is extended for purchasing assets beyond a certain amount.
Second Schedule Part One (Section 100C): The two parts of Second Schedule Part One (which provided state exemption or required fulfilling conditions) have been merged into one. This means all categories now must fulfill the conditions of Section 100C, which involves fresh registration and reports from four to five agencies for entitlement.
Tax Credit for Turnover (Section 113): The period for adjusting tax on turnover (when it’s higher than tax on taxable income) has been reduced from three years to two years.
Restrictions on Ineligible Persons (New Section 114C):
This section restricts ineligible persons from purchasing property above ₹100 million, motor vehicles above ₹7 million, opening bank accounts above ₹50 million, or withdrawing cash above a certain amount.
Eligible persons are defined as those who file returns and explain their sources of investment.
A new condition states that for any investment, the taxpayer must have 130% of the investment amount available, which includes cash and other liquid or immovable assets.
A non-resident person will still be eligible to buy a car or property, open a bank account, but cannot withdraw cash more than a certain amount if they are not in the eligible category.
Assessment Order (Section 120, Section 2A): Section 2A states that an assessment order under Section 120 is deemed complete only after maximum possible verifications of declarations. However, this provision is not yet operational because the board has not notified it in the official gazette, and issues exist with government departments not inputting data into the online system for verification.
Limitation Period (Section 122): The limitation period for notices has been extended from 180 days to one year, effective from July 1, 2025.
Appeal Effect Orders (Section 124): If an officer’s order is amended by the Commissioner of Appeal or High Court, the officer is mandated to issue an appeal effect order; recovery cannot proceed until this order is issued.
Recovery Proceedings (Sections 138, 140): Recovery proceedings can now only commence after the decision of at least three forums (Commission, Tribunal, and High Court) has gone against the taxpayer.
Information Sharing by Financial Institutions: Banking companies and other financial institutions are now restricted and mandated to share details of every taxpayer directly with the relevant tax authorities. Taxpayers are advised to manage their banking activities carefully.
Officer Posting (Section 56C): An officer can be posted to monitor specific areas like production, supply of goods, renting of services, and stock of goods, but their jurisdiction is limited to these four aspects.
Online Marketplace Registration (Section 181): Courier companies and delivery services are now prohibited from working with any person who is not registered for income tax. Heavy penalties are imposed on courier companies that transport goods for unregistered individuals.
Audit Selection (Section 105A): The criteria for audit selection have changed; a person will not be selected for audit if their income tax case has been selected for audit in the last three years (previously four years).
Overall, while the Finance Act 2025 aims to modernize Pakistan’s tax system through technology, Tahir Mahmood Butt consistently highlights a disconnect between the policy intentions and the ground realities of the country. He criticizes the government’s perceived tendency to view businesses as “thieves” and expresses concerns that overly restrictive policies could push businesses into the unofficial economy or even out of the country, rather than fostering compliance and growth. He frequently calls for the tax board to clarify ambiguous provisions through circulars.
Pakistan’s Digital Tax Shift: Finance Act 2025 Implications
The Finance Act, 2025, signifies a significant policy shift towards a digital taxation system in Pakistan, focusing on e-commerce and online platforms. This shift aims to automate the taxation system through proper use of technology.
Here are the key aspects of the digital taxation system as discussed in the sources:
Policy Shift and Automation
The government’s effort indicates a major policy change, requiring taxpayers, tax consultants, and even the tax board to change their mindset and move towards teamwork.
The entire focus of the budget is on digitally delivered services through e-commerce and online platforms, aiming to set up the taxation system through technology and automation.
The speaker notes that for 38 years in the profession, they have been waiting for a Finance Act that draws a proper policy line for the future, suggesting a move away from a daily basis income or transactional-based tax system. However, the current approach seems to prioritize recovery/collection over developing a foundational and continuous taxation system.
New Definitions and Sections for Digital Transactions
Section 2 of the Income Tax Ordinance has been amended to include new definitions relevant to digital services.
Digitally delivered services are defined in Clause 17C.
E-commerce is defined in 19A.
The online marketplace was also defined.
Section 6A is a new section providing for tax on payments for digital transactions on e-commerce platforms.
This tax is to be imposed on every person who receives payment for the supply of digitally ordered goods or services delivered from within Pakistan using locally operated online platforms, including online marketplaces and websites.
Special rates for this tax are 1% if payment is made through banking channels on digital means, and 2% if it is cash on delivery.
This tax is collected by the person delivering the goods and is declared as a final tax under Section 8.
A point of concern raised is that while the tax is collected on the transaction value, Section 8 typically declares final tax in respect of income arising from the transaction, not just the transaction itself. This could lead to issues in attributing profit to final tax and normal tax when a trader engages in both online and counter sales.
Withholding and Information Furnishing
Section 153 has added new provisions (two A sections) making courier organizations that sell goods through online platforms “prescribed persons”.
These prescribed persons will deduct tax from payments received for supplied goods and remit the balance, and this tax will be finalized.
Section 165C is a new section specifically defining the procedure for furnishing information on online platforms. This includes how and when courier service providers and online platform operators are to file withholding statements, detailing their particulars.
Payment intermediaries are also semi-defined as prescribed persons for withholding purposes under Section 153.
Restrictions and Compliance for Digital Transactions
Section 21R states that 50% of expenditure claimed for sales will be disallowed if the payment received exceeds ₹200,000 and is not through a banking channel or digital means against a single invoice.
The speaker critically questions the practicality of this ₹200,000 limit, especially for small businesses and in the context of “ground realities” like low literacy rates and traditional business practices in Pakistan.
The definition of “digital means” as including “over the counter digital payment services or facilities” also raises ambiguity regarding cash deposits via banking channels.
The speaker suggests that this restriction might lead to businesses issuing multiple invoices to stay below the ₹200,000 limit, similar to practices seen with sales tax regulations.
Section 39 now allows gifts, loans, and advances to be valid if received through digital means, in addition to banking channels or cross cheques.
Section 75 provides for the facility of digital means for asset purchases above a certain amount.
Courier companies and delivery persons are restricted from working with individuals not registered for income tax, with heavy penalties for non-compliance, pushing for digital registration verification.
Data Sharing and Digital Audits
Banking companies and other financial institutions are now restricted to share details of every taxpayer directly with the relevant concern authority (presumably, the revenue authority). This implies a digital sharing of financial data.
The source suggests that the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) is engaging thousands of chartered accountants to audit digital transactions, with assignments given to auditors to perform matching activities from their homes, leading to actions against taxpayers based on this digital monitoring. This refers to section 177D and 214.
Concerns and Flaws
The speaker expresses concerns about the intent of the law makers and whether the board is ready to change its mindset to fulfill that intent.
A significant flaw is noted in Section 6A regarding the finality of tax on transaction value versus income, which needs clarification from the board.
The strict application of Section 21 (including 21R) on small businesses and the general population is seen as potentially discouraging work and leading to non-compliance if legal formalities are too difficult to meet.
The speaker questions the government’s approach of imposing high taxes on business income, implying that it treats business class as “thieves” compared to the salaried class, which could encourage tax evasion.
The speaker highlights the disconnect between policy-making (based on systems in developed countries) and ground realities in Pakistan, where digital literacy and infrastructure may not be sufficient for universal adoption of online and computerized invoicing.
Pakistan’s Digital Tax: Compliance Challenges and Realities
The digital taxation system in Pakistan, as outlined in the Finance Act, 2025, aims to automate tax collection through technology, particularly for e-commerce and online platforms. However, the sources highlight several significant taxpayer compliance issues stemming from policy design, practical implementation, and underlying societal realities:
Mindset and Systemic Readiness: A fundamental concern is whether the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) is ready to change its mindset to align with the new policy shift, requiring teamwork and a move away from an individualistic approach. The speaker questions if the intent of the law makers can be fulfilled given the existing “mindset” of the board and its field formations. There’s also an ongoing debate about whether the focus is on “developing a foundational and continuous taxation system” or merely on “increasing recovery/collection”, which could impact long-term compliance.
Conceptual Flaws and Lack of Clarity in New Provisions:
Section 6A’s Final Tax on Transactions: The new Section 6A imposes a tax on digitally ordered goods or services based on transaction value (1% for digital payments, 2% for cash-on-delivery), declared as a “final tax”. A significant flaw identified is that while final tax typically applies to income arising from a transaction, Section 6A applies it to the transaction itself. This creates complexity for traders who engage in both online and counter sales, making it difficult to attribute profit between final tax and normal tax regimes when filing returns. This ambiguity requires clarification from the board.
Disconnection with “Ground Realities” and Practical Challenges:
Section 21R – Disallowance for Non-Digital Payments: This is a major point of contention. The provision states that 50% of claimed expenditure will be disallowed if payment received exceeds ₹200,000 and is not through a banking channel or digital means against a single invoice.
Impracticality of the Limit: The ₹200,000 limit is seen as too low in the current inflationary environment and is applied universally, including to small businesses and kiosk owners, which is considered impractical.
Digital Literacy and Infrastructure Gap: The sources strongly emphasize the disconnect between policy-making (based on systems in developed countries like Australia, Europe, America) and Pakistan’s “ground realities”. Many citizens and small business owners lack the digital literacy and infrastructure (e.g., for computerized invoicing, QR codes) necessary for universal adoption of online transactions and digital payments.
Discouragement and Evasion: The speaker fears that such strict and difficult legal formalities will “discourage people from working” and push businesses towards the informal economy, potentially leading to increased tax evasion rather than compliance. The concern is that if compliance becomes too hard, businesses will “go auto book” and “start stealing more”.
Loophole Exploitation: The rigid ₹200,000 limit might lead to businesses issuing multiple invoices for a single transaction to circumvent the rule, a practice previously observed with sales tax regulations.
Ambiguity of “Digital Means”: The definition of “digital means” as including “over the counter digital payment services or facilities” is ambiguous, raising questions about whether cash deposits via banking channels would be considered digital payments, leading to uncertainty for taxpayers.
Section 21 – Disallowance for Purchases from Non-NTN Holders: This provision disallows 10% of expenses attributable to purchases made from individuals not holding a National Tax Number (NTN). This places a significant burden on the buyer to verify the seller’s tax registration status. The ambiguity of a CNIC being treated as an NTN for individuals (as per Section 181(4)) further complicates compliance, as it might not be clear if a CNIC holder is truly “registered” in the active taxpayer sense.
Perception of Business Class: The speaker critically notes the government’s perceived notion that the salaried class is “honest” while the “business class are thieves,” reflected in significantly higher tax rates for business income (almost 50% including surcharge and super tax) compared to a maximum of 35% for salary income. This perception and heavy taxation are viewed as drivers for tax-saving behavior or evasion among businesses.
Burden on Service Providers: New provisions in Section 153 and 181 impose heavy penalties on courier organizations and delivery persons who work with individuals not registered for income tax. This shifts the burden of verifying tax registration onto courier companies, making it difficult for unregistered individuals (e.g., small online sellers) to utilize formal delivery services, potentially forcing them into less formal channels.
Data Sharing and Digital Audits: While aimed at increasing compliance, the restriction on banking companies and financial institutions to directly share details of every taxpayer with the revenue authority signifies a significant increase in digital monitoring. The FBR’s plan to engage thousands of chartered accountants to conduct digital audits and matching activities from home (referring to sections 177D and 214) implies a stringent enforcement mechanism based on digital monitoring, which could lead to increased actions against taxpayers. However, concerns remain about the FBR’s own internal data integration and cross-verification capabilities.
Income Tax Audit Selection Rules: Section 105A Explained
Based on the sources, the discussion on Audit Selection Rules primarily revolves around Section 105A of the Income Tax Ordinance. This section dictates the conditions under which a person’s income tax case cannot be selected for audit.
Here’s a breakdown of the rules and their amendments:
Previous Rule (before amendment):
**Prior to the recent changes, Clause 105A stipulated that a person’s case would not be selected for audit if their income tax had been audited in any of the preceding four years.
The speaker noted that for a taxpayer to benefit from this limitation, it was necessary for their case to have been audited previously, not just selected for audit.
New Amendment and Current Rule:
A new amendment has been made to Section 105A.
The updated rule now states that the selection for audit shall not apply to a person whose income tax case has been selected for audit in any of the last three years.
This is a significant change: the period has been reduced from four years to three years.
More importantly, the condition has shifted from having been audited to merely having been selected for audit. This means if a taxpayer’s case was selected for audit in any of the last three years (regardless of whether the audit was completed or not), their case for the next year cannot be selected for audit.
In essence, the amendment to Section 105A provides a relief for taxpayers by reducing the look-back period for audit selection and changing the trigger from an actual audit to just a selection for audit. This means if a taxpayer’s file has recently been put through the selection process, it provides a temporary shield against further audit selections for the subsequent year, provided it falls within the three-year window.
Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!
The provided text offers an extensive discussion on the Finance Act, 2025, primarily focusing on its impact on taxation, e-commerce, and business regulations. Speakers address new provisions such as withholding tax for online marketplaces, the use of AI for input tax credit verification, and changes to assessment procedures and audit selections. Significant attention is given to penalties for non-compliance, the suspension and blacklisting of businesses, and restrictions on cash transactions. The dialogue also explores amendments to income tax definitions, super tax rates, pension income, and asset purchases, emphasizing the government’s push for digitalization and broader tax base collection.
Digitalization and Evolution of Taxation Mechanisms
The sources discuss several key aspects of the taxation mechanism, highlighting changes, new systems, and enforcement measures introduced, particularly with a focus on digitalization and broadening the tax base.
Here’s a breakdown of the taxation mechanisms:
Withholding Taxation on Online Marketplaces (Section 11):
A 2% withholding tax is applied to sales made in online marketplaces.
This 2% is not an additional tax but rather reduces the output liability of the seller.
The online marketplace or courier service acts as the holding agent, deducting the tax and automatically reducing the seller’s output tax on their portal.
This mechanism is part of the broader effort to tax e-commerce.
The tax collected by online marketplaces will be inserted into a monthly statement, which will automatically appear on the seller’s portal, allowing for easy credit of the holding tax.
For online platforms, a special rate of 1% applies if payment is made via bank channel, and 2% if it’s cash on delivery.
This is generally declared as a final tax declaration under Section 7A. However, there is ambiguity regarding how this final tax on transaction value impacts overall taxable income and how it’s reflected in returns, potentially requiring clarification from the C Board.
Automated Risk Management System for Input Tax Credit (AI-based):
A new system has been developed to check input tax credit using AI.
This system, like an “MRI machine,” will verify if the claimed input tax aligns with the business’s line of business or the product being sold. For example, if a mineral water supplier claims to have used iron or wood not typically used in that business, the system will flag it.
If the system stops an input tax credit, a registered person can submit an application to the commissioner within 30 days to justify their claim. If the commissioner remains silent, the restriction is removed; otherwise, the person may need to go to court.
Tax consultants are advised to understand their clients’ business models and product recipes to effectively deal with these restrictions.
Best Judgment Assessment:
This power is given to the commissioner to assess tax when there is non-compliance, such as unpaid taxes (e.g., under 236G) or unfiled returns. It has been a provision in earlier cases as well.
Commissioner’s Powers regarding Business Operations:
Commissioners have been granted three types of powers:
Suspension of bank accounts operations for three days, renewable for another three days, and then permanent closure if commitment is not fulfilled.
Suspension/Blacklisting of business operations: This power, previously lost, has been restored. Direct suspension can occur without notice, despite court orders requiring an opportunity for explanation. The commissioner must decide whether to blacklist or restore within 10 days. Blacklisting affects the right to appeal under Section 21.
Ban on property transfer.
These powers allow control over businesses that might not have bank accounts or are running factories without them.
E-Billing and Digital Device Integration:
The system now requires the use of digital devices with QR codes for e-billing.
Consignments of goods transported by vehicles must be registered in the system, and particulars must be inserted into invoices, which will be integrated for FBR to monitor goods movement.
Tax on Digital Transactions in E-Commerce (Section 11J):
This new section imposes tax on payments received for supplies digitally delivered within Pakistan using online platforms, including marketplaces and websites.
The tax rate is 1% for bank channel payments and 2% for cash on delivery.
This tax is declared as a final tax.
Courier companies or online marketplaces are now designated as “prescribed persons” under Section 153, meaning they will deduct tax from payments to suppliers and deposit it, making it final tax.
If a person’s taxable income becomes greater than their immutable income, they are required to provide audited accounts.
This measure aims at broadening the tax base by bringing the e-commerce sector into the tax ambit.
Tax on Digital Presence (for Non-residents):
A separate law has been introduced for tax on digital presence, primarily targeting foreign vendors who provide goods or services in Pakistan online.
A 5% tax rate is charged on such transactions.
This mechanism differentiates between resident and non-resident online suppliers.
Restrictions on Input Tax and Expenses (Section 21 & 73):
Section 21 (R): If a sale exceeds two lakh rupees and payment is not received through a banking channel or digital means (for a single invoice or multiple transactions in one invoice), 50% of the expenditure attributable to that sale will be disallowed. This applies broadly, even to small shops and manufacturers, and aims to discourage cash transactions.
Section 21 (purchase disallowance): 10% of expenses attributable to purchases are disallowed if the purchase is made from a person who is not a holder of a national tax number (NTN). This is a new board of revenue collection mechanism.
Section 73 (Sales Tax): The source mentions Section 73 (in sales tax) dealing with a limit of 5000 units with one supplier annually. Also, if a buyer does not deposit money into a digital bank account, the input for the supplier may be finished. There is a debate on the interpretation of Section 73(4) regarding unregistered persons selling up to Rs. 10 crore.
There is no clash between Section 21 (Income Tax) and Section 73 (Sales Tax) as they use different criteria (single invoice vs. single account/party).
New Assessment Order Verification (Section 120):
Assessment orders will be completed by verifying declarations against maximum possible data. The operation of this section is contingent on official notification by the board, which has not yet occurred.
The system is intended to check returns against available data, but limitations exist due to the lack of integration of government department data (e.g., from mobile companies, judges’ CPR).
Recovery Proceedings (Sections 138 & 140):
These recovery proceedings will not be initiated until a decision has been made by at least three forums (e.g., commissioner appeal, tribunal, high court). This is seen as a positive development, preventing immediate recovery until higher forums have decided.
Data Sharing (Banking and Financial Institutions):
Banking companies and financial institutions are now required to share details of every taxpayer with FBR. This means tax information is transparent and easily accessible, reducing the ability to hide transactions.
Officer Posting for Monitoring (Section 175(6)C):
FBR officers can be posted to monitor production, supply of goods, rendering of services, and stock of goods. Their scope is limited to these four areas and they cannot question anything else.
Audit Selection Criteria (Section 105A):
A person’s case will not be selected for audit if their income tax returns have been audited in the last four years. This is a significant relief for compliant taxpayers.
E-Commerce Registration Requirement:
Courier companies and online marketplaces are now required to ensure that any person they deal with (e.g., for picking up goods) is registered for income tax. Failure to do so incurs heavy penalties.
Restrictions on Ineligible Persons (Section 114C):
A new section restricts “ineligible” persons from buying property or cars above a certain value, opening bank accounts above a certain limit (e.g., 50 million rupees), or withdrawing cash above a certain amount.
To be “eligible,” a person must have consistently filed returns and statements, and they must explain the sources of investment before investing. These restrictions do not apply to non-residents.
Depreciation Allowance Disallowance (Section 22):
If tax is not deducted at the time of purchasing a new asset, the depreciation allowance for that asset will not be granted.
Changes in Appeal System:
The old appeal arrangement has been reinstated.
Taxpayers now have two rights of appeal: either directly to the tribunal or first to the Commissioner Appeals.
It is generally advised to access the Commissioner Appeal Forum first as it offers more flexibility, time to explain the case, and a friendly environment compared to the tribunal, which has less margin for discretion and limited time for arguments.
Previously, the right of appeal under the Black Act was withdrawn but has been restored.
Other Noteworthy Changes/Discussions:
Broadening of Tax Base: A major focus is shifting to e-commerce to bring a large chunk of previously untaxed businesses into the tax net.
Shift to Transaction-Based System: The overall policy is moving towards a daily basis income and transaction-based system.
Tax on Recreational Clubs: Membership income of recreational clubs (over 10 lakh membership) is now treated as normal business income, not non-profit.
Pension Income (Section 12): Pension income exceeding 1 crore rupees will be taxed at 5%, while up to 1 crore will have a zero rate. A concession is given to those over 70 years of age, where their pension (if less than salary income) is taxed at salary income rates.
Investment Tax Credit (Section 63): Tax credit is offered for investment in low-cost housing schemes.
Asset Purchase Restrictions (Section 75): For cash payments for assets (property, vehicles) above a certain amount (e.g., 2 lakh for sales tax, implicitly higher for income tax related to asset purchase), banking channels are mandated.
Limitation Periods: Changes were made to show cause notice limitation periods, with an extension from 180 days to one year in some cases. However, extensions for tax payers are also requested.
“In-house” Transactions: The concept of “in-house” transactions, where internal documents of transfer are generated without external movement of goods, is acknowledged.
Digital Invoicing: A future seminar is planned on digital invoicing.
Overall, the taxation mechanism is moving towards a highly digitalized, automated, and interconnected system aimed at increasing transparency, broadening the tax base, and enhancing compliance, often by imposing strict restrictions and penalties for non-compliance with digital payment and reporting requirements. However, concerns remain regarding the practicality of these rules given the ground reality of the economy.
Digital Evolution of Tax Compliance and Input Tax Credit
The taxation mechanism in the sources provides a detailed overview of the system for input tax credit, emphasizing new digital advancements and stricter compliance measures.
Here’s a comprehensive discussion:
1. Automated Risk Management System (AI-based Check) A significant development in the taxation mechanism is the introduction of an automated risk management system for input tax credit, powered by Artificial Intelligence (AI). This system is designed to verify the legitimacy of claimed input tax credits. It functions like an “MRI machine,” scrutinizing whether the input tax claimed aligns with the business’s specific line of activity or the product being sold. For instance, if a mineral water supplier claims to have used iron or wood, materials not typically associated with their business, the system will flag and stop that input tax credit.
Resolution Process: If the AI system stops an input tax credit, the registered person has the option to submit an application to the commissioner within 30 days to provide justification for their claim. If the commissioner does not respond within this period, the restriction on the input tax credit is automatically removed. However, if the commissioner upholds the restriction, the person may need to escalate the matter to a court of law.
Consultant’s Role: Tax consultants are advised to thoroughly understand their clients’ business models and product recipes to effectively address and resolve issues arising from these AI-driven restrictions.
2. Restrictions and Disallowances on Input Tax Credit and Related Expenditures
The sources highlight several provisions designed to restrict input tax credit and disallow certain expenditures, primarily aimed at broadening the tax base and discouraging cash transactions:
Disallowance for Purchases from Non-NTN Holders (Section 21): A new provision dictates that if a person makes purchases from an individual who does not hold a National Tax Number (NTN), 10% of the expenses attributable to these purchases will be disallowed. This is a new revenue collection mechanism. The speaker notes a potential ambiguity, as Section 181 may treat a CNIC as an NTN for individuals, which could broaden the scope of this disallowance.
Disallowance for Cash Sales Exceeding Threshold (Section 21R): If a sale exceeds two lakh rupees and the payment is not received through a banking channel or digital means, 50% of the expenditure attributable to that sale will be disallowed. This applies to a single invoice, even if it contains multiple transactions. This measure is intended to discourage large cash transactions across all types of businesses, from small shops to manufacturers. There was initial concern about a clash with Section 73 (Sales Tax), but it was later clarified that Section 21 (Income Tax) and Section 73 (Sales Tax) do not clash as they operate on different criteria (single invoice vs. single account/party).
Impact of Multiple Disallowances: The cumulative effect of these disallowances (10% on certain purchases and 50% on certain sales) could lead to a significant portion of expenses (potentially 60-70%) being disallowed, raising concerns about the feasibility of doing business.
Depreciation Allowance Disallowance (Section 22): If tax is not deducted at the time of purchasing a new asset, the depreciation allowance for that asset will not be granted. This links tax deduction at source to the availability of depreciation, an important component of tax credit for assets.
Digital Payment Mandate for Assets (Section 75): For the purchase of assets like property or vehicles, if the payment exceeds a certain amount, banking channels are mandated. This reinforces the push for digital and traceable transactions.
Sales Tax Input Disallowance (Section 73): In the context of Sales Tax, if a buyer does not deposit money into a digital bank account, the input tax credit for the supplier may be disallowed. This emphasizes the importance of digital payment channels for maintaining input tax eligibility.
3. General Principles and Considerations The shift in the taxation policy is towards a highly digitalized, automated, and interconnected system. The intent is to make tax information transparent and easily accessible, reducing the ability to hide transactions. This comprehensive approach aims to ensure compliance and broaden the tax base, especially by bringing the e-commerce sector into the tax net. However, the practical implications and ground realities of such stringent rules are also a point of discussion. The overall policy is moving towards a daily basis income and transaction-based system. Compliance with law, whether financial or tax-related, is becoming increasingly critical, as digital systems will make it difficult to hide transactions or avoid tracking.
Digital Tax Revolution: Policy, Mechanisms, and Challenges
The sources indicate a significant shift in taxation policy towards a highly digitalized, automated, and interconnected system, with a strong focus on the digital economy. This move aims to enhance transparency, ensure compliance, and broaden the tax base, especially by bringing the e-commerce sector into the tax net.
Here’s a discussion of the digital economy as presented in the sources:
Policy Shift and Intent:
The government’s policy has fundamentally changed, moving towards a “daily basis income transaction base system”.
The entire focus of the recent budget is on digital services, e-commerce, and online platforms.
The intent is to make tax information transparent and easily accessible, making it difficult to hide transactions. This necessitates a change in mindset for both taxpayers and tax consultants, moving “from intimacy to reality”.
Key Measures and Mechanisms in the Digital Economy:
Automated Risk Management System for Input Tax Credit: An AI-based system acts like an “MRI machine” to verify the legitimacy of input tax credit claims, checking if they align with the business’s activity or product. If a claim is flagged, the registered person can apply to the commissioner for justification within 30 days.
Withholding Taxation on E-commerce: A 2% withholding tax is applied to sales made through online marketplaces or courier services. This amount is automatically reduced from the output tax liability. The online marketplace or courier service acts as the withholding agent. Courier companies are now mandated not to work with individuals unregistered for income tax, with heavy penalties for non-compliance.
Disallowance for Cash Sales (Section 21R): If a sale transaction on a single invoice exceeds two lakh rupees (200,000 PKR) and payment is not received through a banking channel or digital means, 50% of the expenditure attributable to that sale will be disallowed. This applies across all business types and is meant to discourage large cash transactions.
Digital Payment Mandate for Asset Purchases (Section 75): For the purchase of assets like property or vehicles exceeding a certain amount, banking channels are mandated.
Sales Tax Input Disallowance (Section 73): In Sales Tax, if a buyer does not deposit money into a digital bank account, the input tax credit for the supplier may be disallowed, further emphasizing digital payments for tax eligibility.
Consignment Registration via Digital Devices: A new system requires registering consignments of goods transported by vehicles using e-billing and digital devices with QR codes, integrating with the FBR system for monitoring.
Registration for Courier Companies/Online Marketplaces: Any courier company or online marketplace must register itself and ensure its users are tax-registered before booking consignments.
Tax on Digital Transactions (Section J-1): A new section applies a tax on payments for digital transactions in e-commerce platforms. For goods delivered within Pakistan using local online platforms (including marketplaces and websites), the rate is 1% if paid through a banking channel and 2% for cash on delivery. This tax is declared as a final tax, meaning no allowances or deductions are given against it, which raises questions about profit allocation for businesses with mixed sales (online and counter).
Definition of E-commerce and Online Marketplace: The ordinance specifically defines “e-commerce” and “online marketplace” to clearly bring them into the tax net.
Tax on Digital Presence: A separate law has been introduced for “Tax on Digital Presence,” primarily targeting foreign vendors providing goods or services in Pakistan, with a 5% tax rate on transactions like advertisements in Pakistan.
Centralized Data and Transparency: The system aims for absolute transparency, with data from various sources (bank accounts, CPR, mobile companies, etc.) becoming readily available at a “single click,” making it difficult to hide transactions or income. FBR officers are also empowered to monitor production, supply of goods, services rendered, and stock.
Implications and Challenges:
Broadening of Tax Base: A primary objective is to capture the large e-commerce sector that was previously outside the tax ambit, aiming to expand the client base.
Compliance and Anti-Fraud: The stringent digital measures are designed to enforce compliance and reduce tax fraud by tracing transactions and making evasion more difficult.
Feasibility Concerns: The cumulative effect of various disallowances (e.g., 10% on purchases from non-NTN holders, 50% on large cash sales) could lead to a significant portion of expenses being disallowed, raising concerns about the practicality of doing business, especially for smaller entities.
Adaptation for Businesses: The move requires businesses, including small shopkeepers, to adopt digital transaction methods and maintain meticulous records, which may be challenging given the “ground realities”.
Equity Issues: Concerns are raised about taxing individuals who may not fall into traditional tax brackets, such as the vast number of mobile users who might not be filers, and the disparity between the documented and undocumented economy.
Consultant’s Role: Tax consultants are urged to understand their clients’ business models and product recipes deeply to navigate these AI-driven restrictions and new compliance requirements.
In essence, the digital economy is no longer just a sector but has become the backbone of the new taxation regime, with a comprehensive digital framework intended to capture, monitor, and tax transactions on a daily and real-time basis, moving away from traditional, less traceable methods.
Business Model Imperative: AI Tax Compliance
The concept of the business model is critically important in the context of the new taxation mechanism, particularly due to the introduction of advanced digital and AI-powered verification systems.
Here’s why understanding the business model is emphasized:
Justifying Input Tax Credit Claims: With the implementation of an automated risk management system for input tax credit, powered by Artificial Intelligence (AI), the legitimacy of claimed input tax credits is rigorously checked. This AI system functions like an “MRI machine,” scrutinizing whether the input tax claimed aligns with the business’s specific line of activity or the product being sold.
Example: If a mineral water supplier claims input tax credit for materials like iron or wood, which are not typically associated with their business or product, the AI system will flag and stop that credit.
Consultant’s Role: To address such challenges effectively, tax consultants are explicitly advised to deeply understand their clients’ business models and product recipes. This includes knowing the raw materials used and the manufacturing process. Without this detailed knowledge, consultants may struggle to justify flagged input tax claims.
Navigating Restrictions and Ensuring Compliance: The sources highlight a shift towards a highly digitalized, automated, and interconnected tax system designed for transparency and increased compliance. Understanding one’s business model is crucial for businesses to:
Face Restrictions: The new systems will intercept input tax claims if they don’t align with the declared business model. A thorough understanding allows businesses to provide the necessary justification to the commissioner if a claim is restricted.
Equip for System Requirements: The overall advice for tax professionals and taxpayers is to “change from intimacy to reality” and equip themselves to meet the requirements of the new system by understanding the business model and product manufacturing.
In essence, the new tax regime demands a comprehensive and detailed understanding of one’s business operations, moving beyond superficial knowledge. This granular understanding of the business model is presented as a fundamental requirement for successful navigation of and compliance with the evolving digital tax landscape.
Digital Taxation: New Era of Compliance
The sources indicate a significant and concerted push towards enhanced tax compliance within the digital economy, driven by a new taxation mechanism and a fundamental shift in policy. The core intent is to broaden the tax base, increase transparency, and ensure that transactions, particularly those in the rapidly growing e-commerce sector, are brought into the tax net and properly accounted for.
Here’s a detailed discussion of tax compliance as presented in the sources:
Policy Shift towards Digitalization and Transparency for Compliance:
The government’s policy has moved towards a “daily basis income transaction base system”. This means a shift from traditional assessment methods to real-time, transaction-based monitoring.
The entire focus of the recent budget is on digital services, e-commerce, and online platforms.
The aim is to make tax information transparent and easily accessible, making it difficult to hide transactions. This necessitates a change in mindset for both taxpayers and tax consultants, moving “from intimacy to reality”.
Key Mechanisms and Tools for Enforcing Compliance:
Automated Risk Management System for Input Tax Credit (AI-based): An Artificial Intelligence (AI) powered system acts like an “MRI machine” to verify the legitimacy of input tax credit claims. This system checks if the claimed input tax aligns with the business’s activity or product. If a claim is flagged, the registered person can apply to the commissioner for justification within 30 days. This puts the onus on businesses to prove the direct relevance of their input purchases to their declared business model and product recipes.
Withholding Taxation on E-commerce: A 2% withholding tax is applied to sales made through online marketplaces or courier services. The online marketplace or courier service acts as the withholding agent, deducting this amount, which then reduces the seller’s output tax liability. This mechanism ensures that a portion of the tax is collected at the source of digital transactions.
Disallowance for Cash Sales (Section 21R): If a sale transaction on a single invoice exceeds two lakh rupees (200,000 PKR) and payment is not received through a banking channel or digital means, 50% of the expenditure attributable to that sale will be disallowed. This measure is designed to discourage large cash transactions across all business types and push for digital payments.
Digital Payment Mandate for Asset Purchases (Section 75): For the purchase of assets like property or vehicles exceeding a certain amount, banking channels are mandated.
Sales Tax Input Disallowance (Section 73): In Sales Tax, if a buyer does not deposit money into a digital bank account, the input tax credit for the supplier may be disallowed, further emphasizing digital payments for tax eligibility.
Consignment Registration via Digital Devices: A new system requires registering consignments of goods transported by vehicles using e-billing and digital devices with QR codes, integrating with the FBR system for monitoring. This allows FBR to monitor the movement of goods.
Registration for Courier Companies/Online Marketplaces: Any courier company or online marketplace must register itself and ensure its users are tax-registered before booking consignments. Failure to comply carries heavy penalties.
Tax on Digital Transactions (Section J-1): A new section applies a tax on payments for digital transactions in e-commerce platforms. For goods delivered within Pakistan using local online platforms, the rate is 1% if paid through a banking channel and 2% for cash on delivery. This tax is declared as a final tax, making deductions or allowances against it unavailable.
Tax on Digital Presence (Foreign Vendors): A separate law introduces a 5% tax rate on foreign vendors providing goods or services in Pakistan, specifically targeting transactions like advertisements. This captures cross-border digital transactions.
Centralized Data and Transparency: The system aims for absolute transparency, with data from various sources (bank accounts, CPR, mobile companies, telecom services, IP addresses) becoming readily available at a “single click,” making it difficult to hide transactions or income. FBR officers are also empowered to monitor production, supply of goods, services rendered, and stock.
Suspension and Blacklisting Powers: The Commissioner has been granted powers to suspend business operations for three days if commitments are not fulfilled, which can lead to permanent closure if default persists. This includes suspension or blacklisting for tax fraud and non-compliance.
Implications and Challenges for Compliance:
Broadening of Tax Base: A primary objective is to capture the large e-commerce sector that was previously outside the tax ambit, aiming to expand the client base and ensure all relevant transactions are taxed.
Stringent Enforcement and Anti-Fraud: The digital measures are designed to enforce compliance and reduce tax fraud by tracing transactions and making evasion more difficult. Tax fraud proceedings are now initiated directly through inquiry, similar to NAB procedures.
Feasibility Concerns and “Ground Realities”: The cumulative effect of various disallowances (e.g., 10% on purchases from non-NTN holders, 50% on large cash sales) could lead to a significant portion of expenses being disallowed, raising concerns about the practicality of doing business, especially for smaller entities and in an economy where cash transactions are prevalent. The sources explicitly question the feasibility of applying such stringent rules without considering “ground realities” in Pakistan, where many small businesses still operate in cash.
Adaptation for Businesses: The move requires businesses, even small shopkeepers, to adopt digital transaction methods and maintain meticulous records. Tax consultants are urged to deeply understand their clients’ business models and product recipes to navigate these AI-driven restrictions and new compliance requirements.
Equity Issues: Concerns are raised about taxing individuals who may not fall into traditional tax brackets, such as the vast number of mobile users who might not be filers, highlighting a disparity between the documented and undocumented economy.
Importance of Proper Documentation and Defense: The new regime emphasizes that “transactions being genuine” and proper “documentary evidence” are the main requirements for compliance. Taxpayers face “huge loss” if records are not properly maintained or cases are not defended.
Audited Accounts Requirement: If taxable income exceeds immovable income, audited accounts are now mandatory, further pushing for formal accounting and compliance.
In essence, tax compliance under the new regime is no longer optional; it is mandated through a comprehensive digital framework that aims to capture, monitor, and tax transactions on a daily and real-time basis, moving away from traditional, less traceable methods. The success of this framework hinges on both the government’s ability to implement it effectively and the taxpayers’ willingness and capacity to adapt to stringent digital and record-keeping requirements.
Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!
The source, an excerpt from “01.pdf,” outlines a new budgetary measure set to take effect from July 1, 2025, specifically targeting cash transactions. This measure, detailed under Income Tax Section 21, imposes a significant penalty of up to 50% on filers (sellers) who accept cash payments for invoices exceeding Rs 2 lakh. The core impact is that 50% of the expenses related to such cash-paid sales will become disallowed, thereby increasing the seller’s taxable profit and, consequently, their tax liability. The document emphasizes the onus on filers to educate their customers to utilize banking channels for payments to avoid these penalties, as non-compliance will lead to substantial fines upon audit.
Budget 2025: Cash Transaction Penalties for Tax Filers
Budget 2025 introduces significant changes, particularly concerning cash transactions for businesses and service providers who are tax filers. A key focus of this budget is to discourage large cash payments and bring more transactions into the formal banking system.
One of the most notable changes is the imposition of a penalty on filers who accept cash payments from customers for invoices exceeding Rs 2 lakh. Specifically, if a seller (Mr. A), who is a proper tax filer, issues an invoice for more than Rs 2 lakh to a customer (Mr. B), and Mr. B pays in cash, then Mr. A will face a penalty of approximately 50%. This penalty applies regardless of whether the customer is a filer or non-filer.
The mechanism of this 50% penalty involves the disallowance of expenses related to that cash-paid invoice. For example, if a filer has a sale of Rs 3 lakh with a cost of sales of Rs 2.5 lakh (leading to a gross profit of Rs 50,000), and the Rs 3 lakh was received in cash, only 50% of the cost (Rs 1,25,000) will be allowed as an expense. This reduction in allowed expenses will increase the filer’s taxable profit. In the example given, the profit would increase from Rs 50,000 to Rs 1,75,000, leading to a higher tax liability. The rationale is that if expenses are reduced, profit increases, and consequently, more tax must be paid.
This new law, which amends Income Tax Section 21, was part of the budget draft presented to the assembly on October 10, 2025. It is expected to be applicable from July 1, 2025. The source indicates a high likelihood (99%) that such laws will pass.
The budget seems to tighten regulations on filers, who are already subject to proper tax return filing, monthly and annual compliance, and audits. The new law aims to indirectly make filers agents for the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR). Filers are now expected to educate their customers and compel them to make payments through banking channels (e.g., cheque or bank draft) instead of cash. The implication is that if filers continue to accept large cash payments, the fines or additional tax they will have to pay might exceed the profit they make on that transaction.
Therefore, businesses are advised to implement this rule immediately and inform all their customers that cash payments for invoices of Rs 2 lakh or more will no longer be accepted. Breaking down invoices to below the Rs 2 lakh threshold is also considered risky, as audits can reveal such management tactics. The overall goal is to push transactions into auditable banking channels, thereby increasing transparency and potentially tax collection.
Cash Payment Penalties in Budget 2025
Budget 2025 introduces significant provisions regarding cash payments, particularly for businesses and service providers who are tax filers. The primary aim of these new rules is to discourage large cash transactions and encourage the use of formal banking channels.
New Rules and Penalty for Cash Payments: If a tax filer (referred to as Mr. A in the source) sells goods or provides services to a customer (Mr. B) and issues an invoice exceeding Rs 2 lakh, and the customer pays this amount in cash, the filer (Mr. A) will face a penalty of approximately 50%. This penalty applies irrespective of whether the customer (Mr. B) is a filer or a non-filer.
Mechanism of the 50% Penalty: The 50% penalty is implemented by disallowing a portion of the expenses related to that cash-paid invoice. For instance, if a filer has sales of Rs 3 lakh with a cost of sales of Rs 2.5 lakh, leading to a gross profit of Rs 50,000, and the Rs 3 lakh payment was received in cash, the tax authorities will only allow 50% of the cost (Rs 1,25,000) as an allowable expense. The remaining 50% of the cost will not be allowed.
This reduction in allowed expenses directly increases the filer’s taxable profit. In the given example, if the cost allowed is only Rs 1,25,000 against sales of Rs 3 lakh, the profit increases from Rs 50,000 to Rs 1,75,000. Consequently, the filer will have to pay significantly more tax on the increased profit. The principle is that when expenses are reduced, profit rises, leading to a higher tax liability.
Implementation and Rationale: This new law amends Income Tax Section 21 and was part of the budget draft presented to the assembly on October 10, 2025. It is expected to be applicable from July 1, 2025, with a high probability (99%) of passing.
The rationale behind this move is to indirectly compel filers to act as agents for the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR). Filers, who already comply with proper tax return filing, monthly and annual compliance, and audits, are now expected to educate their customers and insist on payments through banking channels (e.g., cheque or bank draft) instead of cash. The implication for filers is that accepting large cash payments for invoices over Rs 2 lakh could result in fines or additional taxes that might even exceed the profit made on that specific transaction.
Recommendations for Businesses: Businesses are advised to immediately implement this rule and inform all their customers that cash payments for invoices of Rs 2 lakh or more will no longer be accepted. The source also warns against the tactic of breaking down invoices into multiple smaller ones (below Rs 2 lakh) to circumvent the rule, as such practices can be identified during audits. The overall objective is to push transactions into auditable banking channels to enhance transparency and improve tax collection.
Budget 2025: Cash Transaction Limits and Penalties
Income Tax Section 21 has undergone significant changes in Budget 2025, primarily aimed at regulating cash transactions for tax filers.
Key Changes and Applicability:
Budget 2025 Draft: The draft of Budget 2025, presented to the assembly on October 10, 2025, includes these amendments to Income Tax Section 21.
Effective Date: The new law within Section 21 is expected to be applicable from July 1, 2025. There is a high probability, estimated at 99%, that such laws will be passed.
Targeted Filers: These changes primarily impact tax filers who conduct business or provide services.
The Core Rule and Penalty:
Invoice Threshold: If a filer (Mr. A) issues a single invoice to a customer (Mr. B) for a value exceeding Rs 2 lakh, and the customer pays this amount in cash, the filer will incur a penalty.
Penalty Amount: The penalty charged on Mr. A, the seller who is a proper filer, will be approximately 50%. This penalty applies regardless of whether the customer (Mr. B) is a filer or a non-filer.
Mechanism of the 50% Penalty: The 50% penalty is enforced by disallowing a portion of the expenses related to the cash-paid invoice.
Expense Disallowance: When an audit occurs, if an invoice of Rs 3 lakh was paid in cash, the tax authorities will only allow 50% of the cost related to that sale as an expense. For example, if the cost of sales was Rs 2.5 lakh for a Rs 3 lakh sale, only Rs 1,25,000 (50% of Rs 2.5 lakh) would be allowed as an expense.
Impact on Profit and Tax: By reducing the allowed expenses, the filer’s taxable profit increases significantly. In the given example, if the profit was initially Rs 50,000, reducing the allowed expense from Rs 2.5 lakh to Rs 1,25,000 would increase the profit to Rs 1,75,000. An increased profit directly leads to a higher tax liability. The source emphasizes that the filer might have to pay more in fines or taxes than the profit made on that specific transaction.
Rationale and Implications:
Discouraging Cash Transactions: The primary purpose of this amendment to Section 21 is to discourage large cash payments and push transactions into auditable banking channels.
Filers as FBR Agents: The law effectively makes filers agents of the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR). Filers, who are already compliant with tax return filing, monthly and annual obligations, and audits, are now expected to educate their customers and compel them to make payments through banking channels (e.g., cheque or bank draft).
Risk of Circumvention: The source advises against breaking down invoices into smaller amounts (below Rs 2 lakh) to avoid the rule, as such management tactics can be detected during audits.
Recommendations for Businesses: Businesses are strongly advised to implement this rule immediately and inform all customers that cash payments for invoices of Rs 2 lakh or more will no longer be accepted. It is crucial for filers to understand this law and act accordingly from July 1, 2025, to avoid significant tax penalties during audits.
Budget 2025: Cash Payment Penalties for Tax Filers
Tax filers face significant penalties under the new Budget 2025 provisions, particularly concerning the acceptance of cash payments. The core penalty mechanism and its implications are detailed as follows:
Primary Penalty for Filers If a filer (referred to as Mr. A in the source) sells goods or provides services to a customer (Mr. B) and issues a single invoice exceeding Rs 2 lakh, and the customer makes the payment in cash, then the filer (Mr. A) will incur a penalty of approximately 50%. This penalty applies regardless of whether the customer (Mr. B) is a filer or a non-filer.
Mechanism of the 50% Penalty The 50% penalty is implemented through the disallowance of expenses related to the cash-paid invoice.
Expense Disallowance: According to the new rule in Income Tax Section 21, during an audit, if a filer has an invoice of Rs 3 lakh that was paid in cash, the tax authorities will only allow 50% of the cost of sales related to that transaction as an expense. For example, if the cost of sales for a Rs 3 lakh sale was Rs 2.5 lakh, only Rs 1,25,000 (50% of Rs 2.5 lakh) will be allowed as an expense, while the other 50% will not be allowed.
Impact on Profit and Tax: By reducing the allowed expenses, the filer’s taxable profit significantly increases. In the given example, if the initial profit on the Rs 3 lakh sale was Rs 50,000 (after deducting Rs 2.5 lakh cost), reducing the allowed expense to Rs 1,25,000 means the profit would jump to Rs 1,75,000. An increased profit directly leads to a higher tax liability. The source warns that the fine or additional tax a filer might have to pay later could exceed the profit made on that specific supply or invoice.
Rationale and Broader Implications for Filers The new law, which amends Income Tax Section 21, was part of the budget draft presented on October 10, 2025, and is expected to be applicable from July 1, 2025, with a 99% likelihood of passing.
Discouraging Cash: The primary aim is to discourage large cash transactions and push payments into formal banking channels.
Filers as FBR Agents: The source highlights that filers, who already comply with proper tax return filing, monthly and annual compliance, and audits, are being disproportionately affected. This new law effectively makes filers indirect agents for the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), requiring them to educate their customers and compel them to make payments through banking channels (e.g., cheque or bank draft) instead of cash.
Avoiding Penalties Businesses that are filers are strongly advised to implement this rule immediately and inform all their customers that cash payments for invoices of Rs 2 lakh or more will no longer be accepted. The source also cautions against breaking down invoices into smaller amounts (below Rs 2 lakh) to circumvent the rule, as such “managed” transactions can be detected during audits. Filers are urged to understand this law and adjust their transaction methods from July 1, 2025, to avoid substantial tax liabilities during audits. The source suggests that this move places the burden of ensuring banking channel payments on filers, a role that traditionally belonged to the FBR.
Budget 2025: Promoting Banking Channels for Tax Transparency
The new tax provisions introduced in Budget 2025 place significant emphasis on the use of banking channels for transactions, particularly for payments exceeding Rs 2 lakh. The primary goal of these changes is to discourage large cash transactions and promote financial transparency.
Importance and Purpose of Banking Channels:
Discouraging Cash Payments: The core objective of the new law, which amends Income Tax Section 21, is to push transactions away from cash and into formal banking channels.
Enhancing Transparency and Auditability: Payments made through banking channels (such as cheques or bank drafts) are auditable, meaning they leave a clear financial trail that tax authorities can verify. This helps the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) improve tax collection and identify potential non-compliance.
Preventing Circumvention: The source warns against tactics like breaking down large invoices into smaller ones to avoid the Rs 2 lakh cash payment limit, noting that such “managed” transactions can still be detected during audits, reinforcing the need for transparent banking channel use.
Filers’ Role in Promoting Banking Channels:
Mandate for Filers: Tax filers, who are already compliant with proper tax return filing, monthly and annual obligations, and audits, are now effectively tasked with ensuring their customers use banking channels for payments.
Educating Customers: Filers are expected to educate their customers and compel them to make payments through banking channels (e.g., cheque or bank draft) instead of cash. The source notes that the FBR is indirectly making filers its agents to enforce this behavior.
Avoiding Penalties: To avoid the approximately 50% penalty on expenses, filers must ensure that payments for invoices over Rs 2 lakh are received via banking channels. Failure to do so could result in fines or additional taxes that might exceed the profit made on the transaction.
Recommendations for Businesses: Businesses that are tax filers are advised to immediately implement the new rule and inform all their customers that cash payments for invoices of Rs 2 lakh or more will no longer be accepted. The emphasis is on convincing customers to make payments through banking channels to ensure compliance with the new law, which is expected to be applicable from July 1, 2025.
Income Tax Ordinance 2001: Inadmissible Deductions Under Section 21
Section 21 of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, primarily outlines deductions that are not allowed (inadmissible deductions) in the computation of income. While the full text of Section 21 itself is not explicitly provided with a standalone heading in the excerpts, its contents and application are clearly referenced by other sections and appear within the “Income from Business” division where “Deductions Not Allowed” would typically be found.
Here are the details regarding Section 21:
1. General Application of Section 21:
Income from Business: Section 21’s provisions are directly applied in determining deductions for “Income from Business”.
Income from Property: The provisions of Section 21 apply in the same manner for determining deductions allowed when computing income chargeable under the head “Income from Property”, specifically for amounts related to deductions in Section 15A and non-adjustable amounts received in relation to buildings under Section 16.
Capital Gains: No deduction is allowed for any expenditure incurred in deriving a gain chargeable to tax under the head “Capital Gains” if that expenditure is referred to in Section 21.
Income from Other Sources: The provisions of Section 21 apply in the same manner for determining deductions allowed when computing income chargeable under the head “Income from Other Sources” (Section 40).
Banking Companies: Section 21, along with sub-section (8) of Section 22 and Part III of Chapter IV, applies mutatis mutandis for the computation of a banking company’s income.
Approved Funds: Section 21(e) is specifically referenced in relation to conditions for recognition and approval of:
Recognized Provident Funds (Part I of the Sixth Schedule).
Approved Superannuation Funds (Part II of the Sixth Schedule).
Approved Gratuity Funds (Part III of the Sixth Schedule). While the specific details of Section 21(e) are not provided, its inclusion in these contexts indicates it outlines rules or conditions for deductions pertinent to these funds.
2. Specific Inadmissible Deductions (as inferred from context within “Income from Business” where Section 21 typically falls):
Expenditures requiring tax deduction/collection: Any expenditure from which a person is required to deduct or collect tax under Part V of Chapter X or Chapter XII is not allowed as a deduction, unless the person has already paid or deducted and paid the tax as required by Division IV of Part V of Chapter X.
For purchases of raw materials and finished goods, the disallowance under this clause shall not exceed twenty percent of such purchases.
Recovery of any tax amount under sections 161 or 162 is considered as tax paid.
Fines and Penalties: Any fine or penalty paid or payable by the person for the violation of any law, rule, or regulation.
Personal Expenditures: Any personal expenditures incurred by the person.
Amounts Carried to Reserve Fund or Capitalised: Any amount carried to a reserve fund or capitalised in any way.
Payments by Association of Persons to Members: Any profit on debt, brokerage, commission, salary, or other remuneration paid by an association of persons to a member of the association.
Non-Digital Transactions (for companies): For a company, any expenditure for a transaction paid or payable under a single account head that, in aggregate, exceeds rupees two hundred and fifty thousand, if the payment is not made by digital means from a business bank account notified to the Commissioner under Section 114A.
This rule does not apply to expenditures not exceeding Rupees twenty-five thousand.
It also does not apply to expenditures on account of utility bills, freight charges, travel fare, postage, and payment of taxes, duties, fees, fines, or any other statutory obligation.
This specific clause is effective from a date to be notified by the Board.
Salary Payments to Individuals: Any salary paid or payable exceeding thirty-two thousand rupees per month to an individual unless it is paid by a crossed cheque or direct transfer of funds to the employee’s bank account or through digital means.
Capital Nature Expenditures: Any expenditure of a capital nature, except as specifically provided in Division III of that Part.
Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!
The provided text outlines comprehensive tax regulations, detailing various rates of advance tax and deductions at the source for diverse income types, such as dividends, profit on debt, and payments for goods and services. It extensively covers rules for income classification, taxable income computation, and allowable deductions like depreciation and amortization. The document also addresses international tax operations, offences and prosecutions for non-compliance, and the administrative framework for tax collection and enforcement. Furthermore, it specifies exemptions and reductions for certain entities and industries, alongside procedures for assessment, audit, and appeals.
Based on the sources provided, income tax is a tax imposed for each tax year on every person who has taxable income for that year [11(1)]. It is governed by the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001.
Here’s a breakdown based on the sources:
Imposition: Income tax is imposed subject to the Ordinance [11(1)]. Certain classes of income or persons may be subject to separate taxation or collection/deduction of tax as a final tax [13(4)].
Computation: The income tax payable by a taxpayer is computed by applying the specified rates of tax (found in Division I or II of Part I of the First Schedule) to the taxpayer’s taxable income [12(2), 11(1)]. Any applicable tax credits allowed under the Ordinance are subtracted from this amount [12(2)]. Tax credits are applied in a specific order: foreign tax credit (section 103), then tax credits under Part X of Chapter III, and then credits under sections 147 and 168 [12(3)]. If income tax is to be deducted or collected at source or paid in advance, it must be done accordingly [14(6)].
Taxable Income: The taxable income of a person for a tax year is defined as the total income (under clause (a) of section 10) for the year, reduced (but not below zero) by the total of any deductible allowances under Part IX of Chapter III.
Total Income: The total income of a person for a tax year is the sum of the person’s income under all heads of income for the year. It also includes income exempt from tax under the Ordinance, for the purpose of determining total income.
Heads of Income: All income, for the purpose of imposing tax and computing total income, is classified under the following heads:
Salary [21(a), 23].
Income from Property [21(b)].
Income from Business [21(c), 29].
Capital Gains [21(d)].
Income from Other Sources [21(e), 41].
Income Definition: The term “income” itself includes any amount chargeable to tax under the Ordinance and any amount subject to collection or deduction of tax under certain sections, such as 148, 150, 152(1), 153, 154, 156, 156A, 233, and sub-section (5) of 234 Division III of Chapter XII. It also includes imputable income as defined in clause (28A) of section 2 [15(iii), 16(iii), 8]. “Imputable income” relates to an amount subject to final tax and is the income that would have resulted in the same tax had the amount not been subject to final tax.
Persons Subject to Tax: A “taxpayer” is any person who derives an amount chargeable to tax, and includes any representative, any person required to deduct or collect tax (under Part V of Chapter X and Chapter XII), or any person required to furnish a return of income or pay tax. The persons required to furnish a return of income include every company, and individuals/AOPs whose taxable income exceeds the maximum amount not chargeable to tax, or individuals whose business income exceeds a certain threshold.
Rates of Tax: The First Schedule specifies various rates, including progressive rates for individuals and AOPs based on taxable income, and rates for companies. It also includes rates for minimum tax.
Minimum Tax: Minimum tax is imposed on certain resident companies, permanent establishments of non-resident companies, and individuals/AOPs with turnover above a specified threshold. This tax is based on a percentage of the person’s turnover from all sources for the year, and is payable if it is higher than the actual tax computed under other provisions.
Withholding Tax/Collection at Source: The Ordinance includes provisions for collection and deduction of tax at source under Part V of Chapter X and Chapter XII. This collected or deducted tax may be an adjustable advance tax or a final tax on the income. Tax collected or deducted has priority over other claims.
In essence, income tax under this Ordinance is a charge levied annually on the computed taxable income of persons, derived from various categorized sources, applying specific rates and taking into account credits and deductions. It operates through self-assessment (filing returns) subject to potential audits, advance payments, collection/deduction mechanisms, and defined procedures for collection, recovery, and refunds.
What are the Penalties if Income tax is not Paid on time?
Based on the provided sources, there are specific consequences and penalties for not paying income tax on time, primarily consisting of default surcharge and a distinct penalty for failure to deposit tax due. The sources also outline various recovery procedures.
Here’s a breakdown:
Due Date for Payment:
Generally, the tax payable on taxable income for a tax year (including minimum tax) is due on the due date for furnishing the taxpayer’s return of income for that year [61(1)].
Where tax is payable under an assessment order, amended assessment order, or any other order issued by the Commissioner, a notice specifying the amount is served, and the tax must be paid within thirty days from the date of service of the notice [61(2)].
The Commissioner may grant an extension of time for payment or allow payment in instalments upon written application showing good cause [62(4)]. However, granting such extension or permission to pay by instalments does not preclude liability for default surcharge arising from the original due date [62(6)]. If a taxpayer defaults on an instalment, the whole balance becomes immediately payable [62(5)].
Default Surcharge:
Any person who fails to pay any tax, penalty, or certain other amounts (referred to in sections 140 or 141) on or before the due date is liable for default surcharge [136(1)].
Failure to pay advance tax as required under section 147 also results in liability for default surcharge [137(1A)]. If the tax paid under section 147 is less than ninety percent of the tax chargeable, default surcharge is imposed on the shortfall [138(1B)].
A person who fails to collect or deduct tax as required, or fails to pay collected or deducted tax to the Commissioner by the due date, is also liable for default surcharge on the unpaid amount [139(3)].
The rate of default surcharge is twelve percent or KIBOR plus three percent per annum, whichever is higher, computed for the period commencing on the date the amount was due and ending on the date on which it was paid [136(1), 137(1A), 139(3)].
Penalty for Failure to Deposit Tax Due:
Under Section 182, there is a specific penalty for “Any person who fails to deposit the amount of tax due or any part thereof in the time or manner laid down under this Ordinance or rules made thereunder”.
For the first default, the penalty is five per cent of the amount of the tax in default.
For the second default, an additional penalty of 25% of the amount of tax in default is imposed.
For the third and subsequent defaults, an additional penalty of 50% of the amount of tax in default is imposed.
There is a provision for a 50% reduction in this penalty if the person opts to pay the tax due based on a Commissioner (Appeals) order on or before the due date given in the notice under section 137 and does not file a further appeal under section 131.
Recovery of Unpaid Tax:
For the purpose of recovering any tax due, the Commissioner may serve a notice requiring payment [63(1)].
If the amount is not paid within the specified time, the Commissioner can proceed to recover it out of the taxpayer’s property or through the arrest of the taxpayer [63(1)].
The Commissioner can also require persons owing money to the taxpayer or holding money on their behalf to pay that money directly to the Commissioner. However, the Commissioner cannot issue such a notice for recovery if the taxpayer has filed an appeal under section 127 regarding the order under which the tax is payable and the appeal is not decided, provided ten percent of the tax due has been paid by the taxpayer.
Specific procedures exist for recovery from private companies and associations of persons, estates in bankruptcy, non-resident members of associations, non-resident ship or aircraft owners/charterers, and persons assessed in Azad Jammu and Kashmir.
Recovery proceedings can also be initiated to recover liabilities outstanding under other laws if they are treated as income tax arrears.
It’s important to note that failing to file a tax return by the due date is a separate offence with its own penalties, although late filing can also impact a person’s status on the active taxpayers’ list and may require paying a surcharge for inclusion. The penalties specifically linked to not paying the tax itself when due are the default surcharge and the penalty under Section 182, Entry 5 [136(1), 101, 102]. The old Section 183, which also dealt with penalties for non-payment, has been omitted.
What happens if we do not file income tax return on time?
Based on the sources provided, failing to file an income tax return on time can result in several penalties and consequences:
Monetary Penalties:
Any person who fails to furnish a return of income as required under section 114 within the due date is liable for a penalty.
The penalty is equal to the higher of:
0.1% of the tax payable in respect of that tax year for each day of default.
Rupees one thousand for each day of default.
There are minimum penalty amounts:
Rupees ten thousand in case of an individual having seventy-five percent or more income from salary.
Rupees fifty thousand in all other cases.
The maximum penalty shall not exceed two hundred percent of tax payable by the person in a tax year.
However, the amount of penalty is reduced if the return is filed within a certain period after the due date or extended due date:
Reduced by 75% if filed within one month.
Reduced by 50% if filed within two months.
Reduced by 25% if filed within three months.
“Tax payable” for this penalty refers to the tax chargeable on taxable income based on assessments made or treated as made under sections 120, 121, 122, or 122D.
Separate penalties exist for failure to furnish a wealth statement (Section 182, Entry 1AA), a foreign assets and income statement (Section 182, Entry 1AAA), or a return required by a specific notice under section 117(3) (Section 182, Entry 1B).
Exclusion from Active Taxpayers’ List (ATL) and Related Consequences:
Notwithstanding other provisions, if a person fails to file a return of income under section 114 by the due date (or extended date), such person shall not be included in the active taxpayers’ list for the year for which the return was not filed on time.
Being excluded from the ATL has further consequences:
The person shall not be allowed, for that tax year, to carry forward any loss under Part VIII of Chapter IV.
The person shall not be issued refund during the period they are not included in the active taxpayers’ list.
A person can be included in the active taxpayers’ list after filing a late return if they pay a surcharge. The surcharge amounts are:
Rupees twenty thousand in case of a company.
Rupees ten thousand in case of an association of persons.
Rupees one thousand in case of an individual.
Commissioner’s Power to Require a Return and Make Assessment:
If, in the Commissioner’s opinion, a person was required to file a return under section 114 but failed to do so, the Commissioner may, by notice, require that person to furnish a return within thirty days (or longer/shorter). This notice can be issued for the last five completed tax years, or the last ten if the person hasn’t filed for the last five.
If a person fails to furnish a return of income for a tax year when required by a notice (e.g., under section 114(4)), the Commissioner may, based on available information and best judgment, make an assessment of the person’s taxable income and the tax due thereon. This assessment order will state the taxable income, tax due, tax paid, and appeal process. Such an order can generally be issued within six years after the end of the relevant tax year.
Provisional Assessment for Non-Filers with Withholding Tax:
Where a person’s tax has been collected or deducted at a potentially higher rate (as per Rule 1 of the Tenth Schedule for persons not on ATL or late filers) and the person fails to file a return by the due date or extended date, the Commissioner shall make a provisional assessment of the taxable income and tax due within sixty days of the due date.
In this provisional assessment, the Commissioner shall impute taxable income based on the amount of tax deducted or collected, treating the imputed income as concealed income for the purposes of Section 111.
This provisional assessment becomes a final assessment order after forty-five days from its service unless the person files their return and wealth statement within that period.
If the provisional assessment becomes final, the Commissioner may initiate proceedings for the imposition of penalties under section 182 on account of non-furnishing and concealment of income.
Prosecution:
Any person who, without reasonable excuse, fails to comply with a notice to furnish a return under section 114(3) or (4) commits an offence. This offence is punishable on conviction with a fine or imprisonment for up to one year, or both.
If convicted for this offence and the person still fails to furnish the return within the court-specified period, they commit a further offence punishable with a fine (up to fifty thousand rupees) or imprisonment for up to two years, or both.
Other Measures for Non-ATL Persons:
The Board has powers to issue general orders regarding persons not on the active taxpayers’ list but liable to file. Such orders may entail consequences such as:
Disabling of mobile phones or mobile phone SIMs.
Discontinuance of electricity connection.
Discontinuance of gas connection.
Restriction on foreign travel for citizens of Pakistan (with some exceptions).
In summary, failing to file your income tax return on time can lead to significant monetary penalties, exclusion from the active taxpayers’ list (which prevents loss carry-forward and refunds unless a surcharge is paid), potential best-judgment assessment or provisional assessment with imputed income, and even prosecution.
What is WHT With Holding Tax and is it adjustable in filing of return?
Based on the sources, “Withholding Tax” (WHT) is a common term for amounts of tax that are collected or deducted at source by one person from a payment made to another person. This mechanism involves the payer or a designated collection agent deducting the tax at the time of payment or collection and forwarding it to the tax authorities.
The sources refer to this process using terms such as:
“advance tax and deduction of tax at source”
“advance tax paid to a collection agent” (under Division II of Part V of Chapter X)
“deduction of tax at source” (under Division III of Part V of Chapter X)
Specific “advance tax” provisions under Chapter XII.
Common examples of payments or transactions subject to this collection/deduction mentioned in the sources include:
Imports of goods
Dividends paid
Profit on debt
Payments for goods, services, or contracts
Cash withdrawals from banks
Electricity connections (over a certain threshold)
Sale or transfer of immovable property
Purchase of immovable property
Banking transactions other than through cash for persons not on the active taxpayers’ list
Bonus shares issued by companies
Is Withholding Tax Adjustable in Filing of Return?
Generally, yes, tax collected or deducted at source is adjustable in the filing of the income tax return.
Here’s how the sources describe this:
General Rule of Adjustment: Any amount of tax collected under Division II of Part V (like imports) or deducted under Division III of Part V (like dividends, profit on debt, payments for goods/services) or Chapter XII is treated as tax paid by the person from whom it was collected or deducted. This person is then allowed a tax credit for that amount when computing the tax due on their taxable income for the tax year in which the tax was collected or deducted. Advance tax paid under Section 147 and advance tax paid by provincial sales tax registered persons under Section 147A are also taken into account while working out advance tax payable under Section 147.
When WHT is a “Final Tax”: However, there are specific instances where tax collected or deducted is considered a “final tax” on the income from which it was collected or deducted. When an amount is subject to final tax:
That income amount is not chargeable to tax under any other head of income in computing the person’s taxable income.
No deductions are allowed for expenditures incurred in deriving that income.
The amount is not reduced by any deductible allowance or set-off of any loss.
Tax credits allowed under the Ordinance generally do not reduce the final tax payable.
This means that tax treated as a final tax is not adjustable against the overall tax liability calculated on other sources of taxable income.
Sections specifically mentioned where the tax can be final include Section 148(7), Section 152(1E), Section 154A(2), Section 156(3), Section 156A(2), and Section 236Z(7). Tax under Section 7E (tax on deemed income) is also final. Tax collected on certain imported goods under Section 148(7A) is minimum tax on that income, which functions like final tax. Tax on gains from constructed property with a holding period exceeding four years is zero, and specific rules apply for shorter periods.
Exception for Non-Filer Higher Rates: Even when the tax is a final tax, if separate rates are prescribed for filers and non-filers and a higher rate is collected/deducted from a non-filer, the excess tax collected or deducted on account of the higher non-filer rate shall be adjustable in the return filed for the relevant tax year.
Specific Cases of Adjustable Tax: Several specific provisions in Chapter XII explicitly state the tax collected is adjustable, such as:
Advance adjustable tax on cash withdrawals under Section 231AB.
Adjustable tax collected on monthly electricity bills exceeding a certain amount.
Advance tax collected on the sale or transfer of immovable property under Section 236C (except tax liability under Section 7E which must be discharged).
Advance tax collected on the purchase of immovable property under Section 236K (with an exception for certain non-resident buyers where it is final).
Advance adjustable tax on banking transactions (non-cash) for non-ATL persons under Section 236P.
Specific Case Where WHT is Not Adjustable: Traders qualifying under certain rules in the Ninth Schedule (Special Procedure for Small Traders and Shopkeepers) are not entitled to claim any adjustment of withholding tax collected or deducted under the Ordinance against the tax payable on their trading activity profits and gains. They are also not entitled to adjust any refund due.
Provisional Assessment for Non-Filers (Tenth Schedule): For persons whose tax is collected or deducted at a potentially higher rate for not being on the active taxpayers’ list (as per the Tenth Schedule Rule 1), if they fail to file a return, the Commissioner can make a provisional assessment. However, if the person files their return within a specified period (45 days from provisional assessment service), the tax deducted or collected shall be adjustable against the tax payable in the return filed. If they don’t file and the provisional assessment becomes final, the tax collected/deducted based on imputed income may be treated as final tax, and penalties may be imposed.
In summary, WHT is tax collected/deducted at source. It is generally adjustable against your final tax liability by claiming a tax credit, unless the specific provision under which it is collected or deducted designates it as a final tax on that income source. Even in final tax cases, the excess tax paid due to higher rates for non-filers is typically adjustable.
Pakistan Property Tax Guide 2024
The sources provide detailed information on various aspects of property tax in Pakistan, primarily under the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, which was amended up to June 30, 2024.
Here are the key details regarding property tax:
1. Classification of Income from Property
“Income from Property” is one of the five heads under which income is classified for the imposition of tax and the computation of total income. The other heads are Salary, Income from Business, Capital Gains, and Income from Other Sources.
The income of a person under this head for a tax year is the total amounts derived that are chargeable to tax, reduced by any allowed deductions.
If total deductions exceed chargeable amounts, the person is treated as sustaining a loss under that head.
For resident persons, both Pakistan-source and foreign-source income are considered. For non-resident persons, only Pakistan-source income is considered.
2. Computation of Income from Property (Section 15 & 15A)
Specific deductions are allowed when computing income chargeable under the head “Income from Property” [2, 15A]. These include:
The amount of profit or interest paid on a mortgage or other capital charge if the property is subject to it.
Any expenditure, not exceeding 4% of the rent chargeable to tax, paid or payable for the purpose of deriving rent, including administration and collection charges.
3. Non-Adjustable Amounts Received (Section 16)
If an owner receives an amount from a tenant that is not adjustable against rent, this amount is treated as rent chargeable to tax.
It is allocated equally over the tax year in which it was received and the subsequent nine tax years.
If the tenancy terminates before ten years and the amount is refunded, no portion is allocated to the refund year or subsequent years.
However, if the property is re-let to a “succeeding tenant” who also pays a non-adjustable amount, that “succeeding amount” (reduced by any portion of the “earlier amount” already charged to tax) will be treated as rent as specified above.
4. Tax Rates on Income from Property (Division VIA, First Schedule)
For individuals and associations of persons, the tax rates on gross rent are as follows:
Where gross rent does not exceed Rs. 200,000: Nil.
Where gross rent exceeds Rs. 200,000 but does not exceed Rs. 600,000: 5% of the gross amount exceeding Rs. 200,000.
Where gross rent exceeds Rs. 600,000 but does not exceed Rs. 1,000,000: Rs. 20,000 plus 10% of the gross amount exceeding Rs. 600,000.
5. Withholding Tax on Rent of Immovable Property (Section 155)
Every prescribed person making a payment (in full or part, including advance) for rent of immovable property (which also includes rent for furniture, fixtures, and services related to the property) must deduct tax from the gross amount of rent paid.
The “gross amount of rent” includes any non-adjustable amounts referred to in Section 16(1) or (3).
This withholding tax applies regardless of the head of income under which the rent might be classified.
6. Capital Gains on Immovable Property (Section 37)
Any gain arising from the disposal of immovable property situated in Pakistan is chargeable to tax under the head “Capital Gains”.
The rates are specified in Division VIII of Part I of the First Schedule.
Rates for properties acquired on or before June 30, 2024:
Holding period ≤ 1 year:
Open Plots: 15%
Constructed Property: 15%
Flats: 15%
Holding period > 1 year but ≤ 2 years:
Open Plots: 12.5%
Constructed Property: 10%
Flats: 7.5%
Holding period > 2 years but ≤ 3 years:
Open Plots: 10%
Constructed Property: 7.5%
Flats: 0%
Holding period > 3 years but ≤ 4 years:
Open Plots: 7.5%
Constructed Property: 5%
Flats: 0%
Holding period > 4 years: 0% for all
Rates for properties acquired on or after July 1, 2024:
Holding period ≤ 1 year: 15% for persons appearing on the Active Taxpayers’ List on the date of disposal. For individuals and associations of persons, the rates specified in Division I apply, and for companies, Division II applies.
7. Tax on Deemed Income (Section 7E)
For tax year 2022 and onwards, a tax is imposed on “deemed income” at rates specified in Division VIIIC of Part-I of the First Schedule. The sources indicate this often relates to immovable property, as property transfer registration requires discharge of this tax.
8. Tax on Builders and Developers (Section 7F)
A tax is imposed on the profits and gains of persons deriving income from the business of construction and sale of residential/commercial/other buildings, or development and sale of residential/commercial/other plots, or both activities.
This tax is charged at the rates specified in Division I or II of Part-I of the First Schedule on the taxable profit.
9. Advance Tax on Sale or Transfer of Immovable Property (Section 236C)
Any person responsible for registering, recording, or attesting the transfer of immovable property must collect advance tax from the seller or transferor. This includes local authorities, housing societies, etc..
The tax collected is generally adjustable.
Exception: If the immovable property is acquired and disposed of within the same tax year, the tax collected under this section becomes minimum tax.
Exemptions: This section does not apply to a seller who is a dependent of a Shaheed, war-wounded person, disabled person, or a deceased employee of the armed forces, federal, or provincial government, or to transfers to legal heirs of such persons.
Final Tax Discharge: If the seller/transferor is a non-resident individual holding a Pakistan Origin Card (POC), National ID Card for Overseas Pakistanis (NICOP), or Computerized National ID Card (CNIC) who acquired the property through a Foreign Currency Value Account (FCVA) or NRP Rupee Value Account (NRVA), the tax collected under this section is a final discharge of tax liability for capital gains.
Requirement for Section 7E compliance: Registration/recording/attestation of property transfer will not occur unless the seller/transferor has discharged their tax liability under Section 7E and provided evidence.
Rates for Non-Active Taxpayers (Rule 1 of Tenth Schedule): For sellers/transferors not appearing on the active taxpayers’ list, the tax rate for Section 236C is increased:
Gross amount of consideration received does not exceed Rs. 50 million: 6%.
Gross amount of consideration received exceeds Rs. 50 million but does not exceed Rs. 100 million: 7%.
Gross amount of consideration received exceeds Rs. 100 million: 8%.
10. Advance Tax on Purchase or Transfer of Immovable Property (Section 236K)
Any person responsible for registering, recording, or attesting the transfer of immovable property must collect advance tax from the purchaser or transferee.
This advance tax is adjustable.
Final Tax Discharge: If the buyer/transferee is a non-resident individual holding a POC, NICOP, or CNIC who acquired the property through an FCVA or NRVA, the tax collected under this section is a final discharge of tax liability for such buyer/transferee.
Installment Payments: If payments for purchase or allotment of immovable property are collected in installments, advance tax must be collected from the allottee/transferee with each installment. If the accumulated tax collected through installments equals the total tax payable, no further tax is collected at the time of property transfer.
Rates (Division XVIII, Part IV of First Schedule – as per Finance Act 2024):
Where value of immovable property is up to Rs. 4 million: 0%.
Where the value of immovable property is more than Rs. 4 million:
Filer: 2%.
Non-Filer: 4% (previously 1% until a date notified by the Board).
Rates for Non-Active Taxpayers (Rule 1 of Tenth Schedule): For purchasers/transferees not appearing on the active taxpayers’ list, the tax rate for Section 236K is increased:
Fair Market Value of Immovable Property does not exceed Rs. 50 million: 12%.
Fair Market Value of Immovable Property exceeds Rs. 50 million but does not exceed Rs. 100 million: 14%.
Fair Market Value of Immovable Property exceeds Rs. 100 million: 16%.
11. Wealth Statement and Registration Requirements
The Commissioner may require any individual to furnish a wealth statement detailing their total assets and liabilities (including foreign assets and liabilities) as well as those of their spouse, minor children, and other dependents. This statement must also include assets transferred and consideration for transfer, and details of expenditures. A reconciliation statement of wealth is also required.
Every resident individual taxpayer filing a return of income must furnish a wealth statement and wealth reconciliation statement.
Even if a person is not obliged to furnish a return (because all income is subject to final taxation, e.g., under sections 5, 6, 7, 148, 151, 152, 153(3), 154, 156, 156A, 233(3), 234A), they must still furnish a statement to the Commissioner showing particulars of their income.
Persons with a taxable income of Rs. 500,000 or more, or those under the final tax regime who paid Rs. 20,000 or more tax, must file a wealth statement along with its reconciliation.
Any person (other than a company) who owns immovable property with a land area of 500 square yards or more or owns any flat located in municipal limits, cantonment, Islamabad Capital Territory, or a rating area, is required to furnish a return of income.
12. Directorate-General of Immovable Property (Section 230F)
This directorate is established to perform functions assigned by the Board, including the determination of fair market value of immovable property and identifying instances where the consideration for property transfer has been understated to avoid or reduce withholding tax, conceal unexplained amounts (under Section 111), or avoid/reduce capital gains tax.
The Directorate-General can appoint valuers or experts for property valuation.
13. Exemptions Related to Immovable Property
Profits and gains accruing to a person on the sale of immovable property or shares of a Special Purpose Vehicle to any type of REIT scheme were exempt from tax up to June 30, 2023.
14. Joint Ownership of Property (Section 66)
If immovable property is owned by two or more persons and their respective shares are definite and ascertainable, they are not assessed as an association of persons in respect of that property. Instead, each person’s share in the income from the property is taken into account in computing their individual taxable income.
Pakistan Import Tax Explained
Property tax in the context of imports primarily refers to the advance tax collected by the Collector of Customs on imported goods under Section 148 of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001. This is a crucial aspect of the tax regime for businesses and individuals engaged in import activities.
Here are the detailed provisions regarding taxation on imports:
1. Nature and Collection of Tax on Imports
Advance Tax Collection: The Collector of Customs is responsible for collecting advance tax from every importer of goods. This tax is collected at the time customs duty would be payable, or if the goods are exempt from customs duty, at the time customs duty would have been payable had the goods been dutiable.
Applicability: This advance tax applies to goods classified in Parts I to III of the Twelfth Schedule. The Board has the authority to add, omit, or amend entries in the Twelfth Schedule and to specify conditions for treating goods as raw material under Part II even if classified under Part III.
Legal Framework: The provisions of the Customs Act, 1969, apply to the collection of tax under this section, where relevant. The Board can also determine the minimum value of goods for the purpose of collection.
Treatment of Income: Any amount subject to collection of tax under Division II of Part V of Chapter X (which includes Section 148) is considered “income” for tax purposes. Generally, where income tax is to be collected in advance, it shall be so collected.
2. Status of Tax Collected (Adjustable vs. Minimum Tax)
The tax collected under Section 148 is generally minimum tax on the income of the importer arising from the imports. This means that the collected tax is considered the final tax liability for the income generated from those specific imports.
However, there are important exceptions:
Adjustable Tax for Industrial Undertakings: The tax collected under Section 148 is not minimum tax (implying it is adjustable) when the import is of goods by an industrial undertaking for its own use.
Minimum Tax for Specific Goods: Regardless of the general rule, the tax collected under Section 148 shall be minimum tax on the income of every person arising from imports of:
Edible oil.
Packaging material.
Paper and paper board.
Plastics.
3. Calculation of “Value of Goods” for Tax
The “value of goods” for the purpose of collecting advance tax under Section 148 is determined as follows:
Goods Chargeable at Retail Price: For goods chargeable to tax at retail price under the Third Schedule of the Sales Tax Act, 1990, the value is the retail price of such goods increased by sales tax payable in respect of the import and taxable supply of the goods.
Other Goods: For goods other than those specified above or those with a minimum value notified by the Board, the value is determined under the Customs Act, 1969, as if the goods were subject to ad valorem duty, increased by the customs-duty, federal excise duty, and sales tax, if any, payable on the import of the goods.
Minimum Value as Notified by Board: The Board may also notify a “minimum value” which, if applicable, is used to calculate the tax, increased by the customs-duty, federal excise duty, and sales tax payable.
4. Tax Rates on Imports
The rates of advance tax to be collected by the Collector of Customs under Section 148 are specified in Part II of the First Schedule. These rates vary depending on the type of goods and the importer.
Some examples of rates include:
1% of import value (increased by customs-duty, sales tax, federal excise duty) for:
Industrial undertakings importing remeltable steel (PCT Heading 72.04) and directly reduced iron for their own use.
Persons importing potassic fertilizers or urea.
Manufacturers importing items covered under S.R.O. 1125(I)/2011.
Persons importing Gold, Cotton, or LNG.
Goods classified in Part I of the Twelfth Schedule.
2% of import value (increased by customs-duty, sales tax, federal excise duty) for:
Goods classified in Part II of the Twelfth Schedule.
Persons importing pulses.
3% of import value for commercial importers covered under S.R.O. 1125(I)/2011.
4% of import value for persons importing coal.
4.5% of import value for ship breakers on import of ships.
5.5% of import value for industrial undertakings not covered under S.Nos. 1 to 4 and companies not covered under S.Nos. 1 to 5.
6% of import value for persons not covered under S.Nos. 1 to 6.
Special Rates for Plastic Raw Material:
Industrial undertakings importing plastic raw material (PCT Heading 39.01 to 39.12) for their own use: 1.75%.
Commercial importers importing plastic raw material (PCT Heading 39.01 to 39.12): 4.5%.
Specific Rates for Mobile Phones: A table specifies tax rates based on the C&F value of the mobile phone in US Dollars (e.g., Rs. 70 for up to $30, Rs. 100 for exceeding $30 and up to $100).
5. Exemptions and Tax Concessions
The Second Schedule of the Income Tax Ordinance specifies various exemptions and tax concessions that may apply to imports.
Exemptions from collection under Section 148 include:
Goods specified under Heading 9929, Sub-Chapter VIII of Chapter 99 of the First Schedule to the Customs Act, 1969 [126(v)].
Liquefied Petroleum Gas (LPG) [126(vi)].
Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) [126(vii)].
Note: While LNG is listed as exempt from collection here, it is also listed with a 1% rate in another part of the source [99, 126(vii)]. You may want to verify the current applicability of this specific exemption.
Agricultural tractors imported in CBU condition [126(viii)].
An indirect exporter as defined in the Duty and Tax Remission for Export Rules, 2001 [126(ix)].
Radio Navigational Aid Apparatus imported for an airport on or after January 1, 2006 [126(x)].
Import of specific food items including onions, potatoes, tomatoes, garlic, halal meat (goat, sheep, beef), and live animals (bovine, buffalos, cows, sheep, goats, camels) [127(xii)].
Goods donated for the relief of earthquake victims or flood victims of 2007, provided they are exempt from customs duties and sales tax [127(xiv), 130(xxvi)].
Tents, tarpaulin, and blankets [127(xv)].
Import of ships and floating crafts including tugs, dredgers, and survey vessels [127(xvii)].
One-time import of 32 buses by Daewoo Express Bus Service Ltd [128(xix)].
Goods temporarily imported into Pakistan for subsequent exportation that are exempt from customs duty and sales tax [128(xx)].
Capital goods imported by a manufacturer whose sales are 100% exports, provided they have a certificate from the Commissioner of Income Tax stating the goods will be installed in their own industrial undertaking and exclusively used for export production [128(xxi)].
Capital goods and raw material imported by a manufacturer exporter registered with the Sales Tax Department [129(xxii)].
Petroleum (E&P) companies covered under SRO. 678(I)/2004, with the exception of motor vehicles imported by such companies [129(xxiii), 132(xii)].
Companies importing high speed diesel oil, light diesel oil, high octane blending component or motor spirit, furnace oil, JP-1, MTBE, kerosene oil, crude oil for refining, and chemicals for refining, in respect of such goods [129(xxiv), 132(xi)].
Re-importation of re-usable containers for re-export that qualify for customs-duty and sales tax exemption on temporary import [130(xxv)].
Plant, machinery, equipment, and specific items used in the production of bio-diesel that are exempt from customs-duty and sales tax [130(xxvii)].
The Federal Government, a Provincial Government, or a Local Government [131(vi), (vii), (viii)].
Mineral oil imported by a manufacturer or formulator of pesticides, if exempt from customs-duties [131(v)].
Goods produced or manufactured and exported from Pakistan that are subsequently imported within one year of their exportation, provided conditions of Section 22 of the Customs Act, 1969, are complied with [132(xiii)].
Tax concessions (reduced rates) for imports include:
White Sugar: For specific periods, tax under Section 148 was collected at 0.25% for import of white sugar, commercial import of white sugar, and import of raw sugar by sugar mills (subject to quota).
Border Sustenance Markets: For goods supplied within the limits of Border Sustenance Markets established with Iran and Afghanistan, there is an exemption. However, if these goods are brought outside the market limits, income tax is charged on the import value as per Section 148 provisions. Customs authorities may require a bank guarantee equal to the income tax involved, which is released upon presentation of a consumption certificate [125(iii)].
6. Relation to Other Tax Provisions
Exemption from Withholding Tax on Resale: If an importer has paid tax under Section 148 in respect of goods and subsequently sells those goods in the same condition as they were when imported, that sale is exempt from tax deduction under Section 153(1) (payments for goods or services). This prevents double taxation on the same transaction.
Motor Vehicle Sales: While not a direct import tax, Section 231B mandates advance tax collection at the time of sale of motor vehicles by the manufacturer. If the vehicle is imported, and tax under Section 148 was already collected from the same person for that vehicle, Section 231B does not apply [78(4)]. The value for these vehicles can be the import value assessed by Customs authorities plus duties and taxes.
Certificate of Collection: Every person collecting tax under Division II of Part V (which includes Section 148) must furnish a certificate of collection or deduction of tax to the person from whom the tax has been collected.
Taxation of Exports: Advance, Minimum, and Final Regimes
Taxation on exports involves the collection or deduction of advance tax at various stages of the export process, primarily from foreign exchange proceeds or the value of exported goods. The nature of this tax (whether adjustable, minimum, or final) and the applicable rates can vary depending on the type of export and the exporter.
Here are the details regarding taxation on exports, based on the provided sources:
1. Advance Tax on Export Proceeds (Section 154)
Collection by Authorized Dealers: Every authorized dealer in foreign exchange is required to deduct tax from the foreign exchange proceeds on account of the export of goods by an exporter, at the time of realization of these proceeds [68(1)]. This deduction also includes advance tax [68(1)].
Collection by Banking Companies: Every banking company must deduct tax from the proceeds on account of a sale of goods to an exporter under an inland back-to-back letter of credit or any other arrangement prescribed by the Board, at the time of realization of these proceeds [70(3)].
Collection by Export Processing Zone Authority: The Export Processing Zone Authority collects tax at the time of export of goods by an industrial undertaking located in a Zone [70(3A)].
Deduction by Direct Exporters/Export Houses: Direct exporters and export houses registered under the Duty and Tax Remission for Exports Rules, 2001, and Export Facilitation Scheme, 2021, must deduct tax when making a payment for a firm contract to an indirect exporter as defined under those rules [71(3B)].
Collection by Collector of Customs: The Collector of Customs collects tax from the gross value of goods exported at the time of clearing the goods [71(3C)].
Tax Rates: The tax rates for these collections/deductions are specified in Division IV of Part III of the First Schedule [68(1), 70(3), 70(3A), 71(3B), 71(3C)]. Specifically, the rate of tax to be deducted under sub-sections (1), (3), (3A), or (3B) of section 154 is 1% of the proceeds of the export.
Nature of Tax: The tax deductible under Section 154 (excluding sub-section (1), which is adjustable) on the income of a resident person is minimum tax [67(3), 72]. However, the tax deductible under sub-section (1) of section 154 is adjustable [69(2)].
2. Advance Tax on Export of Services (Section 154A)
Collection by Authorized Dealers: Every authorized dealer in foreign exchange must deduct tax from the realization of foreign exchange proceeds on account of various services, including:
Computer software, IT services, or IT Enabled services [72(1)].
Construction contracts executed outside Pakistan [73(1)(d)].
Foreign commission due to an indenting commission agent [73(1)(da)].
Other services rendered outside Pakistan as notified by the Board [73(1)(e)].
Tax Rates: The rates for these deductions are specified in Division IVA of Part III of the First Schedule [72(1)].
For export proceeds of Computer software or IT services or IT Enabled services, the rate is 0.25% of proceeds for tax years 2023.
Nature of Tax (Final Tax Regime): The tax deductible under Section 154A is generally a final tax on the income arising from these transactions, provided certain conditions are met [73(2)]. These conditions include:
Return has been filed [73(2)(a)].
Withholding tax statements for the relevant tax year have been filed [73(2)(b)].
No credit for foreign taxes paid shall be allowed [74(2)(d)].
Option to Opt Out: The final tax provisions of sub-section (2) of Section 154A will not apply to a person who does not fulfill the specified conditions or who opts not to be subject to final taxation [74(3)].
3. Exemptions and Concessions Related to Exports
Indirect Exporter (Section 148 exemption): The provisions of Section 148 (advance tax on imports) shall not apply to an indirect exporter as defined in the Duty and Tax Remission for Export Rules, 2001 [125(ix)].
Capital Goods and Raw Material for Export Production: Section 148 (advance tax on imports) shall not apply to the import of capital goods by a manufacturer whose sales are 100% exports, provided they have a certificate from the Commissioner stating the goods will be installed in their own industrial undertaking and exclusively used for production of goods to be exported [127(xxi)].
Capital Goods and Raw Material by Manufacturer Exporter: Section 148 also does not apply to capital goods and raw material imported by a manufacturer exporter registered with the Sales Tax Department [127(xxii)]. This is consistent with a previous clause that also exempted capital goods and raw material imported exclusively for own use by a manufacturer registered with Sales Tax Department from Section 148.
Exemption from Section 153(1) for Imported Goods Sold: A sale of goods is exempt from tax deduction under Section 153(1) (payments for goods or services) if:
The sale is made by the importer of the goods [66(a)(i)].
The importer has paid tax under Section 148 in respect of the goods [66(a)(ii)].
The goods are sold in the same condition they were in when imported [66(a)(iii)].
Reduced Rates for Specific Export Services: For certain periods, income from services rendered outside Pakistan and construction contracts executed outside Pakistan were charged at 50% of the rates specified in Division III of Part III of the First Schedule, provided receipts from services and income from contracts were brought into Pakistan in foreign exchange through normal banking channels.
Exclusion from Minimum Tax on Turnover for SMEs: The provisions of Section 113 (minimum tax on turnover) do not apply to SMEs [135(7)]. Their export proceeds are subject to tax as per the rates prescribed for the final tax regime [135(6)].
Adjustable Tax on Supply of Goods by SMEs: The tax deductible under clause (a) of sub-section (1) of section 153 shall not be minimum tax where payments are received on sale or supply of goods by SMEs [135(8)].
General Exemption for Foreign-Source Salary of Residents: Any foreign-source salary received by a resident individual is exempt from tax if the individual has paid foreign income tax in respect of the salary [39(1)]. This includes situations where tax has been withheld by the employer and paid to the foreign revenue authority [39(2)].
4. Other Relevant Provisions
Income from Business of Shipping (Resident Person): A resident person engaged in the business of shipping is charged a presumptive income tax based on tonnage [13(3), 14, 15, 16]. This can be a final tax [124(xi)].
Ships and floating crafts purchased or bare-boat chartered and flying the Pakistan flag pay one US $ per gross registered tonnage per annum [14(a)].
Ships, vessels, and floating crafts not registered in Pakistan and hired under any charter other than bare-boat charter pay fifteen US cents per ton of gross registered tonnage per chartered voyage, not exceeding one US $ per ton of gross registered tonnage per annum [14(b), 15].
A Pakistan resident ship-owning company registered with SECP after November 15, 2019, having its own sea-worthy vessel registered under Pakistan Flag, pays seventy-five US Cents per ton of gross registered tonnage per annum [16(c)].
Foreign Tax Credit (for Residents): Where a resident taxpayer derives foreign source income chargeable to tax in Pakistan and has paid foreign income tax on it, a tax credit is allowed. The credit amount is the lesser of the foreign income tax paid or the Pakistan tax payable on that income [39(1)].
It is important to note that tax collected or deducted under Section 154 and Section 154A is generally considered a final tax on the income arising from export transactions, provided certain conditions are met, such as filing returns and withholding tax statements, and not claiming foreign tax credits [73(2), 74(2)(d), 79(1)]. Where income tax is to be collected or paid in advance, it shall be so collected or paid [8(6)].
Understanding Income Tax Surcharges and Penalties
Based on the provided sources, there are two primary types of surcharges mentioned: a surcharge on high-earning persons and a default surcharge.
Here are the details for each:
1. Surcharge on High-Earning Persons
This type of surcharge is a direct tax on income above a certain threshold.
Imposition: A surcharge is imposed on every individual and association of persons.
Applicability: It applies where the taxable income exceeds rupees ten million.
Rate: The rate is ten percent of the income tax imposed under Division I of Part I of the First Schedule.
Historical Note (Omitted Section 4A): Previously, a surcharge was payable by every taxpayer at the rate of fifteen percent of the income tax payable for a specific period ending on June 30, 2011. This surcharge was to be paid, collected, deducted, and deposited in the same manner as other taxes. However, this provision (Section 4A) was omitted by the Finance Act, 2014.
2. Default Surcharge (Section 205)
The default surcharge is a penalty-like charge imposed for the late payment of taxes or other amounts, or for the failure to collect or deduct taxes. This is detailed under “PART XII DEFAULT SURCHARGE” in the sources.
General Application (Section 205(1)):
Liability: A person is liable for default surcharge if they fail to pay any tax (excluding advance tax under section 147 and default surcharge itself), any penalty, or any amount referred to in section 140 or 141, on or before the due date for payment.
Rate: The rate is twelve percent or KIBOR plus three percent per annum, whichever is higher, on the unpaid amount.
Computation Period: This surcharge is computed for the period commencing on the date the amount was due and ending on the date it was paid.
Waiver for Appeals: If a person opts to pay the tax due based on an order under section 129 on or before the due date in a notice under section 137(2) issued as a consequence of that order, and does not file an appeal under section 131, they shall not be liable to pay default surcharge for the period beginning from the due date of payment in consequence of the appealed order to the date of payment in consequence of the subsequent notice.
On Advance Tax (Section 205(1A) & (1B)):
Failure to Pay Advance Tax: A person who fails to pay advance tax under section 147 is liable for default surcharge at the rate of twelve percent or KIBOR plus three percent per annum, whichever is higher. The surcharge is computed on the unpaid tax from the due date to the payment date or the due date of the income return, whichever is earlier.
Insufficient Advance Tax Payment: If, for any tax year, a taxpayer fails to pay tax under section 147(4A) or (6), or if the tax paid is less than ninety percent of the tax chargeable for the relevant tax year, default surcharge applies. The rate is the same (twelve percent or KIBOR plus three percent per annum, whichever is higher) on the amount by which the tax paid falls short of ninety percent, or on the tax so chargeable.
Calculation Period for Insufficient Advance Tax: This surcharge is calculated from the first day of April in that tax year to the date the assessment is made or June 30 of the next financial year, whichever is earlier. For a special tax year, the default surcharge is calculated from the first day of the fourth quarter of that special tax year until the assessment date or the last day of the special tax year, whichever is earlier.
For Failure to Collect or Deduct Tax (Section 205(3)):
Liability: A person who fails to collect tax (as required under Division II of Part V of Chapter X or Chapter XII) or deduct tax (as required under Division III of Part V of Chapter X or Chapter XII), or fails to pay an amount of tax collected or deducted by the due date as required under section 160, is liable for default surcharge.
Rate: The rate is twelve percent or KIBOR plus three percent per annum, whichever is higher, on the unpaid amount.
Computation Period: This is computed for the period commencing on the date the amount was required to be collected or deducted and ending on the date it was paid to the Commissioner.
Assessment and Refund:
The Commissioner assesses any default surcharge imposed as if it were tax, and the provisions for tax assessment apply.
The Commissioner may, at discretion, assess default surcharge for the full period of default or part thereof, even if the tax due has not actually been paid.
Any default surcharge paid by a person shall be refunded to the extent that the tax, penalty, or other related amount is later held not to be payable.
If the amount of tax or penalty for which default surcharge is chargeable is reduced by an order, the default surcharge levied shall be reduced accordingly.
Effect of Extensions on Due Date:
An extension of time granted for payment of tax due or permission to pay in instalments shall not change the due date for the purpose of charging default surcharge under section 205(1). Liability for default surcharge still arises from the original due date of the tax.
Waiver and Exemption:
The Board may make schemes for the waiver of default surcharge in respect of the recovery of tax arrears or withholding taxes.
The Federal Government or the Board can, by notification in the official Gazette or by an order, exempt any person or class of persons from payment of the whole or part of the penalty and default surcharge payable, subject to specified conditions and limitations.
Company Taxation in Pakistan (2024)
The taxation of companies in Pakistan is governed by a comprehensive set of rules within the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, as amended up to June 30, 2024. These provisions cover general tax rates, specific industry rules, special charges, various tax credits and exemptions, and procedural aspects.
Here are the details regarding company taxation:
1. General Tax Rates for Companies
The standard rates of tax imposed on the taxable income of companies are as follows:
Small company:20%
Banking company:39%
Any other company:29%
It is important to note that these rates were substituted by the Finance Act, 2022. Previously, rates varied, for instance, a banking company was taxed at 50%, a public company (other than banking) at 35%, and a private company (other than banking) at 45%. Historically, for companies other than banking companies, the rate gradually reduced from 35% in tax year 2007 to 29% for tax year 2019 and onwards, with specific rates for interim years. Small companies were previously taxed at 25%.
2. Specific Provisions for Certain Companies and Industries
Banking Companies:
Their income, profits, and gains, and the tax payable thereon, are computed according to the rules in the Seventh Schedule, applicable from tax year 2009 onwards.
They are not subject to withholding tax provisions as a recipient of an amount on which tax is deductible.
Income computed under the Seventh Schedule is charged under the “Income from Business” head at the rates specified in Division II of Part I of the First Schedule.
Advance tax for banking companies is payable in twelve monthly installments by the 15th of every month.
Minimum tax provisions (Section 113) apply to banking companies just as they do to any other resident company.
From tax year 2015 onwards, dividend income and capital gains of banking companies are taxed at the rate specified in Division II of Part I of the First Schedule.
For tax years 2020 and 2021, an enhanced rate of 37.5% applies to taxable income from additional investment in Federal Government securities, instead of the standard Division II rate. This requires a certificate from an external auditor.
A reduced tax rate of 20% applies to taxable income from additional advances for low-cost housing for tax years 2020 to 2023, with a further reduction to 10% for advances to Naya Pakistan Housing and Development Authority schemes. An external auditor’s certificate is required.
Similarly, a reduced tax rate of 20% applies to taxable income from additional advances for Farm Credit in Pakistan for tax years 2020 to 2023. An external auditor’s certificate is also required, and the Commissioner may request further details.
Group relief (Section 59B) and group taxation (Section 59AA) are available to banking companies, provided the holding and subsidiary companies are banking companies, their accounts are audited by a State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) panel firm, and subject to SBP approval.
Adjustments related to ‘Shariah Compliant Banking’ approved by the SBP will not reduce or add to income and tax liability, and a statement certified by auditors comparing Islamic and normal accounting principles must be attached to the return. Adjustments from applicable accounting standards, policies, or SBP instructions are generally excluded from taxable income computation, and notional gains/losses are not recognized until fully realized.
Insurance Companies:
Profits and gains from insurance business are computed according to the rules in the Fourth Schedule.
They are explicitly excluded from the special provisions regarding capital gain tax on the disposal of listed securities (Section 37A and Section 100B).
Oil, Natural Gas, and Other Mineral Deposits:
Special provisions apply to their production, exploration, and extraction.
Profits and gains from the exploration and extraction of wasting mineral deposits (excluding petroleum or natural gas), as specified by the Board with the Minister-in-charge’s approval, are computed according to Part II of the Fifth Schedule.
Resident companies engaged in the exploration and extraction of specific mineral deposits, with undertakings set up between July 1, 1981, and June 30, 1998, benefit from a 50% reduction in tax rates for a five-year period immediately following their initial five years of commercial production.
Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs):
A special procedure is provided for SMEs.
Category-1 (annual business turnover up to Rs. 100 million): Taxed at 7.5% of taxable income. They may opt for a Final Tax Regime at 0.25% of gross turnover.
Category-2 (annual business turnover exceeding Rs. 100 million but not exceeding Rs. 250 million): Taxed at 15% of taxable income. They may opt for a Final Tax Regime at 0.5% of gross turnover.
The option for the Final Tax Regime is irrevocable for three tax years once exercised.
Public vs. Private Companies:
The Ordinance lays out principles for their taxation.
There are specific provisions for the disposal of business by individuals or associations of persons to wholly-owned companies, and the disposal of assets between wholly-owned companies.
In case a private company’s tax cannot be recovered, its directors (excluding employed directors) and shareholders (owning at least 10% of paid-up capital) are jointly and severally liable for the outstanding tax. These individuals can then seek recovery from the company or other liable parties. This liability is treated as tax due under an assessment order.
If a private company defers salary payments to an employee for an earlier tax year, the Commissioner may include that amount in the employee’s income for the earlier year if there are reasonable grounds to believe the deferral occurred.
Companies Not Appearing in Active Taxpayers’ List:
Special rules in the Tenth Schedule govern the collection/deduction of advance income tax and the computation of income and tax payable for such persons (including companies) or those who have not filed their returns by the due date. These rules override other conflicting provisions in the Ordinance.
However, these provisions do not apply to non-resident individuals holding Pakistan Origin Card (POC), National ID Card for Overseas Pakistanis (NICOP), or Computerized National ID Card (CNIC) who maintain a Foreign Currency Value Account (FCVA) or Non-resident Pakistani Rupee Value Account (NRVA) with authorized banks in Pakistan.
Companies in Shipping Business (Resident):
Are subject to a presumptive income tax. (Note: Historical provisions for tonnage tax based on gross registered tonnage have been omitted).
Companies for Power Generation:
Dividend income declared or distributed on shares of a company set up for power generation benefits from a reduced tax rate of 7.5%.
Companies for Film-making:
Historical tax reductions (50% for foreign film-makers, 70% for resident companies on film-making income) have been omitted by the Finance Act, 2021.
3. Special Taxes and Charges Applicable to Companies
Surcharge on High-Earning Persons:
Previously, a surcharge of 10% of the income tax was imposed on individuals and associations of persons with taxable income exceeding Rs. 10 million [previous version information].
However, Section 4A, which contained this provision, was OMITTED by the Finance Act, 2014. Therefore, this surcharge is no longer in effect.
Default Surcharge (Section 205):
Companies are liable for default surcharge if they fail to pay any tax (excluding advance tax and default surcharge), penalty, or other specified amounts by the due date [previous response].
The rate is 12% or KIBOR plus 3% per annum, whichever is higher, computed on the unpaid amount from the due date to the payment date [previous response].
It also applies to failure to pay advance tax or insufficient advance tax payment (less than 90% of the tax chargeable) [previous response].
Furthermore, it applies if a company fails to collect or deduct tax (e.g., withholding tax) or fails to deposit collected/deducted tax by the due date [previous response].
The Commissioner assesses it as if it were tax, and it is refunded if the related tax is later found not payable [previous response].
Crucially, an extension of time for payment does not alter the original due date for default surcharge calculation [previous response].
For minimum tax calculation purposes, “Corporate Tax” excludes default surcharge and penalties.
Tax on Undistributed Profits (Section 5A):
For tax years 2017 to 2019, a tax of 5% of accounting profit before tax was imposed on public companies (excluding scheduled banks or modarabas) that failed to distribute at least 20% of their after-tax profits as cash dividends within six months of the tax year end.
This provision does not apply if a company is restricted from distributing dividends due to an agreement with the Government of Pakistan.
Minimum Tax (Section 113):
Applies to resident companies, permanent establishments of non-resident companies, and certain individuals/AOPs with high turnover.
It comes into play when the calculated tax payable for the year is below a certain threshold (e.g., due to losses).
Specific minimum tax rates (as a percentage of turnover) apply to certain industries, including oil marketing companies, oil refineries, gas companies (with turnover over Rs. 1 billion), Pakistani airlines, poultry industry, fertilizer dealers/distributors, and online marketplaces.
Historically, the purchase price of electricity for corporatized entities of WAPDA (DISCOs) and NTDC was excluded from turnover liable to minimum tax up to tax year 2013, but this clause has been omitted.
Super Tax (Section 4C):
This tax is specifically mentioned in relation to capital gains on the disposal of listed securities. The National Clearing Company of Pakistan Limited (NCCPL) computes and collects this tax at rates specified in Division IIB of Part I of the First Schedule on capital gains.
Additional Tax (Section 99D):
The Ordinance provides for an “Additional tax on certain income, profits and gains”, implying it can apply to companies, though specific details of its application are not provided in the sources.
4. Tax Credits and Exemptions for Companies
Tax Credit for Investment (Section 65B):
A company investing in plant and machinery for extension, expansion, balancing, modernization, or replacement in its industrial undertaking in Pakistan is allowed a credit equal to 10% of the invested amount against its tax payable (including minimum and final taxes). For tax year 2019, this rate was 5%. This credit can be carried forward to subsequent tax years.
If the investment is solely in new plant and machinery (not for BMR), a credit of 20% of the invested amount is allowed against tax payable, in the year the machinery is installed.
Tax Credit for Specified Industrial Undertakings (Section 65G):
Eligible companies making specified capital investments receive a 25% investment tax credit against tax payable (including minimum and final taxes). Any unadjusted credit can be carried forward for up to two subsequent tax years.
Exemptions under International Agreements (Section 44):
Any Pakistan-source income that Pakistan is prevented from taxing under a tax treaty is exempt from tax under the Ordinance.
Foreign Tax Credit (Section 103):
A resident company can claim a tax credit for foreign income tax paid on foreign-source income taxable in Pakistan.
The credit is limited to the lesser of the foreign income tax paid or the Pakistan tax payable on that income.
It applies separately to each head of income.
Any unutilized credit cannot be refunded, carried back, or carried forward.
The foreign income tax must be paid within two years after the end of the tax year in which the foreign income was derived.
Inter-Corporate Dividend within Group Companies:
Income from inter-corporate dividends within group companies (entitled to group taxation under Section 59AA) is exempt, provided the group’s return has been filed for the tax year.
Dividend Income and Long-Term Capital Gains of Venture Capital Funds:
These are exempt from tax if derived from investments in zone enterprises (as defined in the Special Technology Zones Authority Act, 2021) for a period of ten years from the issuance of the license by the Authority to the zone enterprise.
Non-Residents with Special Convertible Rupee Accounts (SCRA):
Non-resident entities (excluding local branches/subsidiaries/offices of foreign banks/companies operating in Pakistan) are exempt from minimum tax (Section 113) and tax on profit on debt (Section 151) for receipts from Pak Rupee denominated Government and corporate securities and redeemable capital listed on a registered stock exchange, provided the investments were made exclusively from foreign exchange remitted via an SCRA.
Capital gains arising to a non-resident company (without a permanent establishment in Pakistan) from investments in debt instruments and Government securities (including treasury bills and Pakistan investment bonds) through an SCRA are also exempt from certain advance tax provisions (Section 147(5B)).
Tax deducted on profit on debt from specified debt instruments and government securities through an SCRA is considered final tax for non-resident persons without a permanent establishment in Pakistan.
Sukuk-Related Exemptions:
Specific Sukuk, like those issued by “The Second Pakistan International Sukuk Company Limited” and “Third Pakistan International Sukuk Company Limited,” are exempt from certain provisions related to currency conversion gains/losses (clause (d) of section 46). Other entities like “WAPDA First Sukuk Company Limited” and “Pakistan International Sukuk Company Limited” are also mentioned, implying potential exemptions.
LNG Terminal Operators and Owners:
These entities are listed, potentially indicating specific exemptions or special tax treatments.
Income from Services and Construction Contracts Outside Pakistan:
Income derived from services rendered outside Pakistan and construction contracts executed outside Pakistan is subject to 50% of the normal rates, provided the receipts are brought into Pakistan in foreign exchange through normal banking channels.
Furthermore, income from technical services rendered outside Pakistan to a foreign enterprise is exempt if received in Pakistan in foreign exchange.
5. Provisions Related to Company Structure and Transactions
Amalgamation/Merger:
“Amalgamation” is defined to include mergers of banking companies, financial institutions, insurance companies, industrial undertakings, or service providers (non-trading), where at least one is a public company.
Expenditure incurred by an amalgamated company on legal, financial advisory, and administrative costs related to the amalgamation process is deductible.
If conditions of the amalgamation scheme (set by SBP/SECP/court) are not met, previously allowed loss set-offs or depreciation allowances become deemed income for the year the default is discovered.
Generally, no gain or loss arises on the issue, cancellation, exchange, or receipt of shares due to a Scheme of Arrangement and Reconstruction under the Companies Act, 2017.
Group Taxation (Section 59AA):
100% owned holding and subsidiary companies can irrevocably opt to be taxed as one fiscal unit.
This is limited to companies locally incorporated under the Companies Act, 2017.
Losses incurred prior to group formation are not eligible for this relief.
The option is contingent on compliance with corporate governance and group designation rules specified by the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP).
The Board may establish rules for group taxation.
As noted above, inter-corporate dividends within such groups are exempt.
Group Relief (Section 59B):
A subsidiary or holding company can surrender its assessed loss (excluding capital or brought-forward losses) to its holding company, subsidiary, or another subsidiary of the holding company.
If surrendered losses are not adjusted, the surrendering subsidiary can carry them forward.
Specific rules apply if the holding company’s ownership falls below certain thresholds within five years, requiring the company to offer previously untaxed profits.
Cash transfers between companies for loss adjustments are not taxable events.
Share transfers for group formation (with SECP/SBP approval) are also not taxable events, but third-party sales are.
Controlled Foreign Company (CFC) Provisions (Section 109A):
A non-resident company is considered a CFC if a resident person controls it, the tax paid by the CFC outside Pakistan is less than 60% of the tax payable in Pakistan, it does not derive active business income, and its shares are not traded on a recognized stock exchange.
The income of a CFC is treated as taxable income of a resident taxpayer and is taxed at the rate specified in Division III of Part I of the First Schedule.
The attributable income is calculated by a specific formula.
Income below Rs. 10 million is considered small.
CFC income is determined in its local currency and converted to Rupees at the State Bank of Pakistan rate on the last day of the tax year.
Importantly, income taxed in Pakistan under CFC rules is not taxed again when received by the resident taxpayer in Pakistan.
6. Taxable Income Computation for Companies
Heads of Income:
Companies derive income under various heads, including “Income from Business,” “Income from Property,” “Capital Gains,” and “Income from Other Sources”.
For resident companies, both Pakistan-source and foreign-source income are considered; for non-resident companies, only Pakistan-source income is relevant.
Deductions:
Generally, no deduction is allowed for any cess, rate, or tax paid or payable in Pakistan.
Expenditure by a company exceeding Rs. 250,000 for a single account head, if not paid digitally from a notified business bank account, is not allowed as a deduction, with an exception for payments of taxes, duties, fees, fines, or other statutory obligations.
Banking companies, Development Finance Institutions (DFIs), Non-Banking Finance Companies (NBFCs), or Modarabas are allowed a deduction for profit accruing on non-performing debts credited to a suspense account in accordance with Prudential Regulations.
Capital Gains:
Gains from the disposal of capital assets are chargeable to tax.
Specifically, gains from the disposal of immovable property in Pakistan are chargeable at rates in Division VIII of Part I of the First Schedule.
Capital gains from the disposal of securities (after July 1, 2010) are chargeable at rates in Division VII of Part I of the First Schedule. This does not apply to banking and insurance companies.
Gains on the disposal of assets located in Pakistan by a non-resident company (even if alienation occurs outside Pakistan) are considered Pakistan-source income and are taxable. The person acquiring such an asset from a non-resident must deduct tax at 10% of the fair market value. If the non-resident company holds assets indirectly through a resident company, the resident company is responsible for collecting advance tax from the non-resident company.
Profit on Debt:
If a company’s business is to derive profit on debt, it is chargeable under “Income from Business,” not “Income from Other Sources”.
Tax is deducted at source from profit on debt at rates specified in Division IA/IB of Part III of the First Schedule.
Specific rates apply to non-resident sukuk holders and non-resident companies with SCRA accounts (as detailed in exemptions above).
A zero percent tax rate applies to profit on debt covered under specific exemptions for non-resident individuals with POC/NICOP/CNIC from rupee accounts funded by foreign exchange.
Unexplained Income or Assets:
Any unexplained income or assets discovered by the Commissioner are included in the company’s income and taxed accordingly.
7. Collection and Recovery of Tax from Companies
Advance Tax (Section 147):
For companies, advance tax for a quarter is computed using a specific formula based on the company’s turnover. If the quarterly turnover is unknown, it’s assumed to be one-fourth of 120% of the turnover of the latest tax year for which a return has been filed.
Failure to pay or insufficient payment of advance tax may result in default surcharge [previous response].
Withholding Tax:
Companies act as withholding agents for various payments, including profit on debt, fees for offshore digital services, capital gains, and brokerage/commission.
Tax deducted on sale/supply of goods (under Section 153(1)(a)) is not a minimum tax if the recipient is a manufacturing company or a public company listed on a registered stock exchange.
Tax deducted on execution of contracts (under Section 153(1)(c)) is adjustable if received by a public company listed on a registered stock exchange.
Payments for advertisement services (to newspaper/magazine owners) and for sale of goods/execution of contracts by a public company listed on a registered stock exchange are exempt from minimum tax under Section 153(1)(b) (rendering of services).
A company receiving tax collected or deducted from an association of persons is allowed a tax credit.
Due Date for Payment:
Section 137 addresses the due date for tax payments. (Specific dates are not detailed in the provided sources, but the section exists).
Recovery of Tax:
The Commissioner has powers to recover tax from a company’s property or through the arrest of the taxpayer.
Tax can also be recovered by the District Officer (Revenue), from liquidators, or from persons holding money on behalf of a taxpayer.
As mentioned, directors and major shareholders of private companies can be held jointly and severally liable for unrecovered tax.
If a company’s tax liability arises in bankruptcy, it is considered a current expenditure and is paid before other creditors’ claims.
8. Administration and General Provisions
Resident Company Definition:A company is a resident company if it is incorporated or formed under any law in Pakistan, or if the control and management of its affairs are situated wholly in Pakistan at any time during the year, or if it is a Provincial Government or Local Government in Pakistan.
Income Tax Authorities:The administration involves various authorities such as the Board, Chief Commissioner Inland Revenue, Commissioner Inland Revenue, and Commissioner Inland Revenue (Appeals).
Power to Amend Schedules/Exemptions:The Federal Government or the Board, by notification in the official Gazette, can amend the Second Schedule to grant exemptions or reductions in tax rates.
This comprehensive overview covers the primary aspects of company taxation as described in the provided sources.
Principles of Tax Exemption and Final Tax Regimes
Tax exemptions in the provided sources refer to specific incomes, classes of income, persons, or classes of persons that are not subject to income tax under certain conditions. The framework for these exemptions is primarily outlined in Part VII of Chapter III and extensively detailed in The Second Schedule.
Here’s a detailed breakdown of tax exemptions:
General Framework of Exemptions
Inclusion in Total Income, but not Taxable Income: While a person’s “total income” includes income exempt from tax under the Ordinance, “taxable income” is derived by reducing total income by deductible allowances, meaning exempt income is not part of the amount subject to tax rates.
Primary Source of Exemptions: The Second Schedule is the main repository for specifying incomes, classes of income, persons, or classes of persons that are:
Exempt from tax under the Ordinance, subject to specified conditions and extent. This is covered in Part I of the Second Schedule.
Subject to reduced tax rates (less than those in the First Schedule). This is covered in Part II of the Second Schedule.
Allowed a reduction in tax liability. This is covered in Part III of the Second Schedule.
Exempt from the operation of specific provisions of the Ordinance. This is covered in Part IV of the Second Schedule.
Government Authority to Grant Exemptions: The Federal Government may, by notification in the official Gazette, amend the Second Schedule to grant exemptions, reduce tax rates, reduce tax liability, or exempt from the operation of any provision. However, such amendments only have legal effect if also provided for in the Ordinance.
Information Collection: The Board has the authority to authorize government departments or agencies to collect and compile data regarding incomes from industrial and commercial undertakings that are exempt from tax.
Exemption Certificates: The Commissioner can issue an exemption or lower rate certificate if an amount is exempt from tax under the Ordinance, is subject to a lower tax rate, or is subject to a one hundred percent tax credit. Persons required to collect or deduct tax must comply with such certificates.
Specific Exemptions from Total Income (as per sources)
Agricultural Income: Any rent or revenue derived from land situated in Pakistan and used for agricultural purposes, and any income from land situated in Pakistan derived from agricultural operations, is exempt from tax.
Diplomatic and United Nations Exemptions:Income of individuals entitled to privileges under the Diplomatic and Consular Privileges Act, 1972, and the United Nations (Privileges and Immunities) Act, 1948, to the extent provided in those respective Acts.
Any pension received by a citizen of Pakistan from former employment in the United Nations or its specialized agencies (including the International Court of Justice), provided the salary from such employment was exempt under the Ordinance.
Foreign Government Officials: Salary received by an employee of a foreign government as remuneration for services rendered to such government is exempt, provided the employee is a citizen of the foreign country (not Pakistan), the services are similar to those performed by Federal Government employees in foreign countries, and the foreign government grants a similar exemption to Federal Government employees performing similar services in that country.
Exemptions under International Agreements:Any Pakistan-source income that Pakistan is not permitted to tax under a tax treaty.
Any salary received by an individual (not being a citizen of Pakistan) to the extent provided for in an Aid Agreement between the Federal Government and a foreign government or public international organization.
Exemption under Foreign Investment (Promotion and Protection) Act, 2022: Investment or investors may be exempt or subject to tax at specific rates and in the manner specified under this Act.
President’s Honours: Mentioned as an exemption, but specific details are not provided in the excerpts.
Profit on Debt: Mentioned as an exemption, but specific details are not provided in the excerpts.
Scholarships: Any scholarship granted to a person to meet the cost of their education is exempt from tax, unless the scholarship is paid directly or indirectly by an associate.
Support Payments: Any income received by a spouse as support payment under an agreement to live apart is exempt from tax.
Government Income: The income of the Federal Government, Provincial Governments, and Local Governments is exempt from tax.
Foreign-Source Income: Exemptions exist for foreign-source income of short-term resident individuals and returning expatriates, though specific details are not provided in these excerpts.
Association of Persons (AOP) Income: If the income of an association of persons is exempt and no tax is payable due to this exemption, the share received by a member out of the AOP’s income remains exempt.
Tax Credit for Certain Organizations (Section 100C): Certain incomes of a trust, welfare institution, or non-profit organization are eligible for a tax credit (effectively making them exempt from tax), including:
So much of the income chargeable under the head “income from business” as is expended in Pakistan for welfare activities, provided the exemption for business income is proportional to its contribution to the aggregate income from all eligible sources.
Unexplained Foreign Exchange Remittances (Section 111): Any amount of foreign exchange remitted from outside Pakistan through normal banking channels not exceeding five million rupees in a tax year, encashed into rupees by a scheduled bank with a certificate from that bank, is not treated as unexplained income or assets.
Omitted Exemptions (Illustrative): The sources mention several omitted clauses from the Second Schedule, indicating past exemptions such as amounts received as monthly installments from certain pension plans (if invested for 10 years), and specific interest income on foreign currency bearer certificates.
Limitations on Exemptions
Original Recipient Rule (Section 55): Where any income is exempt from tax, the exemption is generally limited to the original recipient of that income and does not extend to any person receiving any payment wholly or in part out of that income, unless a specific provision to the contrary is stated in the Ordinance.
Losses from Exempt Business Income (Omitted Provision): Historically, if a person’s business income was exempt due to a tax concession, any loss sustained during the exemption period could not be set off against the person’s taxable income after the exemption expired. While omitted, this highlights the principle of not benefiting from losses generated during exempt periods.
Banking Companies (Fourth Schedule): Generally, exemptions and tax concessions available under the Second Schedule do not apply to the income of a banking company when computed under the Fourth Schedule, with some exceptions for accumulated business loss set-off.
Exemptions from Specific Tax Provisions (Part IV of Second Schedule)
Minimum Tax (Section 113):The provisions of Section 113 regarding minimum tax do not apply to:
National Investment (Unit) Trust.
Collective investment schemes authorized or registered under the Non-banking Finance Companies (Establishment and Regulation) Rules, 2003.
Real estate investment trusts approved and authorized under the Real Estate Investment Trust Regulations, 2015.
Pension funds registered under the Voluntary Pension System Rules, 2005.
Any other company in respect of turnover representing transactions in shares or securities listed on a registered stock exchange.
Past Omissions: Several exemptions from minimum tax were previously provided but later omitted, such as for Provincial Governments, local authorities, and certain businesses.
Alternative Corporate Tax (Section 113C): Exempt income is specifically excluded from accounting income for the purpose of computing Alternative Corporate Tax.
Advance Tax Collection (General – Section 236O): Advance tax under certain chapters shall not be collected or deducted from:
The Federal Government or a Provincial Government.
A foreign diplomat or a diplomatic mission in Pakistan.
A person who produces a certificate from the Commissioner that their income during the tax year is exempt.
Advance Tax on Educational Institutions (Section 236A): Advance tax is not collected if the annual fee does not exceed two hundred thousand rupees, or on amounts paid by way of scholarship. It is also not collected from non-resident persons.
Payments to Non-residents (Section 152): The provisions of Section 152 for payments to non-residents do not apply in the case of a Hajj Group Operator in respect of Hajj operations.
Foreign Experts’ Income Tax: Income tax payable by a foreign expert may be exempted if such expert is acquired with the prior approval of the Ministry of Textile Industry.
Depreciation (Section 22): The provisions of Section 22(8) regarding depreciation do not apply to the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) in respect of assets transferred for the purpose of an ijara agreement.
Opt-out from Final Tax Regimes: For certain types of income where tax is typically collected or deducted as a “final tax” (e.g., petroleum products, services, contracts, commissions), a person may opt out of the final tax regime and choose to file a return of total income under the normal tax regime. This is subject to conditions, such as ensuring that the minimum tax liability under the normal tax regime is not less than a specified percentage (e.g., 10% of commission or discount for petroleum products/commission income).
Income Subject to “Final Tax” (Effective Exemption from Normal Computation)
When tax is collected or deducted as a final tax under Section 169 (or other provisions), the income is treated differently:
It shall not be chargeable to tax under any head of income in computing the person’s taxable income.
No deductions are allowed for expenditures incurred in deriving this income.
The amount of the income is not reduced by any deductible allowances or the set-off of any loss.
The tax deducted shall not be reduced by any tax credit allowed.
Generally, there shall be no refund of the tax collected or deducted, unless the tax so collected or deducted is in excess of the amount for which the taxpayer is chargeable.
For the purpose of minimum tax computation, “tax payable or paid” does not include tax already paid or payable in respect of deemed income which is assessed as a final discharge of tax liability under Section 169 or any other provision. This highlights that final tax regimes operate outside the regular taxable income calculation.
Income Tax Offenses and Penalties
The Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, provides a comprehensive framework for various offenses and their corresponding penalties, including monetary penalties and provisions for prosecution leading to fines or imprisonment. These details are primarily outlined in Chapter X, Part X (Penalty) and Part XI (Offences and Prosecutions) of the Ordinance.
Here are the details regarding penalties as per the provided sources:
I. General Penalties (Section 182 – Offences and Penalties Table)
The Ordinance specifies various offenses and their associated penalties:
Failure to furnish a return of income as required under section 114 within the due date:
Penalty is the higher of 0.1% of the tax payable in respect of that tax year for each day of default, or Rupees one thousand for each day of default.
Minimum penalty is Rupees ten thousand for individuals with 75% or more income from salary, and Rupees fifty thousand in all other cases.
Maximum penalty shall not exceed two hundred percent of tax payable by the person in a tax year.
The amount of penalty is reduced by 75%, 50%, and 25% if the return is filed within one, two, and three months respectively after the due date or extended due date.
“Tax payable” means tax chargeable on the taxable income based on assessment made or treated to have been made under sections 120, 121, 122, or 122D.
Failure to furnish any statement required under section 165:
Penalty of Rupees two thousand.
Additional penalty of Rupees two hundred for each day of default after the imposition of the initial penalty.
If no tax was required to be collected or deducted during the relevant period, the minimum penalty is ten thousand Rupees.
Failure to furnish wealth statement or wealth reconciliation statement:
Penalty of 0.1% of the taxable income per week or Rs. 100,000, whichever is higher.
Failure to furnish a foreign assets and income statement within the due date (Section 116A):
Penalty of 2 percent of the foreign income or value of the foreign assets for each year of default.
Failure to furnish a return of income as required under sub-section (3) of section 117 within the time specified in the notice:
Penalty is the higher of 0.1% of the tax payable for each day of default, or Rs. 1,000 per day of default.
Minimum penalty is Rs. 10,000 for an individual and Rs. 50,000 in all other cases.
Failure to issue cash memo or invoice or receipt when required:
Penalty of five thousand rupees or three percent of the amount of the tax involved, whichever is higher.
Failure to apply for registration:
Penalty of ten thousand rupees.
Failure of a trader or a shopkeeper required to apply for registration under this Ordinance to register or pay advance tax as specified in a special procedure scheme under section 99B:
The shop of such person shall be sealed for seven days for the first default and for twenty-one days for each subsequent default.
Failure to notify the changes of material nature in the particulars of registration:
Penalty of five thousand rupees.
Failure to deposit the amount of tax due or any part thereof in the time or manner laid down:
Penalty of five percent of the amount of the tax in default for the first default.
For the second default, an additional penalty of 25% of the amount of tax in default.
For the third and subsequent defaults, an additional penalty of 50% of the amount of tax in default.
If the person opts to pay the tax due on or before the due date in consequence of an order under section 129 and does not file an appeal under section 131, the penalty payable shall be reduced by 50%.
Repeating erroneous calculation in the return for more than one year whereby amount of tax paid is less than the actual tax payable:
Penalty of thirty thousand rupees or three percent of the amount of the tax involved, whichever is higher.
No penalty shall be imposed to the extent of the tax shortfall occurring as a result of the taxpayer taking a reasonably arguable position.
Failure to maintain records required:
Penalty of ten thousand rupees or five percent of the amount of tax on income, whichever is higher.
Failure to produce the record or documents on receipt of notice under section 177:
On first notice: Penalty of twenty-five thousand rupees.
On second notice: Penalty of fifty thousand rupees.
On third notice: Penalty of one hundred thousand rupees.
Failure to furnish the information required or to comply with any other term of the notice served under section 176 or 108:
Penalty of twenty-five thousand rupees for the first default and fifty thousand rupees for each subsequent default.
Making a false or misleading statement to an Inland Revenue Authority:
Penalty of twenty-five thousand rupees or 50% of the amount of tax shortfall, whichever is higher.
No penalty for tax shortfall in deemed assessments under section 120 if a reasonably arguable position is taken.
Failure to comply with income tax general order issued by the Board (Section 114B):
Penalty of fifty million rupees for the first default and one hundred million for each subsequent default. The effective date is notified by the Board.
Denying or obstructing the access of the Commissioner or any authorized officer to premises, place, accounts, documents, computers or stocks:
Penalty of fifty thousand rupees or fifty percent of the amount of tax involved, whichever is higher.
Concealment of income or furnishing inaccurate particulars of such income:
Penalty of one hundred thousand rupees or an amount equal to the tax which the person sought to evade, whichever is higher.
No penalty for mere disallowance of a claim of exemption or deduction unless proved the claim was knowingly wrong.
Failure to pay tax at the time of making payment as consideration of shares or at the time of registration of shares by the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan or the State Bank of Pakistan, whichever is earlier (Section 37(6)):
Penalty equal to fifty percent of the amount of tax involved.
Obstructing any Income Tax Authority in the performance of official duties:
Penalty of twenty-five thousand rupees.
Contravention of any provision for which no penalty has been specifically provided:
Penalty of five thousand rupees or three percent of the amount of tax involved, whichever is higher.
Failure to collect or deduct tax as required or failure to pay the tax collected or deducted as required under section 160:
Penalty of forty thousand rupees or 10% of the amount of tax, whichever is higher.
If no tax was required to be deducted or collected, the minimum penalty is ten thousand Rupees.
Failure to display NTN or business licence at the place of business (Sections 181C, 181D):
Penalty of five thousand rupees.
Reporting financial institution or reporting entity failing to furnish information or country-by-country report to the Board as required under section 107, 108 or 165B:
Penalty of two thousand rupees for each day of default, subject to a minimum of twenty-five thousand rupees.
Failure to keep and maintain document and information required under section 108 or Income Tax Rules, 2002:
Penalty of ten thousand rupees for the first default, twenty-five thousand rupees for the second, and fifty thousand rupees for the third.
Offshore tax evader involved in offshore tax evasion:
Penalty of one hundred thousand rupees or an amount equal to two hundred percent of the tax which the person sought to evade, whichever is higher.
Enabler enabling, guiding, advising or managing any person to design, arrange or manage a transaction or declaration which has resulted or may result in offshore tax evasion:
Penalty of three hundred thousand rupees or an amount equal to two hundred percent of the tax which was sought to be evaded, whichever is higher.
Person involved in asset move as defined in clause (5C) of section 2 from specified territory to an un-specified territory:
Penalty of one hundred thousand rupees or an amount equal to one hundred percent of the tax, whichever is higher.
Reporting Financial Institution failing to comply with any provisions of section 165B or Common Reporting Standard Rules:
Penalty of Rs. 10,000 for each default and an additional Rs. 10,000 each month until the default is redressed.
Reporting Financial Institution filing an incomplete or inaccurate report under section 165B or Common Reporting Standard Rules:
Penalty of Rs. 10,000 for each default and an additional Rs. 10,000 each month until the default is redressed.
Reporting Financial Institution failing to obtain valid self-certification for new accounts or furnishes false self-certification:
Penalty of Rs. 10,000 for each default and an additional Rs. 10,000 each month until the default is redressed.
Reportable Jurisdiction Person failing to furnish valid self-certification or furnishes false self-certification:
Penalty of Rs. 5,000 for each default and an additional Rs. 5,000 each month until the default is redressed.
Company or Association of Persons contravening the provisions of Section 181E:
Penalty of Rs. 1,000,000 for each default.
Failure to integrate or perform roles and functions as specified, after being duly notified by the Board as SWAPS Agent (Section 237A):
Penalty of five hundred thousand rupees or two hundred percent of the amount of tax involved, whichever is higher.
Failure to integrate business for monitoring, tracking, reporting or recording of sales, services and similar business transactions with the Board or its computerized system (Section 237A):
Penalty up to one million rupees, and if the offense continues after two months of penalty imposition, business premises shall be sealed until integration.
Company and an association of persons failing to fully state all relevant particulars/information in the return, or furnishing blank/incomplete annexures/statements/documents:
Penalty of Rs. 500,000 or 10% of the tax chargeable on the taxable income, whichever is higher.
II. General Provisions for Penalties
Penalties specified in the table for Section 182 are applied consistently and no penalty is payable unless an order in writing is passed by the Commissioner, Commissioner (Appeals), or the Appellate Tribunal after providing an opportunity of being heard.
If the taxpayer admits their default, they may voluntarily pay the amount of penalty due.
It is clarified that establishing mens rea (guilty mind) is not necessary for levying of penalty under this section.
If the amount of tax in respect of which any penalty is payable is reduced in consequence of any order under the Ordinance, the amount of penalty shall be reduced accordingly.
III. Penalty for Return Not Filed Within Due Date (Section 182A)
Notwithstanding other provisions, if a person fails to file a return of income under section 114 by the due date or by the extended date, the Commissioner may impose a penalty. (Specific penalty amounts are detailed above under “Failure to furnish a return of income”).
IV. Exemption from Penalty and Default Surcharge (Section 183)
The Federal Government (by notification) or the Board (by order, with recorded reasons) may exempt any person or class of persons from payment of the whole or part of the penalty and default surcharge payable under the Ordinance, subject to specified conditions and limitations.
V. Recovery of Tax Collected or Deducted (Section 161)
Where a person fails to collect tax or deduct tax from a payment as required, or fails to pay tax collected or deducted, the Commissioner may recover the amount from that person as if it were tax due from them.
The person held personally liable for an amount of tax due to failing to collect or deduct it is entitled to recover that tax from the person from whom it should have been collected or deducted.
The Commissioner may amend a recovery order if deemed erroneous and prejudicial to revenue, after providing an opportunity of being heard.
VI. Offences and Prosecutions (Resulting in Fines and/or Imprisonment)
The Ordinance also outlines various offenses that, upon conviction, can lead to fines, imprisonment, or both, which are distinct from administrative monetary penalties but are categorized under “Offences and Penalties” in the Ordinance structure:
Prosecution for non-compliance with certain statutory obligations (Section 191): Failing to comply with notices (e.g., related to returns, wealth statements, advance tax, information, or tax collection/deduction). Punishable with fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding one year, or both. Continued failure to furnish returns/wealth statements can lead to a further offence punishable with a fine not exceeding fifty thousand rupees or imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years, or both.
Prosecution for failure to furnish information in return of income (Section 191A): Companies or associations of persons failing to fully state particulars, furnishing blank/incomplete particulars or annexures in their return. Punishable with fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding one year or both.
Prosecution for non-registration (Section 191B): Any person required to apply for registration who fails to do so. Punishable with imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months or fine or both.
Prosecution for false statement in verification (Section 192): Making a false statement in verification in any return or document, knowing or believing it to be false. Punishable with fine up to hundred thousand rupees or imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years, or both.
Prosecution for concealment of income (Section 192A): Concealment or furnishing inaccurate particulars of income with a revenue impact of Rs. 500,000 or more. Punishable with imprisonment up to two years or with fine or both.
Prosecution for concealment of an offshore asset (Section 192B): Failure to declare or furnishing inaccurate particulars of an offshore asset with a revenue impact of Rs. 10 million or more. Punishable with imprisonment up to three years or with a fine up to five hundred thousand Rupees or both.
Prosecution for failure to maintain records (Section 193):
Where the failure was deliberate: fine not exceeding fifty thousand rupees or imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years, or both.
In any other case: fine not exceeding fifty thousand rupees.
Prosecution for improper use of National Tax Number Certificate (Section 194): Knowingly or recklessly using a false NTN Certificate, including another person’s. Punishable with a fine not exceeding fifty thousand rupees or imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years, or both.
Prosecution for making false or misleading statements (Section 195): Making a false/misleading statement or omitting material information to an income tax authority.
If made knowingly or recklessly: fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years, or both.
In any other case: fine.
Prosecution for non-compliance with notice under section 116A (Section 195A): Failure to comply with a notice under sub-section (2) of section 116A. Punishable with imprisonment up to one year or with a fine up to fifty thousand Rupees or both.
Prosecution for enabling offshore tax evasion (Section 195B): An enabler guiding, advising, or managing a transaction/declaration resulting in offshore tax evasion. Punishable with imprisonment for a term not exceeding seven years or with a fine up to five million Rupees or both.
Prosecution for obstructing an income tax authority (Section 196): Obstructing an income tax authority in discharge of functions. Punishable with fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding one year, or both.
Prosecution for disposal of property to prevent attachment (Section 197): Disposing of property after receiving notice from Commissioner to prevent attachment. Punishable with fine up to hundred thousand rupees or imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years, or both.
Prosecution for unauthorised disclosure of information by a public servant (Section 198): Disclosing particulars in contravention of the Ordinance. Punishable with a fine of not less than five hundred thousand rupees or imprisonment for a term not exceeding one year, or both.
Prosecution for abetment (Section 199): Knowingly and willfully aiding, abetting, assisting, inciting, or inducing another person to commit an offence. Punishable with fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years, or both.
Offences by companies and associations of persons (Section 200): If a company commits an offence, every person responsible for its conduct at the time is also deemed guilty.
Pakistan Income Tax Regimes and Regulations
Based on the sources, here are the details regarding different tax regimes under the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001:
The Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, is a comprehensive law that consolidates and amends income tax regulations in Pakistan, effective as of June 30, 2024. It imposes income tax for each tax year on every person who has taxable income.
Income is generally categorized under various Heads of Income for taxation purposes, including:
Salary
Income from Property
Income from Business
Capital Gains
Income from Other Sources
Income of a resident person considers both Pakistan-source and foreign-source income, while for non-residents, only Pakistan-source income is considered.
Here are the details on various tax regimes:
1. Normal Tax Regime
This is the standard method of computing tax on a person’s taxable income.
Imposition: Income tax is imposed at the rate or rates specified in Division I or II of Part I of the First Schedule on every person with taxable income for the year.
Computation of Taxable Income:
A person’s income chargeable to tax is computed based on their regularly employed method of accounting.
Companies are required to account for income chargeable under “Income from Business” on an accrual basis, while other persons may use either cash or accrual basis.
The Board may prescribe the accounting method for any class of persons.
Adjustments are made when the accounting method changes to ensure no item is omitted or double-counted.
Income is derived when received (cash basis) or due (accrual basis), and expenditure is incurred when paid (cash basis) or payable (accrual basis).
Rates of Tax for Individuals and Association of Persons (Division I of Part I of the First Schedule):
The rates are set out in a table with different slabs based on taxable income.
For taxable income up to Rs. 600,000, the rate is 0%.
Rates progressively increase with income, up to 35% for taxable income exceeding Rs. 4,000,000.
For professionals (e.g., doctors, lawyers, etc., appearing on the Active Taxpayers’ List) with income exceeding Rs. 50 million, and who are members of a recognized professional body, the maximum rate is 40% instead of 45%. (Note: The 45% rate is not explicitly detailed in the provided table for individuals, but the 40% reduction implies its existence).
Rates of Tax for Companies (Division II of Part I of the First Schedule): These rates exist, but the specific percentage breakdown for companies is not provided in the excerpts.
2. Final Tax Regime (FTR)
Under this regime, the tax collected or deducted at source is considered the final tax liability for the income, meaning no further tax is due on that income, and it is generally not adjustable or refundable.
General Application: This section applies where the tax required to be deducted is a final tax under specific provisions of the Ordinance.
Incomes/Payments Subject to FTR (or treated as such):
Return on Investments in Sukuks (Section 5AA): Tax is imposed on persons receiving returns on Sukuks from a special purpose vehicle or a company. The tax is computed by applying the relevant rate to the gross amount of the return.
Rates (Division IIIB of Part I of the First Schedule):
25% if the Sukuk-holder is a company.
12.5% if the Sukuk-holder is an individual or association of persons and the return is more than one million.
10% if the Sukuk-holder is an individual or association of persons and the return is less than one million.
Income from Sukuks taxed under Section 5AA is not chargeable to tax under “Income from Business”.
Certain Payments to Non-residents (Section 6): Tax is imposed on non-resident persons receiving Pakistan-source royalty, fee for offshore digital services, fee for money transfer operations, card network services, payment gateway services, interbank financial telecommunication services, or fee for technical services. The tax is computed by applying the relevant rate to the gross amount of receipts.
Rates (Division IV of Part I of the First Schedule):
15% of the gross amount of royalty or fee for technical services.
10% in any other case.
This section does not apply if the income is effectively connected with a permanent establishment in Pakistan, in which case it is treated as income from business.
These incomes are not chargeable to tax under “Income from Business”.
Shipping and Air Transport Income of a Non-resident Person (Section 7): Tax is imposed on non-resident persons operating ships or aircrafts for carriage of passengers, livestock, mail, or goods embarked in Pakistan or received in Pakistan for goods embarked outside Pakistan. The tax is computed by applying the relevant rate to the gross amount.
Rates (Division V of Part I of the First Schedule):
8% for shipping income.
The rate for air transport income is implied by Division V, but not specifically given a percentage in the excerpt.
These incomes are not chargeable to tax under “Income from Business”.
Tax on Builders and Developers (Sections 7C, 7D, 7F):
Section 7C (Builders): Tax is imposed on the construction and sale of residential, commercial, or other buildings, computed by applying the relevant rate to the area of the building.
Section 7D (Developers): Tax is imposed on the development and sale of residential, commercial, or other plots, computed by applying the relevant rate to the area of the plots.
Section 7F: Income, profits, and gains of a builder or developer from a project are exempt from sections 113 and 113C (Minimum Tax on Turnover). Any tax paid under this section is not refundable or adjustable against any other tax liability. This indicates a final tax regime.
The Eleventh Schedule provides specific rules for computation of profits and gains of builders and developers and the tax payable thereon.
Payments for Goods or Services (Section 153(6)): The tax deducted under this section is generally a final tax on the income of a resident person arising from the specified transactions.
Toll Collection (Section 235(3)): Tax collected on a lease of the right to collect tolls is a final tax.
Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) (Fourteenth Schedule): SMEs have the option to be taxed under a final tax regime.
Rates (of gross turnover):
Category-1 (annual business turnover not exceeding Rs. 100 million): 0.25%.
Category-2 (annual business turnover exceeding Rs. 100 million but not exceeding Rs. 250 million): 0.5%.
This option, once exercised, is irrevocable for three tax years.
Traders (Section 99A and Ninth Schedule): Traders can opt to be assessed under this Schedule instead of the general Ordinance provisions. If they opt for this, the Commissioner is deemed to have made an assessment of income and tax due as computed under specific rules in the Schedule. This often involves a presumptive or final tax based on working capital or total turnover for specific tax years.
3. Minimum Tax Regime (MTR)
This regime ensures that certain taxpayers pay a minimum amount of tax, even if their computed tax liability under the normal regime is low or they have a loss.
Section 113 (Minimum Tax on the Income of Certain Persons):
Applicability: Applies to resident companies, permanent establishments of non-resident companies, individuals with a turnover of Rs. 100 million or more (from tax year 2017 onwards), and associations of persons with a turnover of Rs. 100 million or more (from tax year 2017 onwards).
Trigger: It applies if, for any reason (including a loss), the tax payable or paid is less than a specified percentage of the person’s turnover from all sources for that year. The specific percentage rate is not provided in the excerpt.
Exclusions from “tax payable or paid” for MTR calculation: This does not include tax already paid or payable in respect of deemed income that is assessed as a final discharge of tax liability (e.g., under Section 169). It also excludes Super Tax paid under Section 4B or 4C.
Banking Companies: The provisions of Section 113 apply to banking companies as they do to any other resident company.
Profit on Debt (Section 151): Tax deductible under this section is a minimum tax on the profit on debt, unless the taxpayer is a company or the profit on debt is taxable under Section 7B. This implies it’s a minimum tax for individuals/AOPs unless specifically covered otherwise.
Rent of Machinery (Section 236S): The tax deductible under this section is a minimum tax on the income of the resident person.
4. Presumptive Tax Regime (PTR)
This involves taxation based on certain presumptions, often gross receipts or other metrics, rather than detailed income and expenditure computations. Some FTR provisions can also be considered presumptive in nature.
Tax on Shipping of a Resident Person (Section 7A): A presumptive income tax is charged on any resident person engaged in the business of shipping. The excerpt does not provide the specific rates or computation method for this presumptive tax.
5. Super Tax
This is an additional tax levied on certain categories of persons.
Super Tax for Rehabilitation of Temporarily Displaced Persons (Section 4B): Imposed for tax years 2015 onwards, at rates specified in Division IIA of Part I of the First Schedule, on income of specified persons. This tax is paid, collected, and deposited according to Section 137.
Super Tax on High Earning Persons (Section 4C): Imposed at rates specified in Division IIB of Part I of the First Schedule. This is a separate levy on high-earning individuals/AOPs.
6. Impact of Active Taxpayers’ List (ATL)
The Active Taxpayers’ List (ATL) influences the rates of tax for certain transactions.
General Rule for Non-ATL Persons (Section 100BA, Tenth Schedule):
For persons not appearing on the active taxpayers’ list (or those appearing but have not filed their return by the due date), the rate of tax required to be deducted or collected under any provision of the Ordinance is increased by one hundred percent of the specified rate.
This rule does not apply to the advance tax collected under Section 231B (advance tax on motor vehicles).
There are also specific property tax rates in the Tenth Schedule for non-ATL persons, based on fair market value (6% to 8% for properties over Rs. 50 million). These higher rates for non-ATL persons do not apply if the person has filed returns for all of the last three preceding tax years.
7. Tax Treaties and Double Taxation Avoidance
The Federal Government may enter into tax treaties, tax information exchange agreements, or multilateral conventions for the avoidance of double taxation, prevention of fiscal evasion, or assistance in the recovery of taxes. These agreements can provide relief from tax payable under the Ordinance.
Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!