The text explores the dramatic transformation of the Gulf Emirates from impoverished, pearl-diving societies to wealthy oil-producing nations. It recounts the historical context, including British influence, the decline of the pearl trade, and the subsequent discovery and exploitation of oil. The narrative highlights the challenges of nation-building, including border disputes, internal power struggles, and the formation of the United Arab Emirates. The sources also examine the resulting social and economic changes, contrasting traditional tribal structures with the rapid modernization and wealth accumulation experienced in the region. Finally, the text considers the lasting impact of oil wealth and the geopolitical implications of the region’s newfound power.

Study Guide: The Gulf Emirates

Quiz

Answer each question in 2-3 sentences.

1. What are some of the significant changes that the Gulf Emirates have experienced since the 1970s?
2. How did the discovery of oil and gas impact the societies of the Gulf Emirates?
3. What was the role of the pearl trade in the Gulf Emirates’ history and economy?
4. Explain the relationship between the Gulf Emirates and the British during the period of the British protectorate.
5. Describe the shift in power between Sheikh Shakbut and Sheikh Zayed in Abu Dhabi and why this change was supported by the British.
6. What was unique about Dubai’s economic growth, as opposed to other Emirates, in the early stages of its development?
7. What were some of the challenges the Gulf Emirates faced when they considered forming a federation?
8. Why did the British withdraw from the Gulf in 1968?
9. How did the 1973 oil crisis impact the Gulf Emirates and the global balance of power?
10. Describe the significance of the TBS islands in relation to the Strait of Hormuz.

Answer Key

1. The Gulf Emirates have experienced dramatic and unprecedented changes since the 1970s, including rapid modernization, increased literacy rates, and high rates of mobile phone usage. These transformations have been fueled by vast oil revenues, contrasting with their history of poverty and nomadic cultures.
2. The discovery of oil and gas transformed the Gulf Emirates from impoverished societies reliant on pearl diving and fishing into wealthy nations with modern infrastructure and advanced economies. This sudden influx of wealth led to rapid urbanization, attracting foreign workers and resulting in the development of large cities.
3. The pearl trade was a significant economic activity in the Gulf for centuries, creating opportunities for some locals to become wealthy and establishing the region’s cosmopolitan credentials. However, most profits went to Indian traders, and the industry collapsed with the introduction of cultured pearls by Japan in the 1930s.
4. During the British protectorate, the Gulf Emirates were under British control for defense and foreign relations. The British aimed to protect strategic shipping routes by establishing treaties with local sheikhs, effectively creating a British monopoly on shipping routes in the region and a significant colonial influence.
5. Sheikh Shakbut was initially wary of rapid development and hoarded oil revenues, which frustrated the British who favored a more progressive leader. His brother, Sheikh Zayed, was more open to change, and the British worked to facilitate his rise to power, believing him more capable of modernizing Abu Dhabi.
6. Dubai’s economic growth was unique because it did not initially depend on oil, but on trade, attracting foreign capital and establishing the port as a free enterprise haven. It focused on strategic investments, like the dredging of the creek, establishing itself as a major global trading post.
7. The Gulf Emirates faced many challenges in forming a federation, including concerns about losing individual sovereignty, pre-existing tribal conflicts, and unequal wealth distribution among the Emirates. The Emirates had different levels of comfort with the potential dominance of Abu Dhabi and Dubai.
8. The British withdrew from the Gulf in 1968 due to economic crisis and decolonization efforts. They could no longer sustain the military presence in the region, leading to the end of the British protectorate.
9. The 1973 oil crisis resulted in a huge transfer of wealth to the Gulf states, and the region began to realize its influence on the global economy. OPEC’s oil embargo demonstrated the ability of the oil-producing countries to impact the Western world, although regional security remained a concern.
10. The TBS islands are significant because of their strategic location near the Strait of Hormuz. This strait is a critical waterway for global oil trade, which made the islands a point of strategic interest for neighboring countries and added to the challenges of establishing the Emirates’ new sovereignty.

Essay Questions

1. Analyze the complex relationship between tradition and modernity in the Gulf Emirates, using specific examples from the text to support your argument.
2. Discuss the impact of British colonialism on the formation and development of the Gulf Emirates, considering both its positive and negative consequences.
3. Compare and contrast the leadership styles and visions of Sheikh Shakbut and Sheikh Zayed, and how their approaches affected the development of Abu Dhabi.
4. Evaluate the role of oil in the transformation of the Gulf Emirates, considering its economic, social, and political impacts.
5. Assess the challenges and successes of the Gulf Emirates in forming the United Arab Emirates, and consider the lasting impacts of that union.

Glossary of Key Terms

Amir: A term for a ruler or prince, often used in the context of the Gulf Emirates.

British Protectorate: A state or territory under the protection of a stronger power, in this case, the British government, with Britain controlling defense and foreign affairs, especially in the Gulf region.

Cultured Pearls: Pearls grown through human intervention in pearl farming, rather than naturally occurring pearls; the proliferation of cultured pearls caused the collapse of the traditional pearl industry.

Free Enterprise Paradise: An economic system with minimal government intervention, emphasizing free trade, open markets, and private property; Dubai sought to establish itself as one, attracting foreign capital.

OPEC (Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries): An intergovernmental organization of oil-producing nations, which was formed to coordinate oil policies and prices, especially to ensure a fair deal for oil-producing countries from international companies.

Persian Gulf: The body of water bordered by the Arabian Peninsula and Iran.

Strait of Hormuz: A narrow waterway connecting the Persian Gulf and the Gulf of Oman, which serves as a crucial shipping route for oil and other goods.

TBS Islands: Islands located in the Strait of Hormuz, that were a point of conflict between the newly formed UAE and Iran.

Trucial States: The name given by the British to the Emirates of the Persian Gulf (now the UAE) during the British protectorate, referring to the truces and agreements made between the British and the local sheikhs.

UAE (United Arab Emirates): A federation of seven emirates in the Arabian Peninsula that was formed after the British withdrew from the Gulf, in response to the new political landscape and concerns about stability in the region.

The Gulf Emirates: From Pearls to Power

Okay, here’s a detailed briefing document summarizing the main themes and important ideas from the provided text:

Briefing Document: The Transformation of the Gulf Emirates

Date: October 26, 2023

Subject: Analysis of the rapid modernization and complex history of the Gulf Emirates, focusing on their economic transformation and political evolution.

Sources: Excerpts from a documentary transcript detailing the history of the Gulf Emirates, with emphasis on their pre-oil past, British influence, the rise of oil wealth, and the formation of the United Arab Emirates (UAE).

Executive Summary:

The provided transcript offers a compelling narrative of the Gulf Emirates, highlighting their dramatic transformation from impoverished, pearl-diving societies to wealthy, modern states. The region’s history is a complex tapestry woven with tribal structures, British colonial influence, the discovery of vast oil reserves, and the challenges of rapid modernization. This document analyzes key themes: the impact of oil, the role of the British protectorate, the emergence of key leaders, and the geopolitical factors that shaped the region.

Key Themes & Analysis

1. Dramatic Transformation and Contradictions:

• Rapid Modernization: The Gulf Emirates experienced unprecedented change, moving “from poverty and desert sands…to the vanguard of modern life.” This included a significant increase in life expectancy (20 years in 40 years), high literacy rates (over 90%), and widespread adoption of technology (200+ cell phones per 100 people).
• Massive Investment: The Amirs invested “$2,000 billion on modernizing their states,” indicating the scale of transformation.
• Clash of Old and New: The text points to a clash between “archaic societies” and modern life, creating a sense of “contradictions and confusion.” Despite modernization, underlying societal structures and tribal dynamics remained influential.
• “Euphoria”: There’s a sense of excitement and optimism, with the region being called “Paradise,” illustrating a generally positive reaction to the changes.

1. The Pre-Oil Era: Pearls and Poverty:

• Limited Economy: Before oil, the economy was largely based on pearling. The text notes that “the people of the gulf were poor. Their only wealth came from the sea.”
• Pearl Trade Disparity: Though the pearl trade brought wealth, most profits went to Indian traders in Bombay, highlighting the region’s economic vulnerability. “Most of the profits went to Indian Pearl traders in Bombay.”
• Subsistence Living: Life was hard, characterized by “wretched conditions, the lack of schools and hospitals.” Daily life involved “houses made from from Palm frons, camels and donkeys as transportation.” The text noted “malnutrition and infant mortality were high.”
• Devastation of the Pearl Industry: The invention of cultured pearls by Japan led to the collapse of the Gulf’s pearl trade and caused “devastating” poverty, with fishing villages turning into “ghost towns.”

1. British Protectorate and its Lasting Impact:

• Commercial Beginnings: British involvement initially began as a commercial presence, evolving into a more established military and political position. “What started out as a commercial presence, a trading post began to develop over time into a more established position then backed up by the military.”
• Trucial States: The region became a British protectorate (the “Trucial States”) in the mid-19th century. The name derived from “a standstill agreement” that was “concluded in 1820 with 11 shakes.”
• Limited British Control: While the British controlled foreign relations and defense, the local rulers maintained control over their internal governments. “We weren’t running their governments for them.”
• Economic Influence: The British needed to pacify strategic shipping routes, granting themselves a monopoly on routes from Bahrain to Abu Dhabi.
• Long-Lasting Marks: British domination left a “long-lasting mark on the inhabitants of the gulf,” with the region’s history and boundaries heavily influenced by the British.

1. The Rise of Oil Wealth and its Consequences:

• Discovery of Oil: Oil exploration began in the 1930s with discoveries being made in the 1950s. “They first discovered oil in Abu Dhabi um both onshore and then offshore.”
• Western Influx: The oil boom led to an influx of Western engineers, scientists, managers, and others, creating a “disorganized version of imperialism.”
• Initial Concerns: The local population was unsure about the reliability of oil wealth and feared a return to poverty. “In their minds, this Black Gold was not necessarily more reliable than pearls had turned out to be.”
• Shik Shakbut’s Hesitancy: The ruler of Abu Dhabi, Shik Shakbut, was hesitant to rapidly develop, keeping his revenues under his bed and in the cellar, demonstrating a lack of experience with large sums. “Shakbut really had uh little appetite for uh rapid development of the Emirate.”
• Shik Zayed’s Vision: His brother, Shik Zayed, was more ambitious and forward-thinking, favoring development and change. “His brother, Sheik Z, was if you like a more outgoing, a more open-minded person who wanted to see things change.” This eventually led to him replacing his brother.
• Transformation of Abu Dhabi: Under Sheikh Zayed, huge sums were used to build schools, hospitals, and infrastructure, leading to a “real industrial and moral Revolution.”
• Wealth and Western Distain: The West viewed the sudden wealth of the Gulf with disdain. “The West snears at these little Arab Nations who seem to have money to burn.”

1. The Emergence of Key Leaders:

• Sheikh Zayed of Abu Dhabi: He emerges as a pivotal figure, credited with spearheading the modernization efforts. “Shik Zed floods the country with huge wads of cash extracted from under his brother’s mattress”
• Sheikh Rashid of Dubai: The ruler of Dubai who was focused on creating a modern trade and attracting foreign investment.
• Sheikh Dr. Sultan bin Muhammad Al-Qasimi of Sharjah: A historian Amir who demonstrates both tradition and modernity in his approach.

1. The Formation of the UAE:

• British Withdrawal: The British announcement of withdrawal from the Gulf in 1968 created a sense of urgency for the Emirates’ future. “The British announced a withdrawal from the Gulf.”
• Federation Idea: The idea of a federation emerged as a means to ensure stability and prosperity, led by Sheikh Zayed. “The people of the gulf should form one large Federation.”
• Challenges to Unity: The formation of the UAE was complex, with different Emirates wary of losing influence to Abu Dhabi and Dubai. “The Emirates are not all equally rich are they ready to lose their identity and their local influence?”
• Independence: The UAE declared independence in 1971, after complex negotiations with each Emirate. “A few weeks later the United Arab Emirates does the same nations are being born where locals remember that pearls were once the Region’s only wealth.”
• Immediate Threats: Iran’s invasion of the Tunbs islands and the threat of Saudi border expansion highlighted the new nation’s fragility.

1. Geopolitical Challenges and Oil’s Power:

• Border Disputes: The newly formed UAE faced immediate threats from Iran and Saudi Arabia. “Iran immediately invades the TBS islands that it wants to reclaim from the UAE.”
• Yom Kippur War and Oil Embargo: The 1973 oil crisis, sparked by the Yom Kippur War, saw Gulf States dramatically increase oil prices and reduce production, demonstrating their newfound global economic influence. “The Gulf States decide to increase the barrel price by 70% and OPEC reduces its output.”
• OPEC’s Role: OPEC was influential in shifting power dynamics between oil companies and producing countries.
• Ongoing Instability: Despite the oil wealth, the region remained vulnerable to instability, with future conflicts looming.

Conclusion:

The transcript provides a rich historical overview of the Gulf Emirates, illustrating how they rapidly transitioned from poverty to prosperity through a combination of oil wealth, political maneuvering, and the influence of Western powers. Despite the unprecedented economic transformation, the region continues to grapple with internal and external challenges related to its newfound power and wealth, underscoring the complexities of its modern history.

The Gulf Emirates: Transformation and Challenges

Frequently Asked Questions about the Gulf Emirates

1. How have the Gulf Emirates transformed since the 1970s?
2. The Gulf Emirates have undergone rapid and dramatic changes, transitioning from relatively poor, nomadic societies to modern, wealthy states. This transformation was largely fueled by the discovery and exploitation of vast oil and gas reserves, leading to unprecedented modernization efforts. They experienced a massive influx of wealth that enabled them to increase life expectancy, literacy rates, and infrastructure. This rapid development created a unique juxtaposition of traditional and modern life.
3. What was life like in the Gulf region before the discovery of oil and gas?
4. Before the oil boom, life in the Gulf was characterized by poverty, with limited economic opportunities mostly centered around pearl diving and fishing. Communities were small, often consisting of nomadic groups, oases, and fishing villages. Transportation was limited to camels and donkeys. The region was under British influence and had a long history of pearl trade, though most of the profits went to foreign traders. Conditions were harsh, with high rates of malnutrition and infant mortality.
5. What was the British role in the Gulf region?
6. The British initially came to the Gulf to combat piracy and protect shipping routes to India, which was part of the British Empire. Over time, this presence evolved into a protectorate, with Britain controlling defense and foreign relations while the local rulers managed their governments. The British also played a role in shaping the borders between the Emirates, leading to a sometimes complicated geographical division. By the late 1960s, however, Britain was facing pressure to decolonize and withdrew from the region.
7. How did the discovery of oil impact the ruling families of the Gulf?
8. The discovery of oil transformed the fortunes of the ruling families, turning them into some of the wealthiest individuals in the world. They initially struggled to adapt to the rapid changes brought on by oil revenues. For example, some leaders were hesitant to embrace rapid development, while others, like Sheikh Zayed of Abu Dhabi, actively promoted change and modernization. This new wealth also created internal power struggles and tensions. It also caused a shift in the balance of power from the old pearl trade, with new sources of revenue.
9. What led to the formation of the United Arab Emirates (UAE)?
10. The formation of the UAE was a direct result of the British withdrawal from the region. The ruling families recognized the need for unity to ensure their security and prosperity, leading them to negotiate a federation. Key figures like Sheikh Zayed of Abu Dhabi and Sheikh Rashid of Dubai worked to build this alliance. However, the process was complex and fraught with disagreements between the different Emirates, who had different levels of wealth and influence, and some of whom feared losing their autonomy to the larger Emirates.
11. How did Dubai become such a prominent city in the UAE?
12. Dubai’s prominence stemmed from its strategic focus on trade. Under the leadership of Sheikh Rashid Al Maktoum, Dubai developed as a major global trading post and a haven for foreign investment. Unlike other Emirates, Dubai’s early growth was not solely dependent on oil. Sheikh Rashid’s vision and investment into the port and infrastructure was vital in making Dubai a major trading hub.
13. What were some of the immediate challenges faced by the newly formed UAE?
14. The newly formed UAE faced several immediate challenges, including territorial disputes with neighboring countries. One such challenge was Iran’s invasion of the Tunbs islands. The country’s borders were often ill-defined due to the old British protectorate system. Internally, the Emirates still had to navigate the political realities of multiple families, different views on development and some degree of mistrust.
15. How did the 1973 oil crisis impact the Gulf States?
16. The 1973 oil crisis had a profound impact on the Gulf States, dramatically increasing their wealth and global influence. The rise in oil prices due to OPEC’s actions transformed the power dynamics, and suddenly these Emirates were major players in the global economy. This crisis also made the region aware of its leverage over the Western world, and they suddenly realized their importance in the global system. This moment was also recognized by some as the largest transfer of wealth in history.

Gulf Transformation: From Pearls to Oil

The discovery of oil and gas in the Gulf region led to a dramatic transformation of the area, shifting it from a state of poverty to one of immense wealth [1, 2]. This transformation occurred rapidly, with the Gulf states moving from a nomadic, pearl-diving economy to a modern, oil-based one [1, 3]. Here are some key aspects of this transformation:

• Early Poverty and Pearl Trade: Before the discovery of oil, the Gulf region was largely characterized by poverty [1]. The main economic activities were fishing, pearl diving, and trade, with pearls being a significant commodity [3, 4]. However, the profits from the pearl trade primarily went to Indian traders, leaving the local population relatively poor [4]. The collapse of the pearl trade due to the invention of cultured pearls in the 1930s caused further economic hardship, leaving many families in poverty and some villages abandoned [2].
• Discovery of Oil and Gas: The discovery of oil and gas in the early to mid-20th century dramatically changed the fortunes of the Gulf Emirates [1, 2]. While other nations in the Middle East, such as Persia, Iraq and Saudi Arabia, had discovered oil earlier, the Gulf states began to see their own oil resources exploited in the lead up to World War II and more substantially in the 1950s [2].
• Influx of Western Influence: The oil boom brought an influx of Westerners, including engineers, scientists, managers, and bankers, who were attracted by the region’s newfound wealth [2]. This period saw a rapid, somewhat disorganized form of imperialism, with Western companies like Exxon, Total, and British Petroleum playing a major role in the development of the oil industry [2].
• Rapid Modernization: The oil wealth fueled rapid modernization and development in the Gulf states. The Amirs invested heavily in infrastructure, education, and healthcare [1, 5]. This included constructing modern cities, schools, hospitals, and other infrastructure projects [1, 5, 6]. For instance, Abu Dhabi and Dubai experienced significant growth, transforming from small villages into major urban centers [6, 7]. The region’s literacy rate increased significantly, and life expectancy rose dramatically [1].
• Economic Diversification: Some of the Gulf states, like Dubai, diversified their economies beyond oil, focusing on trade and attracting foreign investment [6]. Dubai became a major global trading post and free enterprise zone, benefiting from its strategic location and port infrastructure [6]. Former pearl traders also diversified their fortunes into sectors such as banking, jewelry, luxury car dealerships and real estate [4].
• Political and Social Changes: The rise of oil wealth also brought significant political and social changes. The traditional tribal structures of the region began to give way to more modern forms of governance, and the influence of tribal leaders began to shift as the new wealth concentrated power in the hands of the ruling families [5, 6]. The British protectorate over the region ended, and the Gulf states began to assert their independence [4, 7, 8].
• International Influence: The oil crisis of 1973, during which Gulf states and other OPEC members increased oil prices significantly, demonstrated the region’s newfound influence on the global stage [9, 10]. The Gulf states became major players in the world economy [10].
• Concerns and Challenges: Despite the massive wealth, there were also concerns and challenges. There was a fear that the oil resources would eventually be exhausted, leading to a return to poverty [2]. Additionally, the rapid pace of development and modernization led to social and cultural tensions [1]. There were also concerns about regional stability and security, particularly in light of conflicts and tensions with neighboring countries [10]. Some leaders of the Emirates resisted the rapid pace of change and modernization, and initially hesitated to invest in public development [11].

In summary, the discovery of oil and gas in the Gulf region led to a rapid and transformative period. The states went from being poor and dependent on traditional industries like pearl diving to becoming wealthy, modern and influential players on the world stage [1, 4]. This transformation included a large influx of Western influence and a massive investment in modernization, although it also brought challenges, social tensions, and concerns for the future [1, 2].

The Transformation of the Gulf Emirates

The history of the Gulf Emirates is marked by significant transformations, from a past of tribal societies, pearl diving, and British influence to a present of immense oil wealth and modern development [1-3]. Here’s a breakdown of that history:

• Early History: For centuries, the Gulf region was characterized by nomadic Bedouin tribes, small fishing villages, and pearling communities [1, 2]. The area lacked significant cities, with the exception of a few trading posts like Zubara in Qatar [2]. The people were generally poor, with their primary economic activities centered around the sea [2]. The pearl trade was a crucial part of the economy, but most of the profits went to Indian merchants, not the local population [3].
• British Influence: The British became involved in the Gulf in the 19th century, initially to suppress piracy and protect shipping routes to India [3, 4]. The British established a protectorate over the region, signing treaties with various coastal sheikhs, designating the area as the “Trucial States” [4]. Under this arrangement, the British controlled foreign relations and defense, while the local rulers maintained control over internal affairs [4]. This British influence had lasting impacts on the region, including the establishment of borders and the introduction of foreign currency, the Indian Rupee, for trade [3, 4]. The treaties with the British also meant that the local rulers could not cede any land to other foreign powers [4].
• Collapse of the Pearl Trade: The invention of cultured pearls in the 1930s by the Japanese severely impacted the Gulf region’s economy, leading to widespread poverty and the abandonment of some villages [5]. This economic crisis occurred just before the discovery of oil in the region, which provided a new path forward [5].
• Discovery of Oil: While other Middle Eastern countries like Persia, Iraq, and Saudi Arabia discovered oil earlier, the Gulf Emirates began to exploit their own oil resources in the lead-up to World War II and in the 1950s [5]. The discovery of oil and gas was a turning point, attracting Western oil companies and leading to significant changes [5]. This period saw an influx of Western engineers, scientists, managers, and others seeking to profit from the newfound oil wealth [5]. This led to a form of disorganized imperialism, with Western companies playing a significant role in the region’s development [5].
• Modernization and Development: Oil wealth led to rapid modernization and development in the Gulf states [1]. The ruling families, such as Sheikh Zayed in Abu Dhabi and Sheikh Rashid in Dubai, invested heavily in infrastructure, education, and healthcare [1, 6]. This included building modern cities, schools, hospitals, and other infrastructure projects [1, 6]. Life expectancy and literacy rates improved dramatically [1]. Dubai, in particular, focused on trade and foreign investment, becoming a global trading hub [7].
• Political Changes and Independence: As the Gulf States grew in wealth and influence, they began to assert their independence from the British [8]. In 1968, the British announced their intention to withdraw from the region, leading to discussions about forming a federation [8]. The rulers of Abu Dhabi and Dubai led these negotiations [9]. In 1971, the United Arab Emirates (UAE) was formed, uniting six of the smaller emirates into a single nation, with Qatar and Bahrain choosing to become independent nations [9]. The UAE adopted a flag that symbolized the unity of the Arab nation [9].
• Post-Independence Challenges: The newly independent states faced several challenges [10]. Iran invaded some islands claimed by the UAE [10]. Additionally, Saudi Arabia expanded its borders at the expense of Abu Dhabi [10]. Internal power struggles within ruling families led to assassinations and changes in leadership in some areas [9]. The 1973 oil crisis saw the Gulf states increase oil prices and reduce output, which demonstrated their newfound influence in the global economy [10, 11].
• Continued Growth and Influence: Despite the initial challenges, the Gulf Emirates have continued to grow in wealth and influence [11]. They have become major players in the world economy, using their oil wealth to invest in development and diversify their economies [1, 3]. The region has undergone dramatic social and cultural changes due to modernization and the influx of foreign workers [1, 2].

In conclusion, the history of the Gulf Emirates is a story of transformation, from a traditional, impoverished society to a modern, wealthy, and influential region. This transformation has been driven by a combination of factors, including British influence, the discovery of oil, and the leadership of visionary rulers [1-6].

The Fall of the Gulf Pearl Trade

The decline of the pearl trade in the Gulf region was a significant event that had a devastating impact on the local economy and population [1]. Here’s a detailed discussion of this decline:

• Historical Significance of Pearl Trade: For centuries, pearl diving was a major economic activity in the Gulf [2, 3]. The Gulf’s pearls were renowned for their quality and were traded across the world [3]. Pearling was one of the rare economic activities in the region, with trading routes extending from Kuwait to Dubai, and Qatar [3]. However, despite its importance, most of the profits from the pearl trade did not benefit the local population. Instead, they went to Indian pearl traders in Bombay, who then sold the pearls in Europe and America [3].
• The Emergence of Cultured Pearls: The invention of cultured pearls by Mr. Mikimoto in Japan in the 1930s was the main cause of the collapse of the Gulf pearl trade [1, 4]. This new method of pearl production led to a rapid increase in supply, which drastically lowered the price of natural pearls [1]. The production of cultured pearls took off, and the market for natural pearls from the Gulf collapsed [1].
• Economic Devastation: The collapse of the pearl trade had a devastating impact on the Gulf economies, which had been heavily reliant on it [1]. Many families lost their primary source of income and were plunged into poverty [1]. Some entire fishing villages became ghost towns as people were forced to abandon their homes in search of alternative livelihoods [1].
• Attempts to Adapt: Faced with economic ruin, some people tried to return to their original resources, but many had lost their connections to the interior of the country [1]. The population faced near-starvation, and conditions were dire [1]. Former pearl divers were eventually subsidized by the government, which provided them with housing, vehicles, and gathering places [3]. They became part of the native elite [3].
• Transition to Oil: The decline of the pearl trade occurred at the same time that oil exploration was beginning in the Middle East [1]. While the discovery of oil in the region had started earlier in the 20th century in other parts of the Middle East [1], it was not until the run-up to World War II that a glimmer of hope appeared for the Emirates [1]. The discovery of oil was a turning point, offering a new economic path for the Gulf states [1]. It wasn’t long after the collapse of the pearl trade that the massive oil fields were discovered, which led to the transformation of the region [1].
• Long-Term Impact: The collapse of the pearl trade marked the end of an era in the Gulf’s history and the beginning of the oil-driven economy that has transformed the region [1]. While the pearl trade had established some cosmopolitan credentials [3], the discovery of oil was the true turning point [1].

In summary, the decline of the pearl trade was a major economic disaster for the Gulf region, triggered by the advent of cultured pearls [1]. It led to widespread poverty and hardship, but it also set the stage for the region’s eventual transition to an oil-based economy and the unprecedented wealth that followed [1].

Formation of the United Arab Emirates

The formation of the federation in the Gulf was a complex process driven by the need for stability and security following the British withdrawal from the region [1]. Here’s an overview of that process:

• British Withdrawal: In 1968, the British announced their intention to withdraw from the Gulf, which created a sense of vulnerability among the Emirates [1]. The British had been a significant power in the region, and their departure left the Emirates with no military support or established foreign policy [2]. The British decision to withdraw was influenced by economic difficulties and the broader trend of decolonization [1].
• Initial Ideas: The idea of forming a federation among the Gulf states emerged as a response to the impending British withdrawal. Sheikh Zayed of Abu Dhabi and Sheikh Rashid of Dubai were the primary drivers of this initiative [1, 3]. The vision was to create a major Arab country based on stability and prosperity [1]. There was a hope that the combined power of the Emirates could create a stable and prosperous nation modeled on the European system [1].
• Negotiations and Challenges:
• Abu Dhabi-Dubai Axis: Sheikh Zayed and Sheikh Rashid formed a strong alliance, creating a powerful axis that was central to the formation of the federation [3].
• Concerns and Misgivings: Not all Emirates were in agreement, and some had reservations about the proposed federation. The Amir of Raz Alima, Al kazimi, worried about the dominant position of Abu Dhabi and Dubai [3]. Similarly, the Amir of Qatar, Alani, was concerned about the sovereignty of his kingdom [3].
• Family Matters: The negotiations were also complicated by the fact that the ruling families in the region had not always been friendly with each other [3]. There was a history of tribal conflicts and internal power struggles [2, 3].
• Territorial Disputes: The borders drawn by the British were vague, which created territorial disputes [2]. The Emirates were not all equally wealthy and there were questions about whether they would lose their identity by joining a federation dominated by Abu Dhabi and Dubai [3].
• Consultations and Agreements: Despite the challenges, consultations continued for over three years, with rulers meeting, signing draft agreements, and often changing their minds [3]. The British, despite no longer wanting to be a presence in the area, were in favor of grouping their former protectorates together in a larger federation [3]. However, Bahrain and Qatar chose to pursue their own paths to independence [3].
• Formation of the UAE: In 1971, the United Arab Emirates (UAE) was officially formed, uniting six of the emirates [3]. The UAE adopted a flag that symbolized the unity of the Arab nation [3].
• Post-Formation Challenges: Even after the formation of the UAE, challenges persisted [3, 4].
• Iranian Invasion: Iran invaded the TBS islands, which were strategically important near the Strait of Hormuz, a vital shipping route for oil tankers [4].
• Saudi Expansion: Saudi Arabia expanded its borders at the expense of Abu Dhabi [4].
• Internal Power Struggles: There were internal disputes within the ruling families, including assassinations and changes in leadership [3, 4].
• Economic Pressures: The 1973 oil crisis demonstrated the region’s newfound economic power. The Gulf states increased oil prices and reduced output, which had a significant impact on the global economy [4, 5].

In summary, the formation of the federation in the Gulf was a complex process involving negotiations between various rulers, a need to fill the void left by British withdrawal, and the desire to form a stable and prosperous nation, although, this process was also challenged by territorial disputes, tribal conflicts, and external threats.

Gulf Political Instability: A Complex History

Political instability in the Gulf region has been a recurring theme, influenced by various factors including tribal disputes, power struggles within ruling families, external pressures, and the rapid socio-economic changes brought about by oil wealth [1-5].

• Tribal and Family Conflicts: Historically, the Gulf region was characterized by tribal societies, and these tribal and family dynamics continued to play a role in political instability even after the formation of the Emirates [1, 3, 4].
• There was a history of conflict between different tribes and ruling families [4, 6].
• Power transfers were often violent, with examples of nephews murdering uncles and sons deposing fathers [4].
• Internal power struggles, including assassinations and conspiracies, further contributed to instability [4].
• British Influence and Legacy: The British protectorate, while providing some stability, also created conditions for future instability [2, 7].
• The British drew borders that were vague and sometimes arbitrary, leading to territorial disputes between Emirates [6, 8].
• The treaties signed with the British also meant that the local rulers could not cede any land to other foreign powers [7]. This created friction as some rulers sought more autonomy [7].
• When the British withdrew from the Gulf in 1968, it created a power vacuum that further destabilized the region [4, 8].
• External Threats and Interference: The Gulf states faced threats from external powers [9].
• Iran invaded the TBS islands shortly after the formation of the UAE, highlighting the region’s vulnerability [9]. These islands are strategically located near the Strait of Hormuz, a vital shipping route for oil tankers [9].
• Saudi Arabia expanded its borders at the expense of Abu Dhabi, demonstrating the challenges the newly formed nation faced from its neighbors [3, 9].
• The simmering conflict between world powers over control of oil-rich lands also contributed to instability, with competing interests from the British, Americans, and others [3].
• Internal Political Dynamics: The rapid changes brought about by oil wealth created new challenges [1, 10, 11].
• The discovery of oil led to an influx of Westerners, including engineers and financiers, creating a form of disorganized imperialism that could have led to instability [10].
• Some rulers were hesitant to embrace change and modernization, creating internal tensions [3, 11]. For example, Sheikh Shakur of Abu Dhabi was initially reluctant to use the banks, and this led to a transfer of power to his brother who was more forward-thinking [3].
• The transition from traditional, tribal societies to modern, wealthy states created social and political tensions. The influx of money and modernization created a clash between traditional and modern values and created a kind of “delusions of grander” [1].
• Post-Independence Instability: The period immediately following independence was particularly turbulent [4].
• Qatar experienced a coup just six months after independence, where the ruling Amir was ousted by his cousin [9].
• The Yom Kippur War and the subsequent oil crisis of 1973 highlighted the Gulf states’ economic power but also increased the risk of instability [5, 9]. The oil embargo showed how the region could influence the West but also made them targets [5].
• General Instability: The sources emphasize that the Gulf is a notoriously unstable region that has been through three wars in the last 30 years and experienced the Islamic revolution in Iran [1]. These factors contribute to the sense of volatility and uncertainty in the region [1].

In conclusion, political instability in the Gulf has been shaped by a complex interplay of internal and external factors. Tribal conflicts, power struggles, external threats, and the rapid socio-economic changes brought by oil wealth have all contributed to the challenges faced by the region.

By Amjad Izhar
Contact: amjad.izhar@gmail.com
https://amjadizhar.blog

Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products or services that I believe will add value to my readers. Your support helps keep this blog running and allows me to continue providing you with quality content. Thank you for your support!